Long-term Ro60 humoral autoimmunity in primary Sjögren's syndrome is maintained by rapid clonal turnover

Ro60-Roles in RNA Processing, Inflammation, and Rheumatic Autoimmune Diseases

The Ro60/SSA2 autoantigen is an RNA-binding protein and a core component of nucleocytoplasmic ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complexes. Ro60 is essential in RNA metabolism, cell stress response pathways, and cellular homeostasis. It stabilises and mediates the quality control and cellular distribution of small RNAs, including YRNAs (for the 'y' in 'cytoplasmic'), retroelement transcripts, and misfolded RNAs. Ro60 transcriptional dysregulation or loss of function can result in the generation and release of RNA fragments from YRNAs and other small RNAs. Small RNA fragments can instigate an inflammatory cascade through endosomal toll-like receptors (TLRs) and cytoplasmic RNA sensors, which typically sense pathogen-associated molecular patterns, and mount the first line of defence against invading pathogens. However, the recognition of host-originating RNA moieties from Ro60 RNP complexes can activate inflammatory response pathways and compromise self-tolerance. Autoreactive B cells may produce antibodies targeting extracellular Ro60 RNP complexes. Ro60 autoantibodies serve as diagnostic markers for various autoimmune diseases, including Sjögren's disease (SjD) and systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), and they may also act as predictive markers for anti-drug antibody responses among rheumatic patients. Understanding Ro60's structure, function, and role in self-tolerance can enhance our understanding of the underlying molecular mechanisms of autoimmune conditions.

Serological intermolecular epitope spreading in a patient with primary Sjögren's syndrome

Sjögren's syndrome (SS) is one of the prototypic systemic autoimmune diseases characterised by autoreactive T and B cells, sicca symptoms and various extraglandular manifestations. SS is characterised by autoantibodies (anti-Ro52/tripartite motif containing-21 [TRIM21], anti-Ro60 and anti-La) that are important diagnostic biomarkers. Patients have typically stable serostatus; that is, patients who are positive for one or more of these autoantibodies tend to remain thus and vice versa. We describe a rare instance where a woman in her 50s was diagnosed with primary SS and developed new autoantibodies subsequently through serological epitope spreading. She demonstrated primarily glandular features only and clinical stability despite serological evolution. In this case report, we discuss the significance of this molecular feature and the clinical implications for our understanding of autoimmunity.

Machine Learning for the Identification of a Common Signature for Anti-SSA/Ro 60 Antibody Expression Across Autoimmune Diseases

OBJECTIVE

Anti-Ro autoantibodies are among the most frequently detected extractable nuclear antigen autoantibodies, mainly associated with primary Sjögren's syndrome (SS), systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), and undifferentiated connective tissue disease (UCTD). This study was undertaken to determine if there is a common signature for all patients expressing anti-Ro 60 autoantibodies regardless of their disease phenotype.

METHODS

Using high-throughput multiomics data collected from the cross-sectional cohort in the PRECISE Systemic Autoimmune Diseases (PRECISESADS) study Innovative Medicines Initiative (IMI) project (genetic, epigenomic, and transcriptomic data, combined with flow cytometry data, multiplexed cytokines, classic serology, and clinical data), we used machine learning to assess the integrated molecular profiling of 520 anti-Ro 60+ patients compared to 511 anti-Ro 60- patients with primary SS, patients with SLE, and patients with UCTD, and 279 healthy controls.

RESULTS

The selected clinical features for RNA-Seq, DNA methylation, and genome-wide association study data allowed for a clear distinction between anti-Ro 60+ and anti-Ro 60- patients. The different features selected using machine learning from the anti-Ro 60+ patients constituted specific signatures when compared to anti-Ro 60- patients and healthy controls. Remarkably, the transcript Z score of 3 genes (ATP10A, MX1, and PARP14), presenting with overexpression associated with hypomethylation and genetic variation and independently identified using the Boruta algorithm, was clearly higher in anti-Ro 60+ patients compared to anti-Ro 60- patients regardless of disease type. Our findings demonstrated that these signatures, enriched in interferon-stimulated genes, were also found in anti-Ro 60+ patients with rheumatoid arthritis and those with systemic sclerosis and remained stable over time and were not affected by treatment.

