Comment on “An equilibrium isotope effect due to a strong hydrogen bond”

Isotope Effects on Chemical Shifts in the Study of Hydrogen Bonds in Small Molecules

This review is giving a short introduction to the techniques used to investigate isotope effects on NMR chemical shifts. The review is discussing how isotope effects on chemical shifts can be used to elucidate the importance of either intra- or intermolecular hydrogen bonding in ionic liquids, of ammonium ions in a confined space, how isotope effects can help define dimers, trimers, etc., how isotope effects can lead to structural parameters such as distances and give information about ion pairing. Tautomerism is by advantage investigated by isotope effects on chemical shifts both in symmetric and asymmetric systems. The relationship between hydrogen bond energies and two-bond deuterium isotope effects on chemical shifts is described. Finally, theoretical calculations to obtain isotope effects on chemical shifts are looked into.

1H NMR Studies of Intramolecular OH/OH Hydrogen Bonds via Titratable Isotope Shifts

Methanol titrations of partially deuterated 1,4- and 1,3-diols dissolved in nonpolar solvents such as CD₂Cl₂ and benzene-d₆ have provided ¹H NMR measurements of OH/OD isotope shifts, diagnostic for intact intramolecular hydrogen bonds, under conditions of increasing protic solvent concentration. 1,4- and 1,3-diols with conformationally favored intramolecular OH/OH hydrogen bonds can be titrated to constant isotope shift values, albeit with variable sign, in the presence of excess methanol equivalents, providing evidence for intact intramolecular hydrogen bonds under these conditions. Conversely, the isotope shift in a 1,3-diol with a conformationally labile intramolecular hydrogen bond titrated to zero when in the presence of excess equivalents methanol, consistent with intramolecular hydrogen bond rupture under these conditions. Additionally, the titration behavior of hydroxyl chemical shifts in diols and protected derivatives has revealed significant OH/OD isotope shifts in the absence of chemical shift differences (δOH_in = δOH_out) that are necessary for an equilibrium isotope effect, lending evidence for an intrinsic contribution to the isotope effect. OH/OD isotope shift titration thus provides a means for understanding the origins of these isotope effects and for probing the intact or nonintact nature of intramolecular OH/OH hydrogen bonds in response to intermolecular hydrogen bonds provided by a protic solvent.