Critical Review of Large Animal Models for Central Deep Venous Thrombosis

Variation in compressive mechanical properties between subacute and chronic venous thrombosis in a novel unilateral iliac thrombosis model

Background: Interventional therapies to relieve chronic deep vein thrombosis (DVT) fail through inability to penetrate, cross, and remove the occlusion. Development of suitable tools requires fundamental understanding of chronic DVT mechanical properties and a reliable model for testing. Methods: Female farm swine underwent a novel, endovenous generation of long-segment unilateral iliac vein thrombosis. Thrombus was confirmed via venogram, intravascular ultrasound, and transabdominal duplex for 14 days. Thrombus components were quantified via histology. Thrombus mechanical properties were assessed via uniaxial compression. Results: Among seven swine, technical success was 100%. Compared to subacute thrombi (7-day), chronic thrombi (14-day) showed organizing thrombus with diffuse myointimal thickening and collagen matrix formation on histology. The thrombi collagen content was 41% versus 55% (p = 0.17) and the thrombus erythrocyte percentage was 4.3% versus 2.2%, p = 0.21 in 7- versus 14-day thrombi, respectively. The onset point (compression required to load the thrombus fiber network) was 66.6% versus 35.3% (p = 0.004), the secant modulus (resistance to deformation) measured at the onset point was 153.8 versus 275.99 kPa (p = 0.18), and the average shear constant (resistance to shearing), as defined by the Yeoh hyperelastic model, was 1.85 kPa versus 2.85 kPa in 7- versus 14-day thrombi. Conclusions: This study demonstrates the feasibility of an endovenous model generating chronic unilateral venous thrombi in 2 weeks with similar anatomy to humans and provides critical mechanical properties of thrombi for future research.

Comparison of the pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics of apixaban and rivaroxaban in dogs

BACKGROUND

Comparative pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics (PK/PD) of apixaban and rivaroxaban have not been studied in dogs and the propensity of these drugs to cause hypercoagulability after discontinuation is unknown.

HYPOTHESIS

Compare the PK/PD of clinical dosing regimens of PO apixaban and rivaroxaban administered repeatedly to healthy dogs and assess the effect of abrupt drug discontinuation on coagulation.

ANIMALS

Six University-owned, purpose-bred, middle-aged, mixed-breed dogs (4 male, 2 female).

METHODS

Dogs were given apixaban or rivaroxaban PO at 0.5 mg/kg q12h for 7 days with a 14-day washout period between drugs. Plasma drug concentrations were quantitated, and anticoagulant effects were measured using clotting times, calibrated anti-Xa bioactivity assays, and measurements of thrombin generation. The potential for rebound hypercoagulability was assessed by measuring D-dimers, thrombin-antithrombin (TAT) complexes, and antithrombin activity after drug discontinuation.

RESULTS

Plasma drug concentrations and anti-Xa bioactivities were closely correlated for both drugs, but drug concentrations varied considerably among dogs, despite consistent dose regimens. Thrombin generation variables were significantly correlated with the anti-Xa bioactivity of both drugs and no significant differences in the effects of apixaban and rivaroxaban on thrombin generation were observed. Drug discontinuation had no effect on D-dimer concentrations. The concentration of TAT complexes decreased after apixaban discontinuation and did not change after rivaroxaban discontinuation.

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL IMPORTANCE

Repeated PO administration of apixaban or rivaroxaban to healthy dogs produced comparable anticoagulant effects measured by inhibition of thrombin formation. Rebound hypercoagulability after drug discontinuation was not observed and weaning of these drugs in clinical patients might not be necessary.

Preclinical evaluation of a novel endovascular thrombectomy device in a modified swine model for iliac vein thrombosis

Objective

To evaluate the safety and efficacy of a novel endovascular thrombectomy device in a modified swine model of iliac vein thrombosis.

