Redistribution of potentially toxic elements in the hydrosphere after the relocation of a group of tanneries

Beneficial and adverse effects of dam construction in canal tannery wastewater effluent with a high content of chromium in Hazaribagh, Bangladesh

BACKGROUND

Blockage to divide downstream canals into upstream canals, into which tannery wastewater including a high concentration of trivalent chromium [Cr(III)] is directly discharged, has been constructed in Hazaribagh, a tannery built-up area in Bangladesh. However, there has been no study to verify the environmental significance of blockage construction for water pollution of Cr in nature.

METHODS

Consecutive fixed area monitoring for a total of 164 water samples collected outside and inside Hazaribagh from 2014 to 2023 was carried out to clarify the effects of stagnant and flowable canal water in the presence or absence of blockage on Cr(III) and hexavalent Cr [Cr(VI)] concentrations.

RESULTS

Since pollution of Cr(III) and Cr(VI) in Buriganga River (outside Hazaribagh) was not serious, this study then focused on their pollution in canal water (inside Hazaribagh) in the nonblockage period, blockage construction period and blockage destruction period. As expected, the mean Cr(III) concentration in downstream canal water samples in the blockage construction period was more than 98% lower than that in the upstream canal water samples in the same period, while the concentrations were comparable in downstream and upstream canal water samples in the nonblockage period and blockage destruction period. Unexpectedly, the mean concentration of Cr(VI) in the upstream canal water samples in the blockage construction period was 38.6-fold and 3.3-fold higher than that in the downstream canal water samples and the Cr(VI) guideline value by the US-EPA, respectively.

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrated for the first time not only a merit of decreased Cr(III) pollution but also a demerit of increased Cr(VI) pollution in stagnant water derived from blockage construction in natural environments. This bitter lesson obtained by the enclosure of Cr(III)-polluted water is globally applicable for water pollution of Cr(III), which is used in various industries including the leather industry.

Unexpected associations of long-term and excessive exposure to trivalent chromium with hypertension and glycosuria in male tannery workers

Serious health hazards including renal, skin and hearing disorders have been reported in Bangladeshi tannery workers (TWs) who were chronically exposed to a large amount of trivalent chromium [Cr(III)]. However, the effects of Cr(III) exposure on the prevalence of hypertension and the prevalence of glycosuria in TWs remain unknown. Since the Cr level in toenails is an established marker reflecting long-term exposure to Cr(III) in humans, the associations of Cr levels in toenails with the prevalence of hypertension and the prevalence of glycosuria in male tannery and non-tannery office workers (non-TWs) in Bangladesh were investigated in this study. The mean toenail Cr level in non-TWs (0.5 μg/g, n = 49) was comparable to that in the general population reported previously. Mean Cr levels in TWs with a low toenail Cr level (5.7 μg/g, n = 39) and those with a high toenail Cr level (298.8 μg/g, n = 61) were >10-fold and >500-fold higher, respectively, than that in non-TWs. Our univariate and multivariate analyses indicated that the prevalence of hypertension and the prevalence of glycosuria in TWs with a high toenail Cr level, but not in TWs with a low toenail Cr level, were significantly lower than those in non-TWs. This study showed for the first time that long-term and excessive exposure to Cr(III) that is more than >500-fold but not >10-fold higher than the usual exposure level could decrease the prevalence of hypertension and the prevalence of glycosuria in TWs. Thus, this study revealed unexpected effects of exposure to Cr(III) on health.

Zero waste discharge in tannery industries - An achievable reality? A recent review

