Effect of the hydrophobic phase on interfacial phenomena of surfactants, proteins, and particles at fluid interfaces

Cysteines in β-lactoglobulin affects its interfacial adsorption and protein film stabilization

HYPOTHESIS

Disulfide bonds in proteins are strong chemical bonds forming the secondary and tertiary structure like in the dairy protein β-lactoglobulin. We hypothesize that the partial or complete removal of disulfide bonds affects the structural rearrangement of proteins caused by intra- and intermolecular interactions that in turn define the interfacial activity of proteins at oil/water interfaces. The experimental and numerical investigations contribute to the mechanistic understanding of the structure-function relationship, especially for the interfacial adsorption behavior of proteins.

EXPERIMENTAL AND NUMERICAL

Systematically, the 5 cysteines of β-lactoglobulin were recombinantly exchanged by alanine. First, the protein structure of the variants in bulk was analyzed with Fourier-transform-infrared-spectroscopy and molecular dynamic simulations. Second, the structural changes after adsorption to the interface have been also analyzed by molecular dynamic simulations. The adsorption behavior was investigated by pendant drop analysis and the interfacial film properties by dilatational rheology.

FINDINGS

The structural flexibility of β-lactoglobulin with no cysteines encourages its unfolding at the interface, and accelerates the interfacial protein film formation that results in more visco-elastic films in comparison to the reference.

Mitigation Strategies against Antibody Aggregation Induced by Oleic Acid in Liquid Formulations

Polysorbates 20 and 80 (PS20 and PS80) are commonly used in the formulations of biologics to protect against interfacial stresses. However, these surfactants can degrade over time, releasing free fatty acids, which assemble into solid particles or liquid droplets. Here, we apply a droplet microfluidic platform to analyze the interactions between antibodies and oleic acid, the primary free fatty acid resulting from the hydrolysis of PS80. We show that antibodies adsorb within seconds to the polar oleic acid-water interface, forming a viscoelastic protein layer that leads to particle formation upon mechanical rupture. By testing two different monoclonal antibodies of pharmaceutical origin, we show that the propensity to form a rigid viscoelastic layer is protein-specific. We further demonstrate that intact PS80 is effective in preventing antibody adsorption at the oleic acid-water interface only at low antibody concentrations and low pH, where oleic acid is fully protonated. Importantly, introduction of the amino acid l-arginine prevents the formation of the interfacial layer and protein particles even at high antibody concentrations (180 mg mL-1). Overall, our findings indicate that oleic acid droplets in antibody formulations can lead to the formation of protein particles via an interface-mediated mechanism. Depending on the conditions, intact PS80 alone might not be sufficient to protect against antibody aggregation. Additional mitigation strategies include the optimization of protein physicochemical properties, pH, and the addition of arginine.

Creating High Yield Stress Particle-Laden Oil/Water Interfaces Using Charge Bidispersity

Interfacial engineering has been increasingly used to stabilize Pickering emulsions in commercial products and biomedical applications. Pickering emulsion stabilization is aided by interfacial viscoelasticity; however, typically the primary means of stabilization are steric hindrances between high surface concentration shells of particles around the drops. In this work, the concept of creating large interfacial viscoelastic yield stresses with low particle surface concentrations (<50%) using bidisperse charged particle systems is tested to evaluate their potential efficacy in emulsion stabilization. To explore this hypothesis, interfacial rheology and visualization experiments are conducted at o/w interfaces using positively charged amidine, negatively charged carboxylate, and negatively charged sulfate-coated latex spheres and compared to a model based on interparticle forces. Bidisperse particle systems have been observed to create more networked structures than monodisperse systems. For surface concentrations of <50%, bidisperse interfaces created measurable viscoelastic moduli ∼1 order of magnitude larger than monodisperse interfaces. Furthermore, these interfaces have measurable yield stresses on the order of 10-4 Pa·m when monodisperse systems have none. Bidispersity impacts surface viscoelasticity primarily by increasing the overall magnitude of attraction between particles at the interface and not due to changes in the microstructure. The developed model predicts the relative surface fraction that creates the largest moduli and shows good agreement with the experimental data. The results demonstrate the ability to create large viscoelastic moduli for small surface fractions of particles, which may enable stabilization using fewer particles in future applications.

