Strengthening of a model composite restoration using shape optimization: a numerical and experimental study

On the fracture behavior of molar teeth with MOD cavity preparation

Mesial-occlusal-distal (MOD) cavity preparations are commonly used to restore damaged teeth. While numerous in vitro cavity designs have been devised and tested, no analytical frameworks for assessing their resistance to fracture seem to exist. This concern is addressed here by resorting to a 2D slice specimen cut from restored molar teeth with rectangular-base MOD cavity. The evolution of damage due to axial cylindrical indentation is followed in situ. The failure begins with a rapid debonding along the tooth/filler interface and continues with unstable cracking from the cavity corner. The debonding load q_d is fairly fixed while the failure load q_f is insensitive to the presence of filler, increasing with cavity wall thickness h and reducing with cavity depth D. The growth of the corner crack is studied using a 2D fracture analysis in conjunction with the FEM technique. The ratio h = h/D emerges as a viable system parameter. A simple expression for q_f given in terms of h and dentin toughness K_C is developed that predicts well the test data. In vitro studies on full-fledged molar teeth with MOD cavity preparation show that the fracture resistance of filled cavities often exceeds by a large margin that of unfilled ones. Indications are that this may reflect load sharing with the filler. Thus, the fracture resistance of the unfilled cavity provides a lower bound to a compromised MOD filling after long-term aging in the mouth. This bound is well predicted by the slice model. Finally, it is recommended that MOD cavities be prepared, if applicable, such that h > D regardless of the tooth size.

Shape Optimization of Costal Cartilage Framework Fabrication Based on Finite Element Analysis for Reducing Incidence of Auricular Reconstruction Complications

Skin necrosis is the most common complication in total auricular reconstruction, which is mainly induced by vascular compromise and local stress concentration of the overlying skin. Previous studies generally emphasized the increase in the skin flap blood supply, while few reports considered the mechanical factors. However, skin injury is inevitable due to uneasily altered loads generated by the intraoperative continuous negative suction and uneven cartilage framework structure. Herein, this study aims to attain the stable design protocol of the ear cartilage framework to decrease mechanical damage and the incidence of skin necrosis. Finite element analysis was initially utilized to simulate the reconstructive process while the shape optimization technique was then adopted to optimize the three-pretested shape of the hollows inside the scapha and fossa triangularis under negative suction pressure. Finally, the optimal results would be output automatically to meet clinical requirement. Guided by the results of FE-based shape optimization, the optimum framework with the smallest holes inside the scapha and fossa triangularis was derived. Subsequent finite element analysis results also demonstrated the displacement and stress of the post-optimized model were declined 64.9 and 40.1%, respectively. The following clinical study was performed to reveal that this new design reported lower rates of skin necrosis decrease to 5.08%, as well as the cartilage disclosure decreased sharply from 14.2 to 3.39% compared to the conventional method. Both the biomechanical analysis and the clinical study confirmed that the novel design framework could effectively reduce the rates of skin necrosis, which shows important clinical significance for protecting against skin necrosis.

Fracture behavior of restored teeth and cavity shape optimization: Numerical and experimental investigation

OBJECTIVES

Since restored teeth are subject to more damages than intact teeth, investigating their fracture behavior is important. However, so far, improvement of the debonding behavior of the restoration and fracture of restored teeth considering the geometry of the restoration and different restorative materials has remained understudied. The aim of this paper is to numerically and experimentally investigate the debonding behavior of the restoration in premolar teeth in order to reduce the stress of restoration thereby reducing the mechanical failure.

METHODS

the fracture test for intact and Standard Class-II Mesial-Occlusal-Distal (MOD) restoration premolar teeth restored with several types of composite and conventional adhesive was performed in order to investigate their fracture behavior. The mechanical properties and fracture of composites as well as the adhesives used in experimental tests were obtained through separate standard mechanical tests. In addition, a number of composites and other adhesives were also chosen from other references, and by numerically simulating the fracture process of intact teeth and those restored with the materials of interest, the fracture behavior and yield load limit were investigated and predicted for them. Next, in order to reduce the stresses of bonding region and improve the damage behavior, using the stress-induced material transformation (SMT) optimization algorithm applied as code in finite element (FE) software, the shape of the restoration has been optimized based on different restorative materials. In order to confirm the numerical results, the fracture tests of teeth samples were performed with conventional and optimized restoration forms. Furthermore, using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) method, the fracture surface of the tested samples was examined.

RESULTS

since the fracture behavior of teeth restored with different materials is different, the optimized MOD restoration would be also different for each of these restorative materials. By selecting TU-shape for the restoration in each of the samples, the debonding resistance and final fracture of teeth compared to the MOD restoration increased 51% in P_d and 11% in P_f for numerical results and 40% in P_d and 4% in P_f for experimental results. The obtained results suggest that choosing a proper shape for the restoration based on the properties of restorative materials leads to diminished normal and shear stresses and enhanced debonding resistance. Also, the yield load limit of the defective teeth would also improve considerably.

SIGNIFICANCE

The clinical importance of this study is to predict strength of restored teeth and cavity shape optimization under variable conditions. Also, this paper introduces effective parameters on strength reduction/enhancement to dentists.

