Nonsense mutations in the rhodopsin gene that give rise to mild phenotypes trigger mRNA degradation in human cells by nonsense-mediated decay

Mutation analysis of RHO in patients with non-syndromic retinitis pigmentosa

PURPOSE

To identify RHO mutations in patients with non-syndromic retinitis pigmentosa (NS-RP).

METHODS

A total of 143 probands (46 family history and 97 sporadic cases) with NS-RP were recruited from Southeast China. The coding exons and adjacent intronic regions of RHO were PCR-amplified and sequenced by Sanger sequencing. The candidate variant was evaluated by the guidelines of American College of Medical Genetics and further validated through co-segregation analysis within the family.

RESULTS

Five heterozygous mutations in RHO were detected in 5 out of 143 probands, where the frequency of RHO mutations in our cohort was approximately 3.5% (5/143) and 10.8% (5/46) for probands and families with NS-RP, respectively. Three known disease-causing mutations including c.C1030T (p.Q344X), c.C173G (p.T58R), and c.G266A (p.G89D) were identified in three unrelated families. The other two previously unreported mutations c.557C>A (p.S186X) and c.944delA (p.N315TfsX43) were confirmed in Family RP-087 and Family RP-139, respectively. These mutations co-segregated with available affected individuals in each family were not observed in the unaffected family members or in the 112 unrelated controls.

CONCLUSIONS

This report expands the mutational spectrum of RHO gene associated with NS-RP and demonstrates the frequency of RP RHO mutations in Southeast Chinese populations.

Exome sequencing in retinal dystrophy patients reveals a novel candidate gene ER membrane protein complex subunit 3

Inherited retinal dystrophies (IRDs) are a heterogeneous group of visual disorders caused by different pathogenic mutations in genes and regulatory sequences. The endoplasmic reticulum (ER) membrane protein complex (EMC) subunit 3 (EMC3) is the core unit of the EMC insertase that integrates the transmembrane peptides into lipid bilayers, and the function of its cytoplasmic carboxyl terminus remains to be elucidated. In this study, an insertional mutation c.768insT in the C-terminal coding region of EMC3 was identified and associated with dominant IRDs in a five-generation family. This mutation caused a frameshift in the coding sequence and a gain of an additional 16 amino acid residues (p.L256F-fs-ext21) to form a helix structure in the C-terminus of the EMC3 protein. The mutation is heterozygous with an incomplete penetrance, and cosegregates in all patients examined. This finding indicates that the C-terminus of EMC3 is essential for EMC functions and that EMC3 may be a novel candidate gene for retinal degenerative diseases.

Genotype and phenotype characteristics of RHO-associated retinitis pigmentosa in the Japanese population

PURPOSE

To identify the genotypic and phenotypic characteristics of rhodopsin (RHO)-associated retinitis pigmentosa (RP) in the Japanese population.

STUDY DESIGN

Cross-sectional, single-center study METHODS: The medical records of 1336 patients with RP who underwent genetic testing at our clinic between November 2008 and September 2021 were reviewed, and patients with RHO variants were included. The patients were divided into class A and class B to assess genotype-phenotype correlations based on previous reports. The clinical findings, including best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA), OCT parameters (ellipsoid zone [EZ] width and central retinal thickness [CRT]), and presence of macular degeneration, of the 2 groups were compared.

RESULTS

The study included 28 patients diagnosed with RHO-associated RP (class A, 19; class B, 9). The BCVA was significantly worse in class A patients than in class B patients (P = 0.045). Superior EZ width was significantly shorter in class A than in class B patients (P = 0.016). Class A patients tended to have thinner CRT and shorter inferior EZ width than those of class B patients, although this difference was not significant. Macular degeneration was observed in 61.5% of class A and 12.5% of class B patients, demonstrating that macular degeneration can be a common complication in class A variants.

CONCLUSION

Patients with class A variants presented with a severer form of RP than that of patients with class B variants in the Japanese population. These results suggest that the phenotype of RHO-associated RP is linked to the location of the variants and that such a genotype-phenotype correlation is less affected by ethnicities with different genetic backgrounds.

