The model Lysozyme-PSSNa system for electrostatic complexation: Similarities and differences with complex coacervation

Membrane-Free Lateral Flow Assay with the Active Control of Fluid Transport for Ultrasensitive Cardiac Biomarker Detection

Membrane-based lateral flow immunoassays (LFAs) have been employed as early point-of-care (POC) testing tools in clinical settings. However, the varying membrane properties, uncontrollable sample transport in LFAs, visual readout, and required large sample volumes have been major limiting factors in realizing needed sensitivity and desirable precise quantification. Addressing these challenges, we designed a membrane-free system in which the desirable three-dimensional (3D) structure of the detection zone is imitated and used a small pump for fluid flow and fluorescence as readout, all the while maintaining a one-step assay protocol. A hydrogel-like protein-polyelectrolyte complex (PPC) within a polyelectrolyte multilayer (PEM) was developed as the test line by complexing polystreptavidin (pSA) with poly(diallyldimethylammonium chloride) (PDDA), which in turn was layered with poly(acrylic acid) (PAA) resulting in a superior 3D streptavidin-rich test line. Since the remainder of the microchannel remains material-free, good flow control is achieved, and with the total volume of 20 μL, 7.5-fold smaller sample volumes can be used in comparison to conventional LFAs. High sensitivity with desirable reproducibility and a 20 min total assay time were achieved for the detection of NT-proBNP in plasma with a dynamic range of 60-9000 pg·mL-1 and a limit of detection of 56 pg·mL-1 using probe antibody-modified fluorescence nanoparticles. While instrument-free visual detection is no longer possible, the developed lateral flow channel platform has the potential to dramatically expand the LFA applicability, as it overcomes the limitations of membrane-based immunoassays, ultimately improving the accuracy and reducing the sample volume so that finger-prick analyses can easily be done in a one-step assay for analytes present at very low concentrations.

Layer-by-Layer Nanoarchitectonics Using Protein-Polyelectrolyte Complexes toward a Generalizable Tool for Protein Surface Immobilization

Layer-by-layer (LbL) self-assembly is an attractive method for the immobilization of macromolecules at interfaces. Integrating proteins in LbL thin films is however challenging due to their polyampholyte nature. Recently, we developed a method to integrate lysozyme into multilayers using protein-polyelectrolytes complexes (PPCs). In this work, we extended this method to a wide range of protein-polyelectrolyte combinations. We demonstrated the robustness and versatility of PPCs as building blocks. LL-37, insulin, lysozyme, and glucose oxidase were complexed with alginate, poly(styrenesulfonate), heparin, and poly(allylamine hydrochloride). The resulting PPCs were then LbL self-assembled with chitosan, PAH, and heparin. We demonstrated that multilayers built with PPCs are thicker compared to the LbL self-assembly of bare protein molecules. This is attributed to the higher mass of protein in the multilayers and/or the more hydrated state of the assemblies. PPCs enabled the self-assembly of proteins that could otherwise not be LbL assembled with a PE or with another protein. Furthermore, the results also show that LbL with PPCs enabled the construction of multilayers combining different proteins, highlighting the formation of multifunctional films. Importantly, we show that the adsorption behavior and thus the multilayer growth strongly depend on the nature of the protein and polyelectrolyte used. In this work, we elaborated a rationale to help and guide the use of PPCs for protein LbL assembly. It will therefore be beneficial to the many scientific communities willing to modify interfaces with hard-to-immobilize proteins and peptides.

Interpolyelectrolyte Complexes as an Emerging Technology for Pharmaceutical Delivery of Polypeptides