In the recent times, more attention is on industrial waste management due to the unaffordable space for dump yards and landfills and the increased charges for waste dumping. Even though the vegan revolution and plant-based meat products are booming, the traditional slaughterhouses and the wastes produced by them continue to be a concern. Waste valorisation is an established procedure striving to create a closed chain process in industries where there is no refuse. Although a highly polluting industry, slaughterhouse industry wastes have been recycled to economically viable leather since ancient times. However, the tannery industry is causing pollution in par with or even more than the slaughterhouses. Effective management of the liquid and solid wastes from the tannery is of utmost concern because of its toxicity. The hazardous wastes generated enter the food chain, causing long term impacts in the ecosystem. Several leather waste transformation processes are widely used in the industries, and they are yielding good products of economic value. However careful exploration into the processes and products of waste valorisation are often ignored as long as the transformed waste product is of higher value than the waste. The most efficient and environmentally friendly waste management technique should convert the refuse into a value-added utilization without any toxic leftovers. Zero waste concept is an extension of the zero liquid discharge concept, where the solid waste is also treated and reused to such an extent that there is no residue to be sent to the landfill. This review initially presents the existing methods for the de-toxification of tannery wastes and examines the possibility of solid waste management within the tannery industry to attain zero waste discharge.

Decreased hearing levels at frequencies for understanding speech in tannery workers exposed to a high level of trivalent chromium in Bangladesh

Hexavalent chromium [Cr(VI)], which has a strong corrosive effect, has been reported to cause perforation of the eardrum. Trivalent chromium [Cr(III)] also has a weak corrosive effect. However, there has been no study on the effects of exposure to Cr, either Cr(VI) or Cr(III), on hearing levels in animals or humans. In this study, the effect of Cr(III) exposure on hearing levels was determined in a human study. Then the reproducibility of the results obtained in the human study and the etiology were investigated in an animal study. The mean levels of total chromium (t-Cr) in hair and toenails from 100 Bangladeshi tannery workers were >20-fold and >360-fold higher, respectively, than those in hair and toenails from 49 Bangladeshi non-tannery workers (office workers). Multivariate analysis revealed decreases of hearing levels (DHLs) at 1 k and 4 k Hz, frequencies that are crucial for understanding language, but not at 8 k and 12 k Hz, in the tannery workers. Since >99.99% of t-Cr in the wastewater that the workers were in direct contact with in the tanneries was Cr(III), the epidemiological results suggest Cr(III)-mediated DHLs in the tannery workers. The results of animal experiments in this study further showed that treatment with eardrops but not intraperitoneal injection with the same amount of Cr(III) that tannery workers might be exposed to resulted in DHL with a damaged eardrum in mice. Previous studies suggested that Cr(III) can directly reach the eardrums of tannery workers via droplets in the air. Cr(III) could also reach the eardrum via picking an ear canal with a finger contaminated with tannery wastewater including Cr(III). Taken together, the results of both human and animal studies suggest the risk of DHLs caused by damage of the eardrum through external exposure to Cr(III) via the ear canal.

Potential application of a hydrotalcite-like compound for reduction of toxicity to aquatic organisms via rapid and efficient removal of hydrogen sulfide

Hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) is known to have wide ranging toxicities not only as a gas but also as dissolved forms in aquatic environments. The diversity of aquatic organisms can be severely affected by hydrogen sulfide at very low concentrations, indicating the urgent necessity to develop an efficient method for removal of hydrogen sulfide in water. In this study, the removal capacity for hydrogen sulfide of our originally developed hydrotalcite-like compound composed of magnesium and iron (MF-HT) was investigated and its potential application for reduction of toxicity to aquatic organisms was evaluated. The MF-HT experimentally showed a high adsorption capacity of 146.5 mg/g with a fast adsorption equilibrium time of 45 min, both of which are top-class compared with those of other adsorbents previously reported. In fact, removal of hydrogen sulfide (1.2-152.5 mg/L) at an average rate of >97.6% was achieved in groundwater samples (n = 16) by the MF-HT within 60 min. The toxicities of groundwater, indicated by inhibition rate for microalgae (primary producers) and immobilization rate for crustaceans (secondary consumers), were reduced by 96.1% and 82.5% in 2-fold and 4-fold diluted groundwater, respectively, after treatment with the MF-HT for 60 min. These results indicate that MF-HT has an excellent safety record for aquatic organisms. After clarifying the adsorption mechanism, excellent reusability of MF-HT was also confirmed after regeneration using 1 M Na₂CO₃ solution. Considering the efficacy, speed, safety and cost of MF-HT, it could be a novel promising material for solving the problem of hydrogen sulfide pollution in the hydrosphere.