Standardization of calibration and quality control using surface enhanced laser desorption ionization-time of flight-mass spectrometry

Biofluid infrared spectro-diagnostics: pre-analytical considerations for clinical applications

Several proof-of-concept studies on the vibrational spectroscopy of biofluids have demonstrated that the methodology has promising potential as a clinical diagnostic tool. However, these studies also show that there is a lack of a standardised protocol in sample handling and preparation prior to spectroscopic analysis. One of the most important sources of analytical errors is the pre-analytical phase. For the technique to be translated into clinics, it is clear that a very strict protocol needs to be established for such biological samples. This study focuses on some of the aspects of the pre-analytical phase in the development of the high-throughput Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy of some of the most common biofluids such as serum, plasma and bile. Pre-analytical considerations that can impact either the samples (solvents, anti-coagulants, freeze-thaw cycles…) and/or spectroscopic analysis (sample preparation such as drying, deposit methods, volumes, substrates, operators dependence…) and consequently the quality and the reproducibility of spectral data will be discussed in this report.

Peptide profiling of cerebrospinal fluid by mass spectrometry

The search for biomarkers is driven by the increasing clinical importance of early diagnosis. Reliable biomarkers can also assist in directing therapy, monitoring disease activity and the efficacy of treatment. In addition, the discovery of novel biomarkers might provide clues to the pathogenesis of a disease. The dynamic range of protein concentrations in body fluids exceeds 10 orders of magnitude. These huge differences in concentrations complicate the detection of proteins with low expression levels. Since all classical biomarkers have low expression levels (e.g., prostate-specific antigen: 2-4 microg/l; and CA125: 20-35 U/ml), new developments with respect to identification and validation techniques of the low-abundance proteins are required. This review will discuss the current status of profiling cerebrospinal fluid using mass spectrometry-based techniques, and new developments in this area.

Effects of preanalytical variables on peptide and protein measurements in human serum and plasma: implications for clinical proteomics

There is a wealth of knowledge in the field of in vitro diagnostics with regard to preanalytical variables and their impact on the determination of peptide and protein analytes in human serum and plasma. This information is applicable to clinical proteomics investigations, which utilize the same sample types. Studies have demonstrated that the majority of variations and errors in in vitro diagnostics seem to occur in the preanalytical phase prior to specimen analysis. Preanalytical processes include study design, compliance of the subjects investigated, compliance of the technical staff in adherence to protocols, choice of specimens utilized and sample collection and processing. These variables can have a dramatic impact on the determination of analytes and can affect result outcomes, reproducibility and the validity of investigations. By drawing analogies to in vitro diagnostics practices, specific variables that are likely to impact the results of proteomics studies can be identified. Recognition of such variables is the first step towards their understanding and, eventually, controlling their impact. In this article, we will review preanalytical variables, provide examples for their effects on the determination of distinct peptides and proteins and discuss potential implications for clinical proteomics investigations.

Longitudinal analysis of maternal plasma apolipoproteins in pregnancy: a targeted proteomics approach

