Biomechanical evaluation of syndesmotic fixation techniques via finite element analysis: Screw vs. suture button

Better outcomes using suture button compared to screw fixation in talofibular syndesmotic injuries of the ankle: a level I evidence-based meta-analysis

INTRODUCTION

The present meta-analysis evaluated current level I clinical trials which compared the use of a suture button (SB) versus syndesmotic screw (SS) fixation techniques for syndesmosis injuries of the ankle. The outcomes of interest were to compare patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) and complications. It was hypothesised that SB might achieve better PROMs along with a lower rate of complications.

METHODS

This study was conducted according to the 2020 PRISMA statement. In August 2023, PubMed, Web of Science, Google Scholar, and Embase were accessed. All the randomised controlled trials (RCTs) which compared SB versus SS fixation for syndesmosis injuries of the ankle were accessed. Data concerning the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS), and Olerud-Molander score (OMS) were collected at baseline and at last follow-up. Data on implant failure, implant removal, and joint malreduction were also retrieved.

RESULTS

Data from seven RCTs (490 patients) were collected. 33% (161 of 490) were women. The mean length of the follow-up was 30.8 ± 27.4 months. The mean age of the patients was 41.1 ± 4.1 years. Between the two groups (SB and SS), comparability was found in the mean age, and men:women ratio. The SS group evidenced lower OMS (P = 0.0006) and lower AOFAS (P = 0.03). The SS group evidenced a greater rate of implant failure (P = 0.0003), implant removal (P = 0.0005), and malreduction (P = 0.04).

CONCLUSION

Suture button fixation might perform better than the syndesmotic screw fixation in syndesmotic injuries of the ankle.

Investigation into the effect of deltoid ligament injury on rotational ankle instability using a three-dimensional ankle finite element model

Background

Injury to the lateral collateral ligament of the ankle may cause ankle instability and, when combined with deltoid ligament (DL) injury, may lead to a more complex situation known as rotational ankle instability (RAI). It is unclear how DL rupture interferes with the mechanical function of an ankle joint with RAI.

Purpose

To study the influence of DL injury on the biomechanical function of the ankle joint.

Methods

A comprehensive finite element model of an ankle joint, incorporating detailed ligaments, was developed from MRI scans of an adult female. A range of ligament injury scenarios were simulated in the ankle joint model, which was then subjected to a static standing load of 300 N and a 1.5 Nm internal and external rotation torque. The analysis focused on comparing the distribution and peak values of von Mises stress in the articular cartilages of both the tibia and talus and measuring the talus rotation angle and contact area of the talocrural joint.

Results

The dimensions and location of insertion points of ligaments in the finite element ankle model were adopted from previous anatomical research and dissection studies. The anterior drawer distance in the finite element model was within 6.5% of the anatomical range, and the talus tilt angle was within 3% of anatomical results. During static standing, a combined rupture of the anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) and anterior tibiotalar ligament (ATTL) generates new stress concentrations on the talus cartilage, which markedly increases the joint contact area and stress on the cartilage. During static standing with external rotation, the anterior talofibular ligament and anterior tibiotalar ligament ruptured the ankle's rotational angle by 21.8% compared to an intact joint. In contrast, static standing with internal rotation led to a similar increase in stress and a nearly 2.5 times increase in the talus rotational angle.

Conclusion

Injury to the DL altered the stress distribution in the tibiotalar joint and increased the talus rotation angle when subjected to a rotational torque, which may increase the risk of RAI. When treating RAI, it is essential to address not only multi-band DL injuries but also single-band deep DL injuries, especially those affecting the ATTL.

Biomechanical analysis of different internal fixation methods for special Maisonneuve fracture of the ankle joint based on finite element analysis

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to evaluate the biomechanical properties of different internal fixation methods for Maisonneuve fractures under physiological loading conditions.

METHODS

Finite element analysis was used to numerically analyze various fixation methods. The study focused on high fibular fractures and included six groups of internal fixation: high fibular fracture without fixation + distal tibiofibular elastic fixation (group A), high fibular fracture without fixation + distal tibiofibular strong fixation (group B), high fibular fracture with 7-hole plate internal fixation + distal tibiofibular elastic fixation (group C), high fibular fracture with 7-hole plate internal fixation + distal tibiofibular strong fixation (group D), high fibular fracture with 5-hole plate internal fixation + distal tibiofibular elastic fixation (group E), and high fibular fracture with 5-hole plate internal fixation + distal tibiofibular strong fixation (group F). The finite element method was employed to simulate and analyze the different internal fixation models for the six groups, generating overall structural displacement and Von Mises stress distribution maps during slow walking and external rotation motions.

