Simultaneous separation of small interfering RNA and lipids using ion-pair reversed-phase liquid chromatography

Stability indicating ion-pair reversed-phase liquid chromatography method for modified mRNA

Modified messenger RNA (mRNA) represents a rapidly emerging class of therapeutic drug product. Development of robust stability indicating methods for control of product quality are therefore critical to support successful pharmaceutical development. This paper presents an ion-pair reversed-phase liquid chromatography (IP-RPLC) method to characterise modified mRNA exposed to a wide set of stress-inducing conditions, relevant for pharmaceutical development of an mRNA drug product. The optimised method could be used for separation and analysis of large RNA, sized up to 1000 nucleotides. Column temperature, mobile phase flow rate and ion-pair selection were each studied and optimised. Baseline separations of the model RNA ladder sample were achieved using all examined ion-pairing agents. We established that the optimised method, using 100 mM Triethylamine, enabled the highest resolution separation for the largest fragments in the RNA ladder (750/1000 nucleotides), in addition to the highest overall resolution for the selected modified mRNA compound (eGFP mRNA, 996 nucleotides). The stability indicating power of the method was demonstrated by analysing the modified eGFP mRNA, upon direct exposure to heat, hydrolytic conditions and treatment with ribonucleases. Our results showed that the formed degradation products, which appeared as shorter RNA fragments in front of the main peak, could be well monitored, using the optimised method, and the relative stability of the mRNA under the various stressed conditions could be assessed.

Liposomes characterization for market approval as pharmaceutical products: Analytical methods, guidelines and standardized protocols

Liposomes are nano-sized lipid-based vesicles widely studied for their drug delivery capabilities. Compared to standard carries they exhibit better properties such as improved site-targeting and drug release, protection of drugs from degradation and clearance, and lower toxic side effects. At present, scientific literature is rich of studies regarding liposomes-based systems, while 14 types of liposomal products have been authorized to the market by EMA and FDA and many others have been approved by national agencies. Although the interest in nanodevices and nanomedicine has steadily increased in the last two decades the development of documentation regulating and standardizing all the phases of their development and quality control still suffers from major inadequacy due to the intrinsic complexity of nano-systems characterization. Many generic documents (Type 1) discussing guidelines for the study of nano-systems (lipidic and not) have been proposed while there is a lack of robust and standardized methods (Type 2 documents). As a result, a widespread of different techniques, approaches and methodologies are being used, generating results of variable quality and hard to compare with each other. Additionally, such documents are often subject to updates and rewriting further complicating the topic. Within this context the aim of this work is focused on bridging the gap in liposome characterization: the most recent standardized methodologies suitable for liposomes characterization are here reported (with the corresponding Type 2 documents) and revised in a short and pragmatical way focused on providing the reader with a practical background of the state of the art. In particular, this paper will put the accent on the methodologies developed to evaluate the main critical quality attributes (CQAs) necessary for liposomes market approval.

Dynamic in situ growth of bonded-phase silica nanospheres on silica capillary inner walls for open-tubular liquid chromatography

Silica nanospheres (SNS) were grown on the inner walls of silica capillaries through a dynamic in situ nucleation process to prepare a highly porous and large accessible surface area substrate. The SNS were then functionalized with octadecyl (C18), 3-aminopropyltriethoxysilane (APTES), beta-cyclodextrin (β-CD), and amino groups to develop robust and efficient chromatographic stationary phases. The modified silica capillaries were exploited for open-tubular liquid chromatography (OT-LC) and open-tubular capillary electrochromatography (OT-CEC) applications. The prepared stationary phases were compared to conventional capillaries in terms of separation performance. The synthesis process was optimized, and the bonded-phase stationary phases were characterized by the electron microscopy technique. The effects of different solvents, additives, and functional groups on the geometry and chromatographic resolving power of the SNS were envisaged. The capillaries modified with octadecyl groups were evaluated for the separation of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, phenones, alkenylbenzenes, and enantiomers of chlorophenoxy herbicides. As an application instance, an SNS-C18-coated capillary was utilized for the separation of alkenylbenzenes from clove extract and protein digest medium, through OT-LC and OT-CEC techniques, respectively. The β-CD functionalized capillary was applied for the OT-CEC separation of a dichlorprop racemic mixture.

