Automated quantitative assessment of wall motion in patients with poor acoustic windows

Diagnostic value of parametric imaging of left ventricular wall motion from contrast-enhanced echocardiograms in patients with poor acoustic windows

BACKGROUND

Analysis of left ventricular (LV) regional wall motion (RWM) is subjective and may be challenging in patients with suboptimal images, even with contrast enhancement. It was hypothesized that the amplitude and timing of RWM obtained from contrast-enhanced echocardiograms can be accurately represented in still-frame parametric images. This study was designed to (1) test this hypothesis, (2) establish the diagnostic value of these images as an aid for inexperienced readers, and (3) test the feasibility of automated quantitative analysis of RWM.

METHODS

Contrast-enhanced apical 4-chamber, 2-chamber, and 3-chamber LV views were acquired in 45 patients with poor acoustic windows. The interpretation of dynamic images by an experienced reader who classified RWM as normal or abnormal was used as a reference for comparisons against (1) visual interpretation of parametric images, (2) interpretation of dynamic images by two inexperienced readers (American Society of Echocardiography level I) without and subsequently with parametric images, and (3) automated quantification of RWM.

RESULTS

Expert readers detected abnormal RWM in 30 patients (437 of 945 segments). Visual interpretation of parametric images showed good agreement with the reference (sensitivity, 85%; specificity, 82%; accuracy, 84%). The interpretations by inexperienced readers improved with the addition of parametric images, with increases in specificity (from 58% to 79%) and accuracy (from 74% to 84%), despite a slight decrease in sensitivity (from 92% to 91%). Automated classification was feasible and accurate (sensitivity, 82%; specificity, 78%; accuracy, 80%).

CONCLUSION

Parametric images derived from contrast-enhanced echocardiograms of patients with poor acoustic windows accurately depicted RWM, improved the diagnostic accuracy of inexperienced readers, and allowed the objective detection of RWM abnormalities.

Volumetric analysis of regional left ventricular function with real-time three-dimensional echocardiography: validation by magnetic resonance and clinical utility testing

BACKGROUND

Quantitative information on regional left ventricular volumes from real-time three-dimensional echocardiographic (RT3DE) images has significant clinical potential but needs validation.

AIM

To validate these measurements against cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) and test the feasibility of automated detection of regional wall motion (RWM) abnormalities from RT3DE data.

METHODS

RT3DE (Philips) and CMR (Siemens) images were obtained from 31 patients and analysed by using prototype software to semiautomatically calculate indices of regional left ventricular function, which were compared between RT3DE and CMR (linear regression, Bland-Altman). Additionally, CMR images were reviewed by an expert, whose RWM grades were used as a reference for automated classification of segments as normal or abnormal from RT3DE and from CMR images. For each modality, normal regional ejection fraction (REF) values were obtained from 15 patients with normal wall motion. In the remaining 16 patients, REFs were compared with thresholds that were derived from patients with normal wall motion and optimised using receiver operating characteristic analysis.

RESULTS

RT3DE measurements resulted in good agreement with CMR. Regional indices calculated in patients with normal wall motion varied between segments, but overall were similar between modalities. In patients with abnormal wall motion, RWM was graded as abnormal in 74% segments. CMR and RT3DE thresholds were similar (16-segment average 55 (10)% and 56 (7)%, respectively). Automated interpretation resulted in good agreement with expert interpretation, similar for CMR and RT3DE (sensitivity 0.85, 0.84; specificity 0.81, 0.78; accuracy 0.84, 0.84, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Analysis of RT3DE data provides accurate quantification of regional left ventricular function and allows semiautomated detection of RWM abnormalities, which is as accurate as the same algorithm applied to CMR images.

Clinical utility of contrast-enhanced echocardiography

Over the past three decades, echocardiography has become a major diagnostic tool in the arsenal of clinical cardiology for real-time imaging of cardiac dynamics. More and more, cardiologists' decisions are based on images created from ultrasound wave reflections. From the time ultrasound imaging technology provided the first insight into a human heart, our diagnostic capabilities have increased exponentially as a result of our growing knowledge and developing technologies. One of the most intriguing developments that brought about a decade-long combination of expectations and disappointments was the introduction of echocardiographic contrast agents. Despite repeated waves of controversy regarding the readiness of this technology for clinical use, it has overcome multiple hurdles and currently provides useful clinical information that helps cardiologists to diagnose heart disease accurately. Since the initial reports on the use of ultrasound contrast media such as agitated saline or renografin, the major advances in the field of contrast echocardiography have included (1) the development of stable perfluorocarbon-filled microbubbles, frequently referred to as second-generation contrast agents; and (2) the development of contrast-targeted nonlinear imaging modes, such as harmonic imaging, pulse inversion, and power modulation, which allow consistent real-time visualization of these agents. These contrast agents in conjunction with the new imaging technology constitute powerful tools that improve our ability to evaluate left ventricular function and myocardial perfusion, and allow differential diagnosis of thrombi and intravascular masses. In this manuscript, we briefly review some of the literature that has provided the scientific basis for the use of echocardiographic contrast agents in the context of these important variables.

Color encoding of endocardial motion improves the interpretation of contrast-enhanced echocardiographic stress tests by less-experienced readers

BACKGROUND

We hypothesized that color encoding of endocardial motion could aid less-experienced readers in detection of wall-motion abnormalities at rest and stress in patients with poor acoustic windows.

METHODS

Color-encoded images (color kinesis) were obtained at rest and peak dobutamine stress in 4 standard views during intravenous infusion of contrast agent in 117 patients with poorly visualized endocardium. In 101 of 117 patients (86%), in whom contrast enhancement allowed endocardial tracking, images were reviewed by two expert readers without color overlays. Each reader graded regional wall motion as normal, abnormal, or uninterpretable, and their consensus grades served as a gold standard. The same images were then reviewed and graded with and without color overlays by 3 cardiology fellows. The accuracy of the interpretation was calculated against the gold standard separately for the 3 vascular territories (left anterior descending, left circumflex, and right coronary arteries) and averaged for the 3 fellows.

RESULTS

With the addition of color encoding: (1) the number of uninterpretable segments decreased by 55% at rest and 61% at peak stress; and (2) all 3 fellows reached higher levels of accuracy in all 3 vascular territories both at rest (6%-82% average) and at stress (73%-80%).

CONCLUSION

The addition of color encoding of wall motion to contrast-enhanced images obtained in patients with poor acoustic windows during stress tests improves the interpretation of regional left ventricular function by less-experienced readers.