The influence of descriptor database selection on the solvation parameter model for separation processes

Guidelines for descriptor assignments for the solvation parameter model by separation techniques

The solvation parameter model uses six compound descriptors to model equilibrium properties in biphasic systems formally defined as excess molar refraction, E, dipolarity/polarizability, S, overall hydrogen-bond acidity, A, overall hydrogen-bond basicity, B, McGowan's characteristic volume, V, and the gas-liquid partition constant on hexadecane at 25 °C, L. The V descriptor can be assigned from structure and the E descriptor for compounds liquid at 20 °C can be calculated from its refractive index and characteristic volume. The E descriptor for compounds solid at 20 °C and the S, A, B, and L descriptors are assigned from experimental properties traditionally obtained by chromatographic, liquid-liquid partition, and solubility measurements. Here I report an efficient experimental design using the Solver method for the accurate assignment of descriptors for neutral compounds that simultaneously minimizes laboratory resources. This multi-technique approach requires 3 retention factor measurements in a 60 °C temperature range per compound on four columns by gas chromatography, 3 retention factor measurements in a 30 % (v/v) acetonitrile composition range per compound on two columns by reversed-phase liquid chromatography, and eight partition constant measurements by liquid-liquid partition in totally organic and aqueous biphasic systems for a total of 26 experimental measurements. The accuracy of the descriptor assignments was validated by comparison with the values in the Wayne State University (WSU) descriptor database taken as the best estimate of the true descriptor values. The E, S, A, B and L descriptors were assigned simultaneously by the Solver method using the above approach without significant bias and with an average absolute deviation (AAD) of 0.054, 0.018, 0.015, 0.013, and 0.040, respectively, compared with the WSU database values, corresponding to a relative absolute average deviation in percent (RAAD) of 7.2, 1.9, 3.6, 5.1, and 0.84 %, respectively, for 32 varied compounds. This streamlined approach represents a significant improvement on earlier single-technique approaches used as the starting point for the development of the multi-technique approach. For compounds of variable hydrogen-bond basicity modifications to the multi-technique approach were implemented while maintaining the same number of experimental measurements. Acceptable descriptor assignments for B/B° were obtained for compounds liquid at 20 °C for which the E descriptor was available by calculation. For solid compounds at 20 °C the E and B/B° descriptors are restricted to qualitative application where approximate values may be acceptable.

Evaluation of the Goss-modified solvation parameter model for the characterization of biphasic systems and descriptor assignments

The solvation parameter model uses six descriptors identified as excess molar refraction, E, dipolarity/polarizability, S, overall hydrogen-bond acidity, A, overall hydrogen-bond basicity, B, McGowan's characteristic volume, V, and the gas-liquid partition constant on hexadecane at 25 °C, L to model the distribution of neutral compounds in biphasic systems. Abraham's version of this model uses all six descriptors with two separate linear free energy relationship models for the transfer of compounds from a gas phase to a condensed phase and between condensed phases. Goss proposed a modification to this model that uses a single calibration model regardless of the physical state for each phase and five of the descriptors employed in Abraham's model (E descriptor is eliminated). The capability of Abraham's model and the Goss-modified model to characterize the contribution of intermolecular interaction to retention for gas and reversed-phase liquid chromatographic systems and distribution in liquid-liquid partition systems is evaluated using the WSU compound descriptor database. These more accurate values for the Abraham descriptors have not been utilized previously for the evaluation of the Goss-modified model and should be more capable of discerning subtle differences in model performance. It is shown that model quality defined by statistical parameters favors Abraham's model over the Goss-modified model with differences in model quality greater for systems in which Abraham's model indicates a significant contribution from electron lone pair interactions and for systems in which one phase is a solvent containing perfluoroalkyl substituents. There is a small systematic difference for the terms describing the combined contributions of cavity formation and dispersion interactions and for interactions of a dipole-type. The contribution of hydrogen-bonding interactions is virtually identical for the two models. The model intercepts are generally different and potentially assigned to a larger contribution from lack-of-fit for the Goss-modified model. Although the Abraham model descriptors have been routinely employed for applications using the Goss-modified model the possibility that Goss-model specific descriptors should be employed was evaluated. Using the Solver method and Goss-model specific calibration models for chromatographic and liquid-liquid partition systems a new set of Goss-specific descriptors was calculated for 28 varied compounds. These descriptors show good statistical agreement with the Abraham descriptor values with an average deviation of 0.009, -0.003, -0.004, and -0.023, respectively, for the S, A, B, and L descriptors, corresponding to a relative absolute deviation in percent of 2.2 %, 3.9 %, 4.3 %, and 1.2 %, respectively.

