Kinetic analysis of drug-protein interactions by affinity chromatography

Recent advances in computational and experimental protein-ligand affinity determination techniques

INTRODUCTION

Modern drug discovery revolves around designing ligands that target the chosen biomolecule, typically proteins. For this, the evaluation of affinities of putative ligands is crucial. This has given rise to a multitude of dedicated computational and experimental methods that are constantly being developed and improved.

AREAS COVERED

In this review, the authors reassess both the industry mainstays and the newest trends among the methods for protein - small-molecule affinity determination. They discuss both computational affinity predictions and experimental techniques, describing their basic principles, main limitations, and advantages. Together, this serves as initial guide to the currently most popular and cutting-edge ligand-binding assays employed in rational drug design.

EXPERT OPINION

The affinity determination methods continue to develop toward miniaturization, high-throughput, and in-cell application. Moreover, the availability of data analysis tools has been constantly increasing. Nevertheless, cross-verification of data using at least two different techniques and careful result interpretation remain of utmost importance.

Analysis of drug interactions with serum proteins and related binding agents by affinity capillary electrophoresis: A review

Biomolecules such as serum proteins can interact with drugs in the body and influence their pharmaceutical effects. Specific and precise methods that analyze these interactions are critical for drug development or monitoring and for diagnostic purposes. Affinity capillary electrophoresis (ACE) is one technique that can be used to examine the binding between drugs and serum proteins, or other agents found in serum or blood. This article will review the basic principles of ACE, along with related affinity-based capillary electrophoresis (CE) methods, and examine recent developments that have occurred in this field as related to the characterization of drug-protein interactions. An overview will be given of the various formats that can be used in ACE and CE for such work, including the relative advantages or weaknesses of each approach. Various applications of ACE and affinity-based CE methods for the analysis of drug interactions with serum proteins and other binding agents will also be presented. Applications of ACE and related techniques that will be discussed include drug interaction studies with serum agents, chiral drug separations employing serum proteins, and the use of CE in hybrid methods to characterize drug binding with serum proteins.

ACE2 and SARS-CoV-2-Main Protease Capillary Columns for Affinity Chromatography: Testimony of the Binding of Dexamethasone and its Carbon Nanotube Nanovector

In this paper, each of the two following proteins, the angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2) and the Main protease (Main pro) of the Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2) were grafted for the first time on homemade neutravidin poly(GMA-co-EDMA) capillary columns for the research of their ligands. The effect of the column diameter on the quantity of immobilized biotinylated protein was studied. For a capillary length of 40 mm, when its internal diameter varied from 75 to 25 μm, the grafted quantity of ACE2 decreased by 85% (from 1.50 to 0.24 μg). Among all the studied ligands, a particular vigilance has been given for dexamethasone, a widely used molecule today for adult patients hospitalized with SARS-CoV-2. Competition experiments were performed with SARS-CoV-2 Receptor Binding Domain used as reference molecule with the ACE2 affinity column to assess the orthosteric binding site of dexamethasone (Dex) on ACE2. This ligand was then immobilized on Multiwall Carbon Nanotubes (Dex/MWCNT). By comparison of the normalized breakthrough curves measured for Dex and Dex/MWCNT on both the ACE2 and Main pro affinity columns, it was showed for the first time that nanovectorisation of Dex with MWCNT enhanced and stabilized its binding to both ACE2 and Main pro. This last result reinforced the use of Dex and the interest of MWCNT for boosting immune health against COVID 19.

[Advances in chromatography in the study of drug-plasma protein interactions]

