An often-overestimated adverse effect of halides in heat/persulfate-based degradation of wastewater contaminants

Unique effect of bromide ion on intensification of advanced oxidation processes for pollutants removal: A systematic review

Advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) have been developed to decompose toxic pollutants to protect the aquatic environment. AOP has been considered an alternative treatment method for wastewater treatment. Bromine is present in natural waters posing toxic effects on human health and hence, its removal from drinking water sources is necessary. Of the many techniques advanced oxidation is covered in this review. This review systematically examines literature published from 1997 to April 2024, sourced from Scopus, PubMed, Science Direct, and Web of Science databases, focusing on the efficacy of AOPs for pollutant removal from aqueous solutions containing bromide ions to investigate the impact of bromide ions on AOPs. Data and information extracted from each article eligible for inclusion in the review include the type of AOP, type of pollutants, and removal efficiency of AOP under the presence and absence of bromide ion. Of the 1784 documents screened, 90 studies met inclusion criteria, providing insights into various AOPs, including UV/chlorine, UV/PS, UV/H2O2, UV/catalyst, and visible light/catalyst processes. The observed impact of bromide ion presence on the efficacy of AOP processes, alongside the AOP method under scrutiny, is contingent upon various factors such as the nature of the target pollutant, catalyst type, and bromide ion concentration. These considerations are crucial in selecting the best method for removing specific pollutants under defined conditions. Challenges were encountered during result analysis included variations in experimental setups, disparities in pollutant types and concentrations, and inconsistencies in reporting AOP performance metrics. Addressing these parameters in research reports will enhance the coherence and utility of subsequent systematic reviews.

Applications and synergistic degradation mechanisms of nZVI-modified biochar for the remediation of organic polluted soil and water: A review

Increasing organic pollution in soil and water has garnered considerable attention in recent years. Nano zero-valent iron-modified biochar (nZVI/BC) has been proven to remediate the contaminated environment effectively due to its abundant active sites and unique reducing properties. This paper provides a comprehensive overview of the application of nZVI/BC in organic polluted environmental remediation and its mechanisms. Firstly, the review introduced primary synthetic methods of nZVI/BC, including in-situ synthesis (carbothermal reduction and green synthesis) and post-modification (liquid-phase reduction and ball milling). Secondly, the application effects of nZVI/BC were discussed in remediating soil and water polluted by antibiotics, pesticides, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), and dyes. Thirdly, this review explored the mechanisms of the adsorption and chemical degradation of nZVI/BC, and synergistic degradation mechanisms of nZVI/BC-AOPs and nZVI/BC-Microbial interactions. Fourth, the factors that influence the removal of organic pollutants using nZVI/BC were summarized, encompassing synthesis conditions (raw materials, pyrolysis temperature and aging of nZVI/BC) and external factors (reagent dosage, pH, and coexisting substances). Finally, this review proposed future challenges for the application of nZVI/BC in environmental remediation. This review offers valuable insights for advancing technology in the degradation of organic pollutants using nZVI/BC and promoting its on-site application.

Co-Mn-Fe spinel-carbon composite catalysts enhanced persulfate activation for degradation of neonicotinoid insecticides: (Non) radical path identification, degradation pathway and toxicity analysis

The extensive utilization of neonicotinoid insecticides (NNIs) in agricultural practices ultimately poses a significant threat to both the environment and human health. This work focuses on the efficient degradation and detoxification of the representative NNI, thiamethoxam (THX), and explores the underlying mechanism using a Co-Fe-Mn mixed spinel doped carbon composite catalyst activated persulfate. The findings demonstrate that the composite effectively degrades THX, achieving a degradation rate of 95% in 30 mins, while requiring only a fraction (one-sixteenth) of the oxidant dosage compared to pure carbon. The study aimed to examine the negative impact of reactive halogens on reactive oxygen species within a saline environment. The degradation byproducts were linked to the presence of two common electron-withdrawing groups, namely halogens and nitro in the THX molecule. It was hypothesized that the degradation process was primarily influenced by C-N bond breaking and hydroxylation occurring between the diazine oxide and 2-chlorothiazole rings. Consequently, dehalogenation and carbonylation processes facilitated the elimination of halogenated components and pharmacophores from the THX, leading to detoxification. In addition to the identified free radical pathway including SO4•-, •OH and O2•- contributed to THX degradation, the participation of non-radical pathways (1O2 and electron transfer) were also confirmed. The efficacy of detoxification was further validated through toxicity assessment, employing quantitative conformation relationship prediction and microbial culture utilizing Bacillus subtilis.

