Correct assignment of lipophilic dye mixtures? A case study for high-performance thin-layer chromatography–mass spectrometry and performance data for the TLC–MS Interface

Thin layer chromatography/desorption flame-induced atmospheric pressure chemical ionization/mass spectrometry for the analysis of volatile and semi-volatile mixtures

Flame-induced atmospheric pressure chemical ionization (FAPCI) has been used to directly characterize chemical compounds on a glass rod and drug tablet surfaces. In this study, FAPCI was further applied to interface thin layer chromatography (TLC) and mass spectrometry (MS) for mixture analysis.

METHODS

A micro-sized oxyacetylene flame was generated using a small concentric tube system. Hot gas flow and primary reactive species from the micro-flame were directed toward a developed TLC gel plate to thermally desorb and ionize analytes on the gel surface. The resulting analyte ions subsequently entered the MS inlet for detection.

RESULTS

A 1-1.5-mm-wide light-brown line was observed on the TLC plate after the desorption FAPCI/MS (DFAPCI/MS) analysis, revealing that the gel surface withstood a high temperature from the impact of the micro-flame. Volatile and semi-volatile chemical compounds, including amine and amide standards, drugs, and aromatherapy oils, were successfully desorbed, ionized, and detected using this TLC/DFAPCI/MS. The limit of detection of TLC-DFAPCI/MS was determined to be 5 ng/spot for dibenzylamine and ethenzamide.

CONCLUSIONS

TLC/DFAPCI/MS is one of the simplest TLC-MS interfaces showing the advantages such as low costs and an easy set up. The technique is useful for characterizing thermally stable volatile and semi-volatile compounds in a mixture.

High-performance thin-layer chromatography–direct bioautography combined with chemometrics for the distinction of goldenrod species

Thirteen root extract samples of four goldenrod (Solidago) species present in Europe were investigated by hyphenated high-performance thin-layer chromatography (HPTLC). Only S. virgaurea is native, whereas S. gigantea, S. canadensis, and S. graminifolia have been introduced from North America. The bioactive zones in the Aliivibrio fischeri bioautogram were identified as polyacetylenes, labdane diterpenes, or clerodane diterpenes by HPTLC coupled to high-resolution mass spectrometry, exploiting the two interfaces, heated electrospray ionization, and direct analysis in real time. Principal component analysis of the obtained bioprofiles enabled the discrimination of the Solidago species. Furthermore, chemometrics pointed to the discriminative components, the main bioactive markers of the species: Z,Z-matricaria ester from S. virgaurea, solidagenone from S. canadensis, solidagoic acid A, and a dialdehyde clerodane diterpene from S. gigantea, and Z-dehydromatricaria ester from S. graminifolia.

Goldenrod Root Compounds Active against Crop Pathogenic Fungi

Root extracts of three goldenrods were screened for antimicrobial compounds. 2Z,8Z- and 2E,8Z-matricaria esters from European goldenrod (Solidago virgaurea) and E- and Z-dehydromatricaria esters from grass-leaved goldenrod (Solidago graminifolia) and first from showy goldenrod (Solidago speciosa) were identified by high-performance thin-layer chromatography combined with effect-directed analysis and high-resolution mass spectrometry or nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy after liquid chromatographic fractionation and isolation. Next to their antibacterial effects (against Bacillus subtilis, Aliivibrio fischeri, and Pseudomonas syringae pv. maculicola), they inhibited the crop pathogenic fungi Fusarium avenaceum and Bipolaris sorokiniana with half maximal inhibitory concentrations (IC₅₀) between 31 and 107 μg/mL. Benzyl 2-hydroxy-6-methoxybenzoate, for the first time found in showy goldenrod root, showed the strongest antifungal effect, with IC₅₀ of 25-26 μg/mL for both fungal strains.

