Do patients want to see recordings of their surgery?

Cloud Based AI-Driven Video Analytics (CAVs) in Laparoscopic Surgery: A Step Closer to a Virtual Portfolio

Aims: To outline the use of cloud-based artificial intelligence (AI)-driven video analytics (CAVs) in minimally invasive surgery and to propose their potential as a virtual portfolio for trainee and established surgeons. 

Methods: An independent online demonstration was requested from three platforms, namely Theator (Palo Alto, California, USA), Touch Surgery™ (Medtronic, London, England, UK), and C-SATS® (Seattle, Washington, USA). The assessed domains were online and app-based accessibility, the ability for timely trainee feedback, and AI integration for operation-specific steps and critical views.

Results: The CAVs enable users to record surgeries with the advantage of limitless video storage through clouding and smart integration into theatre settings. This can be used to view surgeries and review trainee videos through a medium of communication and sharing with the ability to provide feedback. Theator and C-SATS® provide their users with surgical skills scoring systems with customizable options that can be used to provide structured feedback to trainees. Additionally, AI plays an important role in all three platforms by providing time-based analysis of steps and highlighting critical milestones. 

Conclusion: Cloud-based AI-driven video analytics is an emerging new technology that enables users to store, analyze, and review videos. This technology has the potential to improve training, governance, and standardization procedures. Moreover, with the future adaptation of the technology, CAVs can be integrated into the trainees’ portfolios as part of their virtual curriculum. This can enable a structured assessment of a surgeon’s progression and degree of experience throughout their surgical career.

'Mind if I record this?' Patients making audio-visual recordings of consultations: a survey of surgeons' experiences

INTRODUCTION

Audio-visual recordings made by patients of their clinical encounters are increasingly common. This may be done with or without their doctors' knowledge or consent and is considered admissible legal evidence. Many surgeons may feel uncomfortable with being recorded and lack knowledge regarding the legal implications. The aim of this study was to gauge how surgeons react to being recorded, and what specific medico-legal insight they have regarding these matters.

METHODS

In total, 150 surveys were distributed to surgeons in two hospitals in South Wales by email, Survey Monkey and paper copy between 28 October 2019 and 9 March 2020. The survey was anonymous and recorded level of training, as well as four simple questions regarding how surgeons may react to being recorded and what they felt their legal rights were.

RESULTS

There were 91 respondents: 28 consultants, 36 registrars and 27 junior surgical trainees. Of the respondents, 56% were uncomfortable with being recorded and 23% would stop a consultation if their patient insisted on recording it. These issues were most marked for junior surgical trainees. Sixty-two per cent of respondents were unaware of their legal rights and 21% believed they were legally able to refuse to continue a consultation. This belief was particularly marked among consultants.

CONCLUSION

Many surgeons are uncomfortable with being recorded and lack knowledge regarding their medico-legal standing. Education and guidance from the Royal Colleges would help address this issue and avoid misunderstanding when surgeons are faced with these potentially difficult scenarios.

Reviewing recordings of neonatal resuscitation with parents

BACKGROUND

Recording of neonatal resuscitation, including video and respiratory parameters, was implemented for research and quality purposes at the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) of the Leiden University Medical Center, and parents were offered to review the recording of their infant together with a neonatal care provider. We aimed to provide insight in parental experiences with reviewing the recording of the neonatal resuscitation of their premature infant.

METHODS

This study combined participant observations during parental review of recordings with retrospective qualitative interviews with parents.

RESULTS

Parental review of recordings of neonatal resuscitation was observed on 20 occasions, reviewing recordings of 31 children (12 singletons, 8 twins and 1 triplet), of whom 4 died during admission. Median (range) gestational age at birth was 27+5 (24+5-30+3) weeks. Subsequently, 25 parents (13 mothers and 12 fathers) were interviewed.Parents reported many positive experiences, with special emphasis on the value for getting hold of the start of their infant's life and coping with the trauma of neonatal resuscitation. Reviewing recordings of neonatal resuscitation frequently resulted in appreciation for the child, the father and the medical team. Timing and set-up of the review contributed to positive experiences. Parents considered screenshots/copies of the recording of the resuscitation of their infant as valuable keepsakes of their NICU story and reported that having the screenshots/video comforted them, especially when their child died during admission.

CONCLUSION

Parents consider reviewing recordings of neonatal resuscitation as valuable. These positive parental experiences could allay concerns about sharing recordings of neonatal resuscitation with parents.

Comparison between camcorder, frontal head and temporal mounted action-cam in digestive surgery: Documentation and educational alternative during COVID-19 pandemic

OBJECTIVE

COVID-19 pandemic has made impact both in clinical and educational settings. The number of surgeries has decreased; thus, the surgery videos of all cases are important for both documentation and education. This study aimed to compare three kinds of cameras in recording digestive surgery.