CONCLUSION

Anti-Ro 60+ patients present with a specific inflammatory signature regardless of their disease type, suggesting that a dual therapeutic approach targeting both Ro-associated RNAs and anti-Ro 60 autoantibodies should be considered.

Autoantibody:Autoantigen Competitor Decoys: Application to Cardiac Phenotypes

Autoimmune diseases are often associated with autoantibodies that abnormally target self-antigens (autoantigens). An intuitive therapeutic strategy for diseases caused by aAbs is to design decoys, or soluble molecules that target the antigen combining site of these aAbs, thereby blocking binding of aAb to self-antigen and subsequent tissue damage. Here, we review the known decoy molecules of these types, discuss newer technological opportunities afforded by monoclonal antibody and structural biology advances, and discuss the challenges to this approach. Recent opportunities relevant to this approach for cardiac phenotypes, specifically Ro-associated long QT syndrome, are discussed.

Longitudinal Tracking of Extractable Nuclear Antigen (ENA) Antibodies in a Quaternary Hospital Laboratory Cohort Reveals Dynamic Antibody Profiles

BACKGROUND

Antiextractable nuclear antigens (anti-ENAs) are regarded as diagnostic tests with no established value for serial monitoring. We therefore sought to establish the stability over time of anti-ENAs in a large diagnostic immunopathology laboratory.

METHODS

A retrospective review of all patients who had a serial anti-ENA ordered at the Westmead Hospital (Sydney, Australia) was performed over 24 months. Anti-ENA characterization was performed using line immunoassay, and historical data were available from 2013 onward. The earliest available densitometry readings were compared with the latest available to examine for a change in quantitation or qualitative (serostatus) result (from negative to positive, and vice versa). Medical records were examined for clinical correlations.

RESULTS

A total of 283 patients (24.1%) had serial testing of anti-ENA in the audit period, with each patient having an average of 3.9 ± 2.9 tests each. Most patients were diagnosed with systemic lupus erythematosus or primary Sjögren's syndrome. About 25% and 58% of patients had a qualitative and quantitative change, respectively, in at least 1 anti-ENA in the study period. Changes in anti-ENA levels correlated with erythrocyte sedimentation rate and disease activity. Increasing duration between serial tests increased the probability of observing a change in anti-ENA levels.

CONCLUSION

Certain anti-ENAs are dynamic autoantibodies that may have significance for monitoring disease activity. Laboratories may consider reporting quantitative results. Further disease- and autoantibody-specific studies are required to determine the clinical significance of changes in anti-ENAs.

High-Throughput Detection of Autoantigen-Specific B Cells Among Distinct Functional Subsets in Autoimmune Donors

Antigen-specific B cells (ASBCs) can drive autoimmune disease by presenting autoantigen to cognate T cells to drive their activation, proliferation, and effector cell differentiation and/or by differentiating into autoantibody-secreting cells. Autoantibodies are frequently used to predict risk and diagnose several autoimmune diseases. ASBCs can drive type 1 diabetes even when immune tolerance mechanisms block their differentiation into antibody-secreting cells. Furthermore, anti-histidyl tRNA synthetase syndrome patients have expanded IgM⁺ Jo-1-binding B cells, which clinically diagnostic IgG Jo-1 autoantibodies may not fully reflect. Given the potential disconnect between the pathologic function of ASBCs and autoantibody secretion, direct study of ASBCs is a necessary step towards developing better therapies for autoimmune diseases, which often have no available cure. We therefore developed a high-throughput screening pipeline to 1) phenotypically identify specific B cell subsets, 2) expand them in vitro, 3) drive them to secrete BCRs as antibody, and 4) identify wells enriched for ASBCs through ELISA detection of antibody. We tested the capacity of several B cell subset(s) to differentiate into antibody-secreting cells following this robust stimulation. IgM⁺ and/or IgD⁺, CD27^- memory, memory, switched memory, and B_ND B cells secreted B cell receptor (BCR) as antibody following in vitro stimulation, whereas few plasmablasts responded. Bimodal responses were observed across autoimmune donors for IgM⁺ CD21^lo and IgM^- CD21^lo B cells, consistent with documented heterogeneity within the CD21^lo subset. Using this approach, we detected insulin-binding B cell bias towards CD27^- memory and CD27⁺ memory subsets in pre-symptomatic type 1 diabetes donors. We took advantage of routine detection of Jo-1-binding B cells in Jo-1+ anti-histidyl tRNA synthetase syndrome patients to show that Jo-1-binding B cells and total B cells expanded 20-30-fold using this culture system. Overall, these studies highlight technology that is amenable to small numbers of cryopreserved peripheral blood mononuclear cells that enables interrogation of phenotypic and repertoire attributes of ASBCs derived from autoimmune patients.