After entering human blood circulation, small-molecule drugs interact extensively with various plasma proteins, such as human serum albumin and α1-acid glycoprotein. These interactions profoundly affect the distribution of drugs in vivo and the binding of drugs to targets, thus affecting the efficacy of drugs. In-depth investigation of drug-plasma protein interactions is of great significance for the optimization of drug properties, the development of new drugs, risk assessment, and combination therapy of drugs. Therefore, it is essential to develop highly efficient, sensitive, and accurate methods for elucidating drug-plasma protein interactions. Chromatography is a powerful tool with high throughput, high separation performance, and high sensitivity in the characterization of drug-protein interactions. High-performance affinity chromatography (HPAC) and capillary electrophoresis (CE) have been widely utilized in this field. These methods include the determination of the effects of the posttranslational modification of proteins on binding and the competitive binding of multiple drugs. In addition, various chromatographic methods are used to obtain interaction information such as the binding constant, binding-site number, and dissociation rate constant. In this review, the common strategies and recent advances in HPAC and CE in the study of drug-plasma protein interactions are briefly reviewed. The immobilization methods of proteins, the principles and applications of frontal analysis, zonal elution, ultrafast affinity extraction, peak profiling, and peak decay analysis are discussed for HPAC and affinity capillary electrophoresis (ACE) and capillary electrophoresis frontal analysis (CE-FA) for CE. HPAC relies on the fixation of proteins on the surfaces of chromatographic stationary phases by covalent linking or physical adsorption, followed by obtaining the drug-protein interaction information through a variety of chromatographic methods. In the frontal chromatography analysis, mobile phases with different concentrations of drugs are passed through the HPAC column to obtain different breakthrough times. The process can determine the number of drug binding sites and the binding constant of each site in the affinity protein with high accuracy. The zonal elution method can detect the drug binding sites on proteins using site-specific probes to determine whether there is competition between drugs and probes. The sample consumption and analysis time of the zonal elution method are much less than those in frontal chromatography analysis. The ultrafast affinity extraction method can inject complex samples, such as serum, into affinity columns to determine the free drug components. It can measure the combination and dissociation constants of drug-protein interactions by changing the chromatography flow rate. Peak profiling and peak decay analyses are both effective methods for investigating the dissociation of drugs and proteins. In CE analysis, the drug and protein samples are dissolved in an electrophoresis buffer, and their interactions are measured during electrophoresis with high accuracy and low sample consumption. However, the adsorption of proteins on the capillary wall can compromise CE performance. Common CE methods in drug-protein interaction analysis are ACE and CE-FA. ACE is usually performed by changing the effective mobility of drugs via the addition of different concentrations of proteins. This method has been widely used, and several variant techniques have been developed recently. CE-FA involves the sampling of a drug premixed at a known concentration with a target protein. Compared with other CE methods, CE-FA exhibits the unique advantages of high throughput, automatic online analysis, and the ability to determine high-order drug-protein interactions. Finally, the shortcomings of current chromatography methods are summarized, and the application prospects and development direction of chromatography technology in the field of drug-plasma protein interaction research are discussed.

Rapid screening of bioactive compound in Sanzi Yangqin Decoction and investigating of binding mechanism by immobilized β2-adrenogic receptor chromatography coupled with molecular docking

Screening bioactive compounds from traditional Chinese medicines plays pivotal role in preventing and curing diseases. Sanzi Yangqin Decoction (SYD) is a commonly used prescription for the treatment of cough, asthma and some other respiratory diseases for hundreds of years in practice. This reminds us that there may exist some bioactive compounds strongly binding with the recognized receptors mediating these diseases like β₂-adrenegic receptor (β₂-AR). Therefore, this work intends to screen bioactive compounds from SYD and revealed the binding mechanism by immobilized β₂-AR chromatography and molecular docking. Taking advantages of a 3-high based enzymatic trans-methylation reaction (high speed, high specificity and high activity), the immobilization of β₂-AR was successfully achieved. Representative chromatographic peaks of SYD on the immobilized β₂-AR column was collected and recognized as rosmarinic acid and sinapine thiocyanate. Tension changes of the trachea ring showed that the two compounds were in a concentration-dependent manner when exerting their effects and the concentration ranges were 10^-9-10^-4 mol/L and 10^-12-10^-7 mol/L, respectively. Molecular docking revealed Ser203, Ser204, Ser207, Tyr316 and Asn312 were the main residues for the two compounds to bind with β₂-AR. We concluded that the proposed method is becoming an alternative in rapid recognizing bioactive compounds from complex matrix.