Polyelectrolyte complexes and the derivatives thereof comprise some of the most promising vehicles for the encapsulation and delivery of macromolecular therapeutics. In particular, protein therapeutics, which present a host of special considerations, can often be effectively packaged and delivered using interpolyelectrolyte complexes. While the technologies are still in the developmental phase, there are numerous examples of complexes where control is exerted over spacial and temporal delivery of a model protein cargo or candidate protein therapeutic agent. Here we provide a historical and practical background to promote a deeper understanding of interpolyelectrolyte complexes and the derivative technologies. Additionally, we review the physical principles underlying the association of polyelectrolyte complexes and the application of those principles to novel strategies and technologies driving interpolyelectrolyte complexation. Then, the application of polyelectrolyte complex technology to protein therapeutics is discussed in detail including discussions of several types of protein cargo with a special emphasis on Brain-Derived Neurotrophic Factor. Finally, we focus on the use of stealth polymers in block ionomer complexes, specifically PEG; its benefits, flaws, and possible alternatives. Comprehensive understanding of the field may promote the continued development of derivative technologies for the delivery of particularly intransigent protein therapeutics, much as has been accomplished for small molecule drugs. We also aim to link current advances to the historical developments which inaugurated the field. With consideration to the field, industrial and academic researchers can utilize the discussed technologies and continue to elucidate novel modalities for a myriad of therapeutic and commercial applications.

Influence of temperature and salt on coacervation in an aqueous mixture of poly-L-lysine (PLL) and poly-(sodium styrene sulfonate) (PSSNa)

The mixture of poly-L-lysine (PLL) and long-chain PSSNa can lead to the formation of soluble complexes depending on pH, PLL concentration, ionic strength, and temperature. The influence of these stimuli was studied by zetametry, dynamic and ultra-small-angle light scattering, and turbidimetric measurements. First of all, we studied the stoichiometry of complexation, and then considered the influence of salt concentration and temperature on the behavior of the mixture at different pH values. These findings have allowed us to conclude that the polyelectrolyte-polypeptide stoichiometry is controlled by electrostatic interactions between opposite charges. At mass ratios between 1.8 and 2.3 and with net charges close to neutrality, unstable complexes were formed and flocculated due to the hydrophobic attraction leading to macroscopic phase separation. The linear charge density of the complex is also controlled by the ionic strength. Higher CaCl₂ concentrations reduce the complex stability and decrease the charge density, which leads to surface patch binding (SPB) at higher pH. Finally, the electrostatic interactions and strength of hydrogen bonds increased the stabilization of the complexes formed at temperatures lower than 45 °C. At temperatures higher than 45 °C, hydrophobic interactions became more dominant, causing a destabilization of the complexes.

Uncharged Components of Single-Stranded DNA Modulate Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation With Cationic Linker Histone H1

Liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) of proteins and DNAs has been recognized as a fundamental mechanism for the formation of intracellular biomolecular condensates. Here, we show the role of the constituent DNA components, i.e., the phosphate groups, deoxyribose sugars, and nucleobases, in LLPS with a polycationic peptide, linker histone H1, a known key regulator of chromatin condensation. A comparison of the phase behavior of mixtures of H1 and single-stranded DNA-based oligomers in which one or more of the constituent moieties of DNA were removed demonstrated that not only the electrostatic interactions between the anionic phosphate groups of the oligomers and the cationic residues of H1, but also the interactions involving nucleobases and deoxyriboses (i) promoted the generation of spherical liquid droplets via LLPS as well as (ii) increased the density of DNA and decreased its fluidity within the droplets under low-salt conditions. Furthermore, we found the formation of non-spherical assemblies with both mobile and immobile fractions at relatively higher concentrations of H1 for all the oligomers. The roles of the DNA components that promote phase separation and modulate droplet characteristics revealed in this study will facilitate our understanding of the formation processes of the various biomolecular condensates containing nucleic acids, such as chromatin organization.

Impact of the bulk aggregation on the adsorption of oppositely charged polyelectrolyte-surfactant mixtures onto solid surfaces

The understanding of the deposition of oppositely charged polyelectrolytes-surfactant mixtures onto solid surfaces presents a high interest in current days due to the recognized impact of the obtained layers on different industrial sectors and the performance of several consumer products (e.g. formulations of shampoos and hair conditioners). This results from the broad range of structures and properties that can present the mixed layers, which in most of the cases mirror the association process occurring between the polyelectrolyte chains and the oppositely charged surfactants in the bulk. Therefore, the understanding of the adsorption processes and characteristics of the adsorbed layers can be only attained from a careful examination of the self-assembly processes occurring in the solution. This review aims to contribute to the understanding of the interaction of polyelectrolyte-surfactant mixtures with solid surfaces, which is probably one of the most underexplored aspects of these type of systems. For this purpose, a comprehensive discussion on the correlations between the aggregates formed in the solutions and the deposition of the obtained complexes upon such association onto solid surfaces will be presented. This makes it necessary to take a closer look to the most important forces driving such processes.

