FRoG dose computation meets Monte Carlo accuracy for proton therapy dose calculation in lung

Experimental Validation of a Real-Time Adaptive 4D-Optimized Particle Radiotherapy Approach to Treat Irregularly Moving Tumors

PURPOSE

Treatment of locally advanced lung cancer is limited by toxicity and insufficient local control. Particle therapy could enable more conformal treatment than intensity modulated photon therapy but is challenged by irregular tumor motion, associated range changes, and tumor deformations. We propose a new strategy for robust, online adaptive particle therapy, synergizing 4-dimensional optimization with real-time adaptive beam tracking. The strategy was tested and the required motion monitoring precision was determined.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

In multiphase 4-dimensional dose delivery (MP4D), a dedicated quasistatic treatment plan is delivered to each motion phase of periodic 4-dimensional computed tomography (4DCT). In the new extension, "MP4D with residual tracking" (MP4DRT), lateral beam tracking compensates for the displacement of the tumor center-of-mass relative to the current phase in the planning 4DCT. We implemented this method in the dose delivery system of a clinical carbon facility and tested it experimentally for a lung cancer plan based on a periodic subset of a virtual lung 4DCT (planned motion amplitude 20 mm). Treatments were delivered in a quality assurance-like setting to a moving ionization chamber array. We considered variable motion amplitudes and baseline drifts. The required motion monitoring precision was evaluated by adding noise to the motion signal. Log-file-based dose reconstructions were performed in silico on the entire 4DCT phantom data set capable of simulating nonperiodic motion. MP4DRT was compared with MP4D, rescanned beam tracking, and internal target volume plans. Treatment quality was assessed in terms of target coverage (D95), dose homogeneity (D5-D95), conformity number, and dose to heart and lung.

RESULTS

For all considered motion scenarios and metrics, MP4DRT produced the most favorable metrics among the tested motion mitigation strategies and delivered high-quality treatments. The conformity was similar to static treatments. The motion monitoring precision required for D95 >95% was 1.9 mm.

CONCLUSIONS

With clinically feasible motion monitoring, MP4DRT can deliver highly conformal dose distributions to irregularly moving targets.

Dosimetric validation of a GPU-based dose engine for a fast in silico patient-specific quality assurance program in light ion beam therapy

BACKGROUND

With rapid evolutions of fast and sophisticated calculation techniques and delivery technologies, clinics are almost facing a daily patient-specific (PS) plan adaptation, which would make a conventional experimental quality assurance (QA) workflow unlikely to be routinely feasible. Therefore, in silico approaches are foreseen by means of second-check independent dose calculation systems possibly handling machine log-files.

PURPOSE

To validate the in-house developed GPU-dose engine, FRoG, for light ion beam therapy (protons and carbon ions) as a second-check independent calculation system and to integrate machine log-file analysis into the patient-specific quality assurance (PSQA) program.

METHODS

Spot sizes, depth-dose distributions, and absolute dose calibrations were configured into FRoG and a set of nine regular-shaped targets in combination with more than 170 clinical treatment fields were tested against pinpoint ionization chamber measurements. Both the treatment planning system DICOM RTplans and machine treatment log-files were used as input for the dose kernel in water, and a 3D local γ (1 mm/2%) index was used as the main evaluation metric.

RESULTS

Calculated configuration data matched experimental measurements with submillimetric agreement. For regular-shaped targets, the unsigned average relative difference between calculated and measured dose values was less than 2% for both protons and carbon ions. The mean γ passing rate (PR) was around 98% for both particle species. For clinical treatment beams, DICOM-based recalculations showed a γ-PR more than 99% for both particle species. The same level of agreement was preserved for protons when moving to log-file-based recalculations. A score of around 95% was registered for carbon ion beams, once excluding low-quality machine log-files. Unsigned average relative difference against acquired data was less than 2% also for real clinical beams.

CONCLUSIONS

FRoG was proven as an accurate and reliable tool for PSQA in scanning light ion beam therapy. The proposed method allows for an extremely efficient workflow, without compromising the quality of the plan verification procedure.

Developing an accurate model of spot-scanning treatment delivery time and sequence for a compact superconducting synchrocyclotron proton therapy system

BACKGROUND

A new compact superconducting synchrocyclotron single-room proton solution delivers pulsed proton beams to each spot through several irradiation bursts calculated by an iterative layer delivery algorithm. Such a mechanism results in a new beam parameter, burst switching time (BST) in the total beam delivery time (BDT) which has never been studied before. In this study, we propose an experimental approach to build an accurate BDT and sequence prediction model for this new proton solution.