RESULTS

Group A demonstrated the best ankle stability under slow walking and external rotation, with reduced tibial and fibular stress after fibular fracture fixation. Group D had the least displacement and most stability, while group A had the largest displacement and least stability. Overall, high fibular fracture fixation improved ankle stability. In slow walking, groups D and A had the least and greatest interosseous membrane stress. Comparing 5-hole plate (E/F) and 7-hole plate (C/D) fixation, no significant differences were found in ankle strength or displacement under slow walking or external rotation.

CONCLUSION

Combining internal fixation for high fibular fractures with elastic fixation of the lower tibia and fibula is optimal for orthopedic treatment. It yields superior outcomes compared to no fibular fracture fixation or strong fixation of the lower tibia and fibula, especially during slow walking and external rotation. To minimize nerve damage, a smaller plate is recommended. This study strongly advocates for the clinical use of 5-hole plate internal fixation for high fibular fractures with elastic fixation of the lower tibia and fibula (group E).

Thermomechanical damage in cortical bone caused by margins of surgical drill bit: A finite element analysis

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Conventional surgical drill bits suffer from several drawbacks, including extreme heat generation, breakage, jam, and undesired breakthrough. Understanding the impacts of drill margin on bone damage can provide insights that lay the foundation for improvement in the existing surgical drill bit. However, research on drill margins in bone drilling is lacking. This work assesses the influences of margin height and width on thermomechanical damage in bone drilling.

METHODS

Thermomechanical damage-maximum bone temperature, osteonecrosis diameter, osteonecrosis depth, maximum thrust force, and torque-were calculated using the finite element method under various margin heights (0.05-0.25 mm) and widths (0.02-0.26 mm). The simulation results were validated with experimental tests and previous research data.

RESULTS

The effect of margin height in increasing the maximum bone temperature, osteonecrosis diameter, and depth were at least 19.1%, 41.9%, and 59.6%, respectively. The thrust force and torque are highly sensitive to margin height. A higher margin height (0.21-0.25 mm) reduced the thrust force by 54.0% but increased drilling torque by 142.2%. The bone temperature, osteonecrosis diameter, and depth were 16.5%, 56.5%, and 81.4% lower, respectively, with increasing margin width. The minimum thrust force (11.1 N) and torque (41.9 Nmm) were produced with the highest margin width (0.26 mm). The margin height of 0.05-0.13 mm and a margin width of 0.22-0.26 produced the highest sum of weightage.

CONCLUSIONS

A surgical drill bit with a margin height of 0.05-0.13 mm and a margin width of 0.22-0.26 mm can produce minimum thermomechanical damage in cortical bone drilling. The insights regarding the suitable ranges for margin height and width from this study could be adopted in future research devoted to optimizing the margin of the existing surgical drill bit.

Biomechanical Sequelae of Syndesmosis Injury and Repair

This review characterizes fibula mechanics in the context of syndesmosis injury and repair. Through detailed understanding of fibula kinematics (the study of motion) and kinetics (the study of forces that cause motion), the full complexity of fibula motion can be appreciated. Although the magnitudes of fibula rotation and translation are inherently small, even slight alterations of fibula position or movement can substantially impact force propagation through the ankle and hindfoot joints. Accordingly, implications for clinical care are discussed.

Homogeneous material models can overestimate stresses in high tibial osteotomy: A finite element analysis

Although widely used numerical models can assess the stability of lateral hinges in high tibial osteotomy (HTO) and may provide acceptable results in comparative studies, accurate stress prediction may not be possible due to simplified homogeneous models of the bone. The present study aimed to investigate the effect of a heterogeneous versus four homogeneous models on the results of stress and force. Each of the four homogenized FE models utilized the same elastic modulus of 16,700 MPa for the cortical while employing a single elastic modulus varying from 155 to 5000 MPa for the cancellous. In heterogeneous model, the modulus of each element was assigned using the bone density. It was found that stresses at the hinge in homogeneous models were higher than those in the heterogeneous model. The maximum principal stress (MPS) was 437 MPa for the heterogeneous model while that was 2179, 2351, 2581, and 2637 MPa for the homogeneous models with the elastic moduli of 155, 500, 2130, and 5000 MPa, respectively. Also, the opening force was 150 N for the heterogeneous model significantly lower than 649-1534 N range predicted for the homogeneous models. The use of a homogeneous model in the FE analysis of HTO overestimated the stresses and force. Thus, in addition to casting doubt on the use of a single modulus in the numerical analysis of HTO, Future HTO studies can use our results as a benchmark for comparison purposes and highlight the use of patient-specific bone density - elastic modulus relation in simulation.