pH-induced structural transition during complexation and precipitation of sodium caseinate and ε-Poly-l-lysine

ε-Polylysine (EPL) is a food-grade antimicrobial peptide that forms complexes with proteins. Such complexes are potential carriers for targeted delivery of agents. To elucidate the formation of such complexes, the pH-induced phase transition of EPL and sodium caseinate (SC) complexes were characterized in terms of ionic strengths (I) and EPL/SC weight ratios (r). Electrostatic nanocomplexes (e.g. r = 2^-3, I = 2 mM) were formed near the isoelectric point of SC using turbidimetry, dynamic light scattering, and ζ-potential measurements. Phase analyses revealed that the formation of nanocomplexes primarily depends on the I, and saturated binding was recorded above r = 2^-2. Electrostatic potential modelling of EPL was employed to describe the interaction affinity. A three-dimensional phase boundary curve was established which divided the complexation into a nano-scale and phase separation. Atomic force microscopy images confirmed that nanocomplexes were spherical particles with uniform shapes. Morphologic examination using optical and scanning electron microscopy and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy revealed that the nanocomplexes formed "sponge-like" precipitates at larger length scales. This work reveals the possible mechanism that drives the complexation of sodium caseinate and ε-Poly-l-lysine. This is expected to guide the construction of tailor-made protein complexes in industrial applications.

Self-Reorganizing Multilayer to Release Free Proteins from Self-Assemblies

The deconstruction of self-assemblies based on proteins and polyelectrolytes (PEs) and the subsequent release of intact proteins require either a switch from attractive to repulsive mode or particular PE properties (degradability, responsiveness, or differential affinity). Here, an interfacial self-assembly made of three charged species, i.e., a strong polyacid complexed with a protein and a weak polybase, is shown to self-reorganize upon a shift in pH. When the pH takes a value that is one pH unit lower than the pK_a of the weak polybase, the two PEs associate, thereby releasing the protein. The disassembly thus relies on associative forces rather than on the alteration of the protein-PE coupling strength. Hence, it allows the release of a protein using two simple PEs. The method is illustrated for lysozyme, which recovered up to half of its initial bioactivity after release. In contrast, a control self-assembled film that could not reorganize maintained only about 21% of the protein bioactivity after disassembly. This versatile approach is valuable for drug delivery devices and biomaterials as it allows the release of large numbers of active protein molecules.

Study of the complex coacervation mechanism between ovalbumin and the strong polyanion PSSNa: influence of temperature and pH

We studied the complex between ovalbumin and long flexible poly-(sodium 4-styrene sulfonate) as a function of pH and temperature. We used various techniques [turbidimetry, conductometry, dynamic light scattering, viscosimetry, and ultra-small-angle light scattering (USALS)] to fully characterize the coacervate complex. Different phases of complexation versus temperature were determined by turbidimetric analysis (pH_c, pH_ϕ1, and pH_ϕ2). The optimal protein/polyelectrolyte interaction occurred at pH_opt 4. An increase in temperature made the hydrophobic interactions more favorable in the case of the soluble complex and complex coacervation phases (pH > pH_ϕ2). We systematically determined the activation energy to follow the conformational changes of the complex at different temperatures. At pH_opt, the size of the formed complex showed a remarkable decrease with temperature increase. USALS was used to determine simultaneously the radius of gyration (R_g) and fractal dimension D_f of the coacervate.

Contrasting Assemblies of Oppositely Charged Proteins

Oppositely charged proteins can form soluble assemblies that under specific physical chemical conditions lead to liquid-liquid phase separation, also called heteroprotein coacervation. Increasing evidence suggests that surface charge anisotropy plays a key role in heteroprotein complexation, and coacervation. Here, we investigated complexation of an acidic protein, β-lactoglobulin (BLG), with two basic proteins, rapeseed napin (NAP) and lysozyme (LYS), of similar net charge and size but differing in surface charge distribution. Using turbidity measurements and isothermal titration calorimetry, we confirmed that LYS binds BLG as expected from previous studies. This interaction leads to two types of phase separation phenomena, depending on pH: liquid-solid phase separation in the case of strong electrostatic attraction and liquid-liquid phase separation for weaker attraction. More interestingly, we showed using dynamic light scattering that NAP interacts with BLG, resulting in formation of assemblies in the nanometer size range. The formation of assemblies was also evident when modeling the interactions using Brownian dynamics for both BLG + NAP and BLG + LYS. Similarly, to DLS, BLG and NAP formed smaller assemblies than BLG with LYS. The molecular details rather than the net charge of BLG and NAP may therefore play a role in their assembly. Furthermore, simulated BLG + NAP assemblies were larger than those experimentally detected by DLS. We discuss the discrepancy between experiments and simulations in relation to the limitations of modelling precisely the molecular characteristics of proteins.

