Updated incidence of neurological deficits following insular glioma resection: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Factors affecting the extent of resection and neurological outcomes following transopercular resection of insular gliomas

BACKGROUND

Surgical resection of insular gliomas is a challenge. TO resection is considered more versatile and has lower risk of vascular damage. In this study, we aimed to understand the factors that affect resection rates, ischemic changes and neurological outcomes and studied the utility of IONM in patients who underwent TO resection for IGs.

METHODS

Retrospective analysis of 66 patients with IG who underwent TO resection was performed.

RESULTS

Radical resection was possible in 39% patients. Involvement of zone II and the absence of contrast enhancement predicted lower resection rate. Persistent deficit rate was 10.9%. Although dominant lobe tumors increased immediate deficit and fronto-orbital operculum involvement reduced prolonged deficit rate, no tumor related factor showed significant association with persistent deficits. 45% of patients developed a postoperative infarct, 53% of whom developed deficits. Most affected vascular territory was lenticulostriate (39%). MEP changes were observed in 9/57 patients. 67% of stable TcMEPs and 74.5% of stable strip MEPs did not develop any postoperative motor deficits. Long-term deficits were seen in 3 and 6% patients with stable TcMEP and strip MEPs respectively. In contrast, 25% and 50% of patients with reversible strip MEP and Tc MEP changes respectively had persistent motor deficits. DWI changes were clinically more relevant when accompanied by MEP changes intraoperatively, with persistent deficit rates three times greater when MEP changes occurred than when MEPs were stable.

CONCLUSION

Radical resection can be achieved in large, multizone IGs, with reasonable outcomes using TO approach and multimodal intraoperative strategy with IONM.

Surgical treatment for insular gliomas. A systematic review and meta-analysis on behalf of the EANS neuro-oncology section

Introduction

The appropriate surgical management of insular gliomas is controversial. Management strategies vary considerably between centers.

Research question

To provide robust resection, functional and epilepsy outcome figures, study growth patterns and tumor classification paradigms, analyze surgical approaches, mapping/monitoring strategies, surgery for insular glioblastoma, as well as molecular findings, and to identify open questions for future research.

Material and methods

On behalf of the EANS Neuro-oncology Section we performed a systematic review and meta-analysis (using a random-effects model) of the more current (2000-2023) literature in accordance with the PRISMA guidelines.

Results

The pooled postoperative motor and speech deficit rates were 6.8% and 3.6%. There was a 79.6% chance for postoperative epilepsy control. The postoperative KPI was 80-100 in 83.5% of cases. Functional monitoring/mapping paradigms (which may include awake craniotomies) seem mandatory. (Additional) awake surgery may result in slightly better functional but also worse resection outcomes. Transcortical approaches may carry a lesser rate of (motor) deficits than transsylvian surgeries.

Discussion and conclusions

This paper provides an inclusive overview and analysis of current surgical management of insular gliomas. Risks and complication rates in experienced centers do not necessarily compare unfavorably with the results of routine neuro-oncological procedures. Limitations of the current literature prominently include a lack of standardized outcome reporting. Questions and issues that warrant more attention include surgery for insular glioblastomas and how to classify the various growth patterns of insular gliomas.

Arteries Around the Superior Limiting Sulcus: Motor Complication Avoidance in Insular and Insulo-Opercular Surgery

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Insulo-opercular surgery can cause ischemic motor complications. A source of this is the arteries around the superior limiting sulcus (SLS), which reach the corona radiata, but the detailed anatomy remains unclear. To characterize arteries around the SLS including the long insular arteries (LIAs) and long medullary arteries, we classified them and examined their distribution in relation to the SLS, which helps reduce the risk of ischemia.

METHODS

Twenty adult cadaveric hemispheres were studied. Coronal brain slices were created perpendicular to the SLS representing insular gyri (anterior short, middle short, posterior short, anterior long, and posterior long). The arteries within 10-mm proximity of the SLS that reached the corona radiata were excavated and classified by the entry point.