Polybutylene terephthalate-based stationary phase for ion-pair-free reversed-phase liquid chromatography of small interfering RNA. Part 1: Direct coupling with mass spectrometry

Nowadays, ion-pairing reversed-phase liquid chromatography (IP-RPLC) is the dominating generic method for the analysis of nucleic acid related compounds, such as antisense-oligonucleotides (ASO), small-interfering ribonucleic acid (siRNA) or other DNA or RNA type molecules and their conjugates. Despite of its effective performance, the usage of a high concentration of ion-pairing reagent in the eluent in IP-RPLC is unfavorable for the hyphenation with mass spectrometry (MS) which is required for a detailed structural characterization of the analytes and their structurally related impurities. In this work, we tested a polybutylene terephthalate (PBT)-bonded silica-based stationary phase for the separation of generically synthesized Patisiran as siRNA (antisense and sense single strands as well as their annealed double strand) giving some unexpected selectivity without any presence of ion-pairing reagents. Important chromatographic conditions affecting the separation have been investigated and evaluated. Furthermore, MS and tandem MS (MS/MS) characterization was possible without contamination of the MS system with ion-pair agent and related problems.

Challenges and emerging trends in liquid chromatography-based analyses of mRNA pharmaceuticals

Lipid encapsulated messenger RNA (LNP mRNA) has garnered a significant amount of interest from the pharmaceutical industry and general public alike. This attention has been catalyzed by the clinical success of LNP mRNA for SARS-CoV-2 vaccination as well as future promises that might be fulfilled by the biotechnology pipeline, such as the in vivo delivery of a CRISPR/Cas9 complex that can edit patient cells to reduce levels of low-density lipoprotein. LNP mRNAs are comprised of various chemically diverse molecules brought together in a sophisticated intermolecular complex. This can make it challenging to achieve thorough analytical characterization. Nevertheless, liquid chromatography is becoming an increasingly relied upon technique for LNP mRNA analyses. Although there have been significant advances in all types of LNP mRNA analyses, this review focuses on recent developments and the possibilities of applying anion exchange (AEX) and ion pairing reversed phase (IP-RP) liquid chromatography for intact mRNAs as well as techniques for oligo mapping analysis, 5' endcap testing and lipid compositional assays.

The Role of Separation Techniques in the Analysis of mRNA Therapeutic Drug Substances and Drug Products

Messenger ribonucleic acids (mRNA) therapeutics are becoming more widespread pharmaceutical tools to treat a wide range of diseases or infections, as highlighted by regulatory approval of two vaccines for SARS‑CoV-2. Alongside their use as vaccines, they also play a role in protein replacement therapy to ensure therapeutic protein is synthesized within the patient. Structural elements, such as the 5’ cap, UTR regions, reading frame, and poly A tail are considered as critical quality attributes (CQAs) that are subject to a range of analytical techniques. However, chromatography and other separation methods are commonly used for characterization and quantification of the drug substance and drug product. This article reviews a range of techniques available for separative analysis of mRNA therapeutics, their associated impurities, and delivery vehicles.

Oligonucleotide separation techniques for purification and analysis: What can we learn for today's tasks?

Nucleic acids are the blueprint of life. They are not only the construction plan of the single cell or higher associations of them, but also necessary for function, communication and regulation. Due to the pandemic, the attention shifted in particular to their therapeutic potential as a vaccine. As pharmaceutical oligonucleotides are unique in terms of their stability and application, special delivery systems were also considered. Oligonucleotide production systems can vary and depend on the feasibility, availability, price and intended application. To achieve good purity, reliable results and match the strict specifications in the pharmaceutical industry, the separation of oligonucleotides is always essential. Besides the separation required for production, additional and specifically different separation techniques are needed for analysis to determine if the product complies with the designated specifications. After a short introduction to ribonucleic acids (RNAs), messenger RNA vaccines, and their production and delivery systems, an overview regarding separation techniques will be provided. This not only emphasises electrophoretic separations but also includes spin columns, extractions, precipitations, magnetic nanoparticles and several chromatographic separation principles, such as ion exchange chromatography, ion-pair reversed-phase, size exclusion and affinity.

