Unsuccessful Transfemoral Tricuspid Valve-in-Ring Implantation: Case Report and Literature Review

Transcatheter treatment of the tricuspid valve: current status and perspectives

Transcatheter tricuspid valve interventions (TTVI) are emerging as alternatives to surgery in high-risk patients with isolated or concomitant tricuspid regurgitation. The development of new minimally invasive solutions potentially more adapted to this largely undertreated population of patients, has fuelled the interest for the tricuspid valve. Growing evidence and new concepts have contributed to revise obsolete and misleading perceptions around the right side of the heart. New definitions, classifications, and a better understanding of the disease pathophysiology and phenotypes, as well as their associated patient journeys have profoundly and durably changed the landscape of tricuspid disease. A number of registries and a recent randomized controlled pivotal trial provide preliminary guidance for decision-making. TTVI seem to be very safe and effective in selected patients, although clinical benefits beyond improved quality of life remain to be demonstrated. Even if more efforts are needed, increased disease awareness is gaining momentum in the community and supports the establishment of dedicated expert valve centres. This review is summarizing the achievements in the field and provides perspectives for a less invasive management of a no-more-forgotten disease.

Current Status of Transcatheter Tricuspid Valve Therapies

Tricuspid regurgitation is a complex disease that carries a poor prognosis, and surgical repair is associated with high mortality. In light of the success of other transcatheter-based valve interventions, transcatheter tricuspid therapy has recently seen exponential use both clinically and in innovation. Given the rapid development of many tricuspid systems and multiple on-going clinical trials, the aim of this review is to highlight the current state of transcatheter tricuspid therapeutics and to provide an up-to-date view of their clinical use, outcomes and future directions.

Current and future transcatheter aortic valve replacement valves

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This review analyzes currently available commercial transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) valves as well as valves in investigational status and those in preclinical testing. The design features and clinical outcomes of the Edwards SAPIEN S3 and Medtronic Evolut PRO+ are described and compared with highlight clinical circumstances where one may be favoured over the other.

RECENT FINDINGS

Multiple randomized and nonrandomized trials have compared commercial and investigational TAVR valves. The results of these are summarized and discussed within this review with a focus on how the SAPIEN S3 and Evolut PRO+ both compare to each other as well as various valves in different investigational stages.

SUMMARY

TAVR is an innovative and ground-breaking technology that will forever have revolutionized the management of aortic stenosis. Though the technology and valves themselves have come a long way, further developments are necessary if we are to continue to expand its indications and achieve a safer perioperative experience with more durable valves.

Transcatheter valve-in-ring and para-ring vascular plug implantation for severe tricuspid regurgitation following annuloplasty ring failure: a case report

Background

Moderate or severe tricuspid regurgitation (TR) recurs in up to one-third of patients within 8 years of surgical annuloplasty repair. Reoperation often carries high risk with poor outcomes. Transcatheter valve-in-ring repair is an emerging alternative treatment. However, residual regurgitation is frequent and may necessitate further procedures.

Case summary

A 52-year-old female was diagnosed with severe rheumatic valvular heart disease. The patient underwent mechanical aortic and mitral valve replacement. Additionally, tricuspid repair was performed using a semi-rigid annuloplasty ring (28 mm Edwards Physio Tricuspid). Within 2 years, the patient developed recurrent, isolated severe symptomatic TR, with progressive right ventricular dilatation. The patient was considered prohibitive risk for redo surgery and unsuitable for cardiac transplantation. She underwent percutaneous valve-in-ring transcatheter heart valve (THV) implantation using a 29 mm Sapien S3 (Edwards Lifesciences, CA, USA) valve. Persistent severe residual para-ring TR warranted a further procedure to deploy vascular plugs, significantly reducing the TR to a mild jet with symptomatic improvement.

Discussion

Valve-in-ring THV implantation for failed surgical tricuspid annuloplasty repair is a rare procedure reserved for symptomatic patients at high or prohibitive risk for reoperation. Significant residual TR is a commonly encountered problem with incomplete annuloplasty rings following valve-in-ring procedures and may occur either intra-ring between the THV and the ring or para-ring. Implantation of vascular occlusion devices can be used to successfully treat residual TR at either location with good outcomes at 6-month follow-up. Further work is required to determine the longevity of this treatment.

Multimodality imaging to guide transcatheter treatment of severe degenerative tricuspid regurgitation with tricuspid valve-in-ring implantation and paravalvular leak closure

Tricuspid valve (TV) degeneration after surgical repair with an annuloplasty ring is problematic as redo operation carries high mortality. This can be addressed with transcatheter therapies to implant a valve within in prior ring (tricuspid valve-in-ring). When an incomplete ring is present, paravalvular leak is commonly encountered after tricuspid valve-in-ring (TViR) implant; however, this can be addressed with paravalvular leak closure devices. Multimodality imaging including cardiac computed tomography and three-dimensional (3D) transesophageal echocardiography (TEE) are important for successful TViR implant. We report a case of tricuspid regurgitation after tricuspid repair with an incomplete annuloplasty ring and subsequent paravalvular leak closure.