Degradation of antiviral drug acyclovir by thermal activated persulfate process: Kinetics study and modeling

Pharmaceutical and personal care products (PPCPs) pose a great threat to water environment security. In this study, acyclovir (ACV) was efficiently degraded by thermally activated persulfate (TAP) system. The ACV degradation increased with rising reaction temperature and persulfate dosage. With the existence of inorganic anions and humic acid, ACV removal was retarded to varying degrees. Under strong alkaline condition, it was observed that the degradation of ACV was significantly inhibited. In addition, Kintecus software was employed to simulate ACV removal and achieved a good fit with the experimental results. The contribution rates of main reactive radicals under acidic, neutral, and alkaline conditions were investigated, and the contribution of hydroxyl radical (⋅OH) increased significantly under alkaline condition. The main active species were identified as sulfate radical (SO₄⋅^-) and ⋅OH through quenching experiment, and the second-order reaction rate constants of SO₄⋅^- and ∙OH reacted with ACV were calculated to be 9.17 × 10⁹ M^-1 s^-1 and 2.74 × 10⁹ M^-1 s^-1, respectively. The main degradation pathways included addition of free radicals, oxidation of branch chain and ring opening. The acute and chronic toxicity of intermediates to organisms predicted by ECOSAR were significantly reduced compared with that of ACV.

Overlooked Cytotoxicity and Genotoxicity to Mammalian Cells Caused by the Oxidant Peroxymonosulfate during Wastewater Treatment Compared with the Sulfate Radical-Based Ultraviolet/Peroxymonosulfate Process

Byproduct formation (chlorate, bromate, organic halogen, etc.) during sulfate radical (SO₄^•-)-based processes like ultraviolet/peroxymonosulfate (UV/PMS) has aroused widespread concern. However, hypohalous acid (HOCl and HOBr) can form via two-electron transfer directly from PMS, thus leading to the formation of organic halogenated byproducts as well. This study found both PMS alone and UV/PMS can increase the toxicity to mammalian cells of wastewater, while the UV/H₂O₂ decreased the toxicity. Cytotoxicity of two wastewater samples increased from 5.6-8.3 to 15.7-29.9 mg-phenol/L, and genotoxicity increased from 2.8-3.1 to 5.8-12.8 μg 4-NQO/L after PMS treatment because of organic halogen formation. Organic halogen formation from bromide rather than chloride was found to dominate the toxicity increase. The SO₄^•--based process UV/PMS led to the formation of both organic halogen and inorganic bromate and chlorate. However, because of the very low concentration (<20 μg/L) and relatively low toxicity of bromate and chlorate, contributions of inorganic byproducts to toxicity increase were negligible. PMS would not form chlorate and bromate, but it generated a higher concentration of total organic halogen, thus leading to a more toxic treated wastewater than UV/PMS. UV/PMS formed less organic halogen and toxicity because of the destruction of byproducts by UV irradiation and the removal of byproduct precursors. Currently, many studies focused on the byproducts bromate and chlorate during SO₄^•--based oxidation processes. This work revealed that the oxidant PMS even needs more attention because it caused higher toxicity due to more organic halogen formation.

