Requirements for accurate estimation of shear modulus by magnetic resonance elastography: A computational comparative study

On the soft tissue ultrasound elastography using FEM based inversion approach

Elastography is a medical imaging modality that enables visualization of tissue stiffness. It involves quasi-static or harmonic mechanical stimulation of the tissue to generate a displacement field which is used as input in an inversion algorithm to reconstruct tissue elastic modulus. This paper considers quasi-static stimulation and presents a novel inversion technique for elastic modulus reconstruction. The technique follows an inverse finite element framework. Reconstructed elastic modulus maps produced in this technique do not depend on the initial guess, while it is computationally less involved than iterative reconstruction approaches. The method was first evaluated using simulated data (in-silico) where modulus reconstruction's sensitivity to displacement noise and elastic modulus was assessed. To demonstrate the method's performance, displacement fields of two tissue mimicking phantoms determined using three different motion tracking techniques were used as input to the developed elastography method to reconstruct the distribution of relative elastic modulus of the inclusion to background tissue. In the next stage, the relative elastic modulus of three clinical cases pertaining to liver cancer patient were determined. The obtained results demonstrate reasonably high elastic modulus reconstruction accuracy in comparison with similar direct methods. Also it is associated with reduced computational cost in comparison with iterative techniques, which suffer from convergence and uniqueness issues, following the same formulation concept. Moreover, in comparison with other methods which need initial guess, the presented method does not require initial guess while it is easy to understand and implement.

Reverberant magnetic resonance elastographic imaging using a single mechanical driver

Reverberant elastography provides fast and robust estimates of shear modulus; however, its reliance on multiple mechanical drivers hampers clinical utility. In this work, we hypothesize that for constrained organs such as the brain, reverberant elastography can produce accurate magnetic resonance elastograms with a single mechanical driver. To corroborate this hypothesis, we performed studies on healthy volunteers (n= 3); and a constrained calibrated brain phantom containing spherical inclusions with diameters ranging from 4-18 mm. In both studies (i.e. phantom and clinical), imaging was performed at frequencies of 50 and 70 Hz. We used the accuracy and contrast-to-noise ratio performance metrics to evaluate reverberant elastograms relative to those computed using the established subzone inversion method. Errors incurred in reverberant elastograms varied from 1.3% to 16.6% when imaging at 50 Hz and 3.1% and 16.8% when imaging at 70 Hz. In contrast, errors incurred in subzone elastograms ranged from 1.9% to 13% at 50 Hz and 3.6% to 14.9% at 70 Hz. The contrast-to-noise ratio of reverberant elastograms ranged from 63.1 to 73 dB compared to 65 to 66.2 dB for subzone elastograms. The average global brain shear modulus estimated from reverberant and subzone elastograms was 2.36 ± 0.07 kPa and 2.38 ± 0.11 kPa, respectively, when imaging at 50 Hz and 2.70 ± 0.20 kPa and 2.89 ± 0.60 kPa respectively, when imaging at 70 Hz. The results of this investigation demonstrate that reverberant elastography can produce accurate, high-quality elastograms of the brain with a single mechanical driver.

Fast magnetic resonance elastography with multiphase radial encoding and harmonic motion sparsity based reconstruction

Objective. To achieve fast magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) at a low frequency for better shear modulus estimation of the brain. Approach. We proposed a multiphase radial DENSE MRE (MRD-MRE) sequence and an improved GRASP algorithm utilizing the sparsity of the harmonic motion (SH-GRASP) for fast MRE at 20 Hz. For the MRD-MRE sequence, the initial position encoded by spatial modulation of magnetization (SPAMM) was decoded by an arbitrary number of readout blocks without increasing the number of phase offsets. Based on the harmonic motion, a modified total variation and temporal Fourier transform were introduced to utilize the sparsity in the temporal domain. Both phantom and brain experiments were carried out and compared with that from multiphase Cartesian DENSE-MRE (MCD-MRE), and conventional gradient echo sequence (GRE-MRE). Reconstruction performance was also compared with GRASP and compressed sensing. Main results. Results showed the scanning time of a fully sampled image with four phase offsets for MRD-MRE was only 1/5 of that from GRE-MRE. The wave patterns and estimated stiffness maps were similar to those from MCD-MRE and GRE-MRE. With SH-GRASP, the total scan time could be shortened by additional 4 folds, achieving a total acceleration factor of 20. Better metric values were also obtained using SH-GRASP for reconstruction compared with other algorithms. Significance. The MRD-MRE sequence and SH-GRASP algorithm can be used either in combination or independently to accelerate MRE, showing the potentials for imaging the brain as well as other organs.