Determination of solvation parameter model compound descriptors by gas chromatography

The solvation parameter model uses five system independent descriptors to characterize compound properties defined as excess molar refraction, E, dipolarity/polarizability, S, hydrogen-bond acidity, A, hydrogen-bond basicity, B, and the gas-liquid partition constant at 25 °C on n-hexadecane, L, to model transfer properties in gas-condensed phase biphasic systems. The E descriptor for compounds liquid at 20 °C is available by calculation using a refractive index value while E for solid compounds at 20 °C and the S, A, B, and L descriptors are determined by experiment. As a single-technique approach, it is shown that with up to 20 retention factor measurements on four columns comprising a poly(siloxane) containing methyloctyl or dimethyldiphenylsiloxane monomers (SPB-Octyl or HP-5), a poly(siloxane) containing methyltrifluoropropylsiloxane monomers (Rtx-OPP or DB-210), a poly(siloxane) containing bis(cyanopropylsiloxane) monomers (HP-88 or SGE BPX-90), and a poly(ethylene glycol) stationary phase (DB-WAXetr or HP-INNOWAX) are suitable for assigning the S, A, and L descriptors. Using the descriptors in the updated WSU compound descriptor database as target values the average absolute error in the descriptor assignments for 52 varied compounds in the temperature range 60-140 °C was 0.072 for E, 0.016 for S, 0.008 for A, and 0.022 for L corresponding to 30 %, 3.5 %, and 0.6 % as a relative average absolute error for E, S, and L, respectively. For the higher temperature range of 160-240 °C and 34 varied compounds that are liquid at 20 °C the average absolute error for the S, A and L descriptors was 0.026, 0.020, and 0.031, respectively, with the largest relative average absolute error for S of 3.2 % (< 1 % for the L descriptor). For 35 varied compounds that are solid at 20 °C the relative absolute error for the E, S, A, and L descriptors in the higher temperature range was 0.068, 0.035, 0.020, and 0.020, respectively, with a relative average absolute error for E (6.5 %), S (3.5 %) and L (0.88 %). The S, A, and L descriptor can be accurately assigned on the four-column system over a wide temperature range. The E descriptor for solid compounds at 20 °C exhibits greater variability than desirable. The B descriptor cannot be assigned by the four-column system, which lack hydrogen-bond acid functional groups, and is only poorly assigned on the weak hydrogen-bond acid ionic liquid column SLB-IL100.

Determination of descriptors for the principal flavor compounds of the cinnamons of commerce by gas chromatography and liquid-liquid partition

Descriptors for fourteen semivolatile organic compounds associated with the authenticity, botanical origin, and flavor potential of the cinnamons of commerce were determined using the Solver method and experimental retention factors determined by gas chromatography at several temperatures on a minimum of seven selectivity-selected, open-tubular columns and liquid-liquid partition constants in up to twenty totally organic biphasic systems. The six descriptors that encode the solvation properties of the compounds were used to predict water-gas, octanol-gas, and octanol-water partition constants commonly employed to assess environmental distribution properties. For octanol-water partition constants, log KOW, the predicted partition constants exhibited an average absolute deviation of 0.12 for log KOW experimental - log KOW predicted (n = 14). Soil-water, soil-air, urban aerosol-air, skin-water permeation, and non-specific toxicity to the fathead minnow were predicted for the same compounds to assess their potential environmental impact. The product terms of the solvation parameter model provide a useful insight into the contribution of individual intermolecular interactions to the distribution properties of the cinnamon compounds and their environmental impact.