The journey of toluene to complete mineralization via heat-activated peroxydisulfate in water: intermediates analyses, CO2 monitoring, and carbon mass balance

Our study has thoroughly investigated the complete mineralization of toluene in water via heat-activated peroxydisulfate (PDS) by: (1) monitoring concentrations/peak areas of various intermediates and CO₂ throughout the reaction period and (2) identifying water-soluble and methanol-soluble intermediates, including trimers, dimers, and organo-sulfur compounds, via non-target screening using high-resolution mass spectrometry. Increased temperature and PDS dosage enhanced toluene removal/mineralization kinetics and increased the rate/extent of benzaldehyde formation and its further transformation. Artificial groundwater and phosphate buffer minimally impacted toluene removal but significantly decreased benzaldehyde formation, indicating a shift in transformation pathways. The stoichiometric PDS dose (18 mM at 40 °C) was adequate to completely mineralize toluene (1 mM), with < 10% PDS needed to transform toluene to intermediates. Toluene transformation to intermediates occurred in 47 h (k_obs,toluene = 0.594 h^-1) whereas 564 h were required for complete mineralization (k_obs,CO2 = 0.0038 h^-1). O₂ accumulated once mineralization neared completion. A carbon mass balance, including quantification of nine intermediates and CO₂ throughout the transformation period, showed that unquantified/unknown intermediates (including yellowish-white precipitates) reached as high as 80% of total carbon before transformation to CO₂. Possible toluene transformation pathways via hydroxylation, sulfate addition, and oxidative coupling are proposed.

Ultraviolet light-activated peroxymonosulfate (UV/PMS) system for humic acid mineralization: Effects of ionic matrix and feasible application in seawater reverse osmosis desalination

The use of membrane-based technology has evolved into an important strategy for supplying freshwater from seawater and wastewater to overcome the problems of water scarcity around the world. However, the presence of natural organic matter (NOM), including humic substances affects the performance of the process. Here, we present a systematic report on the mineralization of humic acid (HA), as a model for NOM, in high concentration of salts using the ultraviolet light-activated peroxymonosulfate (UV/PMS) system as a potential alternative for HA elimination during membrane-based seawater desalination and water treatment processes. Effects of various parameters such as PMS concentration, solution type, pH, anions, and anion-cation matrix on HA mineralization were assessed. The results show that 100%, 78% and 58% of HA (2 mg/L TOC) were mineralized with rate constants of 0.085 min^-1, 0.0073 min^-1, and 0.0041 min^-1 after 180 min reaction time at pH 7 when 0.5 mM PMS was used in deionized water, sodium chloride solution (35,000 ppm) and synthetic seawater, respectively. The reduced efficiency under saline conditions was attributed to the presence of anions in the system that acted as sulfate and hydroxyl radicals' scavengers. Furthermore, the safety of the treated synthetic seawater was evaluated by analyzing the residual transformed products. Overall, pretreatment with the UV/PMS system mitigated fouling on the RO membrane.

Misconceptions about the Chemistry of Aqueous Chlorine Atoms and HClOH•(aq), and a Revised Mechanism for the Photochemical Peroxydisulfate/Chloride Reaction

It is widely considered that aqueous chlorine atoms (Cl•) convert to the species HClOH• with a half life of about 3 µs and that this species plays an important role...

A comprehensive kinetic model for phenol oxidation in seven advanced oxidation processes and considering the effects of halides and carbonate

