RB1 gene mutations in Iranian patients with retinoblastoma: report of four novel mutations

Molecular Changes in Retinoblastoma beyond RB1: Findings from Next-Generation Sequencing

Simple Summary

The gene causing retinoblastoma was the first tumor suppressor cloned (1986) and because retinoblastoma is the classic example of autosomal dominant inheritance, there has been little research on non-RB1 alterations in tumors and the impact these alterations have on growth patterns in the eye, metastases and predilection for non-ocular cancers. This study interrogated enucleated retinoblastoma specimens using a MSK-IMPACT clinical next-generation sequencing panel with the aim to correlate them with clinicopathologic characteristics. We found that vitreous seeding (the main reason for eye removal) correlates with copy number variations, specifically 1q gains and 16q loss. We also found that somatic BCOR mutations correlate with propensity for metastasis and this offers a molecular pathway for monitoring high risk tumors. In addition, the finding that 11% of these retinoblastoma patients have additional germline mutations (on other chromosomes) that predispose them to a different host of cancers throughout their lives enables more targeted and specific screening strategies.

Abstract

This investigation uses hybridization capture-based next-generation sequencing to deepen our understanding of genetics that underlie retinoblastoma. Eighty-three enucleated retinoblastoma specimens were evaluated using a MSK-IMPACT clinical next-generation sequencing panel to evaluate both somatic and germline alterations. Somatic copy number variations (CNVs) were also identified. Genetic profiles were correlated to clinicopathologic characteristics. RB1 inactivation was found in 79 (97.5%) patients. All specimens had additional molecular alterations. The most common non-RB1 gene alteration was BCOR in 19 (22.9%). Five (11.0%) had pathogenic germline mutations in other non-RB1 cancer predisposition genes. Significant clinicopathologic correlations included: vitreous seeds associated with 1q gains and 16q loss of heterozygosity (BH-corrected p-value = 0.008, 0.004; OR = 12.6, 26.7, respectively). BCOR mutations were associated with poor prognosis, specifically metastases-free survival (MFS) (nominal p-value 0.03). Furthermore, retinoblastoma patients can have non-RB1 germline mutations in other cancer-associated genes. No two specimens had the identical genetic profile, emphasizing the individuality of tumors with the same clinical diagnosis.

Spectrum of RB1 Germline Mutations and Clinical Features in Unrelated Chinese Patients With Retinoblastoma

Retinoblastoma (Rb) is a primary intraocular malignant tumor that occurs primarily in children, and results from loss-of-function mutations in the RB transcriptional corepressor 1 (RB1) gene. Genetic testing forms the basis of genetic counseling for affected families, as well as for clinical management of this disease. The aim of this study was to identify germline RB1 mutations and correlate the identified mutations with the clinical features of Rb patients. Genomic DNA was isolated from peripheral blood of 180 unrelated Rb patients and their parents (118 unilaterally and 62 bilaterally affected probands). Mutations in the RB1 gene, including the promoter region and exons 1-27 with flanking intronic sequences, were identified by Sanger sequencing. The samples with negative sequencing results were further subjected to methylation-specific multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification (MS-MLPA) to detect gross deletions or duplications. Sixty-three distinct mutations were identified in 75 of the 180 (41.7%) probands. Of the 75 patients carrying RB1 mutations, 56 developed bilateral Rb, while 19 developed unilateral Rb. The total detection rates for bilateral and unilateral Rb were 90.3% (56/62) and 16.1% (19/118), respectively. Among the 75 patients, the spectrum of mutation types comprised 29.3% (22/75) nonsense mutations, 22.7% (17/75) splicing mutations, 17.3% (13/75) small insertions/deletions, 16.0% (12/75) large deletions/duplications, and 13.3% (10/75) missense mutations, while only 1% (1/75) of the mutations were in the promoter region of the RB1 gene. Age at diagnosis was significantly different (p < 0.01) between patients with positive and negative test results for germline RB1 mutations. A c.2359C > T mutation (p.R787X) was identified in identical twins, but one child was affected bilaterally and the other unilaterally. Of the five patients with deletion of the entire RB1 gene, the deletion of two patients was inherited from unaffected parents. In conclusion, in this study, we provide a comprehensive spectrum of RB1 germline mutations in Chinese Rb patients, and describe the correlations among RB1 mutations, age at diagnosis, and laterality; moreover, we report that the clinical features of individuals carrying an identical mutation in the RB1 gene were highly variable, indicating that the pathogenesis of Rb is more complicated than currently believed.