Recent Advances in Supramolecular Affinity Separations: Affinity Chromatography and Related Methods

Affinity chromatography is a technique that uses a stationary phase based on the supramolecular interactions that occur in biological systems or mimics of these systems. This method has long been a popular tool for the isolation, measurement, and characterization of specific targets in complex samples. This review discusses the basic concepts of this method and examines recent developments in affinity chromatography and related supramolecular separation methods. Topics that are examined include advances that have occurred in the types of supports, approaches to immobilization, and binding agents that are employed in this method. New developments in the applications of affinity chromatography are also summarized, including an overview on the use of this method for biochemical purification, sample preparation or analysis, chiral separations, and biointeraction studies.

Affinity chromatography: A review of trends and developments over the past 50 years

The field of affinity chromatography, which employs a biologically-related agent as the stationary phase, has seen significant growth since the modern era of this method began in 1968. This review examines the major developments and trends that have occurred in this technique over the past five decades. The basic principles and history of this area are first discussed. This is followed by an overview of the various supports, immobilization strategies, and types of binding agents that have been used in this field. The general types of applications and fields of use that have appeared for affinity chromatography are also considered. A survey of the literature is used to identify major trends in these topics and important areas of use for affinity chromatography in the separation, analysis, or characterization of chemicals and biochemicals.

Solid-Supported Proteins in the Liquid Chromatography Domain to Probe Ligand-Target Interactions

Ligand-target interactions play a central role in drug discovery processes because these interactions are crucial in biological systems. Small molecules-proteins interactions can regulate and modulate protein function and activity through conformational changes. Therefore, bioanalytical tools to screen new ligands have focused mainly on probing ligand-target interactions. These interactions have been evaluated by using solid-supported proteins, which provide advantages like increased protein stability and easier protein extraction from the reaction medium, which enables protein reuse. In some specific approaches, precisely in the ligand fishing assay, the bioanalytical method allows the ligands to be directly isolated from complex mixtures, including combinatorial libraries and natural products extracts without prior purification or fractionation steps. Most of these screening assays are based on liquid chromatography separation, and the binding events can be monitored through on-line or off-line methods. In the on-line approaches, solid supports containing the immobilized biological target are used as chromatographic columns most of the time. Several terms have been used to refer to such approaches, such as weak affinity chromatography, high-performance affinity chromatography, on-flow activity assays, and high-performance liquid affinity chromatography. On the other hand, in the off-line approaches, the binding event occurs outside the liquid chromatography system and may encompass affinity and activity-based assays in which the biological target is immobilized on magnetic particles or monolithic silica, among others. After the incubation step, the supernatant or the eluate from the binding assay is analyzed by liquid chromatography coupled to various detectors. Regardless of the selected bioanalytical approach, the use of solid supported proteins has significantly contributed to the development of automated and reliable screening methods that enable ligands to be isolated and characterized in complex matrixes without purification, thereby reducing costs and avoiding time-laborious steps. This review provides a critical overview of recently developed assays.

Kinetic Analysis by Affinity Chromatography

Important information on chemical processes in living systems can be obtained by the rates at which these biological interactions occur. This review will discuss several techniques based on traditional and high-performance affinity chromatography that may be used to examine the kinetics of biological reactions. These methods include band-broadening measurements, techniques for peak fitting, split-peak analysis, peak decay studies, and ultrafast affinity extraction. The general principles and theory of each method, as applied to the determination of rate constants, will be discussed. The applications of each approach, along with its advantages and limitations, will also be considered.

Application of biomimetic HPLC to estimate in vivo behavior of early drug discovery compounds

Characterizing the properties of large numbers of compounds and estimating their potential absorption, distribution, metabolism and elimination properties are important early stages in the process of drug discovery and help to reduce later stage attrition. The chromatographic separation principles using stationary phases that contain proteins and phospholipids are more suitable for compound characterization and estimation of the pharmacokinetic properties than the traditional octanol/water partition coefficient. This technology, when standardized, enables the prediction of in vivo behavior and the selection of compounds with the best potential, thus reducing the number of animal experiments. Chromatography may be involved more widely in the future to measure kinetic aspects of compounds’ binding to proteins and receptors which would enable designing compounds that require a lower frequency of doses and have more predictable pharmacokinetic profiles.