Minimally invasive diagnostic tests are needed in obstetrics to identify women at risk for complications during delivery. The apolipoproteins fluctuate in complexity and abundance in maternal plasma during pregnancy and could be incorporated into a blood test to evaluate this risk. The objective of this study was to examine the relative plasma concentrations of apolipoproteins and their biochemically modified subtypes (i.e. proteolytically processed, sialylated, cysteinylated, dimerized) over gestational time using a targeted mass spectrometry approach. Relative abundance of modified and unmodified apolipoproteins A-I, A-II, C-I, C-II, and C-III was determined by surface-enhanced laser desorption/ionization-time of flight-mass spectrometry in plasma prospectively collected from 11 gravidas with uncomplicated pregnancies at 4-5 gestational time points per patient. Apolipoproteins were readily identifiable by spectral pattern. Apo C-III(2) and Apo C-III(1) (doubly and singly sialylated Apo C-III subtypes) increased with gestational age (r(2)>0.8). Unmodified Apo A-II, Apo C-I, and Apo C-III(0) showed no correlation (r(2) = 0.01-0.1). Pro-Apo C-II did not increase significantly until third trimester (140 ± 13% of first trimester), but proteolytically cleaved, mature Apo C-II increased in late pregnancy (702 ± 130% of first trimester). Mature Apo C-II represented 6.7 ± 0.9% of total Apo C-II in early gestation and increased to 33 ± 4.5% in third trimester. A label-free, semiquantitative targeted proteomics approach was developed using LTQ-Orbitrap mass spectrometry to confirm the relative quantitative differences observed by surface-enhanced laser desorption/ionization-time of flight-mass spectrometry in Apo C-III and Apo C-II isoforms between first and third trimesters. Targeted apolipoprotein screening was applied to a cohort of term and preterm patients. Modified Apo A-II isoforms were significantly elevated in plasma from mothers who delivered prematurely relative to term controls (p = 0.02). These results support a role for targeted proteomics profiling approaches in monitoring healthy pregnancies and assessing risk of adverse obstetric outcomes.

Biological and methodical challenges of blood-based proteomics in the field of neurological research

Biomarker discovery is an application of major importance in today's proteomic research. There is an urgent need for suitable biomarkers to improve diagnostic tools and treatment in various neurological diseases, such as neurodegenerative disorders. Recent years have witnessed an enormous interest in proteomics, which is currently seen as an invaluable tool to shed more light on complex interacting signalling pathways and molecular networks involved in several neuropathological conditions. However, while first results of proteomic research studies have sparked much public attention, the momentum of further proteomic biomarker research in neurological disorders may suffer by its very complex methodology which is sensitive to various sources of artefacts. A major source of variability is proteome perturbation caused by sample handling/preservation (preanalytical phase) and processing/measurement (analytical phase). The aim of the present review is to summarize the current literature focusing on the crucial role played by preanalytical and analytical factors that affect the quality of samples and the reliability of the data produced in blood-based proteomic biomarker research in neurology, which may apply to Alzheimer's disease (AD) as well as other neurological disorders. Procedures for sample preparation and protocols for the analysis of serum and plasma samples will be delineated. Finally, the potential usefulness of bioinformatics--allowing for the assembly, store, and processing of data--as well as its contribution to the execution of proteomic studies will be critically discussed.

SprayQc: a real-time LC-MS/MS quality monitoring system to maximize uptime using off the shelf components

With the advent of high-throughput mass spectrometry (MS)-based proteomics, the magnitude and complexity of the performed experiments has increased dramatically. Likewise, investments in chromatographic and MS instrumentation are a large proportion of the budget of proteomics laboratories. Guarding measurement quality and maximizing uptime of the LC-MS/MS systems therefore requires constant care despite automated workflows. We describe a real-time surveillance system, called SprayQc, that continuously monitors the status of the peripheral equipment to ensure that operational parameters are within an acceptable range. SprayQc is composed of multiple plug-in software components that use computer vision to analyze electrospray conditions, monitor the chromatographic device for stable backpressure, interact with a column oven to control pressure by temperature, and ensure that the mass spectrometer is still acquiring data. Action is taken when a failure condition has been detected, such as stopping the column oven and the LC flow, as well as automatically notifying the appropriate operator. Additionally, all defined metrics can be recorded synchronized on retention time with the MS acquisition file, allowing for later inspection and providing valuable information for optimization. SprayQc has been extensively tested in our laboratory, supports third-party plug-in development, and is freely available for download from http://sourceforge.org/projects/sprayqc .

