Evaluation of the suitability of chromatographic systems to predict human skin permeation of neutral compounds

Ability of biomimetic chromatography and physicochemical systems to predict the skin permeation of neutral compounds. A comparison study

Five in vitro physicochemical systems have been evaluated in terms of its ability to emulate the skin permeation of neutral compounds: the permeation in two different PAMPA membranes, the classical octanol-water partition coefficient, and two biomimetic chromatography systems, one based in cerasome electrokinetic chromatography and another based in reversed-phase liquid chromatography measurements. The coefficients of the solvation parameter model equation of the mentioned systems have been compared to the ones of the skin permeation process through different comparison parameters. Moreover, a method to predict whether a physicochemical system is able to emulate satisfactorily a biological one, just by the analysis of the equation coefficients has been developed. Results reveal that the two PAMPA systems are a good choice to emulate directly the skin permeation of neutral compounds. Instead, the other three systems need a volume correction term to provide a satisfactory emulation. However, after the correction, all the evaluated systems show a similar ability to emulate well skin permeation, as predicted.

Evaluation of the Ability of PAMPA Membranes to Emulate Biological Processes through the Abraham Solvation Parameter Model

Two parallel artificial membrane permeability assay (PAMPA) systems intended for emulating skin permeability have been characterized through the solvation parameter model of Abraham using multilinear regression analysis. The coefficients of the obtained equations have been compared to the ones already established for other PAMPA membranes using statistical tools. The results indicate that both skin membranes are similar to each other in their physicochemical properties. However, they are different from other PAMPA membranes (e.g., intestinal absorption and blood-brain PAMPAs), mainly in terms of hydrophobicity and hydrogen bonding properties. Next, all PAMPA membranes have been compared to relevant biological processes also characterized through the solvation parameter model. The results highlight that skin-PAMPA membranes are a very good choice to emulate skin permeability.

Immobilized Keratin HPLC Stationary Phase-A Forgotten Model of Transdermal Absorption: To What Molecular and Biological Properties Is It Relevant?

Chromatographic retention data collected on immobilized keratin (KER) or immobilized artificial membrane (IAM) stationary phases were used to predict skin permeability coefficient (log K_p) and bioconcentration factor (log BCF) of structurally unrelated compounds. Models of both properties contained, apart from chromatographic descriptors, calculated physico-chemical parameters. The log K_p model, containing keratin-based retention factor, has slightly better statistical parameters and is in a better agreement with experimental log K_p data than the model derived from IAM chromatography; both models are applicable primarily to non-ionized compounds.Based on the multiple linear regression (MLR) analyses conducted in this study, it was concluded that immobilized keratin chromatographic support is a moderately useful tool for skin permeability assessment.However, chromatography on immobilized keratin may also be of use for a different purpose-in studies of compounds' bioconcentration in aquatic organisms.

Comparison of supercritical fluid chromatographic methods to predict the skin permeability of pharmaceutical and cosmetic compounds

Supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) was explored as an alternative for liquid chromatography to predict the skin permeability of pharmaceutical and cosmetic compounds. Nine dissimilar stationary phases were applied to screen a test set of 58 compounds. The experimental retention factors (log k), in addition to two sets of theoretical molecular descriptors, were applied to model the skin permeability coefficient. Different modelling approaches, i.e. multiple linear regression (MLR) and partial least squares (PLS) regression, were used. In general, the MLR models performed better than the PLS models for a given descriptor set. The results obtained on a cyanopropyl (CN) column provided the best correlation with the skin permeability data. The retention factors obtained on this column were included in a simple MLR model, together with the octanol-water partition coefficient and the number of atoms (r² = 0.81, RMSEC = 0.537 or 20.5% and RMSECV = 0.580 or 22.1%). The overall best MLR model included the chromatographic descriptor from a phenyl column and 18 descriptors (r² = 0.98, RMSEC = 0.167 or 6.2% and RMSECV = 0.238 or 8.9%). This model showed a good fit, on top of very good predictive features. However, stepwise MLR models with a reduced complexity could also be determined, with the best performance parameters obtained with the CN-column based retention and eight descriptors (r² = 0.95, RMSEC = 0.282 or 10.7% and RMSECV = 0.353 or 13.4%). SFC thus provides a suitable alternative to the liquid chromatographic techniques previously applied to model the skin permeability.

Recent advances for estimating environmental properties for small molecules from chromatographic measurements and the solvation parameter model

The transfer of neutral compounds between immiscible phases in chromatographic or environmental systems can be described by six solute properties (solute descriptors) using the solvation parameter model. The solute descriptors are size (McGowan's characteristic volume), V, excess molar refraction, E, dipolarity/polarizability, S, hydrogen-bond acidity and basicity, A and B, and the gas-liquid partition constant on n-hexadecane at 298.15 K, L. V and E for liquids are accessible by calculation but the other descriptors and E for solids are determined experimentally by chromatographic, liquid-liquid partition, and solubility measurements. These solute descriptors are available for several thousand compounds in the Abraham solute descriptor databases and for several hundred compounds in the WSU experimental solute descriptor database. In the first part of this review, we highlight features important in defining each descriptor, their experimental determination, compare descriptor quality for the two organized descriptor databases, and methods for estimating Abraham solute descriptors. In the second part we focus on recent applications of the solvation parameter model to characterize environmental systems and its use for the identification of surrogate chromatographic models for estimating environmental properties.

