Involvement of β3-adrenergic receptors in in vivo cardiovascular regulation in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss)

Evolution and divergence of teleost adrenergic receptors: why sometimes 'the drugs don't work' in fish

Adrenaline and noradrenaline, released as hormones and/or neurotransmitters, exert diverse physiological functions in vertebrates, and teleost fishes are widely used as model organisms to study adrenergic regulation; however, such investigations often rely on receptor subtype-specific pharmacological agents (agonists and antagonists; see Glossary) developed and validated in mammals. Meanwhile, evolutionary (phylogenetic and comparative genomic) studies have begun to unravel the diversification of adrenergic receptors (ARs) and reveal that whole-genome duplications and pseudogenization events in fishes results in notable distinctions from mammals in their genomic repertoire of ARs, while lineage-specific gene losses within teleosts have generated significant interspecific variability. In this Review, we visit the evolutionary history of ARs (including α1-, α2- and β-ARs) to highlight the prominent interspecific differences in teleosts, as well as between teleosts and other vertebrates. We also show that structural modelling of teleost ARs predicts differences in ligand binding affinity compared with mammalian orthologs. To emphasize the difficulty of studying the roles of different AR subtypes in fish, we collate examples from the literature of fish ARs behaving atypically compared with standard mammalian pharmacology. Thereafter, we focus on specific case studies of the liver, heart and red blood cells, where our understanding of AR expression has benefited from combining pharmacological approaches with molecular genetics. Finally, we briefly discuss the ongoing advances in 'omics' technologies that, alongside classical pharmacology, will provide abundant opportunities to further explore adrenergic signalling in teleosts.

Evolutionary loss of the ß1-adrenergic receptor in salmonids

Whole-genome duplications (WGDs) have been at the heart of the diversification of ß-adrenergic receptors (ß-ARs) in vertebrates. Non-teleost jawed vertebrates typically possess three ß-AR genes: adrb1 (ß1-AR), adrb2 (ß2-AR), and adrb3 (ß3-AR), originating from the ancient 2R (two rounds) WGDs. Teleost fishes, owing to the teleost-specific WGD, have five ancestral adrb paralogs (adrb1, adrb2a, adrb2b, adrb3a and adrb3b). Salmonids are particularly intriguing from an evolutionary perspective as they experienced an additional WGD after separating from other teleosts. Moreover, adrenergic regulation in salmonids, especially rainbow trout, has been intensively studied for decades. However, the repertoire of adrb genes in salmonids has not been yet characterized. An exhaustive genome survey of diverse salmonids, spanning five genera, complemented by phylogenetic sequence analysis, revealed each species has seven adrb paralogs: two adrb2a, two adrb2b, two adrb3a and one adrb3b. Surprisingly, salmonids emerge as the first known jawed vertebrate lineage to lack adrb1. adrb1 is nevertheless highly expressed in the hearts of non-salmonid teleosts, indicating that the wealth of data on adrenergic regulation in salmonids should be generalised to other teleost fishes with caution. It is hypothesised that the loss of adrb1 could have been viable because of the evolutionary radiation of adrb2 and adrb3 genes attributable to the salmonid WGD.

Regulation of heart rate following genetic deletion of the ß1 adrenergic receptor in larval zebrafish

Aim

Although zebrafish are gaining popularity as biomedical models of cardiovascular disease, our understanding of their cardiac control mechanisms is fragmentary. Our goal was to clarify the controversial role of the ß1‐adrenergic receptor (AR) in the regulation of heart rate in zebrafish.

Methods

CRISPR‐Cas9 was used to delete the adrb1 gene in zebrafish allowing us to generate a stable adrb1^−/− line. Larval heart rates were measured during pharmacological protocols and with exposure to hypercapnia. Expression of the five zebrafish adrb genes were measured in larval zebrafish hearts using qPCR.