SELDI-TOF serum proteomics and colorectal cancer: a current overview

Surface enhanced laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (SELDI-TOF-MS) is a widely used technology platform for diagnostic biomarker discovery in tissue, plasma and serum. High-throughput and simplicity of experimental procedures have allowed this technology to become an important research tool for biomarker discovery during the last years. This review provides an overview of SELDI-TOF functionality, its advantages and drawbacks and gives a current literature overview of colorectal cancer based serum biomarker detection. Further improvements in instrumentation sensitivity and labelling chemistries will enable detection of novel, tissue-leakage biomarkers in serum. However, major emphasis should be given on subsequent identification of differentially observed protein peaks detected by SELDI-TOF. Clinical validation in large patient cohorts will then allow transferring novel biomarkers into clinical use.

Quality control based on isotopic distributions for high-throughput MALDI-TOF and MALDI-FTICR serum peptide profiling

In this study, we have implemented a new quality control (QC) parameter for peptide profiling based on isotopic distributions. This QC parameter is an objective measure and facilitates automatic sorting of large numbers of peptide spectra. Peptides in human serum samples were enriched using reversed-phase C(18)-functionalized magnetic beads using a high-throughput robotic platform. High-resolution MALDI-TOF and ultrahigh resolution MALDI-FTICR mass spectra were obtained and a workflow was developed for automated analysis and evaluation of these profiles. To this end, the isotopic distributions of multiple peptides were quantified from both MALDI-TOF and MALDI-FTICR spectra. Odd peptide isotope distributions in TOF spectra could be rationalized from ultrahigh resolution FTICR spectra that showed overlap of different peptides. The comparison of isotope patterns with estimated polyaveragine distributions was used to calculate a QC value for each single mass spectrum. Sorting these QC values enabled the best MALDI spectrum to be selected from replicate spots. Moreover, using this approach spectra containing high intensities of polymers or other contaminants and lacking peptides of interest can be efficiently removed from a clinical dataset. In general, this method simplifies the exclusion of low quality spectra from further statistical analysis.

Integrated multi-level quality control for proteomic profiling studies using mass spectrometry

Background

Proteomic profiling using mass spectrometry (MS) is one of the most promising methods for the analysis of complex biological samples such as urine, serum and tissue for biomarker discovery. Such experiments are often conducted using MALDI-TOF (matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionisation time-of-flight) and SELDI-TOF (surface-enhanced laser desorption/ionisation time-of-flight) MS. Using such profiling methods it is possible to identify changes in protein expression that differentiate disease states and individual proteins or patterns that may be useful as potential biomarkers. However, the incorporation of quality control (QC) processes that allow the identification of low quality spectra reliably and hence allow the removal of such data before further analysis is often overlooked. In this paper we describe rigorous methods for the assessment of quality of spectral data. These procedures are presented in a user-friendly, web-based program. The data obtained post-QC is then examined using variance components analysis to quantify the amount of variance due to some of the factors in the experimental design.

Results

Using data from a SELDI profiling study of serum from patients with different levels of renal function, we show how the algorithms described in this paper may be used to detect systematic variability within and between sample replicates, pooled samples and SELDI chips and spots. Manual inspection of those spectral data that were identified as being of poor quality confirmed the efficacy of the algorithms. Variance components analysis demonstrated the relatively small amount of technical variance attributable to day of profile generation and experimental array.

Conclusion

Using the techniques described in this paper it is possible to reliably detect poor quality data within proteomic profiling experiments undertaken by MS. The removal of these spectra at the initial stages of the analysis substantially improves the confidence of putative biomarker identification and allows inter-experimental comparisons to be carried out with greater confidence.

