Prognostic ability of a good outcome to carpal tunnel release for decompression surgery in the lower extremity

[Retrospective Long-Term Results After Dellon's Nerve Decompression In The Lower Leg For Polyneuropathy]

BACKGROUND

Patients affected by polyneuropathy often report pain, paraesthesia and numbness and are at risk of having an increased propensity to fall with the corresponding complications. In case of persistent symptoms after all conservative and medical treatment options have been exhausted, a nerve decompression in the lower leg as described by Dellon can lead to an improvement of the discomfort for many patients. This article presents our long-term results with Dellon's operation.

METHODS

In this retrospective study, we included 33 patients with diabetic or idiopathic polyneuropathy in whom we performed Dellon's nerve decompression in the lower leg in the years 2011-2013. In 29 out of the 33 patients, we investigated the level of pain (according to the numeric rating scale NRS 0-10), paraesthesia, numbness, Hoffman-Tinel sign, and Semmes-Weinstein monofilaments three months postoperatively. 88 months postoperatively (range 78-111 months), we were able to contact 20 of the 33 patients with a questionnaire asking about their present pain level (NRS 0-10), satisfaction with the postoperative result (NRS 0-10, 0=most satisfied, 10=not satisfied at all) and whether the patients would recommend the surgical procedure to their friends or family.

RESULTS

1. Significant pain reduction three months postoperatively, NRS 4.5 to 2.2, (p=0.000). 2. Significant reduction of paraesthesia three months postoperatively from 84.8 to 24.2% (p=0.000) 3. Significant reduction of numbness three months postoperatively from 97% to 39% (p=0.000). 4. Significant improvement of sensitivity three months postoperatively from 91% no sensitivity to 28% no sensitivity (p=0.000). 5. Significant improvement of Hoffmann-Tinel sign three months postoperatively from 76% to 13% (p=0.000). 88 months postoperatively, we saw a significant pain reduction from an average preoperative pain level of NRS 4.5 to a postoperative pain level of 2.7 (p=0.048). 88 months postoperatively, 65% of the patients would recommend the surgical procedure to their family and friends, and patient satisfaction was high (NRS 3,4).

CONCLUSION

Our long-term results show that Dellon's nerve decompression in the lower extremities leads to a marked, lasting pain reduction and a functional improvement.

Nerve Decompression in the Lower Leg Results in an Improvement in Symptoms in Patients With Both Diabetic and Idiopathic Polyneuropathy

BACKGROUND

Patients suffering from polyneuropathy often complain of pain, tingling, and numbness sensations, as well as an increased risk of falling with the corresponding subsequent complications. If symptoms persist after conservative treatment options have been exhausted, nerve decompression in the lower extremity, as described by Dellon, can bring about an improvement in symptoms in many patients. Dellon originally reported that this surgery led to very successful outcomes in patients with diabetic polyneuropathy. In this study, we compare our postsurgical results in patients with diabetic versus idiopathic polyneuropathy.

METHODS

Thirty-three patients with idiopathic or diabetic polyneuropathy who had undergone Dellon nerve decompression in the lower extremity between 2011 and 2013 were included in the retrospective study. Pain (numeric rating scale [NRS] 0-10; 0, no pain; 10, worst imaginable pain), tingling, numbness, Hoffmann-Tinel sign, and Semes-Weinstein monofilament were assessed in 20 patients with diabetic polyneuropathy and in 13 patients with idiopathic polyneuropathy.

RESULTS

Three months after surgery, a significant reduction in pain was evident in patients with diabetic polyneuropathy, from a preoperative level of NRS 4.9 (minimum, 0; maximum, 10) to 2 (minimum, 0; maximum, 8; P = 0.005). Ninety percent of patients complained of tingling ( P = 0.000) before surgery and 18% after surgery, whereas 100% complained of numbness before surgery and 41% ( P = 0.000) after surgery. One hundred percent of patients had no measurable surface sensitivity before surgery (measured with the Semes-Weinstein monofilament), whereas 3 months after surgery, only 24% of patients still had no measurable surface sensitivity ( P = 0.000). A positive Hoffmann-Tinel sign was recorded in 85% of patients before surgery and only in 11% 3 months after surgery ( P = 0.000). In the case of patients with idiopathic polyneuropathy, a reduction in pain was evident 3 months after surgery, from a preoperative level of NRS 3.9 (minimum, 0; maximum, 9) to 2.2 (minimum, 0; maximum, 9; P = 0.058). Seventy-seven percent of patients complained of tingling before surgery and 42% after surgery ( P = 0.111), whereas 92% complained of numbness before surgery and 50% after surgery ( P = 0.030). Seventy-seven percent of patients had no measurable surface sensitivity before surgery (measured with the Semes-Weinstein monofilament), whereas 3 months after surgery, only 33% of patients still had no measurable surface sensitivity ( P = 0.047). A positive Hoffmann-Tinel sign was recorded in 62% of patients before surgery and only in 17% 3 months after surgery ( P = 0.041).