Protein-Polyelectrolyte Complexes and Micellar Assemblies

In this review, we highlight the recent progress in our understanding of the structure, properties and applications of protein-polyelectrolyte complexes in both bulk and micellar assemblies. Protein-polyelectrolyte complexes form the basis of the genetic code, enable facile protein purification, and have emerged as enterprising candidates for simulating protocellular environments and as efficient enzymatic bioreactors. Such complexes undergo self-assembly in bulk due to a combined influence of electrostatic interactions and entropy gains from counterion release. Diversifying the self-assembly by incorporation of block polyelectrolytes has further enabled fabrication of protein-polyelectrolyte complex micelles that are multifunctional carriers for therapeutic targeted delivery of proteins such as enzymes and antibodies. We discuss research efforts focused on the structure, properties and applications of protein-polyelectrolyte complexes in both bulk and micellar assemblies, along with the influences of amphoteric nature of proteins accompanying patchy distribution of charges leading to unique phenomena including multiple complexation windows and complexation on the wrong side of the isoelectric point.

Integrating Proteins in Layer-by-Layer Assemblies Independently of their Electrical Charge

Layer-by-layer (LbL) assembly is an attractive method for protein immobilization at interfaces, a much wanted step for biotechnologies and biomedicine. Integrating proteins in LbL thin films is however very challenging due to their low conformational entropy, heterogeneous spatial distribution of charges, and polyampholyte nature. Protein-polyelectrolyte complexes (PPCs) are promising building blocks for LbL construction owing to their standardized charge and polyelectrolyte (PE) corona. In this work, lysozyme was complexed with poly(styrenesulfonate) (PSS) at different ionic strengths and pH values. The PPCs size and electrical properties were investigated, and the forces driving complexation were elucidated, in the light of computations of polyelectrolyte conformation, with a view to further unravel LbL construction mechanisms. Quartz crystal microbalance and atomic force microscopy were used to monitor the integration of PPCs compared to the one of bare protein molecules in LbL assemblies, and colorimetric assays were performed to determine the protein amount in the thin films. Layers built with PPCs show higher protein contents and hydration levels. Very importantly, the results also show that LbL construction with PPCs mainly relies on standard PE-PE interactions, independent of the charge state of the protein, in contrast to classical bare protein assembly with PEs. This considerably simplifies the incorporation of proteins in multilayers, which will be beneficial for biosensing, heterogeneous biocatalysis, biotechnologies, and medical applications that require active proteins at interfaces.

Complex coacervation in charge complementary biopolymers: Electrostatic versus surface patch binding

In this review, a number of systems are described to demonstrate the effect of polyelectrolyte chain stiffness (persistence length) on the coacervation phenomena, after we briefly review the field. We consider two specific types of complexation/coacervation: in the first type, DNA is used as a fixed substrate binding to flexible polyions such as gelatin A, bovine serum albumin and chitosan (large persistence length polyelectrolyte binding to low persistence length biopolymer), and in the second case, different substrates such as gelatin A, bovine serum albumin, and chitosan were made to bind to a polyion gelatin B (low persistence length substrate binding to comparable persistence length polyion). Polyelectrolyte chain flexibility was found to have remarkable effect on the polyelectrolyte-protein complex coacervation. The competitive interplay of electrostatic versus surface patch binding (SPB) leading to associative interaction followed by complex coacervation between these biopolymers is elucidated. We modelled the SPB interaction in terms of linear combination of attractive and repulsive Coulombic forces with respect to the solution ionic strength. The aforesaid interactions were established via a universal phase diagram, considering the persistence length of polyion as the sole independent variable.