Computational methods for protein identification from mass spectrometry data

Protein identification using mass spectrometry is an indispensable computational tool in the life sciences. A dramatic increase in the use of proteomic strategies to understand the biology of living systems generates an ongoing need for more effective, efficient, and accurate computational methods for protein identification. A wide range of computational methods, each with various implementations, are available to complement different proteomic approaches. A solid knowledge of the range of algorithms available and, more critically, the accuracy and effectiveness of these techniques is essential to ensure as many of the proteins as possible, within any particular experiment, are correctly identified. Here, we undertake a systematic review of the currently available methods and algorithms for interpreting, managing, and analyzing biological data associated with protein identification. We summarize the advances in computational solutions as they have responded to corresponding advances in mass spectrometry hardware. The evolution of scoring algorithms and metrics for automated protein identification are also discussed with a focus on the relative performance of different techniques. We also consider the relative advantages and limitations of different techniques in particular biological contexts. Finally, we present our perspective on future developments in the area of computational protein identification by considering the most recent literature on new and promising approaches to the problem as well as identifying areas yet to be explored and the potential application of methods from other areas of computational biology.

Searching for potential biomarkers that can be used as biomarkers for diagnosing ankylosing spondylitis

Aim: Ankylosing spondylitis (AS) is a chronic systemic inflammatory rheumatic disorder that primarily affects the axial skeleton. To date there is no satisfactory biomarker for diagnosis or prognosis of AS. This study is focused on detection of potential biomarkers for the diagnosis of AS using surface-enhanced laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (SELDI-TOF-MS) with the ultimate goal of developing a progression biomarker for AS. Materials & methods: Protein profiles of sera of 38 AS patients and 38 healthy controls were obtained using ProteinChip arrays. Different arrays and conditions were compared with find out which condition resulted in the optimal discrimination of both groups. Results: Optimal discrimination was reached using weak cation exchange (CM10) and immobilized metal affinity capture coupled with copper (IMAC-Cu2+) arrays. Using a multimarker approach on protein profiles obtained with CM10 arrays resulted in a sensitivity of 66% and a specificity of 74%. Using a multimarker approach on protein profiles obtained with IMAC-Cu2+ arrays resulted in a sensitivity and specificity of 70%. Conclusions: This is the first study that shows that protein profiling in serum using SELDI-TOF-MS can be used as a diagnostic tool for AS. The biomarkers will be validated to confirm if they can be used as progression biomarkers.

Diagnostic value of serum protein profiling by SELDI-TOF ProteinChip compared with a biochemical marker, FibroTest, for the diagnosis of advanced fibrosis in patients with chronic hepatitis C

BACKGROUND

FibroTest has been validated for the diagnosis of liver fibrosis in patients with chronic hepatitis C.

AIM

To compare FibroTest with a new proteome-based model for the prediction of advanced liver fibrosis.

METHODS

Sera from 191 consecutive patients with simultaneous liver biopsy and FibroTest on fresh sera were used for retrospective mass spectrometry analysis. A new fibrosis index was constructed combining proteomic peaks, selected on differential expression according to fibrosis stages in logistic regression analyses. The main end point was the diagnosis of advanced fibrosis on liver biopsy.

RESULTS

Eight out of 1000 peaks were selected for the construction of the proteomic index. The area under the receiver operating curve (AUROC) of the proteomic index was 0.88 (95% CI: 0.82-0.92), significantly greater than the FibroTest AUROC of 0.81 (95% CI: 0.74-0.86; P = 0.04); the AUROC of the proteomic and FibroTest combination was 0.88 (95% CI: 0.83-0.92). Seven of the eight selected peaks were highly associated with the FibroTest score, with different patterns of association with the five components of FibroTest.

CONCLUSIONS

A proteomic index combining eight peaks had an excellent accuracy value for the diagnosis of advanced fibrosis in patients with chronic hepatitis C. However, despite a statistical significance, the small improvement delivered by proteomics impairs clinical applications because of its cost and its variability compared with the well validated FibroTest.

A method for improving SELDI-TOF mass spectrometry data quality

Background

Surface-enhanced laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (SELDI-TOF MS) is a powerful tool for rapidly generating high-throughput protein profiles from a large number of samples. However, the events that occur between the first and last sample run are likely to introduce technical variation in the results.

Methods

We fractionated and analyzed quality control and investigational serum samples on 3 Protein Chips and used statistical methods to identify poor-quality spectra and to identify and reduce technical variation.