Biomechanics comparison between endobutton fixation and syndesmotic screw fixation for syndesmotic injury ankle fracture; a finite element analysis and cadaveric validation study

Introduction

Various syndesmotic fixation methods in ankle injury are recommended; however, a lack of biomechanical information persists regarding the stiffness of the fixation methods. The current study thus aimed to assess biomechanical cadaveric validation and perform a finite element analysis of syndesmotic fixation comparing endobutton vs. screw after syndesmotic injury with an ankle fracture.

Method

Five pairs of ankles of fresh cadavers were used for the validity test for Anterior Inferior Tibiofibular Ligament (AITFL), Posterior Inferior Tibiofibular Ligament (PITFL), and Interosseous ligament biomechanics properties. Four finite element models (FEM) were created: an intact model, a fracture model with/without syndesmotic injury, an endobutton fixation model, and a syndesmotic screw fixation model. Each FEM was tested vis-à-vis external rotation force, anteroposterior translation force, and compression force until model failure. The primary outcomes were stiffness and force until failure.

Result

The respective anteroposterior translation force for the stiffness of the intact model, the screw fixation model, and the endobutton fixation was 8.14, 9.15, and 8.17 N/mm. The respective external rotation force for the stiffness of intact, screw fixation, and endobutton model was 0.927,0.949, and 0.940 Nm/degree. The respective stress under compression force in the intact, screw fixation, and endobutton model was 39.94,25.59, and 37.30 MPa.

Conclusion

Both screw and endobutton fixation models provided more translation, compression, and rotation stability than normal syndesmosis, but the screw model provided greater translation and compression force stability than the endobutton model. There was no difference in rotational stability between the two models. We thus recommend the same rehabilitation protocol for both fixation methods; however, vigorous translation and compression should be avoided when using endobutton fixation.

Suture button fixation method used in the treatment of syndesmosis injury: A biomechanical analysis of the effect of the placement of the button on the distal tibiofibular joint in the mid-stance phase with finite elements method

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study is to research the effect of suture button (SB) fixation, a method used at the treatment of ankle syndesmosis injury, which was applied in various angles, pretension force, and levels, on the distal tibiofibular joint (DTFJ) in the mid-stance phase, with the help of three-dimensional finite elements method (FEM) METHOD: The ankle of a healthy individual was digitally analyzed by a finite element method-based package computer program. Then, anterior inferior tibiofibular ligament (AITFL), interosseous ligament, posterior inferior tibiofibular ligament (PITFL) and deltoid ligament (DL) were cut and force and rotation has been applied to the proximal tibia, resulting in syndesmosis injury. Then, various suture button applications on the injured model have been analyzed. Three parameters have been changed; which were divergence in the axial plane (20°, 30°, 40°), distance from the ankle (2, 3, 4 cm), and pretension force (200, 300, 600 N) RESULTS: As the result of this study, the rotation, change in the gap between the distal tibia and distal fibula, and the displacements of the fibula in the x and y axes have been obtained, and numerical results were evaluated. As the force increased, rotation, change in the gap between the distal tibia and distal fibula, and the displacements of the fibula decreased. As suture button application rotation increased, change in the gap between the distal tibia and distal fibula, and displacements of the fibula increased. As the distance from the ankle increases and reaches a certain level, the results converge to those of the healthy model; in the proximal, it diverges from healthy results.

CONCLUSION

In the study, it has been shown that abnormal tibiofibular joint movements can be prevented with suture button application, and optimum application parameters (divergence in the axial plane, distance from the ankle, and pretension force) are given for proper reduction.

Computer-aided automatic planning and biomechanical analysis of a novel arc screw for pelvic fracture internal fixation

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

The sacroiliac joint screw is a common fixation method for pelvic posterior ring fractures. The complex anatomical structure around the pelvis makes it impossible to find a suitable fixed path, which increases the difficulty of surgical operation. In this paper, we propose an automatic planning algorithm based on a computer-aided internal arc fixation channel for pelvic fractures for the first time.

METHODS

A channel generation algorithm based on seed derived points was designed, and the optimal channel was selected by scoring rules based on 3D erode algorithm for the generated channel. The biomechanical properties of the internal arc fixation screw and traditional internal straight fixation screw in three postures were compared using biomechanical finite element analysis.