Protein-polyelectrolyte complexes to improve the biological activity of proteins in layer-by-layer assemblies

A standard method of protein immobilization is proposed, based on the use of protein-polyelectrolyte complexes (PPCs) as building blocks for layer-by-layer assembly. Thicker multilayers, with a higher polyelectrolyte fraction, are obtained with PPCs compared to single protein molecules. Biological activity is not only maintained, but specific activity is also higher, as demonstrated for lysozyme-poly(styrene sulfonate) complexes. This is attributed to the more hydrated state of the assemblies. This new method of protein immobilization opens up perspectives for biotechnology and biomedical applications.

Linear viscoelasticity of complex coacervates

Rheology is a powerful method for material characterization that can provide detailed information about the self-assembly, structure, and intermolecular interactions present in a material. Here, we review the use of linear viscoelastic measurements for the rheological characterization of complex coacervate-based materials. Complex coacervation is an electrostatically and entropically-driven associative liquid-liquid phase separation phenomenon that can result in the formation of bulk liquid phases, or the self-assembly of hierarchical, microphase separated materials. We discuss the need to link thermodynamic studies of coacervation phase behavior with characterization of material dynamics, and provide parallel examples of how parameters such as charge stoichiometry, ionic strength, and polymer chain length impact self-assembly and material dynamics. We conclude by highlighting key areas of need in the field, and specifically call for the development of a mechanistic understanding of how molecular-level interactions in complex coacervate-based materials affect both self-assembly and material dynamics.

Degradation and hemostatic properties of polyphosphate coacervates

Sodium polyphosphate is a linear polymer formed from phosphate units linked together by sharing oxygen atoms. Addition of calcium to a solution of sodium polyphosphate results in phase separation and formation of a polyphosphate coacervate best described as a polymeric rich viscoelastic material. Polyphosphate coacervate is an interesting candidate as a biomaterial based on its ability to bind with different cations and to be loaded with drugs. Here, in vitro degradation and hemostatic properties of polyphosphate coacervates are comprehensively evaluated. We show that polyphosphate coacervates degrade and dissolve at a fast rate, losing half of their original mass in a week and transforming to mainly pyrophosphate after 4weeks. This burst dissolution phase happens earlier for the coacervate prepared from very short chain polyphosphate but overall using longer polyphosphate chains does not increase the coacervate longevity significantly. Substitution of Ca with Sr or Ba does not affect the hydrolysis of coacervates but slows down their dissolution into the media. In a whole blood clotting assay, coacervates profoundly decrease the clotting time especially when very long chain polyphosphates are used. While coacervate chain length and divalent cation type were found to significantly affect prothrombin time and thromboplastin time compared to the control, no discernible trends were observed. Platelets adhere in large numbers to coacervates, especially those containing long chain polyphosphate, but the cell morphology observed suggests that they might not to be fully activated. Overall, the long chain polyphosphate coacervate holds a great potential as a resorbable hemostatic agent.

STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

Divalent cation additions to a sodium polyphosphate solution result in polyphosphate coacervates, or highly viscous gel-like materials, having great potential in bio-applications such as drug delivery and hemostasis. As these coacervates degrade in aqueous environments, we undertook a comprehensive evaluation to better understand the impact of polyphosphate chain length and divalent cation substitution on this hydrolytic response in order to better predict degradation behavior in the body. Furthermore, there is great interest in the role of polyphosphates in hemostasis following recent publications showing that platelets secrete polyphosphates upon thrombin stimulation. In this paper, we evaluate the hemostatic potential of polyphosphate coacervates as bulk constructs, demonstrating that indeed these materials hold great potential as a degradable hemostatic agent.

Polymer-surfactant systems in bulk and at fluid interfaces

The interest of polymer-surfactant systems has undergone a spectacular development in the last thirty years due to their complex behavior and their importance in different industrial sectors. The importance can be mainly associated with the rich phase behavior of these mixtures that confers a wide range of physico-chemical properties to the complexes formed by polymers and surfactants, both in bulk and at the interfaces. This latter aspect is especially relevant because of the use of their mixture for the stabilization of dispersed systems such as foams and emulsions, with an increasing interest in several fields such as cosmetic, food science or fabrication of controlled drug delivery structures. This review presents a comprehensive analysis of different aspects related to the phase behavior of these mixtures and their intriguing behavior after adsorption at the liquid/air interface. A discussion of some physical properties of the bulk is also included. The discussion clearly points out that much more work is needed for obtaining the necessary insights for designing polymer-surfactant mixtures for specific applications.