Methods

A modified swine model for iliac vein thrombosis was created using proximal‒distal balloon occlusion combined with autologous venous thrombus and thrombin injections. The safety and efficacy of the newly developed Zylox endovascular thrombectomy system were evaluated in this animal model and its performance was compared with that of the AcoStream aspiration thrombectomy device.

Results

Bilateral iliac vein thrombosis models were successfully created in 12 swine, with 23 iliac veins used for device testing and one for anatomical observation. The thrombus length in the Zylox group was greater than in the AcoStream group (98.42 ± 17.56 mm vs. 84.12 ± 13.30 mm), while thrombus scores were not significantly different between the two groups. Although Grade I thrombus clearance was achieved in all iliac veins in both groups, blood loss in the Zylox group was significantly less than in the AcoStream group (81.09 ± 27.26 ml vs. 162.50 ± 61.96 ml, P < 0.001). Three swine (6 iliac veins) in each group underwent repeat venography evaluations 28 days postthrombectomy, showing that all the veins were patent without any rethrombosis. Histopathologic evaluation immediately and 28 days postthrombectomy revealed no differences between the two groups. No complications or deaths occurred in the swine during the entire process.

Conclusion

The current modified swine model is stable, reproducible, and appropriate for testing endovascular devices. This study preliminarily verified the safety and efficacy of the Zylox thrombectomy system for thrombus removal in this animal model and demonstrated its advantage in controlling blood loss. Future randomized controlled trials in humans are needed to further verify the safety and efficacy of the device.

Safety Window for Effective Lesion Crossing in Patients With Chronic Thromboembolic Pulmonary Hypertension

Background

Balloon pulmonary angioplasty for chronic thromboembolic pulmonary hypertension (CTEPH) is limited by a lack of safe and effective tools for crossing these lesions. We aim to identify a safety window for an intraluminal crossing device in this vascular bed by studying the piercing properties of pulmonary arterial vessel walls and intraluminal CTEPH lesion specimens. As a secondary objective, we also describe the histopathologic features of CTEPH lesions.

Methods

Specimens were procured from 9 patients undergoing pulmonary endarterectomy. The specimens were subsampled and identified grossly as arterial wall or intraluminal CTEPH lesions. The force needed for tissue penetration was measured using a 0.38-mm (0.015-in) diameter probe in an ex vivo experimental model developed in our lab. Concurrent histology was also performed.

Results

The mean force needed to penetrate the arterial wall and intraluminal CTEPH lesions was 1.75 ± 0.10 N (n = 121) and 0.30 ± 0.04 N (n = 56), respectively (P < .001). Histology confirmed the presence of intimal hyperplasia with calcium and hemosiderin deposition in the arterial wall as well as an old, organized thrombus in the lumen.

Conclusions

The pulmonary arterial wall is friable and prone to perforation during instrumentation with workhorse coronary guide wires. However, the results of this study demonstrate that a much lower force is needed for the 0.38-mm (0.015-in) probe to penetrate an intraluminal CTEPH lesion compared to pulmonary arterial intima. This finding suggests the existence of a safety window for lesion-crossing devices, enabling effective balloon pulmonary angioplasty.

Venous thromboembolism swine model with reflux-induced venous hypertension

Objective

This study describes a novel swine model of venous thromboembolism (VTE) with reflux-induced venous hypertension.

Methods

Six pigs underwent disruption of the tricuspid chordae tendineae to create reflux and venous hypertension in the femoral vein. The vein was traumatized 2 to 3 weeks later by repeated withdrawal of a slightly overinflated occlusion balloon across the lumen, followed by balloon occlusion of the outflow. A small amount of thrombin was injected into the traumatized vein segment immediately after outflow occlusion. Thrombosis of the traumatized vein evolved into an organized thrombus seven weeks later. The histological features of the harvested post-thrombotic femoral vein were studied with hematoxylin and eosin and Trichrome stains.