Results

Using diagnostic plots, we were able to visually depict all spectra and to identify and remove those that were of poor quality. We detected a technical variation associated with when the samples were run (referred to as batch effect) and corrected for this variation using analysis of variance. These corrections increased the number of peaks that were reproducibly detected.

Conclusion

By removing poor-quality, outlier spectra, we were able to increase peak detection, and by reducing the variance introduced when samples are processed and analyzed in batches, we were able to increase the reproducibility of peak detection.

Mass spectrometry based proteomics in urine biomarker discovery

All organisms contain 1,000s of proteins and peptides in their body fluids, which undergo disease-specific changes. Advances in the understanding of the functional relevance of these polypeptides under different (patho)physiological conditions and the identification of indicative changes with disease would greatly enhance diagnosis and therapy. The low-molecular-weight proteome, also termed peptidome, provides a rich source of information. Due to its lower molecular weight, the peptidome can be assessed without the need for sample manipulation like tryptic digests. This advantage facilitates comparative analysis but it also raises technical challenges differing from those in proteomics. The first part of this manuscript, is focused on the low-molecular-weight urinary proteome and reviews methodological aspects of sample collection, preparation, analysis, and data evaluation. The second part summarizes the recent progress in the definition and identification of clinically relevant polypeptide markers.

Metrological sharp shooting for plasma proteins and peptides: The need for reference materials for accurate measurements in clinical proteomics and in vitro diagnostics to generate reliable results

Reliable study results are necessary for the assessment of discoveries, including those from proteomics. Reliable study results are also crucial to increase the likelihood of making a successful choice of biomarker candidates for verification and subsequent validation studies, a current bottleneck for the transition to in vitro diagnostic (IVD). In this respect, a major need for improvement in proteomics appears to be accuracy of measurements, including both trueness and precision of measurement. Standardization and total quality management systems (TQMS) help to provide accurate measurements and reliable results. Reference materials are an essential part of standardization and TQMS in IVD and are crucial to provide metrological correct measurements and for the overall quality assurance process. In this article we give an overview on how reference materials are defined, prepared and what role they play in standardization and TQMS to support the generation of reliable results. We discuss how proteomics can support the establishment of reference materials and biomarker tests for IVD applications, how current reference materials used in IVD may be beneficially applied in proteomics, and we provide considerations on the establishment of reference materials specific for proteomics. For clarity, we solely focus on reference materials related to serum and plasma.

High-resolution proteome/peptidome analysis of peptides and low-molecular-weight proteins in urine

All organisms contain thousands of proteins and peptides in their body fluids. A deeper insight into the functional relevance of these polypeptides under different physiological and pathophysiological conditions and the discovery of specific peptide biomarkers would greatly enhance diagnosis and therapy of specific diseases. The low-molecular-weight proteome, also termed peptidome, provides a rich source of information. Due to its unique features, the technical challenges differ somewhat from those in "common" proteomics. In this manuscript, we focus on the low-molecular-weight urinary proteome. We review the methodological aspects of sample collection, preparation, analysis, and subsequent data evaluation. In the second part of this review, we summarize the recent progress in the definition and identification of clinically relevant polypeptide markers.

Laboratory methods to improve SELDI peak detection and quantitation

Background

Protein profiling with surface-enhanced laser desorption-ionisation time-of-flight mass spectrometry (SELDI-TOF MS) is a promising approach for biomarker discovery. Some candidate biomarkers have been identified using SELDI-TOF, but validation of these can be challenging because of technical parameters that effect reproducibility. Here we describe steps to improve the reproducibility of peak detection.

Methods

SELDI-TOF mass spectrometry was performed using a system manufactured by Ciphergen Biosystems along with their ProteinChip System. Serum from 10 donors was pooled and used for all experiments. Serum was fractionated with Expression Difference Mapping kit-Serum Fractionation from the same company and applied to three different ProteinChips. The fractionations were run over a one month period to examine the contribution of sample batch and time to peak detection variability. Spectra were processed and peaks detected using the Ciphergen Express software and variance measured.