RESULTS

The proposed algorithm verified the existence of a more adaptable internal arc fixation channel and can quantitatively plan a relatively optimal constant-curvature internal arc fixation channel in pelvises of ten adults. Significantly high stresses concentrated around the interaction region between the screws and bone may increase the risk of bone fractures and screw loosening in the long term. The experimental results show that the internal arc fixation screw has better strain and deformation performance than the internal straight fixation screw.

CONCLUSIONS

A novel arc internal fixation method for pelvic fractures was proposed to improve the safety and stability of screw fixation of pelvic fracture. The nonparametric test proved that the sacroiliac dislocation model repaired by internal arc fixation screw was significantly different from that repaired by internal straight fixation screw. The computer-aided automatic planning algorithm provides the possibility of robot-assisted pelvic fracture fixation.

A 10-Year Follow-Up of Ankle Syndesmotic Injuries: Prospective Comparison of Knotless Suture-Button Fixation and Syndesmotic Screw Fixation

Background: Acute syndesmosis injury (ASI) is an indication for surgical stabilization if instability is confirmed. In recent years, fixation using the knotless suture-button (SB) device has become increasingly established as an alternative to set screw fixation (SF). This study directly compared the clinical long-term results after prospective randomized inclusion. Materials and Methods: Between 2011 and 2012, 62 patients with ASI were enrolled in a prospective, randomized, and monocentric study. Forty-one patients were available for a 10-year follow-up ((31 males and 10 females), including 21 treated with SB (mean age 44.4 years), and 20 with SF (mean age 47.2 years)). In addition to comparing the demographic data and syndesmosis injury etiology, follow-up assessed the Olerud−Molander Ankle Score (OMAS) and FADI-Score (Foot and Ankle Disability Index Score) with subscales for activities of daily living (ADL) and sports activity. Results: The mean OMAS was 95.98 points (SB: 98.81, SF: 93.00), the mean FADI ADL was 97.58 points (SB: 99.22, SF: 95.86), and the mean FADI Sport was 94.14 points (SB: 97.03, SF: 91.10). None of the measurements differed significantly between the groups (p > 0.05). No clinical suspicion of chronic instability remained in any of the patients, regardless of treatment. Conclusions: The short-term results showed that athletes in particular benefit from SB fixation due to their significantly faster return to sports activities. However, the available long-term results confirm a very good outcome in the clinical scores for both approaches. Chronic syndesmotic insufficiency was not suspected in any of the patients. Level of evidence: I, randomized controlled trial.

A Novel Adjustable EndoButton Fixation Assisted by 3D Printing Technology for Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injury: A Biomechanical Study

Purpose: The recommendations for surgical fixation of tibiofibular syndesmosis injuries are increasingly challenging for many clinical orthopedists, as international consensus has not been published for the optimal treatment of the injury. Thus, we have created a 3D-printed navigation template for a precise bone tunnel and a novel adjustable EndoButton fixation (NAE) for the ideal treatment. The purpose of this research was to evaluate the accuracy of the 3D-printed navigation template and explore the biomechanical performance of the NAE technique by comparing it with the intact syndesmosis, screw technique, and TightRope (TR) technique.

Methods: Twenty-four human cadaveric legs were randomly allocated to four groups: the NAE group (n = 6), TR group (n = 6), screw group (n = 6), and intact group (n = 6). A personalized navigation template based on computed tomography scans was designed, and 3D printing models were generated for the distal tibiofibular syndesmosis. The NAE, TR, and screw group were performed via 3D-printed navigation template, respectively. All groups were tested under increasing loading forces including axial loading (from 100 N to 700 N) and torsional loading (from 1 N to 5 N), which were performed in different ankle positions. The displacements of the tibiofibular syndesmosis were analyzed using the Bose Electroforce 3510-AT biomechanical testing equipment.

Results: Surgical fixations were conducted successfully through a 3D-printed navigation template. Both in axial or torsional loading experiments, no statistically significant difference was observed in the displacements among the NAE, TR, and intact groups in most situations (p > 0.05), whereas the screw group demonstrated obviously smaller displacements than the abovementioned three groups (p < 0.05).

Conclusion: The 3D printing technology application may become beneficial and favorable for locating and making the bone tunnel. Also, the NAE fixation provides the performance of complete ligaments; it also restores physiologic micromotion and avoids insufficient or excessive reduction when compared to the TR and screw technique. This may offer a new fixation for the treatment of tibiofibular syndesmosis injuries that is desirable for clinical promotion.