Investigation of the role of SMN1 and SMN2 haploinsufficiency as a risk factor for Hirayama's disease: Clinical, neurophysiological and genetic characteristics in a Spanish series of 13 patients

Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion for the treatment of pediatric Hirayama disease

PURPOSE

Hirayama disease, a rare cervical myelopathy in children and young adults, leads to progressive upper limb weakness and muscle loss. Non-invasive external cervical orthosis has been shown to prevent further neurologic decline; however, this treatment modality has not been successful at restoring neurologic and motor function, especially in long standing cases with significant weakness. The pathophysiology remains not entirely understood, complicating standardized operative guidelines; however, some studies report favorable outcomes with internal fixation. We report a successful surgically treated case of pediatric Hirayama disease, supplemented by a systematic review and collation of reported cases in the literature.

METHODS

A review of the literature was performed by searching PubMed, Embase, and Web of Science. Full-length articles were included if they reported clinical data regarding the treatment of at least one patient with Hirayama disease and the neurologic outcome of that treatment. Articles were excluded if they did not provide information on treatment outcomes, were abstract-only publications, or were published in languages other than English.

RESULTS

Of the fifteen articles reviewed, 63 patients were described, with 59 undergoing surgery. This encompassed both anterior and posterior spinal procedures and 1 hand tendon transfer. Fifty-five patients, including one from our institution, showed improvement post-treatment. Eleven of these patients were under 18 years old.

CONCLUSION

Hirayama disease is an infrequent yet impactful cervical myelopathy with limited high-quality evidence available for optimal treatment. The current literature supports surgical decompression and stabilization as promising interventions. However, comprehensive research is crucial for evolving diagnosis and treatment paradigms.

How to reconstruct the lordosis of cervical spine in patients with Hirayama disease? A finite element analysis of biomechanical changes focusing on adjacent segments after anterior cervical discectomy and fusion

Purpose

To compare the biomechanical changes of adjacent segments between patients with Hirayama disease and non-pathological people after anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) operation, and to explore the optimal degree of local lordosis reconstruction during surgery.

Methods

A young male volunteer was recruited to establish a three-dimensional finite element model of the lower cervical spine based on the CT data. By adjusting the bony structures and simulating the operation process, the models of non-pathological individuals before and after ACDF, patients with Hirayama disease before and after ACDF, and different local lordosis angles were established. Then, the postoperative range of motion (RoM) and stress of the adjacent segments under flexion, extension, left bending, right bending, left rotation and right rotation were recorded and compared.

Results

The RoM and stress of all segments of lower cervical spine in patients with Hirayama disease are higher than those in non-pathological individual, and this trend still exists after ACDF surgery. When the local lordosis angle is under physiological conditions, the RoM and stress of the adjacent segments are minimum.

Conclusion

Compared with non-pathological people, Hirayama disease patients have differences in cervical biomechanics, which may lead to cervical hypermobility and overload. After ACDF, the possibility of adjacent segments degeneration is greater than that of non-pathological people. When the operation maintains the physiological local lordosis angle, it can slow down the degeneration.

The Relationship Between Preoperative Cervical Sagittal Balance and Clinical Outcome of Patients With Hirayama Disease Treated With Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion

OBJECTIVE

Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) is a common surgical method used to treat patients with Hirayama disease. And sagittal balance indexes have been revealed to be predictors of clinical outcomes in patients with cervical diseases, but their relationships with ACDF-treated Hirayama disease outcomes remain unknown. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the relationship of preoperative cervical sagittal balance indexes and clinical outcomes in ACDF-treated Hirayama disease patients.

METHODS

Eighty patients with Hirayama disease treated by ACDF were reviewed retrospectively. Six cervical sagittal balance parameters were collected including Cobb angle, T1 slope, C1-7 sagittal vertical axis (SVA), C2-7 SVA, center of gravity of the head (CGH)-C7 SVA, range of motion. The recovery outcomes of the patients were divided into 2 groups by Odom score and the differences in recovery between the 2 groups were confirmed by electromyography. The correlation between imaging parameters and postoperative outcome was evaluated with logistic regression. The receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve and area under the ROC curve (AUC) were used to evaluate the significant result of logistic regression and the optimal diagnostic value.

RESULTS

Only 2 parameters, Cobb angle and CGH-C7 SVA, showed statistical correlation with the postoperative outcome assessment by logistic regression. AUC of Cobb angle and CGH-C7 SVA were 0.559 and 0.702 respectively. The optimal predictive threshold was 1.50° and 5.40 mm, respectively.

CONCLUSION

A larger Cobb angle and smaller CGH-C7 SVA seemed to correlate with a better postoperative outcome. These 2 factors could be used to predict the outcome of surgical treatment of Hirayama disease preoperatively.

Hirayama's disease: an Italian single center experience and review of the literature

BACKGROUND

Hirayama's disease (HD), is a benign, self-limited, motor neuron disease, characterized by asymmetric weakness and atrophy of one or both distal upper extremities. In the present study we report the clinical, electrophysiological and MRI features of a group of Italian patients, with review of the literature. Moreover we propose an optimized MRI protocol for patients with suspected or diagnosed HD in order to make an early diagnosis and a standardized follow up.

