A neutron diffraction study of the crystal of benzoic acid from 6 to 293 K and a macroscopic-scale quantum theory of the lattice of hydrogen-bonded dimers

1H/17O Chemical Shift Waves in Carboxyl-Bridged Hydrogen Bond Networks in Organic Solids

We report solid-state 1H and 17O NMR results for four 17O-labeled organic compounds each containing an extensive carboxyl-bridged hydrogen bond (CBHB) network in the crystal lattice: tetrabutylammonium hydrogen di-[17O2]salicylate (1), [17O4]quinolinic acid (2), [17O4]dinicotinic acid (3), and [17O2]Gly/[17O2]Gly·HCl cocrystal (4). The 1H isotropic chemical shifts found for protons involved in different CBHB networks are between 8.2 and 20.5 ppm, which reflect very different hydrogen-bonding environments. Similarly, the 17O isotropic chemical shifts found for the carboxylate oxygen atoms in CBHB networks, spanning a large range between 166 and 341 ppm, are also remarkably sensitive to the hydrogen-bonding environments. We introduced a simple graphical representation in which 1H and 17O chemical shifts are displayed along the H and O atomic chains that form the CBHB network. In such a depiction, because wavy patterns are often observed, we refer to these wavy patterns as 1H/17O chemical shift waves. Typical patterns of 1H/17O chemical shift waves in CBHB networks are discussed. The reported 1H and 17O NMR parameters for the CBHB network models examined in this study can serve as benchmarks to aid in spectral interpretation for CBHB networks in proteins.

Potential energy barrier for proton transfer in compressed benzoic acid

Benzoic acid (BA) is a model system for studying proton transfer (PT) reactions. The properties of solid BA subject to high pressure (exceeding 1 kbar = 0.1 GPa) are of particular interest due to the possibility of compression-tuning of the PT barrier. Here we present simulations aimed at evaluating the value of this barrier in solid BA in the 1 atm - 15 GPa pressure range. We find that pressure-induced shortening of O⋯O contacts within the BA dimers leads to a decrease in the PT barrier, and subsequent symmetrization of the hydrogen bond. However, this effect is obtained only after taking into account zero-point energy (ZPE) differences between BA tautomers and the transition state. The obtained results shed light on previous experiments on compressed benzoic acid, and indicate that a common scaling behavior with respect to the O⋯O distance might be applicable for hydrogen-bond symmetrization in both organic and inorganic systems.

Reliability of the Phonon Density of States Determined by Real-Coded Genetic Algorithm from Heat Capacities of Benzoic Acid Crystals

Constant-pressure heat capacities (C_Ps) of crystalline benzoic acid (BAh) and its deuterated analogue (C₆H₅COOD, BAd) were measured by adiabatic calorimetry, and the phonon density (g(ω)) of states was determined from their C_P data using a real-coded genetic algorithm (RCGA) with just generation gap + real-coded ensemble cross-over. The distribution of g(ω) was in reasonable agreement with the spectroscopic one observed for molecular vibration modes, indicating sufficient reliability of g(ω) determined by the RCGA. Based on the fact that C_Ps reveals an inverse-isotope effect in the temperature range 30-130 K, the determined g(ω)s were used to investigate the molecular mechanism of the effect: g(ω) of BAd revealed blue shifts in the ranges of ω = 80-100 and 150-230 K, as referred to that of BAh. It was suggested from the combined considerations on g(ω) and spectroscopic results that an anticooperative correlation exists between O-H···O hydrogen bonds and interdimer interactions in BA.