Imaging high-performance thin-layer chromatography as powerful tool to visualize metabolite profiles of eight Bacillus candidates upon cultivation and growth behavior

Imaging high-performance thin-layer chromatography (HPTLC) was explored with regard to its ability to visualize changes in the metabolite profile of bacteria. Bacillus subtilis has become a model organism in many fields. The increasing interest in these bacteria is driven by their attributed probiotic activity. However, growth behavior and metabolism of Bacillus species have a considerable influence on their activity and secondary metabolite profile. On the HPTLC plate, cultivation broths of Bacillus species (B. subtilis, B. licheniformis, B. pumilus and B. amyloliquefaciens) and some B. subtilis strains of high genetic similarity up to 99.5% were applied directly and compared with their respective liquid-liquid extracts. The latter as well as the cultivation in a minimal medium reduced the matrix load and improved the zone resolution. Cultivation parameters such as nutrient supply, cultivation temperature, cultivation time and rotational speed (oxygen level) as well as medium change were shown to have a considerable influence on the growth behavior and resulting metabolite profiles. Imaging HPTLC turned out to be an efficient and affordable tool to visualize such influences of cultivation parameters on the metabolite profiles. It converts the complexity of reaction processes occurring during cell cultivation in easy-to-understand images, which are helpful to figure out factors of influence and understand activity changes. The results highlighted that optimal cultivation conditions need to be found for the intended bacterial application, and in particular, these conditions have to be kept constant. It must be ensured that small variations in cultivation parameters of bacteria do not change the specified (probiotic) effect on the health of animals and humans. The HPTLC metabolite profiles represented the cultivation conditions of specific bacteria and were found to be a proof of the activity of distinct bacteria. In addition, HPTLC can also be used to optimize and streamline the culture media. The quality control of cultivation or fermentation processes can benefit from such a powerful tool, as a picture is worth a thousand words.

Open-source add-on kit for automation of zone elution in planar chromatography

RATIONALE

High-throughput capacity, maximal efficiency and automation are missing key features for thin-layer chromatography/high-performance thin-layer chromatography-mass spectrometry (TLC/HPTLC-MS) hyphenations. So far, commercial interfaces have been operated without an automated positioning system. Hence, a 3D-printed, fully automated, open-source add-on user interface was built for elution-head-based TLC/HPTLC-MS.

METHODS

Precise plate movement, batch-wise zone elution, and cleaning processes were automated and synchronized with MS data acquisition. The elution head cleaning was made adjustable in intensity and interval, and remaining elution solvent or particles were thoroughly blown out of the MS transfer line. An adjustable short gas beam across the elution zone was integrated to avoid contamination or leakage by released layer particles, or zone distortion by residual eluent flow when lifting the elution head.

RESULTS

By clicking on zones on the chromatogram, these were selected for consecutive automated positioning below the elution head, sealing and elution. Mean spatial deviations of the positioning on 294 target zones were determined to be 160 μm for track-wise and 190 μm for randomized zone positioning order. Reproducibility of the elution of butyl paraben zones (5.4%, 10 ng/band, n = 70) and its quantitative performance (R² = 0.992-0.999, 5-50 ng/band) were proven.

CONCLUSIONS

The stand-alone electronic system design and the compact footprint were achieved by a minimalistic positioning system and internally installed valves. The open-source OC_manager software opened new perspectives in terms of combining MS data evaluation with previous HPTLC results. The successfully demonstrated TLC/HPTLC-MS automation presents a highly efficient, user-independent hyphenation for a broad range of application fields.

Analysis of unauthorized Sudan dyes in food by high-performance thin-layer chromatography

Food authenticity and food safety are of high importance to organizations as well as to the food industry to ensure an accurate labeling of food products. Respective analytical methods should provide a fast screening and a reliable cost-efficient quantitation. HPTLC was pointed out as key analytical technique in this field. A new HPTLC method applying caffeine-impregnated silica gel plates was developed for eight most frequently found fat-soluble azo dyes unauthorizedly added to spices, spice mixtures, pastes, sauces, and palm oils. A simple post-chromatographic UV irradiation provided an effective sample cleanup, which took 4 min for up to 46 samples in parallel. The method was trimmed to enable 23 simultaneous separations within 20 min for quantitation or 46 separations within 5 min for screening. Linear (4-40 ng/band) or polynomial (10-200 ng/band) calibrations of the eight azo dyes revealed high correlation coefficients and low standard deviations. Limits of detection and quantification were determined to be 2-3 and 6-9 ng/zone, respectively. After an easy sample extraction, recoveries of 70-120% were obtained from chili, paprika, and curcuma powder as well as from chili sauce, curry paste, and palm oil spiked at low (mainly 25-50 mg/kg) and high levels (150-300 mg/kg). For unequivocal identification, the compound in a suspect zone was eluted via a column into the mass spectrometer. This resulted in the hyphenation HPTLC-vis-HPLC-DAD-ESI-MS. Graphical abstract Simplified clean-up by UV irradiation for Sudan dye analysis in food by HPTLC-vis-HPLC-DAD-ESI-MS.