The Autoantigen Repertoire and the Microbial RNP World

Although autoimmunity and autoimmune disease (AID) are relatively common, the repertoire of autoantigens is paradoxically very limited. Highly enriched in this autoantigen repertoire are nucleic acids and their binding proteins, which together form large macromolecular structures. Most of these complexes are of ancient evolutionary origin, with homologs throughout multiple kingdoms of life. Why and if these nucleic acid-protein particles drive the development of autoimmunity remains unresolved. Recent advances in our understanding of the microbiome may provide clues about the origins of autoimmunity - and the particular puzzle of why the autoantigen repertoire is so particularly enriched in ribonucleoprotein particles (RNPs). We discuss the possibility that autoimmunity to some RNPs may arise from molecular mimicry to microbial orthologs.

Identification of a unique anti-Ro60 subset with restricted serological and molecular profiles

Anti-Ro60 is one of the most common and clinically important serum autoantibodies that has a number of diagnostic and predictive capabilities. Most diagnostic laboratories report this simply as a qualitative positive/negative result. The objective of this study was to examine the clinical and serological relevance of a novel subset of anti-Ro60 in patients who display low levels of anti-Ro60 (anti-Ro60low ). We retrospectively identified anti-Ro60 sera during a 12-month period at a major immunopathology diagnostic laboratory in Australia. These all were anti-Ro60-precipitin-positive on the diagnostic gold standard counter-immuno-electrophoresis (CIEP). Lineblot immunoassay was used to stratify patients into either anti-Ro60low or anti-Ro60high subsets. We compared the medical and laboratory parameters associated with each group. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and mass spectrometry techniques were used to analyse the serological and molecular basis behind the two subsets. Anti-Ro60low patients displayed less serological activity than anti-Ro60high patients with less intermolecular spreading, hypergammaglobulinaemia and less tendency to undergo anti-Ro60 isotype-switching than anti-Ro60high patients. Mass spectrometric typing of the anti-Ro60low subset showed restricted variable heavy chain subfamily usage and amino acid point mutations. This subset also displayed clinical relevance, being present in a number of patients with systemic autoimmune rheumatic diseases (SARD). We identify a novel anti-Ro60low patient subset that is distinct from anti-Ro60high patients serologically and molecularly. It is not clear whether they arise from common or separate origins; however, they probably have different developmental pathways to account for the stark difference in immunological maturity. We hence demonstrate significance to anti-Ro60low and justify accurate detection in the diagnostic laboratory.

Commensal orthologs of the human autoantigen Ro60 as triggers of autoimmunity in lupus

The earliest autoantibodies in lupus are directed against the RNA binding autoantigen Ro60, but the triggers against this evolutionarily conserved antigen remain elusive. We identified Ro60 orthologs in a subset of human skin, oral, and gut commensal bacterial species and confirmed the presence of these orthologs in patients with lupus and healthy controls. Thus, we hypothesized that commensal Ro60 orthologs may trigger autoimmunity via cross-reactivity in genetically susceptible individuals. Sera from human anti-Ro60-positive lupus patients immunoprecipitated commensal Ro60 ribonucleoproteins. Human Ro60 autoantigen-specific CD4 memory T cell clones from lupus patients were activated by skin and mucosal Ro60-containing bacteria, supporting T cell cross-reactivity in humans. Further, germ-free mice spontaneously initiated anti-human Ro60 T and B cell responses and developed glomerular immune complex deposits after monocolonization with a Ro60 ortholog-containing gut commensal, linking anti-Ro60 commensal responses in vivo with the production of human Ro60 autoantibodies and signs of autoimmunity. Together, these data support that colonization with autoantigen ortholog-producing commensal species may initiate and sustain chronic autoimmunity in genetically predisposed individuals. The concept of commensal ortholog cross-reactivity may apply more broadly to autoimmune diseases and lead to novel treatment approaches aimed at defined commensal species.

