Carpentier-Edwards aortic pericardial bioprosthetic valve as a valid control in preclinical in vivo ovine studies

Multimodal preoperative imaging for transcatheter mitral valve replacement in the domestic sheep model

Preclinical in vivo evaluation is an essential step in the progression of new cardiac devices into patient use, with studies predominantly performed in the domestic sheep model. A growing area of interest in cardiac device development is transcatheter mitral valve replacement (TMVR). Clinically, multimodal imaging, or computed tomography (CT) and echocardiography (echo) are used extensively to preoperatively determine mitral valve morphology prior to an intervention, but there is no description on how these modalities can be implemented to support preclinical studies. The purpose of this study is to apply clinically relevant CT and echo acquisition and assessment techniques to a large group of naive research sheep in order to analyze and report modality-related effects on mitral valve dimensional reference intervals in the sheep model. To this end, fifty-five adult domestic sheep underwent preoperative CT and echo exams and resultant images were analyzed using a landmark-based multiplanar measurement protocol and compiled into a master dataset for statistical analysis. We found moderate agreement between CT and echo-derived measurements of the mitral valve in sheep and propose the first clinically-relevant dimensional indices for the sheep's naive mitral valve which can be used to guide future studies evaluating novel TMVR devices. This study is the first of its kind in proposing a reproducible method for detailed examination of the mitral valve in the sheep model using clinically-relevant multimodal imaging. As in patients, CT and echo can reveal accurate native mitral valve dimensions in the sheep prior to preclinical TMVR studies.

Biological Equivalence of GGTA-1 Glycosyltransferase Knockout and Standard Porcine Pericardial Tissue Using 90-Day Mitral Valve Implantation in Adolescent Sheep

Objective

There is growing interest in the application of genetically engineered reduced antigenicity animal tissue for manufacture of bioprosthetic heart valves (BHVs) to reduce antibody induced tissue calcification and accelerated structural valve degeneration (SVD). This study tested biological equivalence of valves made from Gal-knockout (GalKO) and standard porcine pericardium after 90-day mitral valve implantation in sheep.

Methods

GalKO (n = 5) and standard (n = 5) porcine pericardial BHVs were implanted in a randomized and blind fashion into sheep for 90-days. Valve haemodynamic function was measured at 30-day intervals. After explantation, valves were examined for pannus, vegetation, inflammation, thrombus, and tissue calcification.

Results

Nine of 10 recipients completed the study. There was no difference between study groups for haemodynamic performance and no adverse valve-related events. Explanted BHVs showed mild pannus integration and minimal thrombus, with no difference between the groups. Limited focal mineral deposits were detected by x-ray. Atomic spectroscopy analysis detected tissue calcium levels of 1.0 µg/mg ± 0.2 for GalKO BHVs and 1.9 µg/mg ± 0.9 for standard tissue BHVs (p = 0.4), considered to be both low and equivalent.

Conclusions

This is the first demonstration of biological equivalence between GalKO and standard pig pericardium. The GalKO mutation causes neither intrinsic detrimental biological nor functional impact on BHV performance. Commercial adaptation of GalKO tissue for surgical or transcatheter BHVs would remove the clinical disparity between patients producing anti-Gal antibody and BHVs containing the Gal antigen. GalKO BHVs may reduce accelerated tissue calcification and SVD, enhancing patient choices, especially for younger patients.

Graphical Abstract

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s13239-021-00585-0.

Establishing Background Pathologic Changes of Valve Replacement Surgery in Sheep

Purpose

Sheep are the standard preclinical model for assessing safety of novel replacement heart valves, yet the anatomic and pathologic effects of invasive surgery, including those involving cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB), are unknown. Thus, we aimed to determine the gross, hematologic and biochemical effects of sham mitral and aortic replacement valve procedures in sheep to establish a useful control for evaluation of novel replacement valves.

Methods

Six control sheep were examined without any surgical intervention. Six sham mitral valve replacements (MVR) and six sham aortic valve replacements (AVR) were performed on 12 sheep. Complete blood counts and serum biochemistry were performed throughout the study. Sheep were sacrificed with a necropsy performed at 90 days.

Results

Renal infarcts (RIs) were the most frequently observed lesion, averaging 4.7 in control sheep, 2.5 with MVR and 5.8 with AVR. The number of infarcts strongly correlated with total estimated area of infarcted kidney (r = .84, p < .01). Additional cardiac interventions were significantly correlated with increased numbers of RIs (r = .85, p < .01). There was no correlation between number of RIs and time on CPB, or between AVR and MVR procedures.