IAM Chromatographic Models of Skin Permeation

Chromatographic retention factor log k_IAM obtained from IAM HPLC chromatography with buffered aqueous mobile phases and calculated molecular descriptors (surface area—S_a; molar volume—V_M; polar surface area—PSA; count of freely rotable bonds—FRB; H-bond acceptor count—HA; energy of the highest occupied molecular orbital—E_HOMO; energy of the lowest unoccupied orbital—E_LUMO; and polarizability—α) obtained for a group of 160 structurally unrelated compounds were tested in order to generate useful models of solutes’ skin permeability coefficient log K_p. It was established that log k_IAM obtained in the conditions described in this study is not sufficient as a sole predictor of the skin permeability coefficient. Simple put, potentially useful models based on log k_IAM and readily available calculated descriptors, accounting for 85 to 91% of the total variability, were generated using Multiple Linear Regression (MLR).The models proposed in the study were tested on a group of 20 compounds with known experimental log K_p values.

Prediction of the chromatographic hydrophobicity index with immobilized artificial membrane chromatography using simple molecular descriptors and artificial neural networks

Screening of physicochemical properties should be considered one of the essential steps in the drug discovery pipeline. Among the available methods, biomimetic chromatography with an immobilized artificial membrane is a powerful tool for simulating interactions between a molecule and a biological membrane. This study developed a quantitative structure-retention relationships model that would predict the chromatographically determined affinity of xenobiotics to phospholipids, expressed as a chromatographic hydrophobicity index determined using immobilized artificial membrane chromatography. A heterogeneous set of 261 molecules, mostly showing pharmacological activity or toxicity, was analyzed chromatographically to realize this goal. The chromatographic analysis was performed using the fast gradient protocol proposed by Valko, where acetonitrile was applied as an organic modifier. Next, quantitative structure-retention relationships modeling was performed using multiple linear regression (MLR) methods and artificial neural networks (ANNs) coupled with genetic algorithm (GA)-inspired selection. Subsequently, the selection of the best ANN was supported by statistical parameters, the sum of ranking differences approach with the comparison of rank by random numbers and hierarchical cluster analysis.

Evaluating micellar liquid chromatographic methods on octadecyl particle-based and monolithic columns to predict the skin permeation of drug and cosmetic molecules

A micellar liquid chromatographic method was developed to assist in the modeling of the skin permeability of pharmaceutical and cosmetic compounds. The composition of the mobile phase was determined by means of a two-factor central composite design, after which it was tested on both a particle-based and monolithic column. The latter provided the opportunity to increase the flow rate from 1 to 8 mL/min without reaching too high backpressures. The micellar conditions allowed analyzing a large test set of compounds with diverse characteristics with just one mobile-phase composition. The obtained experimental chromatographic descriptors besides two sets of theoretical molecular descriptors were used to model the skin permeability coefficient log K_p, applying multiple linear regression and partial least squares regression approaches. The micellar method on the monolithic column provided useful models with similar or even slightly better performance parameters than the method on the particle-based column. Furthermore, a much faster analysis can be achieved when applying a flow rate of 8 mL/min, making the micellar monolithic method ideal to estimate skin permeability.

RP-18 TLC Chromatographic and Computational Study of Skin Permeability of Steroids

The skin permeability of steroids, as investigated in this study, is important because some of these compounds are, or could, be used in preparations applied topically. Several models of skin permeability, involving thin layer chromatographic and calculated descriptors, were generated and validated using K_p reference values obtained in silico and then tested on a group of solutes whose experimental K_p values could be found (log K_p^exp). The study established that the most applicable log K_p model is based on RP-18 thin layer chromatographic data (R_M) and the calculated descriptors V_M (molar volume) and PSA (polar surface area). Two less efficient, yet simple, equations based on PSA or V_M combined with HD (H-donor count) can be used with caution for rapid, rough estimations of compounds’ skin permeability prior to their chemical synthesis.