Prognostic value of Sjögren's syndrome autoantibodies

Sjögren's syndrome is in part considered an autoimmune disease because patient sera contain antibodies binding self-structures. In fact, in addition to anti-Ro (or SSA) and anti-La (or SSB), which are included in the classification criteria, there are a wide variety of autoantibodies found among these patients. We reviewed English-language MEDLINE sources. Anti-Ro and anti-La found among healthy individuals, including mothers giving birth to infants with neonatal lupus, predicts future connective tissue disease. Those with Sjögren's syndrome can be divided into two groups; patients with only exocrine gland involvement and those with systemic disease. The presence of anti-Ro/La is associated with systemic, extraglandular disease. Rheumatoid factor is also associated with extraglandular disease while anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide (CCP) is likely associated with inflammatory arthritis and progression to rheumatoid arthritis. Anti-mitochondrial antibodies are uncommon but predict progression to primary biliary cirrhosis. Cryoglobulinemia is found in excess among those with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. Determination of autoantibodies on the sera of Sjögren's syndrome patients has prognostic implications for Sjögren's syndrome itself as well as associated diseases.

Precipitating anti-dsDNA peptide repertoires in lupus

Anti-double-stranded (ds)DNA autoantibodies are prototypical serological markers of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), but little is known about their immunoglobulin variable (IgV) region composition at the level of the secreted (serum) proteome. Here, we use a novel proteomic workflow based on de novo mass spectrometric sequencing of anti-dsDNA precipitins to analyse IgV subfamily expression and mutational signatures of high-affinity, precipitating anti-dsDNA responses. Serum anti-dsDNA proteomes were oligoclonal with shared (public) expression of immunoglobulin (Ig)G heavy chain variable region (IGHV) and kappa chain variable region (IGKV) subfamilies. IgV peptide maps from eight subjects showed extensive public and random (private) amino acid replacement mutations with prominent arginine substitutions across heavy (H)- and light (L)-chains. Shared sets of L-chain complementarity determining region 3 (CDR3) peptides specified by arginine substitutions were sequenced from the dominantly expressed IGKV3-20 subfamily, with changes in expression levels of a clonal L-chain CDR3 peptide by quantitative multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) paralleling the rise and fall of anti-dsDNA levels by Farr radioimmunoassays (RIA). The heavily mutated IgV peptide signatures of precipitating anti-dsDNA autoantibody proteomes reflect the strong selective forces that shape humoral anti-dsDNA responses in germinal centres. Direct sequencing of agarose gel precipitins using microlitre volumes of stored sera streamlines the antibody sequencing workflow and is generalizable to other precipitating serum antibodies.

The value of rituximab treatment in primary Sjögren's syndrome

The rationale for B cell depletion therapy with rituximab in primary Sjögren's syndrome relies upon the well-established role of B cell hyperactivity in immunopathogenesis. In line with this notion, several biomarkers of B cell activity are significantly affected by treatment, both in the target organs and periphery. In contrast to most biological outcomes, clinical outcomes are not consistent between studies. Although two large RCTs did not meet their primary endpoint, several beneficial clinical effects of treatment have been shown. As discussed in this review, differences in study design and patient characteristics could explain the variation in results. Interestingly, a newly developed composite endpoint of subjective and objective outcomes did show a significant effect of rituximab in one of the large RCTs. Response predictors need to be identified to define more targeted inclusion criteria and achieve precision medicine. The positive effects seen on biological and clinical parameters warrant future studies to investigate this promising treatment modality.

B Cell Depletion Therapy Normalizes Circulating Follicular Th Cells in Primary Sjögren Syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To assess the effect of B cell depletion therapy on effector CD4+ T cell homeostasis and its relation to objective measures of disease activity in patients with primary Sjögren syndrome (pSS).