RESULTS

A total of 122 arteries were identified. Sixty-three (52%), 20 (16%), and 39 (32%) arteries penetrated the insula (LIAs), peak of the SLS, and operculum (long medullary arteries), respectively. 100 and six (87%) arteries penetrated within 5 mm of the peak of the SLS. The arteries were distributed in the anterior short gyrus (19%), middle short gyrus (17%), posterior short gyrus (20%), anterior long gyrus (19%), and posterior long gyrus (25%). Seven arteries (5.7%) had anastomoses after they penetrated the parenchyma.

CONCLUSION

Approximately 90% of the arteries that entered the parenchyma and reached the corona radiata were within a 5-mm radius of the SLS in both the insula and operculum side. This suggests that using the SLS as a landmark during insulo-opercular surgery can decrease the chance of ischemia.

The Utility of Motor Evoked Potential Monitoring for Predicting Postoperative Motor Deficit in Patients With Insular Gliomas

PURPOSE

Motor evoked potential (MEP) monitoring has been widely applied in various neurosurgical operations. This study aimed to assess the predictive value of MEP monitoring for postoperative motor deficit (PMD) in patients with insular gliomas.

METHODS

Demographic and clinical data, MEP monitoring data, and follow-up data of 42 insular glioma patients were retrospectively reviewed, and 40 patients were finally enrolled. The value of MEP monitoring for predicting PMD was assessed with sensitivity, specificity, and false-positive/false-negative rates. Binary multivariate logistic regression analysis was performed to further identify the predictive value of MEP monitoring.

RESULTS

Statistical analysis showed that irreversible MEP changes, but not all MEP changes, were more effective in predicting PMD. The sensitivity and specificity of irreversible MEP changes for predicting long-term PMD were 85.71 and 93.94%, whereas the false-positive and -negative rates were 25.00 and 3.12% respectively. In addition, irreversible MEP changes were identified as the only independent predictor for long-term PMD (odds ratio, 101.714; 95% confidence interval, 6.001-1724.122; p = 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

MEP monitoring has been proven to be feasible in insular glioma surgery. Irreversible MEP changes showed good performance in predicting PMD. Their absence can offer an optimistic expectation for the long-term motor outcome. The findings can provide the surgical team with a more effective interpretation of MEP changes and contribute to exploring tailored MEP warning criteria.

Insula in epilepsy - "untying the gordian knot": A systematic review

PURPOSE

Despite significant advances in epileptology, there are still many uncertainties about the role of the insula in epilepsy. Until recently, most insular onset seizures were wrongly attributed to the temporal lobe. Further, there are no standardised approaches to the diagnosis and treatment of insular onset seizures. This systematic review gathers the available information about insular epilepsy and synthesizes current knowledge as a basis for future research.

METHOD

Adhering to the PRISMA guidelines, studies were meticulously extracted from the PubMed database. The empirical data pertaining to the semiology of insular seizures, insular networks in epilepsy, techniques of mapping the insula, and the surgical intricacies of non-lesional insular epilepsy were reviewed from published studies. The corpus of information available was then subjected to a process of concise summarization and astute synthesis.

RESULTS

Out of 235 studies identified for full-text review, 86 studies were included in the systematic review. The insula emerges as a brain region with a number of functional subdivisions. The semiology of insular seizures is diverse and depends on the involvement of particular subdivisions. The semiological heterogeneity of insular seizures is explained by the extensive connectivity of the insula and its subdivisions with all four lobes of the brain, deep grey matter structures, and remote brainstem areas. The mainstay of the diagnosis of seizure onset in the insula is stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG). The surgical resection of the insular epileptogenic zone (when possible) is the most effective treatment. Open surgery on the insula is challenging but magnetic resonance-guided laser interstitial thermal therapy (MRgLITT) also holds promise.

CONCLUSION

The physiological and functional roles of the insula in epilepsy have remained obfuscated. The dearth of precisely defined diagnostic and therapeutic protocols acts as an impediment to scientific advancement. This review could potentially facilitate forthcoming research endeavours by establishing a foundational framework for uniform data collection protocols, thereby enhancing the feasibility of comparing findings across future studies and promoting progress in this domain.

