Evaluation of non-traditional modifiers for analytical and preparative enantioseparations using supercritical fluid chromatography

Evaluation of greenness and analytical performances of separative methods for chiral separation of novel lactam-based P2RX7-antagonists

In this work, a preparative supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) method was first developed to separate a series of chiral compounds evaluated as lactam-based P2RX7 antagonists. Subsequently, high-performance liquid chromatography, SFC, and capillary electrophoresis (CE) were comparatively investigated as QC tools to determine the enantiomeric purity of the separated isomers, including analytical performance and greenness. The screening of the best conditions was carried out in liquid and SFC on the nine derivatives and the amylose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate)-based chiral stationary phase was found to be highly efficient. The same screening was carried out in CE and very different conditions, either in acidic or basic background electrolyte and different cyclodextrins used as chiral selectors, allowed the separation of six of the nine derivatives. 1-((3,4-Dichlorophenyl)carbamoyl)-5-oxopyrrolidine-2-carboxylic acid (compound 1) was chosen as a probe, and its semi-preparative separation by SFC and enantiomeric verification using the three techniques are presented. Its limit of detection and limit of quantification are calculated for each method. Finally, the greenness of each quality control method was evaluated.

Investigation into the performance and stability of immobilized and coated polysaccharide columns in supercritical fluid chromatography

In this study, the performance of the widely used "golden four" coated chiral stationary phases (Chiralpak AD-3, Chiralcel OD-3, Chiralpak AS-3, and Chiralcel OJ-3) was compared with their corresponding immobilized versions (Chiralpak IA-3, Chiralpak IB-3, Chiralpak IB N-3, Chiralpak IH-3, and Chiralpak IJ-3) under supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) conditions with a set of 30 racemic compounds. Using the traditional modifiers, methanol and isopropanol, the immobilized columns (Chiralpak IB N-3 and Chiralpak IH-3) showed an improved general ability to successfully resolve the enantiomers of the target analytes relative to their coated versions (Chiralcel OD-3 and Chiralpak AS-3), while the coated columns (Chiralpak AD-3, Chiralcel OD-3, and Chiralcel OJ-3) performed better than their immobilized versions (Chiralpak IA-3, Chiralpak IB-3, and Chiralpak IJ-3). An investigation of the non-traditional modifiers, dichloromethane, ethyl acetate, and tetrahydrofuran with immobilized columns, revealed a generally decreased ability to successfully resolve the enantiomers of the target analytes, relative to the use of the traditional modifiers, methanol and isopropanol. The stability of the coated columns (Chiralpak AD-H and Chiralcel OD-H) was evaluated by injecting "forbidden" solvents, including dichloromethane, dimethyl sulfoxide, and tetrahydrofuran. After 200 injections of these solvents on coated columns, the retention factors and resolutions slightly decreased, and a significant increase in column backpressure was observed, indicating some degree of stationary phase degradation.

Chiral chromatography method screening strategies: Past, present and future

Method screening is an integral part of chromatographic method development for the separation of racemates. Due to the highly complex retention mechanism of a chiral stationary-phase, it is often difficult, if not impossible, to device predefined method-development steps that can be successfully applied to a wide group of molecules. The standard approach is to evaluate or screen a series of stationary and mobile-phase combinations to increase the chances of detecting a suitable separation condition. Such a process is often the rate-limiting step for high-throughput analyses and purification workflows. To address the problem, several solutions and strategies have been proposed over the years for reduction of net method-screening time. Some of the strategies have been adopted in practice while others remained confined in the literature. The main objective of this review is to revisit, critically discuss and compile the solutions published over the last two decades. We expect that making the diverse set of solutions available in a single document will help assessing the adequacy of existing screening protocols in laboratories conducting chiral separation.

Analytical and preparative enantioseparations in supercritical fluid chromatography using different brands of immobilized cellulose tris (3,5-dichlorophenylcarbamate) columns: Some differences

The aim of this study was to determine the impact of the origin and the manufacturing processes of the chiral stationary phases (CSPs) on their chromatographic behaviors. Hence, four chiral stationary phases based on immobilized tris (3,5-dichlorophenylcarbamate) derivative of cellulose supplied by four different manufacturers were evaluated. A set of twenty-nine compounds, including commercially available and in-house synthesized compounds, with a broad range of lipophilicity and polarity was chosen. Three main parameters were evaluated on all stationary phases: retention factor, selectivity and loading capacity. This work highlighted that the retention factor strongly varied according to the manufacturer. Regardless of the characteristic of the tested compounds i.e. neutral, acidic or basic, there was a trend in retention ability of the four chiral stationary phases: retention was increasing from CHIRAL ART Cellulose-SC, REFLECT I-Cellulose C, Chiralpak IC to Lux i-Cellulose-5. On the contrary, selectivity did not follow the same trend as retention. The difference in selectivity between each column towards one compound was quite low while the difference in resolution depended on the nature of the compounds investigated and was significant in certain cases. Finally, the four different columns presented similar and high loading capacity.