Results

In all six pigs, initial disruption of the chordae tendineae was successfully performed to create tricuspid reflux and venous hypertension. After two-stage sequential procedures, a thrombus formed in the target femoral vein segment. Histology of the harvested thrombotic vein showed features of an organizing thrombus with collagen formation and fibrosis.

Conclusions

The novel swine VTE model may serve as a platform for developing and testing human-sized therapeutic procedures and devices in translational venous research.

Clinical Relevance

This study describes a swine model of VTE created by incorporating all three elements of Virchow's triad. The model uniquely incorporates reflux-induced venous hypertension, which may be used in studying venous insufficiency and VTE in those with systemic venous hypertension. Likewise, this model may serve as a platform for development and evaluation of diagnostic imaging or therapeutic procedures and devices in subjects with systemic venous hypertension.

Evaluation of a new paclitaxel-coated balloon catheter in an in vivo porcine peripheral venous model: Feasibility, safety, and drug deliverability

PURPOSE

To evaluate in vivo the feasibility, safety, and paclitaxel (PTX) deliverability of a newly developed non-commercially available Paclitaxel-Coated Balloon (PCB) catheter in the swine healthy peripheral vein model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In total 12 PCBs were deployed in 12 venous segments. Primary feasibility endpoint was the successful application of the devices to the veins of the animals. Primary efficacy endpoint was the determination of the drug content in the venous tissue at 24 h and 7 days after balloon expansion, as assessed by analysis of the vein tissue with High Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC) coupled with tandem mass spectrometry. Primary safety endpoint was freedom from any major adverse event. Secondary endpoint was the investigation of any independent factor affecting the primary endpoints.

RESULTS

Paclitaxel was detected in five out of six tissue samples 24 h post-intervention and five out of six tissues at 7 days following the procedure (10 tissue samples out of 12). The mean weight of tissue that was examined was 0.20604 ± 0.29822 g (range: 1.02823-0.03377 g) and the mean PTX concentration detected was 8.4 ± 13.1 μg/g (range: 0-36.1 μg/g). The average drug content detected at 24 h (17.1 ± 17.1 μg/g) was numerically superior, but non-statistically significant, compared to 7 days (3.1 ± 3.6 μg/g). An average of 33.8% of the drug remained on the balloon after retrieval. According to the multiple linear regression analysis, there was no significant correlation between transition time, PTX remaining on the balloon, time of analysis (24 h/7 days) and PTX tissue concentration. No abnormalities were noted during autopsy.

CONCLUSION

The newly developed PCB successfully delivered within the healthy venous wall a dose of Paclitaxel that inhibits neointimal hyperplasia. No safety issues were raised at short-term follow-up.

Comparison between canine and porcine models of chronic deep venous thrombosis

OBJECTIVE

To first induce chronic deep venous thrombosis in the left iliac veins of canines and porcines and then compare these two models to validate endovascular treatment devices.

METHODS

Thrombin and fibrinogen were used to produce a solid thrombus in the left iliac veins of a stenosis model. The researchers used venous angiography and histological staining to investigate the progression of thrombosis.

RESULTS

A left iliac vein thrombus was successfully formed in all experimental animals, including six Labrador dogs and three Bama miniature pigs, and there was minimal surgical bleeding. All dogs survived until 90 days, and three pigs died on Days 29, 33, and 58.

CONCLUSION

The researchers first established the models and then observed the progression of chronic deep venous thrombosis of the iliac vein in large animals for up to 90 days. Dogs are better suited for chronic deep venous thrombosis models due to their uncomplicated anatomy, excellent obedience, and proneness to physical activity compared with pigs.

