Growth, dormancy and lysis: the complex relation of starter culture physiology and cheese flavour formation

Bacterial proteome adaptation during fermentation in dairy environments

The enzymatic repertoire of starter cultures belonging to the Lactococcus genus determines various important characteristics of fermented dairy products but might change in response to the substantial environmental changes in the manufacturing process. Assessing bacterial proteome adaptation in dairy and other food environments is challenging due to the high matrix-protein concentration and is even further complicated in particularly cheese by the high fat concentrations, the semi-solid state of that matrix, and the non-growing state of the bacteria. Here, we present bacterial harvesting and processing procedures that enable reproducible, high-resolution proteome determination in lactococcal cultures harvested from laboratory media, milk, and miniature Gouda cheese. Comparative proteome analysis of Lactococcus cremoris NCDO712 grown in laboratory medium and milk revealed proteome adaptations that predominantly reflect the differential (micro-)nutrient availability in these two environments. Additionally, the drastic environmental changes during cheese manufacturing only elicited subtle changes in the L. cremoris NCDO712 proteome, including modified expression levels of enzymes involved in flavour formation. The technical advances we describe offer novel opportunities to evaluate bacterial proteomes in relation to their performance in complex, protein- and/or fat-rich food matrices and highlight the potential of steering starter culture performance by preculture condition adjustments.

Isolation, identification, and characterization of thermophilic lactic acid bacteria isolated from whey of Kars Kashar cheeses

Kars Kashar cheese is an artisanal pasta-filata type cheese and geographically marked in Eastern Anatolia of Turkey. The aims of this research were to determine for the first time thermophilic lactic acid bacteria (LAB) of Kars Kashar cheese and characterize the technological properties of obtained isolates. In our research, a number of 15 samples of whey were collected from the different villages in Kars. These samples were incubated at 45 °C and used as the source material for isolating thermophilic LAB. A total of 250 colonies were isolated from thermophilic whey, and 217 of them were determined to be presumptive LAB based on their Gram staining and catalase test. A total of 170 isolates were characterized by their phenotypic properties and identified using the MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry method. Phenotypic identification of isolates displayed that Enterococcus and Lactobacillus were the predominant microbiota. According to MALDI-TOF MS identification, 89 isolates were identified as Enterococcus (52.35%), 57 isolates as Lactobacillus (33.53%), 23 isolates as Streptococcus (13.53%), and one isolate as Lactococcus (0.59%). All thermophilic LAB isolates were successfully identified to the species level and it has been observed that MALDI-TOF MS can be successfully used for the identification of selected LAB. The acidification and proteolytic activities of the isolated thermophilic LAB were examined, and the isolates designated for use as starter cultures were also genotypically defined.

The stressostat: A novel approach in adaptive laboratory evolution to improve end-product resistance

End-product inhibition in pH-controlled batch cultures, is the major limiting factor for bacterial biomass formation in the starter culture industry as well as in many other biotechnological processes. Adaptive laboratory evolution (ALE) has emerged over the past decades as a powerful tool for phenotype optimization, but none of the existing ALE methods could select for improved end-product resistance. Therefore, we developed the stressostat (STress Resistance Evolution in Substrate Surplus) as a novel continuous ALE method. Stressostat cultivation applies end-product concentrations as constant evolutionary pressure on microorganisms in the presence of substrate surplus. In this study, we improved the lactate resistance of Lactococcus lactis FM03P in 35 days of stressostat cultivations. The lactate concentrations increased over time from 530 to 675 mM, indicating the successful selection for variants with improved lactate resistance. Thirty-four variants were isolated and grouped into four clusters based on their growth rates at high lactate concentrations. In the high-throughput screening without pH control, most isolated variants could grow at high lactate concentrations (870-928 mM), while the wild type was completely inhibited. The variants grew slower than wild type at low lactate media indicating possible evolutionary trade-off. However, in pH-controlled batch cultivations, most variants produced more biomass than the wild type. In conclusion, stressostat cultivation is a valuable method to obtain L. lactis variants with improved end-product resistance and further characterization is needed to elucidate underlying resistance mechanisms and potential industrial applications.