Open-Source-Based 3D Printing of Thin Silica Gel Layers in Planar Chromatography

On the basis of open-source packages, 3D printing of thin silica gel layers is demonstrated as proof-of-principle for use in planar chromatography. A slurry doser was designed to replace the plastic extruder of an open-source Prusa i3 printer. The optimal parameters for 3D printing of layers were studied, and the planar chromatographic separations on these printed layers were successfully demonstrated with a mixture of dyes. The layer printing process was fast. For printing a 0.2 mm layer on a 10 cm × 10 cm format, it took less than 5 min. It was affordable, i.e., the running costs for producing such a plate were less than 0.25 Euro and the investment costs for the modified hardware were 630 Euro. This approach demonstrated not only the potential of the 3D printing environment in planar chromatography but also opened new avenues and new perspectives for tailor-made plates, not only with regard to layer materials and their combinations (gradient plates) but also with regard to different layer shapes and patterns. As such an example, separations on a printed plane layer were compared with those obtained from a printed channeled layer. For the latter, 40 channels were printed in parallel on a 10 cm × 10 cm format for the separation of 40 samples. For producing such a channeled plate, the running costs were below 0.04 Euro and the printing process took only 2 min. All modifications of the device and software were released open-source to encourage reuse and improvements and to stimulate the users to contribute to this technology. By this proof-of-principle, another asset was demonstrated to be integrated into the Office Chromatography concept, in which all relevant steps for online miniaturized planar chromatography are performed by a single device.

Molecular Ionization-Desorption Analysis Source (MIDAS) for Mass Spectrometry: Thin-Layer Chromatography

Molecular ionization-desorption analysis source (MIDAS), which is a desorption atmospheric pressure chemical ionization (DAPCI) type source, for mass spectrometry has been developed as a multi-functional platform for the direct sampling of surfaces. In this article, its utility for the analysis of thin-layer chromatography (TLC) plates is highlighted. Amino acids, which are difficult to visualize without staining reagents or charring, were detected and identified directly from a TLC plate. To demonstrate the full potential of MIDAS, all active ingredients from an analgesic tablet, separated on a TLC plate, were successfully detected using both positive and negative ion modes. The identity of each of the compounds was confirmed from their mass spectra and compared against standards. Post separation, the chemical signal (blue permanent marker) as reference marks placed at the origin and solvent front were used to calculate retention factor (Rf) values from the resulting ion chromatogram. The quantitative capabilities of the device were exhibited by scanning caffeine spots on a TLC plate of increasing sample amount. A linear curve based on peak are, R2 = 0.994, was generated for seven spots ranging from 50 to 1000 ng of caffeine per spot.

Production of cyathane type secondary metabolites by submerged cultures of Hericium erinaceus and evaluation of their antibacterial activity by direct bioautography

Background

Fungi of the phylum Basidiomycota are well-known to form a broad spectrum of biologically active secondary metabolites, especially low molecular weight compounds such as terpenoids. Hericium erinaceus produces various cyathane type diterpenoids including erinacines. However, no quantitative data and production kinetics have been reported on the biosynthesis of the erinacines C and P in submerged cultures. In the present study, the production of erinacine C was optimized, and the product formation kinetics as well as the antimicrobial activity were studied by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), high-performance thin-layer chromatography (HPTLC) and direct bioautography.

Results

Oatmeal and Edamin^® K were identified to be crucial media components for an efficient production of erinacine C. The highest concentrations of erinacine C were obtained in the optimized culture medium on the 9^th culture day (approximately 260 mg L⁻¹). The production of erinacine P was strongly time dependent. The maximum concentration of erinacine P of 184 mg L⁻¹ was observed on the third culture day. Afterwards, the concentrations of erinacine P decreased while the concentrations of erinacine C steadily increased. Comparable results were obtained by HPTLC with UV detection and HPLC with diode-array detection (DAD) analyses. Direct bioautography allowed for an additional analysis of the antimicrobial activity of the secondary metabolites.

Conclusions

The C and N sources oatmeal and Edamin^® K induced the formation of erinacine C. Detailed product formation kinetics of the erinacines C and P have been reported for the first time. HPTLC combined with the Aliivibrio fischeri bioassay allowed for an instant detection of cyathane diterpenoids in crude extracts and for an evaluation of the antimicrobial activity of the secondary metabolites directly on the plate.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s40694-015-0018-y) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.