Results

Compared with genetically matched wild‐types (adrb1^+/+), adrb1^−/− larvae exhibited ~20 beats min⁻¹ lower heart rate, measured from 2 to 21 days post‐fertilization (dpf). Nevertheless, adrb1^−/− larvae exhibited preserved positive chronotropic responses to pharmacological treatment with AR agonists (adrenaline, noradrenaline, isoproterenol), which were blocked by propranolol (general ß‐AR antagonist). Regardless of genotype, larvae exhibited similar increases in heart rate in response to hypercapnia (1% CO₂) at 5 dpf, but tachycardia was blunted in adrb1^−/− larvae at 6 dpf. adrb1 gene expression was abolished in the hearts of adrb1^−/− larvae, confirming successful knockout. While gene expression of adrb2a and adrb3a was unchanged, adrb2b and adrb3b mRNA levels increased in adrb1^−/− larval hearts.

Conclusion

Despite adrb1 contributing to the setting of resting heart rate in larvae, it is not strictly essential for zebrafish, as we generated a viable and breeding adrb1^−/− line. The chronotropic effects of adrenergic stimulation persist in adrb1^−/− zebrafish, likely due to the upregulation of other ß‐AR subtypes.

Shaping the cardiac response to hypoxia: NO and its partners in teleost fish

The reduced availability of dissolved oxygen is a common stressor in aquatic habitats that affects the ability of the heart to ensure tissue oxygen supply. Among key signalling molecules activated during cardiac hypoxic stress, nitric oxide (NO) has emerged as a central player involved in the related adaptive responses. Here, we outline the role of the nitrergic control in modulating tolerance and adaptation of teleost heart to hypoxia, as well as major molecular players that participate in the complex NO network. The purpose is to provide a framework in which to depict how the heart deals with limitations in oxygen supply. In this perspective, defining the relational interplay between the multiple (sets of) proteins that, due to the gene duplication events that occurred during the teleost fish evolutive radiation, do operate in parallel with similar functions in the (different) heart (districts) and other body districts under low levels of oxygen supply, represents a next goal of the comparative research in teleost fish cardiac physiology.

•

The flexibility of the teleost heart to O₂ limitations is illustrated by using cyprinids as hypoxia tolerance models.

•

Major molecular mediators of the teleost cardiac response are discussed with a focus on the nitrergic system.

•

A comparative analysis of gene duplication highlights conserved targets which may orchestrate the cardiac response to hypoxia.

The goldfish Carassius auratus: an emerging animal model for comparative cardiac research

The use of unconventional model organisms is significantly increasing in different fields of research, widely contributing to advance life sciences understanding. Among fishes, the cyprinid Carassius auratus (goldfish) is largely used for studies on comparative and evolutionary endocrinology, neurobiology, adaptive and conservation physiology, as well as for translational research aimed to explore mechanisms that may be useful in an applicative biomedical context. More recently, the research possibilities offered by the goldfish are further expanded to cardiac studies. A growing literature is available to illustrate the complex networks involved in the modulation of the goldfish cardiac performance, also in relation to the influence of environmental signals. However, an overview on the existing current knowledge is not yet available. By discussing the mechanisms that in C. auratus finely regulate the cardiac function under basal conditions and under environmental challenges, this review highlights the remarkable flexibility of the goldfish heart in relation not only to the basic morpho-functional design and complex neuro-humoral traits, but also to its extraordinary biochemical-metabolic plasticity and its adaptive potential. The purpose of this review is also to emphasize the power of the heart of C. auratus as an experimental tool useful to investigate mechanisms that could be difficult to explore using more conventional animal models and complex cardiac designs.

Cardiac influence of the β3-adrenoceptor in the goldfish (Carassius auratus): a protective role under hypoxia?