Conclusion

The sheep model for AVR and MVR requires invasive surgery and CPB, which are associated with background anatomic and pathologic changes, especially in cases with additional surgical cardiac interventions. These findings serve as a critical control for future evaluation and development of novel replacement valves in order to distinguish device-related safety issues from expected outcomes of the surgical procedure and normal background changes in sheep.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s13239-021-00563-6.

Strategies to Improve Survival from Surgery for Heart Valve Implantation in Sheep

Sheep are a commonly used and validated model for cardiovascular research and, more specifically, for heart valve research. Implanting a heart valve on the arrested heart in sheep is complex and is often complicated by difficulties in restarting the heart, causing significant on-table mortality. Therefore, optimal cardioprotective management during heart valve implantation in sheep is essential. However, little is known about successful cardioprotective management techniques in sheep. This article reports our experience in the cardioprotective management of 20 female sheep that underwent surgical aortic valve replacement with a stented tissue-engineered heart valve prosthesis. During this series of experiments, we modified our cardioprotection protocol to improve survival. We emphasize the importance of total body hypothermia and external cooling of the heart. Furthermore, we recommend repeated cardioplegia administration at 20 min intervals during surgery, with the final dosage of cardioplegia given immediately before the de-clamping of the aorta. To reduce the number of defibrillator shocks during a state of ventricular fibrillation (VF), we have learned to restart the heart by reclamping the aorta, administering cardioplegia until cardiac arrest, and de-clamping the aorta thereafter. Despite these encouraging results, more research is needed to finalize a protocol for this procedure.

New Model for the Assessment of Transcatheter Aortic Valve Replacement Devices in Sheep

BACKGROUND

Transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) is an effective therapy in treating high-risk patients suffering from aortic stenosis. Animal models used to evaluate safety and efficacy of TAVR devices prior to clinical use lack a stenotic aortic annulus, a critical impediment to long-term TAVR device evaluation. We sought to create a reproducible model of aortic stenosis using a modified aortic annuloplasty (MAA) procedure in sheep, followed by deployment and long-term evaluation of TAVR devices using this model.

METHODS

Twelve sheep underwent the MAA procedure and were recovered. Transthoracic echocardiography (TTE) was used to monitor changes in the aortic annulus in the postoperative period. At 60 days post-MAA, Test group animals were anesthetized for TAVR insertion and Control animals underwent a necropsy. Test animals were recovered following TAVR insertion and observed for a postoperative period of 140 days.

RESULTS

Twelve sheep survived the annuloplasty procedure and the 60-day recovery period. Gross examination of seven Control group animals revealed the implanted annuloplasty ring segments formed hard protrusions into the aortic annulus. Five sheep in the Test group underwent successful deployment of Abbott's experimental TAVR device without evidence of migration. Examination at 140 days post-TAVR insertion showed all devices tightly anchored within the modified aortic annulus.

CONCLUSIONS

The MAA procedure creates stenotic segments in the aortic annulus with adequate rigidity for anchorage and long-term evaluation of TAVR devices. This represents the first model that successfully mimics human aortic stenosis and provides a clinically relevant TAVR deployment platform for long-term evaluation in sheep.

Noninferiority of Shanghai Cingular biotech's bovine pericardial valve preclinical study in juvenile ovine model

BACKGROUND

This study introduces a newly Chinese domestic-designed/manufactured bovine pericardial valve, the SCBC valve (Shanghai Cingular Biotech Corporation, Shanghai, China), and evaluates its hemodynamic performance and calcification potential compared with the Carpentier-Edwards (CE) Perimount(TM) valve (Edwards Lifesciences, Irvine, CA, USA) in juvenile sheep for preclinical study.

METHODS

Five SCBC valves in study group and three CE Perimount(TM) valves (6900P with TFX) in control group were implanted in the mitral position of juvenile sheep and followed up for five months. Transthoracic echocardiography (TTE) for hemodynamic measurement was performed ten days, three months and five months postoperatively. Valve calcification was assessed by X-ray after euthanasia. Other collected data included macroscopic examination, blood analysis, microorganism culture and histological assessment.

RESULTS

All sheep in two groups lived to sacrifice without evidence of valvular dysfunction. The SCBC valve had similar hemodynamic performance and susceptibility of calcification compared with the CE Perimount(TM) valve in juvenile ovine model. In all other parameters, the SCBC valve also exhibited no significant difference compared with the CE Perimount(TM) valve.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study demonstrated that the SCBC valve can exhibit similar mid-term satisfactory safety and efficacy compared with the CE Perimount(TM) valve in the mitral position of juvenile sheep model.