CONCLUSIONS

Not only patients with diabetic polyneuropathy but also those with idiopathic polyneuropathy benefit from Dellon nerve decompression surgery in the lower extremities.

Surgical treatment of superimposed, lower extremity, peripheral nerve entrapments with diabetic and idiopathic neuropathy

BACKGROUND

Although it is recognized that people with peripheral neuropathy have an increased prevalence of chronic nerve entrapment, controversy still exists over their management. The present report details the evaluation, surgical approach, and outcome of a large cohort of people with diabetic and with idiopathic neuropathy.

METHODS

A retrospective review of 158 consecutive patients, 96 with diabetic and 62 with idiopathic neuropathy, was done to analyze the results of neurolysis of multiple sites of chronic nerve compression in the lower extremity. Of these patients, 50 had a contralateral limb decompressed for a total of 208 limbs included in the study. Outcomes included visual analog scale (VAS) for pain in the 109 patients who had pain level greater than 8.0, measurement of the cutaneous pressure threshold for sensibility, self-reported change in pain medication usage, and self-reported change in balance.

RESULTS

With a minimum follow-up of 1 year, 88% of patients with preoperative numbness reported improvement in sensation (P < 0.001). Of the 84 patients with impaired balance, 81% reported improvement in balance. Of those whose VAS was greater than 8, 83% reported an improvement in VAS (P < 0.001). There was a concomitant reduction in pain medication usage. There was no difference in outcomes between patients with diabetic versus idiopathic neuropathy in response to nerve decompression.

CONCLUSIONS

Neurolysis of lower extremity chronic nerve compressions in patients with neuropathy and superimposed nerve compressions is an effective method for relieving pain, restoring sensation, and improving balance.

Decompressive surgery of lower limbs for symmetrical diabetic peripheral neuropathy

BACKGROUND

Symmetrical peripheral neuropathy is a common complication of diabetic neuropathy. No treatments are known to be effective for progressive pain and sensory loss associated with diabetic neuropathy. Alternative effective treatment strategies have been sought.

OBJECTIVES

To systematically review the evidence from randomized controlled trials concerning the role of decompressive surgery of lower limbs for symmetrical diabetic peripheral neuropathy.

SEARCH STRATEGY

We searched the Cochrane Neuromuscular Disease Trials Register (May 2006), CENTRAL (The Cochrane Library, Issue 2 2006), MEDLINE from (January 1966 to August 2006), EMBASE (from January 1980 to August 2006), LILACS (from January 1982 to August 2006), and CINAHL (from January 1982 to August 2006).

SELECTION CRITERIA

We included all randomized or quasi-randomized controlled human trials in which any form of decompressive surgery of the lower limbs nerves had been used to treat diabetic symmetrical distal polyneuropathy (DSDP) compared with no treatment or medical therapy. Patients with DSDP were included if they had decompression (with or without neurolysis) of at least two of the following nerves in both lower limbs, for the treatment of DSDP: the posterior tibial nerve (including calcaneal, medial and lateral plantar nerves), deep peroneal nerve at the ankle, common peroneal nerve at the knee, lateral femoral cutaneous nerve and sural nerves in the posterior calf region. The primary outcome measure was the change in pain measured by the visual analogue scale (VAS) between the baseline and a follow-up period of greater than three months.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

We identified 142 publications from the above search strategies. The three authors of this manuscript reviewed abstracts of all papers independently. Only eight of these were considered relevant to the question at hand. The data from these 8 studies were entered onto standardized data extraction forms. We planned to use Review Manager to pool the results from appropriate studies comparing the same treatments; dichotomous outcomes to obtain pooled relative risks (RR); measured outcomes to obtain pooled weighted mean differences; and a fixed-effect analysis unless there was evidence of serious heterogeneity between studies sufficient to justify the use of random-effects analysis.

MAIN RESULTS

This review failed to identify a single randomized controlled trial or any other well designed prospective study controlling for the non-operated limb that showed improvements in pre defined end points after decompressive surgery.

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

The results of this review suggest that the role of decompressive surgery for diabetic symmetric distal neuropathy is unproven.

Diabetic neuropathy: medical and surgical approaches

This article establishes the most critical, practical, and successful treatment options and their controversies for the practicing clinician caring for the patient with symptomatic diabetic neuropathy from the available literature.