A rapid and quantitative reversed-phase HPLC-DAD/ELSD method for lipids involved in nanoparticle formulations

Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) have shown great success as drug delivery systems, especially for mRNA vaccines, as those developed during the Covid-19 pandemics. Lipid analysis is critical to monitor the formulation process and control the quality of LNPs. The present study is focused on the development and validation of a high-performance liquid chromatography – diode array detector –evaporative light scattering detector (HPLC-DAD/ELSD) based method for the simultaneous quantification of 7 lipids, illustrating the main components of LNPs: ionizable lipids, the neutral co-lipid cholesterol, phospholipids, hydrophilic polymer-lipids for colloidal stability (e.g., a PEGylated lipid). In particular, this study focuses on two innovative synthetic lipids: a switchable cationic lipid (CSL3) which has demonstrated in vitro and in vivo siRNA transfection abilities, and the palmitic acid-grafted-poly(ethyloxazoline)₅₀₀₀ (PolyEtOx), used as an alternative polymer to address allergic reactions attributed to PEGylated lipids. The HPLC separation was achieved on a Poroshell C18 column at 50 °C using a step gradient of a mobile phase composed of water/methanol mixtures with 0.1% (v/v) trifluoroacetic acid (TFA). This method was validated following ICH Q2(R1) & (R2) guidelines in terms of linearity (R² ≥ 0.997), precision (relative standard deviation on peak areas < 5% for intermediate repeatability), accuracy (recoveries between 92.9% and 108.5%), and sensitivity. Indeed, low detection and quantitation limits were determined (between 0.02 and 0.04 µg and between 0.04 and 0.10 µg, respectively). Due to its high selectivity, this method allowed the analysis of lipid degradation products produced through degradation studies in basic, acidic, and oxidative conditions. Moreover, the method was successfully applied to the analysis of several liposome formulations at two key steps of the development process. Consequently, the reported HPLC method offers fast, versatile, selective and quantitative analysis of lipids, essential for development optimization, chemical characterization, and stability testing of LNP formulations.

Effect of ion-pairing reagent hydrophobicity on liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry analysis of oligonucleotides

We performed a systematic study of thirteen alkylamines used as ion-pairing reagents for ion-pair reversed-phase liquid chromatography (IP RP LC) separations of oligonucleotides on a C18 column. We proposed a method to classify the hydrophobicity of alkylamines by their retention in RP LC. The IP reagent hydrophobicity correlated with the retention and resolution of oligonucleotides in the corresponding IP mobile phases. The baseline resolution was achieved up to 30 mer for hydrophilic, or up to 50 mer for hydrophobic IP reagents. Hydrophobic alkylamines permitted useful oligonucleotide separations at relatively low buffer concentrations, such as 5-10 mM alkylamine-acetate IP systems. These buffers were compatible with mass spectrometry detection, however, replacement of acetic acid with hexafluoroisopropanol in the mobile phase improved the MS signal by 2-3 orders of magnitude. Experiments with native and chemically modified oligonucleotides highlighted the mixed-mode nature of IP RP LC. When using hydrophobic IP reagents, the ionic retention mechanism of oligonucleotides is enhanced while hydrophobic retention is diminished.

Polymerized phosphonium ionic liquid functionalized silica microspheres as mixed-mode stationary phase for liquid chromatographic separation of phospholipids

There is a large and growing demand for the vigorous development of new high performance liquid chromatography stationary phases in order to solve complex phospholipids separation. Herein, phosphonium-based ionic liquid trioctyl(allyl)phosphonium bromide ([P_888Allyl]Br) was first synthesized with trioctylphosphine and allyl bromide. With [P_888Allyl]Br as the polymerizable monomer, polymerized phosphonium ionic liquid functionalized silica microsphere (PIL@SiO₂) was further synthetized via click chemistry reaction. Significantly, based on the inherent amphiphilic nature of the introduced [P_888Allyl]Br, the packed PIL@SiO₂ column displayed hydrophilic/hydrophobic mixed-mode retention mechanisms. The PIL@SiO₂ column can achieve separation of nucleic acid bases and nucleosides, sulfonamides, amides and anilines with excellent selectivity in a shorter separation time. The column efficiency reached 109,700 N/m for 2-iodoacetamide. One of the important characteristics of the PIL@SiO₂ column is that both phospholipid classes and species can be efficiently separated via the same column, outperforming that of the commercial amino column. Furthermore, the application potential of the PIL@SiO₂ column was further verified via separation of phospholipids extracted from soy lecithin. The proposed PIL@SiO₂ column provides a promising candidate for separation of complex phospholipid samples.