As one of the most powerful approaches to mechanistically understanding complex chemical reactions and performing simulations or predictions, kinetic modeling has been widely used to investigate advanced oxidation processes (AOPs). However, most of the available models are built based on limited systems or reaction mechanisms so they cannot be readily extended to other systems or reaction conditions. To overcome such limitations, this study developed a comprehensive model on phenol oxidation using over 540 reactions, covering the most common reaction mechanisms in nine AOPs-four peroxymonosulfate (PMS), four peroxydisulfate (PDS), and one H₂O₂ systems-and considering product formation and the effects of co-existing anions (chloride, bromide, and carbonate). Existing models in the literature were first gathered and then revised by correcting inaccurately used reactions and adding other necessary reactions. Extensive model tuning and validation were next conducted by fitting the model against experimental data from both this study and the literature. The effects of anions were found to follow PDS/CuO > H₂O₂/UV > other PDS or PMS systems. Halogenated organic byproducts were mainly observed in the PMS systems in the presence of halides. Most of the 543 reactions were found to be important based on the sensitivity analysis, with some anions-involved reactions being among the most important, which explained why these anions substantially altered some of the reaction systems. With this comprehensive model, a deep understanding and reliable prediction can be made for the oxidation of phenol (and likely other phenolic compounds) in systems containing one or more of the above AOPs.

A combined radical and non-radical oxidation processes for efficient degradation of Acid Orange 7 in the homogeneous Cu(II)/PMS system: important role of chloride

Trace copper ion (Cu(II)) in water and wastewater can trigger peroxymonosulfate (PMS) activation to oxidize organic compounds, but it only works under alkaline conditions. In this work, we found that the presence of chloride could significantly accelerate the oxidation of Acid Orange 7 (AO7) by the Cu(II)/PMS process at a wide pH range (4.0-9.0). The observed pseudo-first-order rate constant k for AO7 oxidation was linearly correlated with the increased Cl^- concentration (0-300 mM). An increase in mineralization rate was observed in the presence of Cl^-, while the overall mineralization was quite low. Decomposition of PMS facilitated when Cl^- concentration or pH value increased. Based on the scavenger experiments and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) measurement, the mechanism of Cu(II)-catalyzed PMS oxidation process in the presence of Cl^- was proposed as both the radical and non-radical pathway, and ¹O₂ was the reactive oxygen species in the Cu(II)/PMS system. Finally, a possible degradation pathway of AO7 was elucidated. The feasibility of in situ utilizing high salinity and trace cupric species to accelerate the degradation of organic pollutants by the Cu(II)/PMS process in water and wastewater was demonstrated. However, the identification of undesired chlorinated by-products reminds us of cautiousness in assessing the application of Cu(II)/PMS system under chloride-rich environment. The findings of this work provide a simple and efficient approach to apply PMS in the remediation of refractory organic contaminants in the presence of trace cupric species under a high salinity environment with a wide range of pH.

Degradation and chlorination mechanism of fumaric acid based on SO4•-: an experimental and theoretical study

It is well known that chloride ions could affect the oxidation kinetics and mechanism of contaminant based on SO₄^•- in the wastewater. Here, the degradation of an organic acid, fumaric acid (FA), was investigated in the presence of chloride (0-300 mM) by the Fe(II)/peroxymonosulfate (Fe(II)/PMS) system. A negative impact of chloride was observed on the rates of FA degradation. The degree of inhibitory effect was higher in Fe(II)/PMS addition order. Some chlorinated byproducts were identified during the FA oxidation process in the presence of Cl^- by the ultraperformance liquid chromatography and quadrupole-time of flight mass spectrometer (UPLC-QTOF-MS). With the increasing content of Cl^-, an accumulation of adsorbable organic halogen (AOX), an increase in acute toxicity, and an inhibition of mineralization were observed. According to the results of kinetic modeling, the production and transformation of oxidative species were dependent on Cl^- dosage and reaction time. SO₄^•- was supposed to be the main radical for FA degradation with Cl^- concentration below 5 mM, whereas Cl₂^•- was primarily responsible for the depletion of FA at [Cl^-] > 5 mM. A possible degradation pathway of FA was discussed. This study reveals the potential environmental risk of organic acid and is necessary to explore useful strategies for ameliorating the treatment of chloride-rich wastewater.