Ramifications and Insights on the Role of Water in Chiral Sub/Supercritical Fluid Chromatography

More than 40 cosolvents have been used with carbon dioxide to alter its solvation strength. Among the most interesting systems is the subcritical/supercritical CO₂/alkanol eluents. Using small amounts of water in CO₂/MeOH is known to be beneficial in chiral subcritical/supercritical chromatography. However, the ramifications of introducing water as a cosolvent component is not entirely understood. In this work, we demonstrate important aspects of the CO₂/MeOH/H₂O system on nine chiral stationary phases with very different surface chemistries, encompassing derivatized polysaccharides, macrocyclic glycopeptides, iso-butylmercaptoquinine, isopropyl macrocyclic oligosaccharides, and π-electron acceptor/π-electron donor phases. A hydrophilicity scale has been shown to be useful in predicting if a given chiral column chemistry would show a significant enhancement in separation efficiency in the presence of water in the CO₂/MeOH system. We demonstrate up to 8-fold enhancements in plate counts of chiral separations with a concomitant decrease in retention times, as predicted by the qualitative test. The same chiral analysis can now be completed in almost a third of the time with the addition of small amounts of water, thereby decreasing organic solvent consumption by a considerable amount. Hydrophobic stationary phases show a minimal increase in efficiency and decrease in analysis times and optimized separations show much larger reduced plate heights, compared to more hydrophilic stationary phases. Furthermore, the presence of water can alter the nature of the adsorption isotherm under nonlinear conditions. Small amounts of water can be used to tune nonlinear tailing peaks into fronting ones, significantly improving preparative enantiomeric separations.

Productivity and solvent waste in supercritical fluid chromatography for preparative chiral separations: a guide for a convenient strategy

The advent of supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) in the 90s has changed preparative liquid chromatography. SFC is an improved way for separating chiral compounds during drug discovery processes yielding upwards of one hundred grams of pure enantiomers or during clinical trials requiring higher quantities. The need to purify approximately 45 mg of racemic mixture raises concerns regarding processing parameters, including injection volumes and frequency, column size, chromatographic method, and feed composition. In this study, Chiralpak® AD-H amylose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) polysaccharide-based stationary phase columns of various dimensions were investigated for the purification of propranolol using EtOH (+0.3% triethylamine)/CO₂ 15/85 v/v as the mobile phase. Production rate (mg/h), productivity (kilograms of racemate separated per kilogram of chiral stationary phase per day; kkd), solvent usage (L/g) and environmental factor (E Factor) were calculated for four column sizes for sequence and stacked modes of injection. The parameters were optimized to determine a method yielding high productivity or reduced environmental impact. In the stacked mode of injection, which allows for rapid processing compared with the sequential mode, the shortest column presents the best productivity of 0.176 kkd. A semi-preparative column (30 mm i.d.) yielded the best production rate of 467 mg purified per hour but had the worst environmental impact with an E Factor of approximately 56,414 (due to the solvent volume used during column equilibration). At Column Dilution (ACD) and mixed stream injection mode were also compared to separate 495 mg of propranolol. With ACD injection, 915 mL of ethanol and approximately 48 min were required, whereas with mixed stream injection, 1200 mL of ethanol and 63 min were required.

Doing more with less: Evaluation of the use of high linear velocities in preparative supercritical fluid chromatography

The evaluation of higher than typical linear velocities is discussed for supercritical fluid chromatographic purifications on the preparative scale. SFC separation efficiency suffers far less at high linear velocities than HPLC by the rapid mass transfer of analytes carried by compressed CO₂ through the stationary phase. The technique is discussed using chiral test compounds and columns. In many cases, running at high linear velocities can yield significant time savings and decreased consumption of mobile phase solvent, while also lowering energy consumption. Within the practical limitations of commercial instrumentation, using 20 μm particles can aid in achieving higher linear velocities not attainable with smaller 5 μm particles, particularly when running with high percentages of organic co-solvent. Use of larger particles for the stationary phase also lowers the associated column cost. These benefits can yield an overall purification process that is more productive and environmentally friendly.