Substantial regional differences in the biomechanical behavior of molar treated with selective caries tissue removal technique: a finite element study

OBJECTIVES

Selective caries removal (SCR) is recommended over non-selective removal for managing deep carious lesions to avoid pulp exposure and maintain pulp vitality. During SCR, residual carious dentin is left behind and sealed beneath the restoration. The biomechanical effects of such residual lesions on the restored tooth remain unclear and were assessed using finite element modeling (FEM).

METHODS

Based on μ-CT images of a healthy permanent human third molar, we developed five finite element models. Generic class I and II cavity restorations were modeled where residual lesions of variable sizes were either left or fully removed on occlusal and proximal surfaces. The cavities were restored with adhesive composite. All 3D-FE models were compared with a model of a healthy, non-treated molar. A vertical load of 100 N was applied onto the occlusal surface.

RESULTS

Regardless of the lesion size, in molars with occlusal lesions higher mean stresses were predicted along the filling-lesion interface than in all other models. The smallest occlusal lesion (Ø₁ = 1 mm) resulted in the highest maximum stresses at the filling-lesion interface with large stress concentrations at the filling walls indicating failure risk. In conclusion, lesion site and extent are influencing parameters affecting the filling-lesion interactions and thus the biomechanical behavior of the tooth after SCR.

SIGNIFICANCE

Retaining carious lesions around the pulpal floor affects the deformation and stress states in tooth-filling complexes. The higher stresses observed in molars with occlusal lesions may affect restoration stability and longevity. Suprisingly, more extended occlusal lesions may provide a more favorable tooth performance than less extended ones. In contrast, in molars with proximal lesions the residual lesion had only limited effect on the tooth's biomechanical condition.

In Vitro Performance of Class I and II Composite Restorations: A Literature review on Nondestructive Laboratory Trials—Part II

A literature review was conducted on adhesive Class I and II restorations and nondestructive in vitro tests using the PubMed/Medline database for the 1995-2010 period. The first part of this review has presented and critically appraised selected literature dealing with the quality and in vitro behavior of adhesive Class II restorations using photoelasticity, finite element analysis, and microleakage study protocols. This second part reviews additional parameters, which are deformation and fracture resistance to cyclic loading, shrinkage stress and tooth deformation following restoration placement, bond strength (microtensile, tensile, and shear tests), and marginal and internal adaptation. In addition, a “relevance score” has been proposed that aims to classify the different study protocols according, firstly, to the resulting quality, quantity, and consistency of the evidence and then, secondly, to their potential clinical relevance, as estimated by their ability to simulate oral and biomechanical strains. The highest clinical relevance was attributed to marginal and internal adaptation studies, following cyclic loading in a moist environement. However, a combination of in vitro protocols will have an even greater predictive potential and has to be considered as a crucial preclinical research approach with which to investigate the numerous restorative configurations that cannot be efficiently and rapidly tested in vivo.

In Vitro Performance of Class I and II Composite Restorations: A Literature Review on Nondestructive Laboratory Trials—Part I

Posterior adhesive restorations are a basic procedure in general dental practices, but their application remains poorly standardized as a result of the number of available options. An abundant number of study hypotheses corresponding to almost unlimited combinations of preparation techniques, adhesive procedures, restorative options, and materials have been described in the literature and submitted to various evaluation protocols. A literature review was thus conducted on adhesive Class I and II restorations and nondestructive in vitro tests using the PubMed/Medline database for the 1995-2010 period. The first part of this review discusses the selected literature related to photoelasticity, finite element analysis (FEM), and microleakage protocols. Based on the aforementioned evaluation methods, the following parameters proved influential: cavity dimensions and design, activation mode (light or chemical), type of curing light, layering technique, and composite structure or physical characteristics. Photoelasticity has various limitations and has been largely (and advantageously) replaced by the FEM technique. The results of microleakage studies proved to be highly inconsistent, and the further use of this technique should be strictly limited. Other study protocols for adhesive Class II restorations were also reviewed and will be addressed in part II of this article, together with a tentative relevance hierarchy of selected in vitro methods.

Stress Analysis of a Class II MO-Restored Tooth Using a 3D CT-Based Finite Element Model

A computational method has been developed for stress analysis of a restored tooth so that experimental effort can be minimized. The objectives of this study include (i) developing a method to create a 3D FE assembly model for a restored tooth based on CT images and (ii) conducting stress analysis of the restored tooth using the 3D FE model established. To build up a solid computational model of a tooth, a method has been proposed to construct a 3D model from 2D CT-scanned images. Facilitated with CAD tools, the 3D tooth model has been virtually incorporated with a Class II MO restoration. The tooth model is triphasic, including the enamel, dentin, and pulp phases. To mimic the natural constraint on the movement of the tooth model, its corresponding mandible model has also been generated. The relative high maximum principal stress values were computed at the surface under loading and in the marginal region of the interface between the restoration and the tooth phases.

Effect of Cavity Design on the Strength of Direct Posterior Composite Restorations: An Empirical and FEM Analysis

The aim of the present study was to verify the hypothesis that cavity design does not affect the strength of direct composite restorations as do material properties. Finite element modeling (FEM) and empirical testing were done for two cavity designs: a box shape (cube) and a concave shape (U). Two microhybrid composites were used to prepare the samples with the help of split stainless steel moulds. Compressive strength was tested. The results were statistically analyzed. Both FEA and empirical testing were complementary to each other in that the concave shape showed a significantly higher strength than box. Material properties affected the values only when box shape was used. The null hypothesis is thus rejected, and it is concluded that design significantly affects the strength of direct composite restorations.