The transfrontal isthmus approach for insular glioma surgery

OBJECTIVE

The classic transopercular or transsylvian approach to insular gliomas removes the tumor laterally through the insular cortex. This study describes a new anteroposterior approach through the frontal isthmus for insular glioma surgery.

METHODS

The authors detailed the surgical techniques for resection of insular gliomas through the transfrontal isthmus approach. Fifty-nine insular gliomas with at least Berger-Sanai zone I involvement were removed with the new approach, and extent of resection and postoperative neurological outcomes were assessed.

RESULTS

Fifty-nine patients were enrolled in the study, including 35 men and 24 women, with a mean (range) age 44.3 (19-75) years. According to the Berger-Sanai classification system, the most common tumor was a giant glioma (67.8%), followed by involvement of zones I and IV (18.6%). Twenty-two cases were Yaşargil type 3A/B, and 37 cases were Yaşargil type 5A/B. The average angle between the lateral plane of the putamen and sagittal line was 33.53°, and the average width of the isthmus near the anterior insular point was 33.33 mm. The average angle between the lateral plane of the putamen and the sagittal line was positively correlated with the width of the isthmus near the anterior insular point (r = 0.935, p < 0.0001). The median (interquartile range [IQR]) preoperative tumor volume was 67.82 (57.64-92.19) cm3. Of 39 low-grade gliomas, 26 (66.67%) were totally resected; of 20 high-grade gliomas, 19 (95%) were totally resected. The median (IQR) extent of resection of the whole group was 100% (73.7%-100%). Intraoperative diffusion-weighted imaging showed no cases of middle cerebral artery- or lenticulostriate artery-related stroke. Extent of insular tumor resection was positively correlated with the angle of the lateral plane of the putamen and sagittal line (r = -0.329, p = 0.011) and the width of the isthmus near the anterior insular point (r = -0.267, p = 0.041). At 3 months postoperatively, muscle strength grade exceeded 4 in all cases, and all patients exhibited essentially normal speech. The median (IQR) Karnofsky performance score at 3 months after surgery was 90 (80-90).

CONCLUSIONS

The transfrontal isthmus approach changes the working angle from lateral-medial to anterior-posterior, allowing for maximal safe removal of insular gliomas.

Seizure outcome after resection of insular glioma: a systematic review, meta-analysis, and institutional experience

OBJECTIVE

Gliomas arising from the insular cortex can be epileptogenic, with a significant proportion of patients having medically refractory epilepsy. The impact of surgery on seizure control for such tumors is not well established. In this study, the authors aimed to investigate seizure outcomes after resection of insular gliomas using a meta-analysis and institutional experience.

METHODS

Three databases (Ovid MEDLINE, Embase, and Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials) were systematically searched for published studies of seizure outcomes after insular glioma resection from database inception to March 27, 2021. In addition, data were retrospectively collected on all adults (age > 17 years) who had undergone insular glioma resection between June 1997 and June 2015 at the authors' institution. Primary outcome measures were seizure freedom rates at 1 year and the last follow-up. Secondary outcome measures consisted of persistent postoperative neurological deficit beyond 90 days, mortality, and tumor progression or recurrence.

RESULTS

Eight studies reporting on 453 patients who had undergone 460 operations were included in the meta-analysis. The pooled mean age of the patients was 42 years. The pooled percentages of patients with extents of resection (EORs) ≥ 90%, 70%-89%, and < 70% were 55%, 33%, and 11%, respectively. The pooled seizure freedom rate at 1 year was 73% for Engel class IA and 78% for Engel class I. The pooled seizure freedom rate at the last follow-up was 60% for Engel class IA and 79% for Engel class I. The pooled percentage of persistent neurological deficit beyond 90 days was 3%. At the authors' institution, 109 patients had undergone resection of insular glioma. A greater EOR was the only significant independent predictor of seizure freedom after surgery (HR 0.290, p = 0.017). The optimal threshold for seizure freedom corresponded to an EOR of 81%. Patients with an EOR > 81% had a significantly higher seizure freedom rate (OR 2.16, p = 0.048).