Recent advances in therapeutic nucleic acids and their analytical methods

Therapeutic nucleic acids are various chemically modified RNA or DNA with different functions, which mainly play roles at the gene level. Owing to its accurately targeting at pathogenic genes, nucleic acid based therapeutics have a wide range of application prospects. Recently, the improvement on chemical synthesis and delivery materials accelerated the development of therapeutic nucleic acids rapidly. Up to now, 17 nucleic acid based therapeutics approved by Food and Drug Administration (FDA) or European Medicines Agency (EMA). The development of therapeutics raised higher requirements for analytical methods, both in quality control and in clinical research. The first part of this review introduces different classes of therapeutic nucleic acids, including antisense oligonucleotide (ASO), RNA interference (RNAi) therapy, mRNA, aptamer and other classes which are under research. The second part reviews the therapeutic nucleic acids commercialized from 2019 to now. The third part discusses the analytical methods for nucleic acid based therapeutics, including liquid chromatography-based methods, capillary gel electrophoresis (CGE), hybridization enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and other infrequently used methods. Finally, the advantages and shortcomings of these methods are summarized, and the future development of analysis methods are prospected.

Analytical characterization of DNA and RNA oligonucleotides by hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry

Liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry has been widely implemented as a powerful tool for providing in-depth characterization of nucleic acid therapeutic modalities, such as anti-sense oligonucleotides and small interfering RNAs (siRNAs). In this study, we developed a generic hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) hyphenated with tandem mass spectrometry method in the absence of ion-pairing reagents and demonstrated its capability as an attractive and robust alternative for oligonucleotide and siRNA analysis. HILIC separation of mixtures of unmodified and fully phosphorothioate-modified DNA oligonucleotides and their synthetic 3' exonuclease-digested metabolites were also assessed. High-resolution mass spectrometric (HRMS) analysis was used to determine the deconvoluted masses of oligonucleotide and siRNA standards and their impurities. To enable unbiased sequence characterization with tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS), we also optimized higher-energy C-trap dissociation (HCD) on improving the sequence coverage of DNA and RNA oligonucleotides. Lastly, we evaluated on-column sensitivity for a phosphorothioate oligonucleotide by performing targeted analysis with either targeted selected ion monitoring (tSIM) or parallel reaction monitoring (PRM). Higher on-column sensitivity of 13 ng, equivalent to 2.0 pmol, of a phosphorothioate oligonucleotide was achieved by tSIM analysis as compared to PRM analysis.

Impurity profiling of siRNA by two-dimensional liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry with quinine carbamate anion-exchanger and ion-pair reversed-phase chromatography

A short RNA with the sequence of the antisense strand of Patisiran has been selected as test material for the investigation of its common impurities using three different two-dimensional liquid chromatography (2D-LC) platforms. On the one hand, a quinine (QN) carbamate-based weak anion-exchange (AX) stationary phase (QN-AX) and a classical C18 reversed phase (RP) stationary phase in ion-pair (IP) mode with tripropylammonium acetate, respectively, have been used in the first dimension (¹D) to provide the selectivity for impurities formed during the synthesis of the RNA. In the next step, certain peaks of interest from ¹D have been transferred by multiple-heart-cutting (MHC) into a ²D in which an ESI-MS-compatible non-ionpairing RP method has been used for desalting via a diverter valve to remove non-volatile phosphate buffer components and ion-pair agents, respectively. Thus, a sensitive electrospray-ionization quadrupole time of flight mass spectrometry (ESI-TOF-MS) analysis of resolved impurity peaks of the siRNA has become possible under MS-friendly conditions. With both 2D-LC setups, peak purity of the ON has been evaluated by selective comprehensive (high resolution) sampling of the main peak. In a third MHC 2D-LC approach, the QN-AX LC mode was online coupled with the IP-RPLC in the ²D using UV detection. It allows the separation of additional impurities which coeluted in the first dimension. The potential of these methods for comprehensive impurity profiling of ON therapeutics is illustrated and discussed.