In silicoevaluation and optimisation of magnetic resonance elastography of the liver

Objective.Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) is widely adopted as a biomarker of liver fibrosis. However,in vivoMRE accuracy is difficult to assess.Approach.Finite element model (FEM) simulation was employed to evaluate liver MRE accuracy and inform methodological optimisation. MRE data was simulated in a 3D FEM of the human torso including the liver, and compared with spin-echo echo-planar imaging MRE acquisitions. The simulated MRE results were compared with the ground truth magnitude of the complex shear modulus (∣G*∣) for varying: (1) ground truth liver ∣G*∣; (2) simulated imaging resolution; (3) added noise; (4) data smoothing. Motion and strain-based signal-to-noise (SNR) metrics were evaluated on the simulated data as a means to select higher-quality voxels for preparation of acquired MRE summary statistics of ∣G*∣.Main results.The simulated MRE accuracy for a given ground truth ∣G*∣ was found to be a function of imaging resolution, motion-SNR and smoothing. At typical imaging resolutions, it was found that due to under-sampling of the MRE wave-field, combined with motion-related noise, the reconstructed simulated ∣G*∣ could contain errors on the scale of the difference between liver fibrosis stages, e.g. 54% error for ground truth ∣G*∣ = 1 kPa. Optimum imaging resolutions were identified for given ground truth ∣G*∣ and motion-SNR levels.Significance.This study provides important knowledge on the accuracy and optimisation of liver MRE. For example, for motion-SNR ≤ 5, to distinguish between liver ∣G*∣ of 2 and 3 kPa (i.e. early-stage liver fibrosis) it was predicted that the optimum isotropic voxel size is 4-6 mm.

Viscoelastic parameters of invasive breast cancer in correlation with porous structure and elemental analysis data

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Invasive ductal carcinoma (IDC) is the most common and aggressive type of breast cancer. As many clinical diagnoses are concerned with the tumor behavior at the compression, the IDC characterization using a compression test is performed in the present study. In the field of tissue characterization, most of the previous studies have focused on healthy and cancerous breast tissues at the cellular level; however, characterization of cancerous tissue at the tissue level has been under-represented, which is the target of the present study.

METHODS

Throughout this article, 18 IDC samples are tested using a ramp-relaxation test. The strain rate in the ramp phase is similar for all samples, whereas the strain level is set at 2,4 and 6%. The experimental stress-time data is interpolated by a viscoelastic model. Two relaxation times, as well as the instantaneous and long-term shear moduli, are calculated for each specimen.

RESULTS

The results show that the long-term and instantaneous shear moduli vary in the range of 0.31-17.03 kPa and 6.03-55.13 kPa, respectively. Our assessment of the viscoelastic parameters is accompanied by observing structural images of the IDCs and inspecting their elemental composition. It is concluded that IDCs with lower Magnesium to Calcium ratio (Mg:Ca) have smaller shear modulus and longer relaxation time, with a p-value of 0.001 and 0.01 for the correlation between Mg:Ca and long-term shear modulus, and Mg:Ca and early relaxation time.

CONCLUSIONS

Our identification of the IDC viscoelastic parameters can contribute to the IDC inspection at the tissue level. The results also provide useful information for modeling of breast cancer.

MR elastography inversion by compressive recovery

Direct inversion (DI) derives tissue shear modulus by inverting the Helmholtz equation. However, conventional DI is sensitive to data quality due to the ill-posed nature of Helmholtz inversion and thus providing reliable stiffness estimation can be challenging. This becomes more problematic in the case of estimating shear stiffness of the lung in which the low tissue density and short T2* result in considerably low signal-to-noise ratio during lung MRE. In the present study, we propose to perform MRE inversion by compressive recovery (MICRo). Such a technique aims to improve the numerical stability and the robustness to data noise of Helmholtz inversion by using prior knowledge on data noise and transform sparsity of the stiffness map. The developed inversion strategy was first validated in simulated phantoms with known stiffness. Next, MICRo was compared to the standard clinical multi-modal DI (MMDI) method forin vivoliver MRE in healthy subjects and patients with different stages of liver fibrosis. After establishing the accuracy of MICRo, we demonstrated the robustness of the proposed technique against data noise in lung MRE with healthy subjects. In simulated phantoms with single-directional or multi-directional waves, MICRo outperformed DI with Romano filter or Savitsky and Golay filter, especially when the stiffness and/or noise level was high. In hepatic MRE application, agreement was observed between MICRo and MMDI. Measuringin vivolung stiffness, MICRo demonstrated its advantages over filtered DI by yielding stable stiffness estimation at both residual volume and total lung capacity. These preliminary results demonstrate the potential value of the proposed technique and also warrant further investigation in a larger clinical population.