Microbial interactions shape cheese flavour formation

Cheese fermentation and flavour formation are the result of complex biochemical reactions driven by the activity of multiple microorganisms. Here, we studied the roles of microbial interactions in flavour formation in a year-long Cheddar cheese making process, using a commercial starter culture containing Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactococcus strains. By using an experimental strategy whereby certain strains were left out from the starter culture, we show that S. thermophilus has a crucial role in boosting Lactococcus growth and shaping flavour compound profile. Controlled milk fermentations with systematic exclusion of single Lactococcus strains, combined with genomics, genome-scale metabolic modelling, and metatranscriptomics, indicated that S. thermophilus proteolytic activity relieves nitrogen limitation for Lactococcus and boosts de novo nucleotide biosynthesis. While S. thermophilus had large contribution to the flavour profile, Lactococcus cremoris also played a role by limiting diacetyl and acetoin formation, which otherwise results in an off-flavour when in excess. This off-flavour control could be attributed to the metabolic re-routing of citrate by L. cremoris from diacetyl and acetoin towards α-ketoglutarate. Further, closely related Lactococcus lactis strains exhibited different interaction patterns with S. thermophilus, highlighting the significance of strain specificity in cheese making. Our results highlight the crucial roles of competitive and cooperative microbial interactions in shaping cheese flavour profile.

The Impact of Different Inoculation Schemes on the Microbiota, Physicochemical and Sensory Characteristics of Greek Kopanisti Cheese throughout Production and Ripening

Kopanisti is a Greek PDO cheese, which is traditionally produced by the addition of an amount of over-mature Kopanisti, called Mana Kopanisti, to initiate cheese ripening. The aim of this study was the production of four types of Kopanisti cheese (A-D) using pasteurized cow milk, and a combination of the following starters/adjuncts in order to test their ability to be used in Kopanisti cheese production: A: Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis and Lacticaseibacillus paracasei, B: L. lactis and Lc. paracasei/Mana Kopanisti, C: L. lactis and Lc. paracasei/Ligilactobacillus acidipiscis and Loigolactobacillus rennini, D: Lig. acidipiscis and Loig. rennini. Throughout production and ripening, classical microbiological, metataxonomics and physicochemical analyses were employed, while the final products (Day 35) were subjected to sensory analysis as well. Most interestingly, beta-diversity analysis of the metataxonomics data revealed the clusters constructed among the Kopanisti types based on the different inoculation schemes. On day 35, Kopanisti A-C types clustered together due to their similar 16S microbiota, while Kopanisti D was highly differentiated. On the contrary, ITS data clustered Kopanisti B and C together, while Kopanisti A and D were grouped seperately. Finally, based on the sensory evaluation, Kopanisti C appeared to have the most suitable bacteria cocktail for the Kopanisti cheese production. Therefore, not only were the conventional starters used, but also the Lig. acidipiscis and Loig. rennini strains could be used in a standardized Kopanisti cheese production that could lead to final products of high quality and safety.

Causality Verification for the Correlation between the Presence of Nonstarter Bacteria and Flavor Characteristics in Soft-Type Ripened Cheeses