(Non)linear Interfacial Rheology of Tween, Brij and Span Stabilized Oil-Water Interfaces: Impact of the Molecular Structure of the Surfactant on the Interfacial Layer Stability

During emulsification and further processing (e.g., pasteurizing), the oil-water interface is mechanically and thermally stressed, which can lead to oil droplet aggregation and coalescence, depending on the interfacial properties. Currently, there is a lack of insights into the impact of the molecular structure (headgroup and FA chain) of low molecular weight emulsifiers (LME) on the resulting interfacial properties. Additionally, the crystallization/melting of the oil/the emulsifier is often neglected within interfacial rheological experiments. Within this study, the stability of interfaces formed by Tween, Span or Brij was determined as a function of their molecular structure, taking crystallization effects of the LME into account. The headgroup was kept constant while varying the FA, or vice versa. The interfacial film properties (viscoelasticity) were investigated at different temperatures using dilatational and interfacial shear rheology. Both the headgroup and the FA chain impacted the interfacial properties. For the same FA composition, a rather small hydrophobic headgroup resulted in a higher packed interface. The interfacial elasticity increased with increased FA chain length (C12 to C18). This seemed to be particularly the case when the emulsifier crystallized on the interface among cooling. In the case of a densely packed interface, network formation due to chain crystallization of the LME's FA chains occurs during the cooling step. The resulting interface shows predominantly elastic behavior.

Molecular Dynamics Computational Study of Sustainable Green Surfactant for Application in Chemical Enhanced Oil Recovery

Green surfactant (GS) flooding, an environmentally friendly chemical Enhanced Oil Recovery (cEOR) method, is explored in this molecular dynamics (MD) simulation study. This study evaluates the ability of (S)-2-dodecanamido-aminobutanedioic as a GS for cEOR, assessing its performance with hexane (C6), dodecane (C12), and eicosane (C20) as representative oils. In the case of the bulk system, a comprehensive molecular-level investigation provides structural details such as the radial distribution function, solvent-accessible surface area, GS adsorption dynamics, diffusivity, and emulsion stability of the GS, oil, and water systems. Also the impact of the three distinct oils on interfacial tension was examined in the existence of GS molecules. The findings reveal rapid GS molecule aggregation and adsorption on oil droplets, with various impacts on emulsion stability depending on the oil type. Additionally, GS enhances the aggregation of heavy C20 oil molecules in a water medium. The study demonstrates GS's role as an effective emulsifier, facilitating oil droplet recovery, with electrostatic interactions governing micelle formation and van der Waals interactions influencing oil droplet emulsification. These results align with prior experimental data, affirming GS's promising application potential in cEOR while prioritizing environmental sustainability.

The effect of aromatic side chains on the dilational rheological properties of N-acyltaurate amphiphiles at water-decane interfaces

To elucidate the effect of aromatic side chains on dilational rheological properties of N-acyltaurate amphiphiles at the decane-water interface, the interfacial rheological properties of sodium N-2-(2-naphthoxy)-tetradecanoyltaurinate (12+N-T) and sodium N-2-(p-butylphenoxy)-tetradecanoyltaurinate (12+4B-T) were investigated utilizing the drop shape analysis method. The effects of adsorption time, interfacial pressure, oscillating frequency, and bulk concentration on the interfacial dilational modulus and phase angle were explored. The results show that the 12+4B-T molecule with a longer hydrophobic chain shows a higher ability for reducing the interfacial tension (IFT). In addition, the interfacial films of both 12+N-T and 12+4B-T are dominated by diffusion exchange at high concentrations. The rigidity of molecules controls the diffusion exchange at low concentrations, while the molecular hydrodynamic radius determines the diffusion exchange at high concentrations. Thus, at low concentrations, the stronger intermolecular interaction between 12+4B-T molecules results in higher dilational modulus values than 12+N-T. When approaching the CMC (critical micelle concentration) value, the rapid diffusion exchange of 12+4B-T between the sublayer micelles and the interface causes a significant decrease in the dilational modulus, while the relatively rigid structure of 12+N-T enables a higher dilational modulus than 12+4B-T. What's more, the longer hydrophobic chain allows 12+4B-T molecules to escape from the interface more easily, resulting in a higher phase angle at low concentrations. However, the diffusion exchange of 12+4B-T is slower than that of 12+N-T, which results in lower phase angles for 12+4B-T than 12+N-T at high concentrations. In general, the introduction of a rigid naphthalene ring in the molecular structure gives the interfacial film greater strength at high concentration. The research results in this paper provide a new technique for the strength regulation of interfacial surfactant adsorption films.