The goldfish (Carassius auratus) exhibits a remarkable capacity to survive and remain active under prolonged and severe hypoxia, making it a good model for studying cardiac function when oxygen availability is a limiting factor. Under hypoxia, the goldfish heart increases its performance, representing a putative component of hypoxia tolerance; however, the underlying mechanisms have not yet been elucidated. Here, we aimed to investigate the role of β3-adrenoreceptors (ARs) in the mechanisms that modulate goldfish heart performance along with the impact of oxygen levels. By western blotting analysis, we found that the goldfish heart expresses β3-ARs, and this expression increases under hypoxia. The effects of β3-AR stimulation were analysed by using an ex vivo working heart preparation. Under normoxia, the β3-AR-selective agonist BRL₃₇₃₄₄ (10^-12 to 10^-7 mol l^-1) elicited a concentration-dependent increase of contractility that was abolished by a specific β3-AR antagonist (SR_59230A; 10^-8 mol l^-1), but not by α/β1/β2-AR inhibitors (phentolamine, nadolol and ICI118,551; 10^-7 mol l^-1). Under acute hypoxia, BRL₃₇₃₄₄ did not affect goldfish heart performance. However, SR_59230A, but not phentolamine, nadolol or ICI118,551, abolished the time-dependent enhancement of contractility that characterizes the hypoxic goldfish heart. Under both normoxia and hypoxia, adenylate cyclase and cAMP were found to be involved in the β3-AR-dependent downstream transduction pathway. In summary, we show the presence of functional β3-ARs in the goldfish heart, whose activation modulates basal performance and contributes to a hypoxia-dependent increase of contractility.

Effects of epinephrine exposure on contractile performance of compact and spongy myocardium from rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) during hypoxia

Hypoxia results in elevated circulating epinephrine for many fish species, and this is likely important for maintaining cardiac function. The aims of this study were to assess how hypoxia impacts contractile responses of ventricular compact and spongy myocardium from rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and to assess how and if epinephrine may protect myocardial performance from a depressive effect of hypoxia. Work output and maximum contraction rate of isolated preparations of spongy and compact ventricular myocardium from rainbow trout were measured. Tissues were exposed to the blood PO₂ that they experience in vivo during environmental normoxia and hypoxia and also to low (5 nM) and high (500 nM) levels of epinephrine in 100% air saturation (PO₂ 20.2 kPa) and during hypoxia (PO₂ 2 kPa, 10% air saturation). It was hypothesized that hypoxia would result in a decrease in work output and maximum contraction rate in both tissue types, but that epinephrine exposure would mitigate the effect. Hypoxia resulted in a decline in net work output of both tissue types, but a decline in maximum contraction rate of only compact myocardium. Epinephrine restored the maximum contraction rate of compact myocardium in hypoxia, appeared to slightly enhance work output of only compact myocardium in air saturation but surprisingly not during hypoxia, and restored net work of hypoxic spongy myocardium toward normoxic levels. These results indicate hypoxia has a similar depressive effect on both layers of ventricular myocardium, but that high epinephrine may be important for maintaining inotropy in spongy myocardium and chronotropy in compact myocardium during hypoxia.

β3 -AR and the vertebrate heart: a comparative view

Recent cardiovascular research showed that, together with β1- and β2-adrenergic receptors (ARs), β3-ARs contribute to the catecholamine (CA)-dependent control of the heart. β3-ARs structure, function and ligands were investigated in mammals because of their applicative potential in human cardiovascular diseases. Only recently, the concept of a β3-AR-dependent cardiac modulation was extended to non-mammalian vertebrates, although information is still scarce and fragmentary. β3-ARs were structurally described in fish, showing a closer relationship to mammalian β1-AR than β2-AR. Functional β3-ARs are present in the cardiac tissue of teleosts and amphibians. As in mammals, activation of these receptors elicits a negative modulation of the inotropic performance through the involvement of the endothelium endocardium (EE), Gi/0 proteins and the nitric oxide (NO) signalling. This review aims to comparatively analyse data from literature on β3-ARs in mammals, with those on teleosts and amphibians. The purpose is to highlight aspects of uniformity and diversity of β3-ARs structure, ligands activity, function and signalling cascades throughout vertebrates. This may provide new perspectives aimed to clarify the biological relevance of β3-ARs in the context of the nervous and humoral control of the heart and its functional plasticity.