METHODS

Eight patients with clinical suspicion of Hirayama disease underwent evaluation between January 2007 and November 2013. All patients underwent standard nerve conduction studies (NCS), electromyography (EMG) and motor/sensory evoked potentials (MEP/SEP). Cervical spine MRI studies were conducted with a 1.5 Tesla MRI scanner in neutral and flexion position, including sagittal T1-weighted sequences and sagittal and axial T2-weighted sequences. The following diagnostic features were evaluated: abnormal cervical curvature, localized cervical cord atrophy in the lower tract (C4-C7), presence of cord flattening (CF), intramedullary signal hyperintensity on T2 weighted sequences, anterior shifting of the posterior wall of the cervical dural sac (ASD) and presence of flow voids (EFV) in the posterior epidural space during flexion.

RESULTS

All patients complained of weakness in hand muscles as initial symptoms, associated with hand tremor in three of them and abnormal sweating of the hand palm in two of them. No sensory deficits and weakness at lower limbs were reported by any patients. Distal deep tendon reflexes at upper limbs were absent in all patients with the absence of the right tricipital reflex in one of them. Deep tendon reflexes at lower limbs were normal and no signs of pyramidal tract involvement were present. The clinical involvement at onset was unilateral in six patients (three left-sided and three right-sided) and bilateral asymmetric in two of them, with the right side more affected. With the progression of the disease all patients but one experienced weakness and wasting of hand muscles and forearm bilaterally, but still asymmetric. The duration of the progression phase of the disease ranged from eight months to three years. In all patients, NCS and EMG findings were consistent with a spinal metameric disorder involving the C7-T1 myotomes bilaterally; sensory conduction and electrophysiologic features at lower limbs were normal. MEP and SEP were normal and we did not observe the disappearance of the spinal potential during the neck flexion in any of the patients. MRI is the best diagnostic tool in the diagnosis of HD; it can confirm clinical diagnosis and exclude other conditions responsible for the neurological deficits leading to a correct patient management and therapy, limiting arm impairment. On MRI all patients had loss of the normal cervical lordosis (100%). Five patients had loss of attachment of posterior dural sac and anterior dural shift on flexion MRI with presence of flow voids from venous plexus congestion (62.5%); three patients had no anterior dislocation of the dural sac and no epidural vein congestion. Two patients showed localized cord atrophy, one at C5-C6 and the other at C6-C7 level (25%). Three patients had T2 intramedullary hyperintensities (37.5%) and cord flattening (CF) was present in 5 patients of 8 (62.5%).

CONCLUSIONS

HD is a rare entity and a self-limited condition, but it has to be early differentiated from other diseases that may determine myelopathy and amyotrophy to establish a correct therapy and limit arm impairment. MRI is very important to confirm the clinical suspect of HD and a standardized MRI protocol using axial and sagittal images in both neutral and flexing position is needed, in order to diagnose and follow up affected patients.

Mutational analysis of glycyl-tRNA synthetase (GARS) gene in Hirayama disease

Sporadic juvenile muscular atrophy of the distal upper extremity or Hirayama's disease (HD) and autosomal dominant motor distal neuronopathy/axonopathy (CMT2D/dSMA-V), produced by glycyl-tRNA synthetase (GARS) gene mutations, share some clinical features including: young age of onset, predilection for the distal upper extremity, asymmetry, sparing of proximal muscles and unusual cold sensitivity. However, incomplete penetrance of GARS gene mutations may account for apparently non-familial cases. In order to inquire whether GARS gene mutations are associated with HD we studied seven patients fulfilling the clinical and electrodiagnostic criteria for HD. All patients underwent MRI of cervical spine that excluded compressive myelopathy in neutral position and intramedullary pathology. Each patient was tested for the presence of mutations in GARS by sequencing all coding exons amplified from genomic DNA. No pathogenic mutations were found, excluding the role of GARS gene as a possible factor in the aetiology of HD in this cohort.

Hirayama disease

OBJECT

Controversy exists over the choice of surgical candidates and prognosis of Hirayama disease. The purpose of this study was to examine the outcomes of patients with cervical flexion myelopathy who received surgical treatment.

METHODS

A retrospective study was conducted. From May 2002 through December 2006, 6 young patients with cervical flexion myelopathy were seen in the Department of Neurosurgery at Chang Gung Memorial Hospital. The neurological and radiological findings in all 6 patients met the criteria for Hirayama disease. All patients had evidence of a tight dural canal or forward migration of the posterior wall of the dural canal in dynamic MR imaging studies. Five patients were treated with surgical decompressive procedures (4 anterior and 1 posterior) and 1 patient received conservative treatment. Duration of follow-up ranged from 13 months to 4 years.

RESULTS

Motor function improved in 3 of 5 surgically treated patients and sensory function improved in 2. Neurological symptoms were unchanged in the conservatively treated patient. During follow-up MR imaging in the surgical group, anterior effacement during neck flexion was noted in 1 patient treated with a posterior approach.

CONCLUSIONS

Hirayama disease is so rare that it is easily misdiagnosed. Diagnosis is achieved via clinical presentation, neurophysiological examination, and neuroradiological imaging studies (dynamic MR imaging). The anterior decompressive approach may be better for patients showing anterior effacement and severe cervical kyphosis during neck flexion in MR imaging.