Dysplastic nevus: why this term should be abandoned in dermatoscopy

Advances in melanoma: epidemiology, diagnosis, and prognosis

Unraveling the multidimensional complexities of melanoma has required concerted efforts by dedicated community of researchers and clinicians battling against this deadly form of skin cancer. Remarkable advances have been made in the realm of epidemiology, classification, diagnosis, and therapy of melanoma. The treatment of advanced melanomas has entered the golden era as targeted personalized therapies have emerged that have significantly altered the mortality rate. A paradigm shift in the approach to melanoma classification, diagnosis, prognosis, and staging is underway, fueled by discoveries of genetic alterations in melanocytic neoplasms. A morphologic clinicopathologic classification of melanoma is expected to be replaced by a more precise molecular based one. As validated, convenient, and cost-effective molecular-based tests emerge, molecular diagnostics will play a greater role in the clinical and histologic diagnosis of melanoma. Artificial intelligence augmented clinical and histologic diagnosis of melanoma is expected to make the process more streamlined and efficient. A more accurate model of prognosis and staging of melanoma is emerging based on molecular understanding melanoma. This contribution summarizes the recent advances in melanoma epidemiology, classification, diagnosis, and prognosis.

Dysplastic nevus part I: Historical perspective, classification, and epidemiology

Since the late 1970s, the diagnosis and management of dysplastic nevi have been areas fraught with controversy in the fields of dermatology and dermatopathology. Diagnostic uncertainty and lack of standardized nomenclature continue to propagate confusion among clinicians, dermatopathologists, and patients. In part I of this CME review article, we summarize the historical context that gave rise to the debate surrounding dysplastic nevi and review key features for diagnosis, classification, and management, as well as epidemiology. We discuss essentials of clinical criteria, dermoscopic features, histopathologic features, and the diagnostic utility of total body photography and reflectance confocal microscopy in evaluating dysplastic nevi, with emphasis on information available since the last comprehensive review a decade ago.

Histogenesis of cutaneous malignant melanoma: The vast majority do not develop from melanocytic nevus but arise de novo as melanoma in situ

It has been considered that most cutaneous malignant melanomas arise from pre-existing melanocytic nevus. Many clinical and histopathological studies seem to support this concept. Dysplastic nevus originally proposed by Clark's group is a key entity of the intermediate lesion between benign nevus and melanoma. The latest edition of the WHO Classification of Skin Tumours (2018) has excluded Clark nevus (dysplastic nevus of mild atypia) from dysplastic nevus, the latter being now classified into the low- and high-grade by the degrees of nuclear atypia. The World Health Organization classification regards dysplastic nevus of both grades as the intermediate lesion between common acquired nevus and the radial growth-phase melanoma. An extensive genetic study recently performed by Bastian's group indicated the existence of intermediate lesions between nevus and melanoma. In spite of these findings, some investigators doubt the concept of the intermediate lesions including dysplastic nevus and insist that the majority of melanomas arise de novo as melanoma in situ, not in association with a preceding nevus. The concept of de novo genesis of melanoma may be supported by a recent meta-analysis study revealing that 71% of melanomas likely arose de novo and 29% from pre-existing nevus. In this review article, from the viewpoint of de novo genesis of melanoma, the author critically discusses the relevant findings of melanoma genesis and proposes a new framework to interpret the morphological and genetic data alternatively. Clarification of the oncogenic process of melanoma has great impact not only on clinical dermatology but also on basic oncology.

Dermoscopy of a Spark's nevus

Spark’s nevus is a particular type of melanocytic nevus that on histology shows features of both Spitz’s and Clark’s nevus. Clinically, it is an asymmetric, irregular, multicolored, pigmented lesion that is not clearly distinguishable from melanoma or dysplastic (Clark’s) nevus. Dermoscopic features have not been described yet, and one could speculate that they are similar to those of Clark’s nevi because the histopathologic architecture of Spark’s nevus is similar to that of a Clark’s nevus, resembling Spitz’s nevi in the epithelioid morphology of melanocytes. We present a 32-year-old woman with a Spark’s nevus, who upon dermoscopy showed a pronounced atypical network with accentuation of the blue veil and mostly peripheral dots.

Evaluation of electrical impedance spectroscopy as an adjunct to dermoscopy in short-term monitoring of atypical melanocytic lesions

BACKGROUND

Early detection of melanoma is vital for treatment outcome and survival. Short-term sequential digital dermoscopic monitoring (ST-SDDM) involves the capture and assessment of dermoscopic images of one or more atypical melanocytic lesions (AMLs), at baseline and after four months, in order to detect early morphologic changes. Electrical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) is a diagnostic tool with high sensitivity for the detection of malignant melanocytic lesions.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to assess whether EIS, in addition to ST-SDDM, could improve the selection of AMLs requiring surgery.

METHODS

In this retrospective descriptive study, 22 AMLs in 19 patients were monitored with both ST-SDDM and EIS. A modified EIS decision-making algorithm was established. AMLs were excised if any dermoscopic changes were seen and/or if the EIS score had increased significantly at follow-up. Statistical analyses were made including sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV.

RESULTS

A total of seven lesions (32%) were excised. Four lesions (57%) were excised solely because of dermoscopic changes including a 0.4 mm-thick melanoma and three benign nevi. Three benign lesions (43%) were excised because of increased EIS scores without any dermoscopic changes. The EIS scores at follow-up showed high variability as compared to the initial scores.

CONCLUSION

The addition of EIS to ST-SDDM did not identify additional malignant lesions. There was no correlation between dermoscopic changes seen with ST-SDDM and increased EIS scores. Three histopathologically benign lesions were needlessly excised. Moreover, the low reproducibility and the possible interoperator variability of the method raised concerns.

Dysplastic nevus: Fact and fiction

The term "dysplastic nevus" (DN) implies that this nevus exists as a distinct and defined entity of potential detriment to its host. We examine the current data, which suggest that this entity exists as histologically and possibly genetically different from common nevus, with some overlapping features. Studies show that a melanoma associated with a nevus is just as likely to arise in a common nevus as in DN. Furthermore, there is no evidence that a histologically defined DN evolves into a melanoma or that the presence of 1 or more DN on an individual patient confers any increased melanoma risk. We suggest that the term "dysplastic nevus" be abandoned so that the focus can shift to confirmed and relevant indicators of melanoma risk, including high nevus counts and large nevus size.

Outcomes of biopsies and excisions of dysplastic acral nevi: a study of 187 lesions

BACKGROUND

Despite their frequency in clinical practice, controversy exists regarding the significance and management of dysplastic nevi (DN). Although the perception of DN as precursors to melanoma is questionable, excisions of biopsy-proven DN are commonplace in clinical practice. The management of dysplastic acral nevi is of interest given the challenge of surgery at acral sites.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the outcomes of biopsies of clinically atypical acral nevi and excisions of histologically dysplastic acral nevi (HDN).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Retrospective review of consecutive patients at a private dermatology practice who had a biopsy of an atypical acral nevus from December 2004 to July 2012.

RESULTS

One hundred eighty-seven atypical acral nevi were biopsied from 168 patients (77 (41%) HDN, 108 (58%) common nevi). Based on initial histology, 30 (39%) HDN were recommended for excision and eight (10%) for clinical observation. Twenty-seven of the 77 HDN were excised; 23 (85%) revealed scar only, and four (15%) revealed residual DN not involving the margin.

CONCLUSION

Routine excision of biopsy-proven dysplastic acral nevi may not be necessary.