The effect of the assigned descriptors for phthalate esters on the characterization of their separation properties using the solvation parameter model

Revised descriptors are determined for fifteen phthalate esters for use in the solvation parameter model and form part of the Wayne State University (WSU) compound descriptor database. For thirteen phthalate esters a comparison is made with the same compounds in the Abraham descriptor database. Gas chromatographic retention factors on poly(methyloctylsiloxane), SPB-Octyl, and poly(cyanopropylphenyldimethylsiloxane), DB-225, stationary phases are used to facilitate an assessment of the contribution of cavity formation and dispersion interactions, L descriptor, and dipole-type interactions, S descriptor, to the experimental retention factors (log k) for the phthalate esters with minimum interference from competing intermolecular interactions. The results indicate a systematic overprediction of the cavity and dispersion interaction term and underprediction of dipole-type interactions for the Abraham descriptors compared with the WSU descriptors for the phthalate esters. The average absolute deviation (AAD) for 13 phthalate esters on SPB-Octyl is 0.039 (WSU descriptors) compared with 0.252 (Abraham descriptors) and for 9 phthalate esters on DB-225 0.030 (WSU descriptors) compared with 0.167 (Abraham descriptors). The results for dipole-type interactions are confirmed and extended to include the hydrogen-bond basicity of the phthalate esters, B descriptor, by evaluation of partition constants in aqueous biphasic systems and the n-heptane-2,2,2-trifluoroethanol biphasic system. Differences in the contribution of the hydrogen-bond basicity of the phthalate esters to the experimental partition constants are largely random with respect to database selection but important for the accurate prediction of the partition constants. The AAD for the partition constant for 15 phthalate esters is 0.063 (WSU descriptors) compared with 0.320 (Abraham descriptors) for the heptane-2,2,2-trifluoroethanol biphasic system and 0.13 (WSU descriptors) compared with 0.25 (Abraham descriptors) for 9 phthalate esters in the octanol-water biphasic system. The WSU descriptors for the phthalate esters exhibit a better fit with the experimental data for separation systems and are free of the extreme values predicted for the Abraham descriptors for several phthalate esters.

The effect of descriptor database selection on the physicochemical characterization and prediction of water-air, octanol-air and octanol-water partition constants using the solvation parameter model

The distribution of neutral compounds in biphasic separation systems can be described by the solvation parameter model using six solute properties, or descriptors. These descriptors (McGowan's characteristic volume, excess molar refraction, dipolarity/polarizability, hydrogen-bond acidity and basicity, and the gas-liquid partition constant on n-hexadecane at 298.15 K) are curated in two publicly accessible databases for hundreds (WSU compound descriptor database) or thousands (Abraham compound descriptor database). These databases were developed independently using different approaches resulting in descriptor values that vary for many compounds. Previously, it was shown that the two descriptor databases are not interchangeable, and the WSU descriptor database consistently demonstrated improved model performance for chromatographic systems where the uncertainty in the dependent variable was minimized by suitable quality control and calibration procedures. In this report we wish to evaluate whether the same conclusions are true for models with a dependent variable containing significant measurement uncertainty. To evaluate this hypothesis, we assembled databases for water-air, octanol-air, and octanol-water partition constants reported by multiple laboratories using various measurement methods. It was found that database selection has little effect on model quality or model predictive capability but significantly affects the assignment of the contribution of individual intermolecular interactions to the dependent variable. The latter information is database specific, and a quantitative comparison of system constants should be restricted to models using the same compound descriptor database.

Selectivity evaluation of extraction systems

Extraction is the most common sample preparation technique prior to chromatographic analysis for samples which are too complex, too dilute, or contain matrix components incompatible with the further use of the separation system or interfere in the detection step. The most important extraction techniques are biphasic systems involving the transfer of target compounds from the sample to a different phase ideally accompanied by no more than a tolerable burden of co-extracted matrix compounds. The solvation parameter model affords a general framework to characterize biphasic extraction systems in terms of their relative capability for solute-phase intermolecular interactions (dispersion, dipole-type, hydrogen bonding) and within phase solvent-solvent interactions for cavity formation (cohesion). The approach is general and allows the comparison of liquid and solid extraction phases using the same terms and is used to explain the features important for the selective enrichment of target compounds by a specific extraction phase using solvent extraction, liquid-liquid extraction, and solid-phase extraction for samples in a gas, liquid, or solid phase. Hierarchical cluster analysis with the system constants of the solvation parameter model as variables facilitates the selection of solvents for extraction, the identification of liquid-liquid distribution systems with non-redundant selectivity, and evaluation of different approaches using liquids and solids for the isolation of target compounds from different matrices.