Flavor characteristics of ripened cheese are established by various bacteria, such as lactic acid bacteria, Actinobacteria, and Proteobacteria, which spontaneously develop during the cheese-manufacturing process. We previously revealed the relationship between bacterial microbiota and flavor components in soft-type ripened cheeses by using a multiomics approach that combined metagenomics and metabolomics; however, we could not establish a causal relationship. This study aimed to substantiate the causal nature of the correlations revealed by the multiomics approach by using cheese-ripening tests with single isolate inoculation. The bacterial diversity and composition in surface mold-ripened cheeses from Japan and France varied, depending on the differences between the milks (pasteurized or raw), cheese positions (core or rind), and manufacturers. Although the volatile compounds did not clearly reflect the distinctive characteristics of the cheese samples, nonstarter lactic acid bacteria, Actinobacteria, and Proteobacteria positively correlated with ketones and sulfur compounds, as evidenced by a Spearman's correlation analysis. Cheese-ripening tests conducted after inoculation with single bacterial strains belonging to the above-mentioned taxa confirmed that these bacteria formed volatile compounds, in agreement with the correlations observed. In particular, various flavor compounds, such as acids, esters, ketones, and sulfur compounds, were detected in cheese inoculated with Pseudoalteromonas sp. TS-4-4 strain. These findings provide important insights into the role of nonstarter bacteria in the development of cheese flavor and into the effectiveness of the multiomics approach in screening for bacteria that can improve the quality of cheese products. IMPORTANCE Our previous study revealed that the existence of various bacteria, such as lactic acid bacteria, Actinobacteria, and Proteobacteria, clearly correlated with the abundance of flavor components, such as volatile compounds, in soft-type ripened cheeses via a multiomics approach that used 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing and headspace gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. However, this approach only showed correlations derived from statistical analyses rather than causal relationships. Therefore, in the present study, we performed cheese-ripening tests using nonstarter bacteria to substantiate the correlations revealed by the multiomics approach in soft-type ripened cheese. Our results suggest the capability of nonstarter bacteria, such as Proteobacteria, to impart flavor to cheese and the effectiveness of the multiomics approach in screening for microbial isolates that can improve the quality of cheese. Overall, our research provides new insights into the importance of bacteria in cheese production.

Functional production of clostridial circularin A in Lactococcus lactis NZ9000 and mutational analysis of its aromatic and cationic residues

Circular bacteriocins, also known as bacterial head-to-tail cyclized peptides, are a subgroup of ribosomally synthesized and post-translationally modified peptides (RiPPs). Compared with their conventional linear counterparts, circular bacteriocins are highly stable over a broad temperature and pH range, and circularization decreases proteolytic degradation by exopeptidases. These features render them great potential as scaffold candidates to withstand strident conditions in food- and pharmaceutical applications. However, the biosynthesis and bioactivity of circular bacteriocins still remain largely unknown. To investigate and gain more insights into the biosynthesis of circular bacteriocins and to achieve efficient production and characterization of bacteriocin variants, we developed an efficient cloning and heterologous expression system for clostridial circularin A and successfully produced this circular peptide in Lactococcus lactis NZ9000. We report three system formats with single plasmid or plasmid combinations to achieve successful cloning and functional production of circularin A in L. lactis. These systematic varieties enabled us to choose the appropriate method to efficiently obtain various constructs with desired properties. With the established heterologous systems in L. lactis, we performed several mutagenesis studies in the precursor peptide to study its structure/function relationships. The overlay activity assay revealed that these mutant variants had variable effects on different indicator strains: lysine substitution for certain glutamine residue(s) greatly decreased its bioactivity against Clostridium perfringens and L. lactis NZ9000, and alanine replacement for the cationic residues significantly reduced the activity against Lactobacillus sake ATCC 15521, whereas alanine substitution for the aromatic residues decreased its bioactivity against all three testing strains dramatically. Moreover, the conditions for bacteriocin production were optimized. Results show that supplementing the minimal medium with extra glucose (or sucrose) and immediate nisin-induction improved the peptide yield significantly. Briefly, we developed an excellent system for the production of circularin A and a wide range of variant peptides in a convenient host, as well as a method for fast detection of peptide production and activity. This system facilitated our mutagenesis studies which provided valuable insights into the effects of mutating specific residues on its biosynthesis and bioactivity, and will eventually enable more complex research into the biosynthesis of circularin A.

Functional strain redundancy and persistent phage infection in Swiss hard cheese starter cultures