Comparison of in-silico modelling and reversed-phase liquid chromatographic retention on an octadecyl silica column to predict skin permeability of pharmaceutical and cosmetic compounds

This study focuses on the in-silico modelling of the skin permeability using a test set of pharmaceutical and cosmetic compounds. Two sets of theoretical molecular descriptors, obtained from the E-Dragon and Vega ZZ software programs, were used in the models. Different linear regression methods, i.e. Multiple Linear Regression (MLR) and Partial Least Squares (PLS) regression, were applied for modelling and estimating the skin permeability. The best model was obtained using a stepwise MLR approach on the E-Dragon descriptor set. In a second step, the retention of the test set compounds was measured on a C18 column at two pH levels: pH 5.5 and pH 7. Different organic-modifier fractions were applied in the mobile phase to be able to extrapolate the retention factors to a log k_w value, with k_w the estimated retention factor in an aqueous mobile phase without organic modifier. Thereafter it was examined whether combining this chromatographic descriptor with the theoretical descriptors could improve the modelling of the skin permeability. The chromatographic descriptor often did not show an added value compared to the models containing only theoretical descriptors. Therefore, the in-silico models were preferred, and these models could be useful to predict the skin permeability of pharmaceutical and cosmetic compounds.

Application of RP-18 TLC Retention Data to the Prediction of the Transdermal Absorption of Drugs

Several chromatographic parameters (R_M⁰ and S obtained from RP-18 TLC with methanol—pH 7.4 phosphate buffer mobile phases by extrapolation to zero concentration of methanol; R_f and R_M obtained from RP-18 TLC with acetonitrile—pH 7.4 phosphate buffer 70:30 v/v as a mobile phase) and calculated molecular descriptors (molecular weight—M_W; molar volume—V_M; polar surface area—PSA; total count of nitrogen and oxygen atoms—(N+O); H-bond donor count—HD; H-bond acceptor count—HA; distribution coefficient—log D; total energy—E_T; binding energy—E_b; hydration energy—E_h; energy of the highest occupied molecular orbital—E_HOMO; energy of the lowest unoccupied orbital—E_LUMO; electronic energy—E_e; surface area—S_a; octanol-water partition coefficient—log P; dipole moment—DM; refractivity—R, polarizability—α) and their combinations (R_f/PSA, R_M/M_W, R_M/V_M) were tested in order to generate useful models of solutes’ skin permeability coefficient log K_p. It was established that neither R_M⁰ nor S obtained in the conditions used in this study is a good predictor of the skin permeability coefficient. The chromatographic parameters R_f and R_f/PSA were also unsuitable for this purpose. A simple and potentially useful, purely computational model based on (N+O), log D and HD as independent variables and accounting for ca. 83% of total variability was obtained. The evaluation of parameters derived from R_M (R_M, R_M/M_W, R_M/V_M) as independent variables in log K_p models proved that R_M/V_M is the most suitable descriptor belonging to this group. In a search for a reliable log K_p model based on this descriptor two possibilities were considered: a relatively simple model based on 5 independent variables: (N+O), log D, R_M/V_M, E_T and E_h and a more complex one, involving also E_b, M_W and PSA.

Lipophilicity and biomimetic properties measured by HPLC to support drug discovery

HPLC methods that use chromatographic retention times for gaining information about the properties of compounds for the purpose of designing drug molecules are reviewed. Properties, such as lipophilicity, protein binding, phospholipid binding, and acid/base character can be incorporated in the design of molecules with the right biological distribution and pharmacokinetic profile to become an effective drug. Standardization of various methodologies is suggested in order to obtain data suitable for inter-laboratory comparison. The published HPLC methods for lipophilicity, acid/base character, protein and phospholipid binding are critically reviewed and compared with each other using the solvation equation approach. One of the most important discussion points is how these data can be used in models and how they can influence the drug discovery process. Therefore, the published models for volume of distribution, unbound volume of distribution and drug efficiency are also discussed. The general relationships between the chemical structure and biomimetic HPLC properties are described in view of ranking and selecting putative drug molecules.

In vitro skin models as a tool in optimization of drug formulation

(Trans)dermal drug therapy is gaining increasing importance in the modern drug development. To fully utilize the potential of this route, it is important to optimize the delivery of active ingredient/drug into/through the skin. The optimal carrier/vehicle can enhance the desired outcome of the therapy therefore the optimization of skin formulations is often included in the early stages of the product development. A rational approach in designing and optimizing skin formulations requires well-defined skin models, able to identify and evaluate the intrinsic properties of the formulation. Most of the current optimization relies on the use of suitable ex vivo animal/human models. However, increasing restrictions in use and handling of animals and human skin stimulated the search for suitable artificial skin models. This review attempts to provide an unbiased overview of the most commonly used models, with emphasis on their limitations and advantages. The choice of the most applicable in vitro model for the particular purpose should be based on the interplay between the availability, easiness of the use, cost and the respective limitations.

Recent advances in capillary electrophoretic migration techniques for pharmaceutical analysis

Since the introduction about 30 years ago, CE techniques have gained a significant impact in pharmaceutical analysis. The present review covers recent advances and applications of CE for the analysis of pharmaceuticals. Both small molecules and biomolecules such as proteins are considered. The applications range from the determination of drug-related substances to the analysis of counterions and the determination of physicochemical parameters. Furthermore, general considerations of CE methods in pharmaceutical analysis are described.