Folding Behaviors of Protein (Lysozyme) Confined in Polyelectrolyte Complex Micelle

The folding/unfolding behavior of proteins (enzymes) in confined space is important for their properties and functions, but such a behavior remains largely unexplored. In this article, we reported our finding that lysozyme and a double hydrophilic block copolymer, methoxypoly(ethylene glycol)5K-block-poly(l-aspartic acid sodium salt)10 (mPEG(5K)-b-PLD10), can form a polyelectrolyte complex micelle with a particle size of ∼30 nm, as verified by dynamic light scattering and transmission electron microscopy. The unfolding and refolding behaviors of lysozyme molecules in the presence of the copolymer were studied by microcalorimetry and circular dichroism spectroscopy. Upon complex formation with mPEG(5K)-b-PLD10, lysozyme changed from its initial native state to a new partially unfolded state. Compared with its native state, this copolymer-complexed new folding state of lysozyme has different secondary and tertiary structures, a decreased thermostability, and significantly altered unfolding/refolding behaviors. It was found that the native lysozyme exhibited reversible unfolding and refolding upon heating and subsequent cooling, while lysozyme in the new folding state (complexed with the oppositely charged PLD segments of the polymer) could unfold upon heating but could not refold upon subsequent cooling. By employing the heating-cooling-reheating procedure, the prevention of complex formation between lysozyme and polymer due to the salt screening effect was observed, and the resulting uncomplexed lysozyme regained its proper unfolding and refolding abilities upon heating and subsequent cooling. Besides, we also pointed out the important role the length of the PLD segment played during the formation of micelles and the monodispersity of the formed micelles. Furthermore, the lysozyme-mPEG(5K)-b-PLD10 mixtures prepared in this work were all transparent, without the formation of large aggregates or precipitates in solution as frequently observed in other protein-polyelectrolyte systems. Hence, the present protein-PEGylated poly(amino acid) mixture provides an ideal water-soluble model system to study the important role of electrostatic interaction in the complexation between proteins and polymers, leading to important new knowledge on the protein-polymer interactions. Moreover, the polyelectrolyte complex micelle formed between protein and PEGylated polymer may provide a good drug delivery vehicle for therapeutic proteins.

Synergetic effect of sodium polystyrene sulfonate and guanidine hydrochloride on the surface properties of lysozyme solutions

A study of the dilational surface viscoelastic properties of mixed solutions of lysozyme and denaturants allows us to characterize the changes of protein tertiary structure in the surface layer upon adsorption at the liquid–gas interface.

Slow complexation dynamics between linear short polyphosphates and polyallylamines: analogies with "layer-by-layer" deposits

Polyelectrolyte "complexes" have been studied for almost a century and find more and more applications in cosmetics and DNA transfection. Most of the available studies focused on the thermodynamic aspects of the "complex" formation, mainly to determine phase diagrams and the influence of diverse physicochemical aspects on the formation of "complexes", but conversely less effort has been given to the kinetics of such processes. We describe herein the "complexation" kinetics of a short linear sodium polyphosphate (PSP) with poly(allylamine hydrochloride) (PAH) in the presence of 10 mM, 0.15 M and 1 M NaCl. We find, by using a combination of physicochemical techniques, that mixtures containing a 1 to 1 molar ratio of phosphate and amino groups allow the formation of "complexes" having a few 100 nm in diameter which progressively grow to particles up to 1.5 microns in hydrodynamic diameter, the growth process being accompanied by some progressive sedimentation. During this slow aggregation kinetics, the polyelectrolytes undergo a release of counterions and the zeta potential changes from a positive value to a negative one of -20 mV which is close to the zeta potential of (PSP-PAH)(n) films deposited under identical physicochemical conditions. Even though the complexes have a negative electrophoretic mobility, they contain an equimolar amount of amino and phosphate groups. This allows us to make some assumption about the structure of such "complexes" and to compare them with other published structures. We will also compare them with the aggregates found during the "layer-by-layer" deposition of the same species under the same conditions.