CONCLUSIONS

Maximal safe resection can be performed with minimal surgical morbidity to achieve favorable seizure freedom rates in both the short and long term. When gross-total resection is not possible, an EOR > 81% confers the greatest sensitivity and specificity for achieving seizure freedom. Systematic review registration no.: CRD42021249404 (https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/).

Awake Mapping With Transopercular Approach in Right Insular-Centered Low-Grade Gliomas Improves Neurological Outcomes and Return to Work

BACKGROUND

Asleep vs awake surgery for right insula-centered low-grade glioma (LGG) is still debated.

OBJECTIVE

To compare neurological outcomes and return to work after resection for right insular/paralimbic LGG performed without vs with awake mapping.

METHODS

A personal surgical experience of right insula-centered LGG was analyzed, by comparing 2 consecutive periods. In the first period (group 1), patients underwent asleep surgery with motor mapping. In the second period (group 2), patients underwent intraoperative awake mapping of movement and cognitive functions.

RESULTS

This consecutive series included 143 LGGs: 41 in group 1 (1999-2009) and 102 in group 2 (2009-2020). There were no significant difference concerning preoperative clinicoradiological characteristics and histopathology results between both groups. Intraoperative motor mapping was positive in all cases in group 1. In group 2, beyond motor mapping, somatosensory, visuospatial, language, and/or cognitive functions were identified during cortical-subcortical stimulation. Postoperatively, 3 patients experienced a long-lasting deterioration with 2 hemiparesis due to deep stroke (1.3%) and 1 severe depressive syndrome, all of them in group 1 vs none in group 2 (P = .022). The rate of RTW was 81.5% in group 1 vs 95.5% in group 2 (P = .016). The tumor volume and extent of resection did not significantly differ across both groups.

CONCLUSION

This is the first study comparing asleep vs awake surgery for right insula-centered LGG. Despite similar extent of resection, functional outcomes were significantly better in awake patients by avoiding permanent neurological impairment and by increasing RTW. These results support the mapping of higher-order functions during awake procedure.

Awake Surgery for Left Posterior Insular Low-Grade Glioma Through the Parietorolandic Operculum: The Need to Preserve the Functional Connectivity. A Case Series

Objective: Surgical approach to low-grade glioma (LGG) involving the posterior insula is challenging, especially in the left hemisphere, with a high risk of sensorimotor, language, or visual deterioration. In this study, a case series of 5 right-handed patients harboring a left posterior insular LGG is reported, by detailing a transcorticosubcortical approach.

Method: The five surgeries were achieved in awake patients using cortical and axonal electrostimulation mapping. The glioma was removed through the left rolandic and/or parietal opercula, with preservation of the subcortical connectivity.

Results: The cortical mapping was positive in the five patients, enabling the selection of an optimal transcortical approach, via the anterolateral supramarginal gyrus in four patients and/or via the lateral retrocentral gyrus in three cases (plus through the left superior temporal gyrus in one case). Moreover, the white matter tracts were identified in all cases, i.e., the lateral part of the superior longitudinal fasciculus (five cases), the arcuate fasciculus (four cases), the thalamocortical somatosensory pathways (four cases), the motor pathway (one case), the semantic pathway (three cases), and the optic tract (one case). Complete resection of the LGG was achieved in two patients and near-total resection in three patients. There were no postoperative permanent sensorimotor, language, or visual deficits.

Conclusion: A transcortical approach through the parietorolandic operculum in awake patients represents safe and effective access to the left posterior insular LGG. Detection and preservation of the functional connectivity using direct electrostimulation of the white matter bundles are needed in this cross-road brain region to prevent otherwise predictable postsurgical impairments.