Enhanced fluidity liquid chromatography: A guide to scaling up from analytical to preparative separations

The evolution of supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) instrumentation, improved detection capability, and expanded modifier range has led to extending the reach of SFC to the analysis of a broader spectrum of analytes beyond enantioselective separations. However, preparative SFC has yet to see the same technological revitalization, especially in regards to the purification of highly polar analytes. Enhanced fluidity liquid chromatography (EFLC) has been demonstrated as one of the ways to extend the applicable range of SFC instrumentation to highly polar analytes such as proteins, carbohydrates, and nucleotides. Despite recent applications of EFLC for challenging mixtures of hydrophilic metabolites and analogs, its viability in preparative purification, which is of great importance to the pharmaceutical industry, remains unknown. Herein, multiple chromatographic parameters that are critical to achieve feasible EFLC purification methods were investigated, including system pressure as a function of modifier composition (for several MeOH:H₂O ratios), effect of diluent injection conditions on peak shape, and optimization of mass load with diluent composition. The usage of 50% acetonitrile or methanol diluents provided the most volumetric loading capacity. In the case of sucrose, leveraging higher analyte solubility in water proved to be more favorable than the volumetric loading capacity of diluents with higher organic content. In fact, an 80 mg injection of sucrose was possible on a 2 cm preparative HILIC column with minimal peak shape degradation. The combined information led to the successful demonstration of EFLC for the preparative separation of sugars using readily available MS-directed SFC instrumentation.

Rapid purification of diastereoisomers from Piper kadsura using supercritical fluid chromatography with chiral stationary phases

Supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) with chiral stationary phases (CSPs) is an advanced solution for the separation of achiral compounds in Piper kadsura. Analogues and stereoisomers are abundant in natural products, but there are obstacles in separation using conventional method. In this paper, four lignan diastereoisomers, (-)-Galbelgin, (-)-Ganschisandrin, Galgravin and (-)-Veraguensin, from Piper kadsura were separated and purified by chiral SFC. Purification strategy was designed, considering of the compound enrichment, sample purity and purification throughput. Two-step achiral purification method on chiral preparative columns with stacked automated injections was developed. Unconventional mobile phase modifier dichloromethane (DCM) was applied to improve the sample solubility. Four diastereoisomers was prepared at the respective weight of 103.1mg, 10.0mg, 152.3mg and 178.6mg from 710mg extract with the purity of greater than 98%.

Preliminary kinetic evaluation of an immobilized polysaccharide sub-2μm column using a low dispersion supercritical fluid chromatograph

The performance of a 3×50mm, 1.6μm d_p column with an immobilized polysaccharide stationary phase (ChiralPak IA-U) was evaluated for efficiency, and pressure drop, with respect to flow rate and modifier concentration using supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC). This appears to be the first such report using such a column in SFC. A unique low dispersion (ultra-high performance) SFC was used for the evaluation. The minimum reduced plate height of 2.78, indicates that the maximum efficiency was similar to or better than coated polysaccharide columns. Selectivity was different from ChiralPak AD, with the same chiral selector, as reported by many others. At high flows and high methanol concentrations, pump pressures sometimes approached 600bar. With 5% methanol, pressure vs. flow rate was non-linear suggesting turbulent flow in the connector tubing. The optimum flow rate (F_opt) at 40% methanol was ≈0.8mL/min, where the column efficiency was highest. At 5% methanol, F_opt increased to ≈1.6mL/min, but efficiency degraded noticeably. The differences in F_opt suggests that the solute diffusion coefficients are a strong function of modifier concentration. Several sub-1min separations, including a 7.5s separation, are presented.

Preparative Scale Resolution of Enantiomers Enables Accelerated Drug Discovery and Development

The provision of pure enantiomers is of increasing importance not only for the pharmaceutical industry but also for agro-chemistry and biotechnology. In drug discovery and development, the enantiomers of a chiral drug depict unique chemical and pharmacological behaviors in a chiral environment, such as the human body, in which the stereochemistry of the chiral drugs determines their pharmacokinetic, pharmacodynamic and toxicological properties. We present a number of challenging case studies of up-to-kilogram separations of racemic or enriched isomer mixtures using preparative liquid chromatography and super critical fluid chromatography to generate individual enantiomers that have enabled the development of new candidate drugs within AstraZeneca. The combination of chromatography and racemization as well as strategies on when to apply preparative chiral chromatography of enantiomers in a multi-step synthesis of a drug compound can further facilitate accelerated drug discovery and the early clinical evaluation of the drug candidates.

Ultrafast chiral separations for high throughput enantiopurity analysis

Ultrafast chiral chromatography enables high throughput enantiopurity analysis (over one thousand samples in an 8 h workday) for enantioselective synthesis investigations.