METHODS

We compared three cameras: Panasonic HV-770 Full HD Camcorder, Sony FDR-X3000 Action-cam, and Ordro EP7 Hands-Free FPV Camera. Each camera was used in several recording for superficial and visceral digestive surgeries and we compared the following: operation field, image focus, surgeon's comfort, practicality, and record settings.

RESULTS

Camcorder needs 10-15 min to set up and longer dismounting time, has steady vantage view and focus, good image quality, can be zoomed, but the recording may be obstructed by the surgeon's head. Action camera needs 5-10 min to set up and the dismounting time was equal between Camcorder and Ordro. Action camera depicts surgeon's vision, however, zoom could not be applied while recording. Sony FDR-X3000 used in this study had good image quality, but the use of this camera in a long surgery may generate neck stiffness due to its weight. Ordro EP7 was comfortable in any surgery but it had inferior image quality compared to the others.

CONCLUSIONS

Panasonic HC-V770 and Sony FDR X3000 had good image quality, where camcorder excelled in longer surgeries due to its comfort, action-cam excelled for shorter surgeries due to ease of use and settings. Ordro EP7 was the most comfortable among all but has lowest image quality.

Anxiety at outpatient hysteroscopy

This review summarises current understanding and research on the association between anxiety and outpatient hysteroscopy. Women undergoing hysteroscopy suffer from significant levels of anxiety, with repercussions on pain perception, success rates and satisfaction. Using validated tools such as the Spielberger State-Trait Anxiety Index (STAI) or the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) in the outpatient hysteroscopy setting, average state anxiety scores similar or greater than those measured before more invasive procedures under general anaesthesia have been consistently reported. This clearly suggests a significant gap between our clinical viewpoint of what is "minimally invasive" and patients' expectations. In spite of its potential role of confounder in studies on pain-reduction interventions, we found that patient anxiety was evaluated in only 9 (13 %) out of a sample of 70 randomised controlled trials on outpatient hysteroscopy published since 1992. Factors such as trait anxiety, age, indication and the efficiency of the clinic can be correlated to state anxiety before hysteroscopy, but more robust data are needed. Promising non-pharmacological interventions to reduce anxiety at hysteroscopy include patient education, communication through traditional or multimedia approaches, interaction and support during the procedure and music listening.

Surgical Videos for Accident Analysis, Performance Improvement, and Complication Prevention

Conventional audit of surgical records through review of surgical results provides useful knowledge but hardly helps identify the technical reasons lying behind specific outcomes or complications. Surgical teams not only need to know that a complication might happen but also how and when it is most likely to happen. Functional awareness is therefore needed to prevent complications, know how to deal with them, and improve overall surgical performance. The authors wish to argue that the systematic recording and reviewing of surgical videos, a “surgical black box,” might improve surgical care, help prevent complications, and allow accident analysis. A possible strategy to test this hypothesis is presented and discussed. Recording and reviewing surgical interventions, apart from helping us achieve functional awareness and increasing the safety profile of our performance, allows us also to effectively share our experience with colleagues. The authors believe that those potential implications make this hypothesis worth testing.

How can patients’ understanding about their surgery be improved? – Implications for everyday practice

A pácienseink kezelésekről való tájékozottsága a megfelelő kommunikáció nagyon fontos eredménye. Az elégtelen kommunikáció félreértésekhez, aggodalomhoz és peres eljárások indításához vezethet. A betegoktatás céljából számos eszköz használható, de sebészeti beavatkozások esetében a műtétek filmre rögzítése a legmegfelelőbb. Célkitűzés: Vizsgálatunkban a műtéti felvételek használhatóságát kívántuk tisztázni a tájékoztatás során, a pácienseink véleménye alapján. Betegek és módszer: A szerzők 100, nőgyógyászati endoszkópia előtt álló pácienst kérdeztek meg, hogy beleegyeznek-e abba, hogy a műtétjükről felvétel készüljön. A szerkesztett felvételeket a kórházból való távozás előtt mutatták be a betegeknek, akik egyúttal egy kérdőívet is kitöltöttek. Eredmények: A csoport összes páciense beleegyezett a felvétel készítésébe, és 92 beteg kívánta a műtéti felvételt megtekinteni. A filmek átlagos hosszúsága 5 perc volt. A páciensek 88%-a gondolta úgy, hogy a felvétel megtekintése hozzásegítette őket a betegségük és a kezelés lényegének jobb megértéséhez. Összegzés: A szerkesztett filmfelvételek segíthetnek abban, hogy a páciensek megértsék a betegségük, illetve a kezelés lényegét. Annak ellenére, hogy ez egy időigényes tájékoztatási forma, a filmek segíthetnek továbbá abban is, hogy a családorvosok is tájékozódhassanak betegeik kezeléséről.