Surgical treatment of glial tumors of the paralimbic system

BACKGROUND

Tumors of the paralimbic system were considered inoperable for a long time due to high risk of postoperative complications. However, there have been significant changes in surgical tactics for these neoplasms over the past decades. Despite the improvement of surgical principles for these tumors and development of new approaches, risks of surgical treatment are still high (up to 33.6%).

OBJECTIVE

To assess the results of surgical treatment of paralimbic glial tumors and identify predictors of adverse outcomes.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed postoperative outcomes in 52 patients with paralimbic glial tumors at the neurosurgical department of the Pirogov National Medical Surgical Center between 2016 and 2020. Tumor dimensions and topography with surrounding structures were evaluated using preoperative MRI. Resection quality was evaluated within the first postoperative day considering MRI data. We applied transcranial or transcortical electrostimulation, direct cortical and subcortical bi- and monopolar stimulation for intraoperative functional assessment of corticospinal tract. Neurological examination was performed prior to surgery, after 24 hours, 7 days, and 6 months.

RESULTS

Total resection was performed in 39 patients, almost total - 5 patients, subtotal - 6 patients, partial resection - 2 patients. Mean volume of tumors before surgery was 95.1±55.1 cm³. After surgery, volume ranged from 0 to 24.7 cm³ (mean 2.2±5.01 cm³). After 24 hours, neurological symptoms de novo or aggravation of preoperative motor deficit was revealed in 17 (33%) patients. However, this impairment regressed in most patients, and only 4 (7%) patients retained these disorders after 6 months.

CONCLUSION

Transcortical or combined surgical approach in conjunction with multimodal neurophysiological monitoring allows total or close to total resection of paralimbic glioma in 85% of cases. Risk of postoperative complications is 7%. Unfavorable prognostic factors of neurological impairment are decrease in muscle response amplitude ≥50% according to transcranial neurophysiological stimulation and tumor spread medial to perforator arteries.

The ubiquitin hydrolase OTUB1 promotes glioma cell stemness via suppressing ferroptosis through stabilizing SLC7A11 protein

The ubiquitin hydrolase OTUB1 has been elucidated to be highly expressed in tumors, however, its roles in glioma progression are still confusing. Here, via analyzing several online datasets, OTUB1 expression was shown to be remarkably increased in glioma tissues compared to that in the adjacent tissues, and predicted a poor overall survival of glioma patients. Then OTUB1 was knocked down in glioma cells and it was found that OTUB1 knockdown significantly reduced glioma cell stemness by detecting sphere-formation ability, stemness marker expression, and ALDH activity. Mechanistic experiments revealed that OTUB1 stabilized SLC7A11 protein via directly interacting with SLC7A11, which is a key suppressor of ferripotosis. Indeed, OTUB1 knockdown triggered ferroptosis dependent on SLC7A11 expression. Notably, ectopic expression of SLC7A11 attenuated the inhibition of OTUB1 knockdown on the stemenss of glioma cells. Finally, we found a positive correlation between OTUB1 and SLC7A11 expression in clinical samples. Taken together, this work identifies a novel OTUB1/SLC7A11 axis contributing to glioma cell stemness.

Surgery of Insular Diffuse Gliomas-Part 2: Probabilistic Cortico-Subcortical Atlas of Critical Eloquent Brain Structures and Probabilistic Resection Map During Transcortical Awake Resection

BACKGROUND

Insular diffuse glioma surgery is challenging, and tools to help surgical planning could improve the benefit-to-risk ratio.

OBJECTIVE

To provide a probabilistic resection map and frequency atlases of critical eloquent regions of insular diffuse gliomas based on our surgical experience.

METHODS

We computed cortico-subcortical "eloquent" anatomic sites identified intraoperatively by direct electrical stimulations during transcortical awake resection of insular diffuse gliomas in adults.