Genetic screening in Iranian patients with retinoblastoma

PurposeThe most common intraocular tumor in childhood, retinoblastoma, is largely associated with mutations in the RB1 gene. In the most comprehensive RB1 screening in Iran, we evaluated the RB1 mutations in 106 patients with retinoblastoma, including 73 bilateral (heritable) and 33 unilateral (sporadic) cases.Patients and methodsMutations were identified using amplification refractory mutation system (ARMS) PCR and direct sequencing of the 27 coding exons of RB1 and multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification (MLPA).Results and ConclusionWe found 33 (31%) and 64 (60%) patients with sporadic unilateral and bilateral retinoblastoma, respectively as well as 9 (8.5%) cases with hereditary bilateral retinoblastoma. In total, we identified 52 causative RB1 mutations in 106 patients (global mutation rate of 49%). Of the 52 patients, 48 (92%) had sporadic and familial bilateral and 4 (8%) had sporadic unilateral RB. Therefore, the detection rate of RB1 mutations was 66% (48/73) and 12% (4/33) in bilateral and unilateral cases, respectively. Mutations were classified as nonsense in 31 (60%), missense in 1 (2%), large deletion in 11 (21%), small deletion in the 7 novel (15%) and splice site mutation in 2 (4%) patients with RB. Of 31 nonsense mutations, 23 (74%) occurred in the 11 Arginine codons of the RB1. Seven mutations (13%) were novel, and 45 (87%) had been previously reported. Thirty-three mutations were single-base substitutions leading to 31 nonsense amino acid changes and 2 splice site mutations in introns 12 and 16 of RB1. The altered 3D model structures of the RB1 novel mutant proteins are also predicted in this study.

Genetic screening in patients with Retinoblastoma in Israel

Retinoblastoma (Rb) is a childhood tumor (~1 in 20,000 live births) developing in the retina due to mutations in the RB1 gene. Identification of the oncogenic mutations in the RB1 gene is important for the clinical management and for genetic counseling to families with a child or a parent affected with the tumor. Here we present our experience in detecting the pathogenic mutations in blood samples, from 150 unrelated Rb patients and highlight the relevant counseling issues. Mutation screening in the RB1 gene was based on Sanger sequencing, mosaicism of recurrent CpG transition mutations was detected by allele specific PCR and multiplex ligation dependent probe amplification for detecting of large deletions/duplications. The overall detection rate of mutations in our cohort was 55% (82/150). In the familial cases it was 100% (17/17), in bilateral and unilateral-multifocal sporadic cases 91% (50/55), and in the unilateral sporadic cases 19% (15/78). Nonsense mutations and small deletions or insertions that results in transcripts with premature termination codons that are subject to nonsense mediated decay were the most frequent, detected in 50/82 (61%) of the patients. The rest were large deletions detected in 14/82 (17%), splice site mutations detected in 11/82 (13%), missense mutations in four patients and mutations in the promoter sequence in three patients. Mutation mosaicism ranging from 10 to 30% was detected by allele specific PCR in ten patients, 9% (5/55) of patients with bilateral tumor and 33% (5/15) of the patients with unilateral tumor. In three patients rare variants were detected as the only finding which was also detected in other healthy family members. Allele specific amplification of recurrent mutations raises in our cohort the identification rate from 82 to 91% in the sporadic bilateral cases and from 13 to 19% in the unilateral sporadic cases. Most mosaic cases could not be identified by Sanger sequencing and therefore screening for recurrent CpG transition mutations by allele specific amplification is of utmost importance. Molecular screening is important for the genetic counseling regarding the risk for tumor development and the relevance for prenatal diagnosis but in several families is accompanied by detecting rare variants that might be rare polymorphisms or low penetrant mutations.

A stepwise strategy for rapid and cost-effective RB1 screening in Indian retinoblastoma patients

India has the highest number of retinoblastoma (RB) patients among the developing countries owing to its increasing population. Of the patients with RB, about 40% have the heritable form of the disease, making genetic analysis of the RB1 gene an integral part of disease management. However, given the large size of the RB1 gene with its widely dispersed exons and no reported hotspots, genetic testing can be cumbersome. To overcome this problem, we have developed a rapid screening strategy by prioritizing the order of exons to be analyzed, based on the frequency of nonsense mutations, deletions and duplications reported in the RB1-Leiden Open Variation Database and published literature on Indian patients. Using this strategy for genetic analysis, mutations were identified in 76% of patients in half the actual time and one third of the cost. This reduction in time and cost will allow for better risk prediction for siblings and offspring, thereby facilitating genetic counseling for families, especially in developing countries.

Two novel cases of trilateral retinoblastoma: genetics and review of the literature

Retinoblastoma (RB) is the most common eye tumor in children; it originates from germline and/or somatic mutations that inactivate both alleles of the RB1 gene located on chromosome 13q14. Patients with unilateral or bilateral RB infrequently may develop an additional intracranial neuroblastic tumor, usually in the pineal gland, which characterizes the trilateral retinoblastoma (TRB) syndrome. The most common chromosomal abnormalities detected in TRB are deletions at 13q14, even if some rare cases of RB1 point mutations were described. In our report, we investigated two patients with TRB who showed a germline RB1 point mutation that has never been found to date and a large deletion involving RB1, respectively. Genetic data were compared to our in-house series and to current literature; these data suggested a role for other candidate regions in the pathogenesis of TRB. Moreover, our study highlights the need for new approaches allowing a multigenic analysis to clarify the genotype-phenotype correlation in TRB.