Venous congestion affects neuromuscular changes in pigs in terms of muscle electrical activity and muscle stiffness

Early detection of venous congestion (VC)-related diseases such as deep vein thrombosis (DVT) is important to prevent irreversible or serious pathological conditions. However, the current way of diagnosing DVT is only possible after recognizing advanced DVT symptoms such as swelling, pain, and tightness in affected extremities, which may be due to the lack of information on neuromechanical changes following VC. Thus, the goal of this study was to investigate acute neuromechanical changes in muscle electrical activity and muscle stiffness when VC was induced. The eight pigs were selected and the change of muscle stiffness from the acceleration and muscle activity in terms of integral electromyography (IEMG) was investigated in three VC stages. Consequently, we discovered a significant increase in the change in muscle stiffness and IEMG from the baseline to the VC stages (p < 0.05). Our results and approach can enable early detection of pathological conditions associated with VC, which can be a basis for further developing early diagnostic tools for detecting VC-related diseases.

Endovascular Porcine Model of Iliocaval Venous Thrombosis

OBJECTIVE

To develop a large animal model of iliocaval deep venous thrombosis (DVT), which enables development and evaluation of interventional management and existing imaging modalities.

METHODS

The experimental protocol consisted of a total endovascular approach. Pigs were percutaneously accessed through the right internal jugular and bilateral femoral veins. Three balloon catheters were inflated to induce venous stasis in the infrarenal inferior vena cava (IVC) and bilateral common iliac veins (CIVs). Hypercoagulability was induced by injecting 10 000 IU of thrombin. After 2.5 hours, the balloon catheters were removed before animal recovery. After seven, 14, 21, 28, or 35 days, animals were euthanised; the IVC and CIV were harvested en bloc, cross sectioned and prepared for histological examination. Multimodal imaging was performed before and after thrombus creation, and before animal euthanasia.

RESULTS

Thirteen female domestic pigs with a mean weight of 59.3 kilograms were used. The mean maximum IVC diameter and area were 16.4 mm and 1.2 cm², respectively. The procedure was successful in 12 animals with occlusive venous thrombosis in the region of interest on immediate post-operative magnetic resonance venography and a mean thrombus volume of 19.8 cm³. Clinical pathology results showed platelet consumption, D dimer increase, and inflammatory response. Histological evaluation demonstrated a red cell, fibrin, and platelet rich thrombus on day 1, with progressive inflammatory cell infiltration from day 7. Collagen deposition appeared in week 2 and neovascularisation in week 3.

CONCLUSION

Endovascular occlusion combined with thrombin infusion is a reliable minimally invasive approach to produce acute and subacute DVT in a large animal model.

Endovascular Venous Stenosis and Thrombosis Large Animal Model: angiographic, histological, and biomechanical characterization

PURPOSE

Characterize an ovine endovascular radiofrequency ablation based venous stenosis and thrombosis model for studying venous biomechanics and response to intervention.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Unilateral short-segment (n= 2) or long-segment (n = 6) iliac vein stenoses were created in eight adult sheep using an endovenous radiofrequency (RF) ablation technique. Angiographic assessment was performed at baseline, immediately after venous stenosis creation, and after 2-week (n = 6) or 3-month (n = 2) survival. Stenosed iliac veins and contralateral healthy controls were harvested for histological and biomechanical assessment.

RESULTS

At follow-up, the short-segment RF ablation group showed stable stenosis without occlusion. The long-segment group showed complete venous occlusion/thrombosis with formation of collateral veins. Stenosed veins showed significant wall thickening (0.28 mm vs 0.16 mm; p = 0.0175) and confluent collagen deposition compared to healthy controls. Subacute non-adherent thrombi were apparent at 2 weeks, which were replaced by fibrous luminal obliteration with channels of recanalization at 3 months. Stenosed veins demonstrated increased longitudinal stiffness (448.5 ± 5.4 kPa vs. 314.6 ± 1.5 kPa, p < 0.0001) and decreased circumferential stiffness (140.8 ± 2.6 kPa vs. 246.0 ± 1.6 kPa, p < 0.0001) compared to healthy controls.

CONCLUSION

Endovenous radiofrequency ablation is a reliable technique for creating venous stenosis and thrombosis in a large animal model with histological and biomechanical attributes similar to those seen in humans. This platform can facilitate understanding of venous biomechanics and testing of venous specific devices and interventions.