RESULTS

From 61 insular diffuse gliomas (39 left, 22 right; all left hemispheric dominance for language), we provided a frequency atlas of eloquence of the opercula (left/right; pars orbitalis: 0%/5.0%; pars triangularis: l5.6%/4.5%; pars opercularis: 37.8%/27.3%; precentral gyrus: 97.3%/95.4%; postcentral and supramarginal gyri: 75.0%/57.1%; temporal pole and superior temporal gyrus: 13.3%/0%), which tailored the transcortical approach (frontal operculum to reach the antero-superior insula, temporal operculum to reach the inferior insula, parietal operculum to reach the posterior insula). We provided a frequency atlas of eloquence identifying the subcortical functional boundaries (36.1% pyramidal pathways, 50.8% inferior fronto-occipital fasciculus, 13.1% arcuate and superior longitudinal fasciculi complex, 3.3% somatosensory pathways, 8.2% caudate and lentiform nuclei). Vascular boundaries and increasing errors during testing limited the resection in 8.2% and 11.5% of cases, respectively. We provided a probabilistic 3-dimensional atlas of resectability.

CONCLUSION

Functional mapping under awake conditions has to be performed intraoperatively in each patient to guide surgical approach and resection of insular diffuse gliomas in right and left hemispheres. Frequency atlases of opercula eloquence and of subcortical eloquent anatomic boundaries, and probabilistic 3-dimensional atlas of resectability could guide neurosurgeons.

Surgery of Insular Diffuse Gliomas-Part 1: Transcortical Awake Resection Is Safe and Independently Improves Overall Survival

BACKGROUND

Insular diffuse glioma resection is at risk of vascular injury and of postoperative new neurocognitive deficits.

OBJECTIVE

To assess safety and efficacy of surgical management of insular diffuse gliomas.

METHODS

Observational, retrospective, single-institution cohort analysis (2005-2019) of 149 adult patients surgically treated for an insular diffuse glioma: transcortical awake resection with intraoperative functional mapping (awake resection subgroup, n = 61), transcortical asleep resection without functional mapping (asleep resection subgroup, n = 50), and stereotactic biopsy (biopsy subgroup, n = 38). All cases were histopathologically assessed according to the 2016 World Health Organization classification and cIMPACT-NOW update 3.

RESULTS

Following awake resection, 3/61 patients had permanent motor deficit, seizure control rates improved (89% vs 69% preoperatively, P = .034), and neurocognitive performance improved from 5% to 24% in tested domains, despite adjuvant oncological treatments. Resection rates were higher in the awake resection subgroup (median 94%) than in the asleep resection subgroup (median 46%; P < .001). There was more gross total resection (25% vs 12%) and less partial resection (34% vs 80%) in the awake resection subgroup than in the asleep resection subgroup (P < .001). Karnofsky Performance Status score <70 (adjusted hazard ratio [aHR] 2.74, P = .031), awake resection (aHR 0.21, P = .031), isocitrate dehydrogenase (IDH)-mutant grade 2 astrocytoma (aHR 5.17, P = .003), IDH-mutant grade 3 astrocytoma (aHR 6.11, P < .001), IDH-mutant grade 4 astrocytoma (aHR 13.36, P = .008), and IDH-wild-type glioblastoma (aHR 21.84, P < .001) were independent predictors of overall survival.

CONCLUSION

Awake surgery preserving the brain connectivity is safe, allows larger resections for insular diffuse gliomas than asleep resection, and positively impacts overall survival.

Surgical strategy for insular glioma

PURPOSE

The goal of this article is to review the outcomes of insular glioma surgery and discuss strategies to minimize postoperative morbidity.

METHODS

The authors reviewed the published literature on low- and high-grade insular gliomas with a focus on glioma biology, insular anatomy, and surgical technique.

RESULTS

Maximal safe resection of insular gliomas is associated with improved survival and is the primary goal of surgery. Protecting patient speech and motor function during insular glioma resection requires versatile integration of insular anatomy, cortical mapping, and microsurgical technique. Both the transsylvian and transcortical corridors to the insula are associated with low morbidity profiles, but the transcortical approach with intraoperative mapping is more favorable for gliomas within the posterior insular region.

CONCLUSIONS

Surgical strategy for insular gliomas is dependent on biological, anatomical, and clinical factors. Technical mastery integrated with intraoperative technologies can optimize surgical results.