Undefined starter cultures are poorly characterized bacterial communities from environmental origin used in cheese making. They are phenotypically stable and have evolved through domestication by repeated propagation in closed and highly controlled environments over centuries. This makes them interesting for understanding eco-evolutionary dynamics governing microbial communities. While cheese starter cultures are known to be dominated by a few bacterial species, little is known about the composition, functional relevance, and temporal dynamics of strain-level diversity. Here, we applied shotgun metagenomics to an important Swiss cheese starter culture and analyzed historical and experimental samples reflecting 82 years of starter culture propagation. We found that the bacterial community is highly stable and dominated by only a few coexisting strains of Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. lactis. Genome sequencing, metabolomics analysis, and co-culturing experiments of 43 isolates show that these strains are functionally redundant, but differ tremendously in their phage resistance potential. Moreover, we identified two highly abundant Streptococcus phages that seem to stably coexist in the community without any negative impact on bacterial growth or strain persistence, and despite the presence of a large and diverse repertoire of matching CRISPR spacers. Our findings show that functionally equivalent strains can coexist in domesticated microbial communities and highlight an important role of bacteria-phage interactions that are different from kill-the-winner dynamics.

Developments in effective use of volatile organic compound analysis to assess flavour formation during cheese ripening

In the burgeoning demand for optimization of cheese production, ascertaining cheese flavour formation during the cheese making process has been the focal point of determining cheese quality. In this research reflection, we have highlighted how valuable volatile organic compound (VOC) analysis has been in assessing contingent cheese flavour compounds arising from non-starter lactic acid bacteria (NSLAB) along with starter lactic acid bacteria (SLAB), and whether VOC analysis associated with other high-throughput data might help provide a better understanding the cheese flavour formation during cheese process. It is widely known that there is a keen interest to merge all omics data to find specific biomarkers and/or to assess aroma formation of cheese. Towards that end, results of VOC analysis have provided valuable insights into the cheese flavour profile. In this review, we are pinpointing the effective use of flavour compound analysis to perceive flavour-forming ability of microbial strains that are convenient for dairy production, intertwining microbiome and metabolome to unveil potential biomarkers that occur during cheese ripening. In doing so, we summarised the functionality and integration of aromatic compound analysis in cheese making and gave reflections on reconsidering what the role of flavour-based analysis might have in the future.

Adaptive Laboratory Evolution as a Means To Generate Lactococcus lactis Strains with Improved Thermotolerance and Ability To Autolyze

Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis (referred to here as L. lactis) is a model lactic acid bacterium and one of the main constituents of the mesophilic cheese starter used for producing soft or semihard cheeses. Most dairy L. lactis strains grow optimally at around 30°C and are not particularly well adapted to the elevated temperatures (37 to 39°C) to which they are often exposed during cheese production. To overcome this challenge, we used adaptive laboratory evolution (ALE) in milk, using a setup where the temperature was gradually increased over time, and isolated two evolved strains (RD01 and RD07) better able to tolerate high growth temperatures. One of these, strain RD07, was isolated after 1.5 years of evolution (400 generations) and efficiently acidified milk at 41°C, which has not been reported for industrial L. lactis strains until now. Moreover, RD07 appeared to autolyze 2 to 3 times faster than its parent strain, which is another highly desired property of dairy lactococci and rarely observed in the L. lactis subspecies used in this study. Model cheese trials indicated that RD07 could potentially accelerate cheese ripening. Transcriptomics analysis revealed the potential underlying causes responsible for the enhanced growth at high temperatures for the mutants. These included downregulation of the pleiotropic transcription factor CodY and overexpression of genes, which most likely lowered the guanidine nucleotide pool. Cheese trials at ARLA Foods using RD01 blended with the commercial Flora Danica starter culture, including a 39.5°C cooking step, revealed better acidification and flavor formation than the pure starter culture. IMPORTANCE In commercial mesophilic starter cultures, L. lactis is generally more thermotolerant than Lactococcus cremoris, whereas L. cremoris is more prone to autolysis, which is the key to flavor and aroma formation. In this study, we found that adaptation to higher thermotolerance can improve autolysis. Using whole-genome sequencing and RNA sequencing, we attempt to determine the underlying reason for the observed behavior. In terms of dairy applications, there are obvious advantages associated with using L. lactis strains with high thermotolerance, as these are less affected by curd cooking, which generally hampers the performance of the mesophilic starter. Cheese ripening, the costliest part of cheese manufacturing, can be reduced using autolytic strains. Thus, the solution presented here could simplify starter cultures, make the cheese manufacturing process more efficient, and enable novel types of harder cheese variants.