METHODS

Twenty-four patients with pSS treated with rituximab (RTX) and 24 healthy controls (HC) were included. Frequencies of circulating effector CD4+ T cell subsets were examined by flow cytometry at baseline and 16, 24, 36, and 48 weeks after the first RTX infusion. Th1, Th2, follicular Th (TFH), and Th17 cells were discerned based on surface marker expression patterns. Additionally, intracellular cytokine staining was performed for interferon-γ, interleukin (IL)-4, IL-21, and IL-17 and serum levels of these cytokines were analyzed.

RESULTS

In patients with pSS, frequencies of circulating TFH cells and Th17 cells were increased at baseline compared with HC, whereas frequencies of Th1 and Th2 cells were unchanged. B cell depletion therapy resulted in a pronounced decrease in circulating TFH cells, whereas Th17 cells were only slightly lowered. Frequencies of IL-21-producing and IL-17-producing CD4+ T cells and serum levels of IL-21 and IL-17 were also reduced. Importantly, the decrease in circulating TFH cells was associated with lower systemic disease activity over time, as measured by the European League Against Rheumatism Sjögren's Syndrome Disease Activity Index scores and serum IgG levels.

CONCLUSION

B cell depletion therapy in patients with pSS results in normalization of the elevated levels of circulating TFH cells. This reduction is associated with improved objective clinical disease activity measures. Our observations illustrate the pivotal role of the crosstalk between B cells and TFH cells in the pathogenesis of pSS.

IgV peptide mapping of native Ro60 autoantibody proteomes in primary Sjögren's syndrome reveals molecular markers of Ro/La diversification

We have used high-resolution mass spectrometry to sequence precipitating anti-Ro60 proteomes from sera of patients with primary Sjögren's syndrome and compare immunoglobulin variable-region (IgV) peptide signatures in Ro/La autoantibody subsets. Anti-Ro60 were purified by elution from native Ro60-coated ELISA plates and subjected to combined de novo amino acid sequencing and database matching. Monospecific anti-Ro60 Igs comprised dominant public and minor private sets of IgG1 kappa and lambda restricted heavy and light chains. Specific IgV amino acid substitutions stratified anti-Ro60 from anti-Ro60/La responses, providing a molecular fingerprint of Ro60/La determinant spreading and suggesting that different forms of Ro60 antigen drive these responses. Sequencing of linked anti-Ro52 proteomes from individual patients and comparison with their anti-Ro60 partners revealed sharing of a dominant IGHV3-23/IGKV3-20 paired clonotype but with divergent IgV mutational signatures. In summary, anti-Ro60 IgV peptide mapping provides insights into Ro/La autoantibody diversification and reveals serum-based molecular markers of humoral Ro60 autoimmunity.

Autoantibodies in Sjögren's Syndrome

We compiled information on antibodies in Sjögren syndrome, focusing more on clinical manifestations associated with anti-Ro/SSA and anti-La/SSB antibodies and studies regarding novel antibodies. We reviewed previous as well as most recent studies with the subject heading Sjogren in combination with antibodies and congenital heart block (CHB). Almost half of asymptomatic mothers giving birth to children with CHB ultimately develop Sjögren. We discussed studies concerning the presence of antibodies predating clinical manifestations of disease. Studies in the future are required to ascertain the pathogenic mechanisms associated with these antibodies and the specific clinical manifestation related to new autoantibodies.

Secreted autoantibody repertoires in Sjögren's syndrome and systemic lupus erythematosus: A proteomic approach

The structures of epitopes bound by autoantibodies against RNA-protein complexes have been well-defined over several decades, but little is known of the clonality, immunoglobulin (Ig) variable (V) gene usage and mutational status of the autoantibodies themselves at the level of the secreted (serum) proteome. A novel proteomic workflow is presented based on affinity purification of specific Igs from serum, high-resolution two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, and de novo and database-driven sequencing of V-region proteins by mass spectrometry. Analysis of anti-Ro52/Ro60/La proteomes in primary Sjögren's syndrome (SS) and anti-Sm and anti-ribosomal P proteomes in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) has revealed that these antibody responses are dominated by restricted sets of public (shared) clonotypes, consistent with common pathways of production across unrelated individuals. The discovery of shared sets of specific V-region peptides can be exploited for diagnostic biomarkers in targeted mass spectrometry platforms and for tracking and removal of pathogenic clones.