Cetacean Toll-like receptor 4 and myeloid differentiation factor 2, and possible cetacean-specific responses against Gram-negative bacteria

Evolutionary Impacts of Pattern Recognition Receptor Genes on Carnivora Complex Habitat Stress Adaptation

Many mammals develop specific immune responses owing to the changes in their ecological niche and diet that are essential for animal survival. However, pattern recognition receptors (PRRs) serve as the first line of defense in innate immunity and generate immune responses in the host. However, the evolutionary impacts on PRR genes in Carnivora are not well studied. Herein, we explored the evolution of 946 PRR gene sequences in 43 Carnivora species to elucidate the molecular mechanisms of carnivore adaptation to complex habitats. We found that the PRRs were relatively conserved, and different gene families showed different evolutionary patterns. PRRs were highly purified based on their overall roles in Carnivora species but interspersed with positive-selection patterns during evolution. Different niche types may have jointly driven the evolution of PRR genes. In particular, the selection pressure of toll-like receptor (TLR) 10 was relaxed in seven species with pseudogenes, which may have emerged during recent evolutionary events. We speculated that a "functional compensation" mechanism may exist for genes with overlapping functions in the TLR gene family. Additionally, TLR2, TLR4, NLRC5, and DECTIN1 were subject to positive selection in semi-aquatic species, and the adaptive evolution of these genes may have been related to the adaptation to semi-aquatic environments. In summary, our findings offer valuable insights into the molecular and functional evolution of PRR genes, which are important for immune adaptations in Carnivora.

Widespread positive selection on cetacean TLR extracellular domain

Toll like receptors (TLRs), key members of innate immune system, can recognize a wide diversity of pathogens and initiate both innate and adaptive immune responses in vertebrate. Cetaceans must have faced new challenges of pathogens when their terrestrial relatives transitioned from the terrestrial to aquatic environment. Here, we sequenced the extracellular domain (ECD) of 10 TLRs in cetacean lineages because this region involved in the recognition of pathogens. A total of 148 sites ranging between 5-26 codons (0.01%-4.83%) were identified to be robust candidates of positive selection at the ECD of 10 TLRs. In addition, the majority (90.54%) of these positively selected codons were found to have radical amino acid changes, which strengthen the evidence of positive selection. Importantly, more radical amino acid changes in selected sites were enriched in the period of early evolutionary transition from land to semi-aquatic and from semi-aquatic to full-aquatic habitat, which might endow cetaceans with a faster adaptation to new pathogens as they transitioned into novel habitat. Interestingly, similar selective intensity was detected in both viral and non-viral TLRs in cetaceans, which was not in line with previous studies on primates and birds that reported stronger positive selection in non-viral TLRs than in viral TLRs. This result may be explained by the fact that cetaceans might have faced diversity of bacteria and viruses during its transitions from terrestrial to aquatic environment whereas both primates and birds probably being affected by only a restricted number of related viruses due to their homogeneous habitat.

Adaptive evolution and functional constraint at TLR4 during the secondary aquatic adaptation and diversification of cetaceans

BACKGROUND

Cetaceans (whales, dolphins and porpoises) are a group of adapted marine mammals with an enigmatic history of transition from terrestrial to full aquatic habitat and rapid radiation in waters around the world. Throughout this evolution, the pathogen stress-response proteins must have faced challenges from the dramatic change of environmental pathogens in the completely different ecological niches cetaceans occupied. For this reason, cetaceans could be one of the most ideal candidate taxa for studying evolutionary process and associated driving mechanism of vertebrate innate immune systems such as Toll-like receptors (TLRs), which are located at the direct interface between the host and the microbial environment, act at the first line in recognizing specific conserved components of microorganisms, and translate them rapidly into a defense reaction.

RESULTS

We used TLR4 as an example to test whether this traditionally regarded pattern recognition receptor molecule was driven by positive selection across cetacean evolutionary history. Overall, the lineage-specific selection test showed that the dN/dS (ω) values along most (30 out of 33) examined cetartiodactylan lineages were less than 1, suggesting a common effect of functional constraint. However, some specific codons made radical changes, fell adjacent to the residues interacting with lipopolysaccharides (LPS), and showed parallel evolution between independent lineages, suggesting that TLR4 was under positive selection. Especially, strong signatures of adaptive evolution on TLR4 were identified in two periods, one corresponding to the early evolutionary transition of the terrestrial ancestors of cetaceans from land to semi-aquatic (represented by the branch leading to whale + hippo) and from semi-aquatic to full aquatic (represented by the ancestral branch leading to cetaceans) habitat, and the other to the rapid diversification and radiation of oceanic dolphins.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study thus far to characterize the TLR gene in cetaceans. Our data present evidences that cetacean TLR4 has undergone adaptive evolution against the background of purifying selection in response to the secondary aquatic adaptation and rapid diversification in the sea. It is suggested that microbial pathogens in different environments are important factors that promote adaptive changes at cetacean TLR4 and new functions of some amino acid sites specialized for recognizing pathogens in dramatically contrasted environments to enhance the fitness for the adaptation and survival of cetaceans.