Controlling Solvent Polarity to Regulate Protein Self-Assembly Morphology and Its Universal Insight for Fibrillation Mechanism

The mechanism of ethanol-induced fibrillation of β-lactoglobulin (β-lg) in the acidic aqueous solution upon heating was investigated using various techniques, mainly thioflavin T fluorescence, atomic force microscopy, nonreducing electrophoresis, mass spectrometry, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, and circular dichroism spectroscopy. The results showed that fibrillation occurred with a heating time increase, but high ethanol content slowed down the process. At a low ethanol volume fraction, peptides existed after heating for 2 h, with long and straight fibrils formed after 4-6 h, while at a high ethanol volume fraction, the proteins aggregated with very few peptides appeared at the early stage of heating, and short and curved fibrils formed after heating for 8 h. Ethanol weakened the hydrophobic interactions between proteins in the aqueous solution; therefore the latter could not completely balance the electrostatic repulsion, and thus suppressing the fibrillation process. It is believed that the fibrillation of β-lg in the acidic solution upon heating is mainly dominated by the polypeptide model; however, ethanol inhibited the hydrolysis of proteins, and the self-assembly mechanism changed to the monomer model.

New insights into protein stabilized emulsions captured via neutron and X-ray scattering: An approach with β-lactoglobulin at triacylglyceride-oil/water interfaces

HYPOTHESIS

To analyze protein stabilized emulsions, SAXS and SANS are emerging techniques capturing oil droplet radius, interfacial coverage and structure. Protein shape, thus protein structure change during interfacial adsorption with partial protein unfolding is detected via SAXS analysis at and below the monolayer concentration for proteins, known as critical interfacial concentration (CIC). SANS determines the same phenomena below and above the CIC, via contrast variation and coarse-grained modelling.

EXPERIMENTS

β-lactoglobulin concentration dependent SAXS experiments were performed focusing on molecular length scales to characterize protein shape in water, and interfacial structure in emulsions. Complementary SANS experiments with contrast variation via deuterated triacylglyceride-oil provided insight into oil droplet radius, interfacial coverage and structure via data analysis with scattering models and low-resolution shape reconstruction with the DENFERT model.

FINDINGS

SAXS and SANS experiments allowed to determine the interfacial structure below and above the CIC, as well as oil droplet radius and interfacial coverage. These findings were identified via Q-4 Porod scattering at low-Q, protein scattering at high Q, and a Q-2 scattering of the interface. Since SANS with accurate contrast variation highlights the interface in comparison to other techniques like FTIR, the presented results show a high impact to understand interfaces in emulsions.

Glycyrrhizic acid aggregates seen from a synthetic surfactant perspective

Bio- or plant-based surfactants are a sustainable and renewable alternative to replace synthetic chemicals for environmental, drugs and food applications. However, these "green" surfactants have unique molecular structures, and their self-assembly in water might lead to complex morphologies and unexpected properties. The micellization of saponin molecules, such as glycyrrhizic acid (GA), differs significantly from those of conventional synthetic surfactants, yet these differences are often overlooked. Saponins self-assemble in complex hierarchical helical morphologies similar to bile salts, rather than the expected globular, ellipsoidal and wormlike micelles. Here, we review two potential routes for molecular self-assembly of GA, namely kinetics of crystallization and thermodynamic equilibrium, focusing on their structure as a function of concentration. Some uncertainty remains to define which route is followed by GA self-assembly, as well as the first type of aggregate formed at low concentrations, thus we review the state-of-the-art information about GA assembly. We compare the self-assembly of GA with conventional linear surfactants, and identify their key similarities and differences, from molecular and chemical perspectives, based on the critical packing parameter (CPP) theory. We expect that this work will provide perspectives for the unclear process of GA assembly, and highlight its differences from conventional micellization.