Results

Experimental parameters specific to the serum fraction and ProteinChip, including spot protocols (laser intensity and detector sensitivity) were optimized to decrease peak detection variance. Optimal instrument settings, regular calibration along with controlled sample handling and processing nearly doubled the number of peaks detected and decreased intensity variance.

Conclusion

This report assesses the variation across fractionated sera processed over a one-month period. The optimizations reported decreased the variance and increased the number of peaks detected.

Potential biomarkers for diagnosis of sarcoidosis using proteomics in serum

BACKGROUND

Sarcoidosis is a multi-systemic inflammatory disorder, which affects the lungs in 90% of the cases. The main pathologic feature is chronic inflammation resulting in non-caseating granuloma formation. Until now there is no satisfying biomarker for diagnosis or prognosis of sarcoidosis. This study is focused on the detection of potential biomarkers in serum for the diagnosis of sarcoidosis using surface-enhanced laser desorption ionization-time of flight-mass spectrometry (SELDI-TOF-MS).

METHODS

For detection of potential biomarkers, protein profiles of anion exchange fractionated serum of 35 sarcoidosis patients and 35 healthy controls were compared using SELDI-TOF-MS. Sensitivities and specificities of the potential biomarkers obtained with SELDI-TOF-MS, generated with decision tree algorithm, were compared to the conventional markers angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE) and soluble interleukin-2 receptor (sIL-2R).

RESULTS

Optimal classification was achieved with metal affinity binding arrays. A single marker with a mass-to-charge (m/z) value of 11,955 resulted in a sensitivity and specificity of 86% and 63%, respectively. A multimarker approach of two peaks, m/z values of 11,734 and 17,377, resulted in a sensitivity and specificity of 74% and 71%, respectively. These sensitivities and specificities were higher compared to measurements of ACE and sIL-2R. Identification of the peak at m/z 17,377 resulted in the alpha-2chain of haptoglobin.

CONCLUSIONS

This study acts as a proof-of-principle for the use of SELDI-TOF-MS in the detection of new biomarkers for sarcoidosis. The peak of the multimarker at m/z 17,377 was identified as the alpha-2chain of haptoglobin.

Vers une standardisation des outils pour les études de protéomique clinique

Proteins identified in biological fluids of cancer patients could be helpful for both diagnosis and prognosis. However, clinical proteomics based on analysis of protein profiles in biological fluids has demonstrated various flaws, most of them related to the difficulties met in reproducibility. These difficulties could be partly overcome by accurate standardisation of pre-analytical and analytical steps of these studies. The size of the patient cohort is one of the parameters that determine the powerfulness of the study. Recruitment of a cohort with a sufficient size often implies multicentric studies in which analysis of the reproducibility between centres and standardisation of pre-analytical and analytical steps are essential. Such a standardisation requires the use of calibrated samples as common references.

Current literature in mass spectrometry

In order to keep subscribers up‐to‐date with the latest developments in their field, John Wiley & Sons are providing a current awareness service in each issue of the journal. The bibliography contains newly published material in the field of mass spectrometry. Each bibliography is divided into 11 sections: 1 Books, Reviews & Symposia; 2 Instrumental Techniques & Methods; 3 Gas Phase Ion Chemistry; 4 Biology/Biochemistry: Amino Acids, Peptides & Proteins; Carbohydrates; Lipids; Nucleic Acids; 5 Pharmacology/Toxicology; 6 Natural Products; 7 Analysis of Organic Compounds; 8 Analysis of Inorganics/Organometallics; 9 Surface Analysis; 10 Environmental Analysis; 11 Elemental Analysis. Within each section, articles are listed in alphabetical order with respect to author (6 Weeks journals ‐ Search completed at 4th. Oct. 2006)