Column length is a structure-independent measure of solvent consumption in liquid chromatography

The best structures of LC columns-A theoretical perspective

The largest peak capacity (n) that LC analysis can generate in isocratic or gradient elution analysis of a given sample in a given time at a given pressure is proportional to the quality factor (qmax) of its column structure. In this study, the multi-channel structures with open pseudo-planar channels (OPPC) and open circular channels (OCC) where compared with PC2 - a typical core-shell column packed with 2 μm particles. These columns have qmax of 1.27, 1.17 and 0.41, respectively. The former two qmax are the highest among all known column structures - about 3 times higher than qmax of PC2. This means that the OPPC and OCC can generate about 3 times higher n compared to what a PC2 can in the same analysis time (tanal) at the same pressure, or they require about 81 times shorter tanal (81 is the 4th power of 3) to generate the same n as a PC2 can at the same pressure. However, while PC2 is a commercially available column, there are substantial challenges in manufacturing the OPPC and OCC that can compete with PC2 in practical applications. In order to be competitive with PC2, the OPPC and OCC should have sub-1μm characteristic dimensions (e.g., the inter-pillar distance, g, in OPPC-based pillar array columns, internal diameters of OCC). Thus, in order to compete with PC2 in one scenario, an OPPC requires g ≤ 0.14 μm. Additionally, to be competitive with PC2, OPPC and OCC should be able to sustain the same high pressure. Highlighting the challenges of their design and manufacturing might help to develop the manufacturable columns substantially superior to the packed ones.

Dimensionless plate height is unsuitable for comparing chromatographic columns

Dimensionless plate height (h) is differently defined for the columns with different type of internal filling (internal support structure). It is h = H/d for open columns (d is the internal diameter), h = H/dp for packed columns (dp is the particle size), h = H/ddom (ddom is the domain size) for columns with other filling (e.g., monolithic, pillar array). The plate height (H) and the column kinetic performance in general depend on the flow channels through the column filling - on their cross-sectional dimensions (dchan), shape, and wall porosity. Other than through their effect on the flow channels, the dimensions of skeleton of the filling and the ddom do not affect H. Parameters d, dp and ddom cannot be found from external measurements of a column as a "black box" separation device and, therefore, are unmeasurable subjective metrics, and, therefore, so is h. Moreover, in some fillings (e.g., monolithic, pillar array) ddom can be chosen independently of dchan. By increasing ddom without changing dchan, one can make h as small as desired with no effect on H and on the column kinetic performance in general. This implies that h does not represent column performance and cannot be used for comparing differently structured column. In this report, previously introduced measurable (objective) performance metrics - the kinetic performance factor (q) and the quality factor (qmax) are described and evaluated. The latter is suitable for comparing differently structured columns. A column practically achievable performance depends not only on qmax, but on the largest pressure that a column can tolerate, the narrowest flow channels that can be manufactured and other practical factors. Practically achievable performance of several column types is compared in this report.

Transport diameters of liquid chromatography columns

The transport diameter (d_M) of a chromatographic column is an objective (measurable) representation of cross-sectional dimensions of the column flow-through channels, and of the effect of porosity of the column internal support structure on velocity of transporting solvent molecules along the column. A column kinetic performance is trade-off between the column separation performance, analysis time and pressure. The d_M is a key factor in definition of the kinetic performance factor - an objective metric of a column kinetic performance - and of other objective performance metrics. General equations for evaluation of d_M are developed. The d_M of PLOT, particulate and pillar-array columns are evaluated and discussed.