Characterization of solution-phase drug-protein interactions by ultrafast affinity extraction

A number of tools based on high-performance affinity separations have been developed for studying drug-protein interactions. An example of one recent approach is ultrafast affinity extraction. This method has been employed to examine the free (or non-bound) fractions of drugs and other solutes in simple or complex samples that contain soluble binding agents. These free fractions have also been used to determine the binding constants and rate constants for the interactions of drugs with these soluble agents. This report describes the general principles of ultrafast affinity extraction and the experimental conditions under which it can be used to characterize such interactions. This method will be illustrated by utilizing data that have been obtained when using this approach to measure the binding and dissociation of various drugs with the serum transport proteins human serum albumin and alpha₁-acid glycoprotein. A number of practical factors will be discussed that should be considered in the design and optimization of this approach for use with single-column or multi-column systems. Techniques will also be described for analyzing the resulting data for the determination of free fractions, rate constants and binding constants. In addition, the extension of this method to complex samples, such as clinical specimens, will be considered.

Analysis of stereoselective drug interactions with serum proteins by high-performance affinity chromatography: A historical perspective

The interactions of drugs with serum proteins are often stereoselective and can affect the distribution, activity, toxicity and rate of excretion of these drugs in the body. A number of approaches based on affinity chromatography, and particularly high-performance affinity chromatography (HPAC), have been used as tools to study these interactions. This review describes the general principles of affinity chromatography and HPAC as related to their use in drug binding studies. The types of serum agents that have been examined with these methods are also discussed, including human serum albumin, α1-acid glycoprotein, and lipoproteins. This is followed by a description of the various formats based on affinity chromatography and HPAC that have been used to investigate drug interactions with serum proteins and the historical development for each of these formats. Specific techniques that are discussed include zonal elution, frontal analysis, and kinetic methods such as those that make use of band-broadening measurements, peak decay analysis, or ultrafast affinity extraction.

Chromatographic studies of drug interactions with alpha1-acid glycoprotein by ultrafast affinity extraction and peak profiling

Interactions with serum proteins such as alpha₁-acid glycoprotein (AGP) can have a significant effect on the behavior and pharmacokinetics of drugs. Ultrafast affinity extraction and peak profiling were used with AGP microcolumns to examine these processes for several model drugs (i.e., chlorpromazine, disopyramide, imipramine, lidocaine, propranolol and verapamil). The association equilibrium constants measured for these drugs with soluble AGP by ultrafast affinity extraction were in the general range of 10⁴-10⁶M^-1 at pH 7.4 and 37°C and gave good agreement with literature values. Some of these values were dependent on the relative drug and protein concentrations that were present when using a single-site binding model; these results suggested a more complex mixed-mode interaction was actually present, which was also then used to analyze the data. The apparent dissociation rate constants that were obtained by ultrafast affinity extraction when using a single-site model varied from 0.14 to 7.0s^-1 and were dependent on the relative drug and protein concentrations. Lower apparent dissociation rate constants were obtained by this approach as the relative amount of drug versus protein was decreased, with the results approaching those measured by peak profiling at low drug concentrations. This information should be useful in better understanding how these and other drugs interact with AGP in the circulation. In addition, the chromatographic approaches that were optimized and used in this report to examine these systems can be adapted for the analysis of other solute-protein interactions of biomedical interest.

Chromatographic Studies of Protein-Based Chiral Separations

The development of separation methods for the analysis and resolution of chiral drugs and solutes has been an area of ongoing interest in pharmaceutical research. The use of proteins as chiral binding agents in high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) has been an approach that has received particular attention in such work. This report provides an overview of proteins that have been used as binding agents to create chiral stationary phases (CSPs) and in the use of chromatographic methods to study these materials and protein-based chiral separations. The supports and methods that have been employed to prepare protein-based CSPs will also be discussed and compared. Specific types of CSPs that are considered include those that employ serum transport proteins (e.g., human serum albumin, bovine serum albumin, and alpha1-acid glycoprotein), enzymes (e.g., penicillin G acylase, cellobiohydrolases, and α-chymotrypsin) or other types of proteins (e.g., ovomucoid, antibodies, and avidin or streptavidin). The properties and applications for each type of protein and CSP will also be discussed in terms of their use in chromatography and chiral separations.