Abiotic oxidation of arsenite in natural and engineered systems: Mechanisms and related controversies over the last two decades (1999-2020)

Abiotic oxidation of toxic As(III) to As(V) is being deemed as a necessary step for the overall arsenic decontamination in both natural and engineered systems. Direct oxidation of As(III) by chemical oxidants, such as ozone, permanganate, ferrate, chlorine and chloramine, or naturally occurring minerals like Mn, Fe oxides, seems straightforward. Both O₂ and H₂O₂ are ineffective for arsenite oxidation, but they can be activated by reducing substances like Fe²⁺, Fe⁰ to increase the oxidation rates. Photo-induced oxidation of As(III) has been demonstrated effective in Fe complexes or minerals, NO₃^-/NO₂^-, dissolved organic matter (DOM), peroxygens and TiO₂ systems. Although a variety of oxidation methods have been developed over the past two decades, there remain many scientific and technical challenges that must be overcome before the rapid progress in basic knowledge can be translated into environmental benefits. To better understand the trends in the existing data and to identify the knowledge gaps, this review describes in detail the complicated mechanisms for As(III) oxidation by various methods and emphasizes on the conflicting data and explanation. Some prevailing concerns and challenges in the sphere of As(III) oxidation are also pointed out so as to appeal to researchers for further investigations.

Electron-transfer-dominated non-radical activation of peroxydisulfate for efficient removal of chlorophenol contaminants by one-pot synthesized nitrogen and sulfur codoped mesoporous carbon

Synergistic adsorption and oxidative degradation (via persulfate activation) on metal-free carbonaceous materials are expected to be environmentally friendly and highly efficient approach toward contaminants removal. Herein, nitrogen and sulfur codoped mesoporous carbon (NSDMC) were firstly synthesized via co-carbonization of calcium citrate and thiourea without any templates. NSDMC samples exhibit remarkably enhanced adsorption capacity and oxidative degradation (by activating PDS) for chlorophenols elimination. Increased S_BET and introduced N-containing functional groups are beneficial for chlorophenols adsorption, PDS accessibility and successive activation. Doped sulfur species (especially for thiophenic S) can enhance the electron-transport performance of NSDMC, further promoting PDS activation and chlorophenols degradation. It can be ascribed to the synergistic effect of N and S codoping. NSDMC-30 (containing 5.83 at.% nitrogen and 2.15 at.% sulfur, and possessing S_BET of 1935.9 m² g^-1) exhibits the optimal adsorption and catalytic oxidation capability for 4-CP removal. Degradation rate constant of NSDMC-30 is 0.125 min^-1, which is 3.0 times and 7.8 times higher than nitrogen-doped MC and pristine MC, respectively. Radicals quenching experiments and EPR tests demonstrate that non-radical pathways play dominant role for PDS activation and chlorophenols degradation. Based on the influences of catalyst loading, initial 4-CP concentration, and PDS dosage on degradation kinetics of 4-CP, the pre-adsorption is unveiled to be the critical step determining oxidation rate of chlorophenols. More importantly, the results of in-situ Raman and electrochemical tests show that the surface-confined and activated PDS complex (carbon-PDS*) and continuous electron transfer from co-adsorbed 4-CP are mainly responsible for the oxidative degradation of chlorophenols. The intermediate products and TOC removal indicate that chlorophenols can be efficiently degraded and mineralized by as-synthesized NSDMC via activating PDS. Besides, the present NSDMC/PDS system is also applicable for purification of actual polluted water samples. This work provides in-depth knowledge of carbon-driven nonradical process for PDS activation and contaminants remediation.

Physico-chemical processes

By summarizing 187 relevant research articles published in 2019, the review is focused on the research progress of physicochemical processes for wastewater treatment. This review divides into two sections, physical processes and chemical processes. The physical processes section includes three sub-sections, that is, adsorption, granular filtration, and dissolved air flotation, whereas the chemical processes section has five sub-sections, that is, coagulation/flocculation, advanced oxidation processes, electrochemical, capacitive deionization, and ion exchange. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Totally 187 research articles on wastewater treatment have been reviewed and discussed. The review has two major sections with eight sub-topics.