METHODS

Test fields and clinical treatment plans were used to investigate each beam delivery parameter that impacted BDT. The machine delivery log files were retrospectively analyzed to quantitatively model energy layer switching time (ELST), spot switching time (SSWT), spot spill time (SSPT), and BST. A total of 102 clinical IMPT treatment fields' log files were processed to validate the accuracy of the BDT prediction model in comparison with the result from the current commercial system. Interplay effect is also investigated as a clinical application by comparing this new delivery system model with a conventional cyclotron accelerator model.

RESULTS

The study finds that BST depends on the amount of data to be transmitted between two sequential radiation bursts, including a machine irradiation log file of the previous burst and a command file to instruct the proton system to deliver the next burst. The 102 clinical treatment fields showed that the accuracy of each component of the BDT matches well between machine log files and BDT prediction model. More specifically, the difference of ELST, SSWT, SSPT, and BST were (- 3.1 ± 5.7)%, (5.9 ± 3.9)%, (2.6 ± 8.7)%, and (- 2.3 ± 5.3)%, respectively. The average total BDT was about (2.1 ± 3.0)% difference compared to the treatment log files, which was significantly improved from the current commercial proton system prediction (58 ± 15)%. Compared to the conventional cyclotron system, the burst technique from synchrocyclotron effectively reduced the interplay effect in mobile tumor treatment.

CONCLUSION

An accurate BDT and sequence prediction model was established for this new clinical compact superconducting synchrocyclotron single-room proton solution. Its application could help users of similar facilities better assess the interplay effect and estimate daily patient treatment throughput.

Management of Motion and Anatomical Variations in Charged Particle Therapy: Past, Present, and Into the Future

The major aim of radiation therapy is to provide curative or palliative treatment to cancerous malignancies while minimizing damage to healthy tissues. Charged particle radiotherapy utilizing carbon ions or protons is uniquely suited for this task due to its ability to achieve highly conformal dose distributions around the tumor volume. For these treatment modalities, uncertainties in the localization of patient anatomy due to inter- and intra-fractional motion present a heightened risk of undesired dose delivery. A diverse range of mitigation strategies have been developed and clinically implemented in various disease sites to monitor and correct for patient motion, but much work remains. This review provides an overview of current clinical practices for inter and intra-fractional motion management in charged particle therapy, including motion control, current imaging and motion tracking modalities, as well as treatment planning and delivery techniques. We also cover progress to date on emerging technologies including particle-based radiography imaging, novel treatment delivery methods such as tumor tracking and FLASH, and artificial intelligence and discuss their potential impact towards improving or increasing the challenge of motion mitigation in charged particle therapy.

How can we consider variable RBE and LETd prediction during clinical practice? A pediatric case report at the Normandy Proton Therapy Centre using an independent dose engine

BACKGROUND

To develop an auxiliary GPU-accelerated proton therapy (PT) dose and LETd engine for the IBA Proteus®ONE PT system. A pediatric low-grade glioma case study is reported using FRoG during clinical practice, highlighting potential treatment planning insights using variable RBE dose (DvRBE) and LETd as indicators for clinical decision making in PT.

METHODS

The physics engine for FRoG has been modified for compatibility with Proteus®ONE PT centers. Subsequently, FRoG was installed and commissioned at NPTC. Dosimetric validation was performed against measurements and the clinical TPS, RayStation (RS-MC). A head patient cohort previously treated at NPTC was collected and FRoG forward calculations were compared against RS-MC for evaluation of 3D-Γ analysis and dose volume histogram (DVH) results. Currently, treatment design at NPTC is supported with fast variable RBE and LETd calculation and is reported in a representative case for pediatric low-grade glioma.

RESULTS

Simple dosimetric tests against measurements of iso-energy layers and spread-out Bragg Peaks in water verified accuracy of FRoG and RS-MC. Among the patient cohort, average 3D-Γ applying 2%/2 mm, 3%/1.5 mm and 5%/1 mm were > 97%. DVH metrics for targets and OARs between FRoG and RayStation were in good agreement, with ∆D50,CTV and ∆D2,OAR both ⪅1%. The pediatric case report demonstrated implications of different beam arrangements on DvRBE and LETd distributions. From initial planning in RayStation sharing identical optimization constraints, FRoG analysis led to plan selection of the most conservative approach, i.e., minimized DvRBE,max and LETd,max in OARs, to avoid optical system toxicity effects (i.e., vision loss).

CONCLUSION

An auxiliary dose calculation system was successfully integrated into the clinical workflow at a Proteus®ONE IBA facility, in excellent agreement with measurements and RS-MC. FRoG may lead to further insight on DvRBE and LETd implications to help clinical decision making, better understand unexpected toxicities and establish novel clinical procedures with metrics currently absent from the standard clinical TPS.