Automated high-throughput preparation and characterization of oligonucleotide-loaded lipid nanoparticles

Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) are increasingly employed to improve delivery efficiency and therapeutic efficacy of nucleic acids. Various formulation parameters can affect the quality attributes of these nanoparticle formulations, but currently there is a lack of systemic screening approaches to address this challenge. Here, we developed an automated high-throughput screening (HTS) workflow for streamline preparation and analytical characterization of LNPs loaded with antisense oligonucleotides (ASOs) in a full 96-well plate within 3 hrs. ASO-loaded LNPs were formulated by an automated solvent-injection method using a robotic liquid handler, and assessed for particle size distribution, encapsulation efficiency, and stability with different formulation compositions and ASO loadings. Results indicated that the PEGylated lipid content significantly affected the particle size distribution, while the ionizable lipid / ASO charge ratio impacted the encapsulation efficiency of ASOs. Furthermore, results from our HTS approach correlated with those from the state-of-the-art scale-up method using a microfluidic formulator, therefore opening up a new avenue for robust formulation development and design of experiment methods, while reducing material usage by 10 folds, improving analytical outputs and accumulation of information by 100 folds.

Analytical characterization of liposomes and other lipid nanoparticles for drug delivery

Lipid nanoparticles, especially liposomes and lipid/nucleic acid complexed nanoparticles have shown great success in the pharmaceutical industry. Their success is attributed to stable drug loading, extended pharmacokinetics, reduced off-target side effects, and enhanced delivery efficiency to disease targets with formidable blood-brain or plasma membrane barriers. Therefore, they offer promising formulation options for drugs limited by low therapeutic indexes in traditional dosage forms and current "undruggable" targets. Recent development of siRNA, antisense oligonucleotide, or the CRISPR complex-loaded lipid nanoparticles and liposomal vaccines also shed light on their potential in enabling versatile formulation platforms for new pharmaceutical modalities. Analytical characterization of these nanoparticles is critical to drug design, formulation development, understanding in vivo performance, as well as quality control. The multi-lipid excipients, unique core-bilayer structure, and nanoscale size all underscore their complicated critical quality attributes, including lipid species, drug encapsulation efficiency, nanoparticle characteristics, product stability, and drug release. To address these challenges and facilitate future applications of lipid nanoparticles in drug development, we summarize available analytical approaches for physicochemical characterizations of lipid nanoparticle-based pharmaceutical modalities. Furthermore, we compare advantages and challenges of different techniques, and highlight the promise of new strategies for automated high-throughput screening and future development.

Characterization of therapeutic oligonucleotides by liquid chromatography

Marketed therapies in the pharmaceutical landscape are rapidly evolving and getting more diverse. Small molecule medicines have dominated in the past while antibodies have grown dramatically in recent years. However, the failure of traditional small and large molecules in accessing certain targets has led to increased R&D efforts to develop alternative modalities. Therapeutic oligonucleotides (ONs) can accurately be directed against their ribonucleic acid (RNA) target and represent a promising approach in previously untreated diseases. Established automated synthesis of ONs coupled with chemical improvements and the advance of new drug delivery technologies has recently brought ONs to a heightened level of interest. The first part of the present review describes the different classes of oligonucleotides, namely antisense oligonucleotide (ASO), small interfering RNA (siRNA), microRNA (miRNA), aptamer and immunostimulatory ON, with a focus on their delivery systems relevant for future analytical characterization. The second part reviews the typical impurities in therapeutic ON products. The third part discusses the use of historical methods anion exchange chromatography (AEX), ion-pair reversed phase liquid chromatography (IP-RP), mixed-mode chromatography (MMC) and recent analytical methodologies of hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC), two-dimensional liquid chromatography (2D-LC) mass spectrometry for the characterization of ASO and siRNA modalities. The effects of physicochemical properties of RPLC columns and ion-pair agents on ON separation are specifically addressed with possible future directions for method development provided. Finally, some innovative analytical developments for the analysis of siRNAs and their delivery materials to pave the way toward the use of multi-attribute methods in the near future are discussed.