Apparent Failures in Interpretation of Interfacial Characterization When Formulating Emulsions Stabilized by Cellulose Nanocrystals

Cellulose nanocrystals (CNCs) are sustainable particles that are effective at stabilizing emulsions by adsorbing at droplet interfaces and providing a steric barrier to coalescence. However, CNCs have surface charges that reduce the coverage of the emulsion droplets due to the electrostatic repulsion between CNCs. In such cases, adding salt is a typical (and straightforward) way to adjust the formulation so that the charges are screened, allowing increased coverage of the droplets. At the outset of this work, we hypothesized that characterization of the interfacial tension and interfacial shear rheology of the oil-water interface would be correlated to interfacial coverage and therefore predictive of the optimal salt concentration for emulsion stability. Included in the methods section as a useful reference to others is the presentation of a detailed derivation for the equations needed to compute interfacial shear moduli in a custom, double-gap geometry. In contrast to our hypothesis, we found that interfacial tension did not correlate well with emulsion stability and that the native surface-active compounds in corn oil overwhelmed any influence of the CNCs on the interfacial tension. Additionally, we found that interfacial shear rheology (which can be painstakingly difficult to measure) was not a useful tool for formulating these emulsions. This is because at commonly used concentrations of CNCs, the bulk rheology is increased to a much greater degree than that of the interface, making the details of the interfacial rheology unimportant. Finally, we found that at concentrations of CNCs that are typical in industrial processes, characterizing the bulk viscoelastic properties of the aqueous suspending phase without added oil (a relatively simple measurement) is sufficient to predict the influence of NaCl concentration on charge screening between the CNCs and, by extension, increased surface coverage of droplets for greater emulsion stability.

Investigating water/oil interfaces with opto-thermophoresis

Charging of interfaces between water and hydrophobic media is a mysterious feature whose nature and origin have been under debate. Here, we investigate the fundamentals of the interfacial behaviors of water by employing opto-thermophoretic tweezers to study temperature-gradient-induced perturbation of dipole arrangement at water/oil interfaces. With surfactant-free perfluoropentane-in-water emulsions as a model interface, additional polar organic solvents are introduced to systematically modify the structural aspects of the interface. Through our experimental measurements on the thermophoretic behaviors of oil droplets under a light-generated temperature gradient, in combination with theoretical analysis, we propose that water molecules and mobile negative charges are present at the water/oil interfaces with specific dipole arrangement to hydrate oil droplets, and that this arrangement is highly susceptible to the thermal perturbation due to the mobility of the negative charges. These findings suggest a potential of opto-thermophoresis in probing aqueous interfaces and could enrich understanding of the interfacial behaviors of water.

Microgels as globular protein model systems

Understanding globular protein adsorption to fluid interfaces, their interfacial assembly, and structural reorganization is not only important in the food industry, but also in medicine and biology. However, due to their intrinsic structural complexity, a unifying description of these phenomena remains elusive. Herein, we propose N-isopropylacrylamide microgels as a promising model system to isolate different aspects of adsorption, dilatational rheology, and interfacial structure at fluid interfaces with a wide range of interfacial tensions, and compare the results with the ones of globular proteins. In particular, the steady-state spontaneously-adsorbed interfacial pressure of microgels correlates closely to that of globular proteins, following the same power-law behavior as a function of the initial surface tension. However, the dilatational rheology of spontaneously-adsorbed microgel layers is dominated by the presence of a loosely packed polymer corona spread at the interface, and it thus exhibits a similar mechanical response as flexible, unstructured proteins, which are significantly weaker than globular ones. Finally, structurally, microgels reveal a similar spreading and flattening upon adsorption as globular proteins do. In conclusion, microgels offer interesting opportunities to act as powerful model systems to unravel the complex behavior of proteins at fluid interfaces.