Retinitis Pigmentosa: Novel Therapeutic Targets and Drug Development

Retinitis pigmentosa (RP) is a heterogeneous group of hereditary diseases characterized by progressive degeneration of retinal photoreceptors leading to progressive visual decline. It is the most common type of inherited retinal dystrophy and has a high burden on both patients and society. This condition causes gradual loss of vision, with its typical manifestations including nyctalopia, concentric visual field loss, and ultimately bilateral central vision loss. It is one of the leading causes of visual disability and blindness in people under 60 years old and affects over 1.5 million people worldwide. There is currently no curative treatment for people with RP, and only a small group of patients with confirmed RPE65 mutations are eligible to receive the only gene therapy on the market: voretigene neparvovec. The current therapeutic armamentarium is limited to retinoids, vitamin A supplements, protection from sunlight, visual aids, and medical and surgical interventions to treat ophthalmic comorbidities, which only aim to slow down the progression of the disease. Considering such a limited therapeutic landscape, there is an urgent need for developing new and individualized therapeutic modalities targeting retinal degeneration. Although the heterogeneity of gene mutations involved in RP makes its target treatment development difficult, recent fundamental studies showed promising progress in elucidation of the photoreceptor degeneration mechanism. The discovery of novel molecule therapeutics that can selectively target specific receptors or specific pathways will serve as a solid foundation for advanced drug development. This article is a review of recent progress in novel treatment of RP focusing on preclinical stage fundamental research on molecular targets, which will serve as a starting point for advanced drug development. We will review the alterations in the molecular pathways involved in the development of RP, mainly those regarding endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress and apoptotic pathways, maintenance of the redox balance, and genomic stability. We will then discuss the therapeutic approaches under development, such as gene and cell therapy, as well as the recent literature identifying novel potential drug targets for RP.

Genetic dissection of non-syndromic retinitis pigmentosa

Retinitis pigmentosa (RP) belongs to a group of pigmentary retinopathies. It is the most common form of inherited retinal dystrophy, characterized by progressive degradation of photoreceptors that leads to nyctalopia, and ultimately, complete vision loss. RP is distinguished by the continuous retinal degeneration that progresses from the mid-periphery to the central and peripheral retina. RP was first described and named by Franciscus Cornelius Donders in the year 1857. It is one of the leading causes of bilateral blindness in adults, with an incidence of 1 in 3000 people worldwide. In this review, we are going to focus on the genetic heterogeneity of this disease, which is provided by various inheritance patterns, numerosity of variations and inter-/intra-familial variations based upon penetrance and expressivity. Although over 90 genes have been identified in RP patients, the genetic cause of approximately 50% of RP cases remains unknown. Heterogeneity of RP makes it an extremely complicated ocular impairment. It is so complicated that it is known as “fever of unknown origin”. For prognosis and proper management of the disease, it is necessary to understand its genetic heterogeneity so that each phenotype related to the various genetic variations could be treated.

Tritan color vision deficiency may be associated with an OPN1SW splicing defect and haploinsufficiency

Here we present evidence implicating disrupted RNA splicing as a potential cause of inherited tritan color vision. Initially we tested 51 subjects for color vision deficiencies. One made significant tritan errors; the others were classified as normal trichromats. The putative tritan subject was the only one of the 51 subjects found to be heterozygous for an OPN1SW gene mutation that disrupts RNA splicing in an in vitro assay. In order to gather further support for the role of the splicing mutation in tritan color vision, the putative tritan subject's mother and sister were examined. They also made tritan errors and had the same OPN1SW gene mutation.

Characterizing variants of unknown significance in rhodopsin: A functional genomics approach

Characterizing the pathogenicity of DNA sequence variants of unknown significance (VUS) is a major bottleneck in human genetics, and is increasingly important in determining which patients with inherited retinal diseases could benefit from gene therapy. A library of 210 rhodopsin (RHO) variants from literature and in‐house genetic diagnostic testing were created to efficiently detect pathogenic RHO variants that fail to express on the cell surface. This study, while focused on RHO, demonstrates a streamlined, generalizable method for detecting pathogenic VUS. A relatively simple next‐generation sequencing‐based readout was developed so that a flow cytometry‐based assay could be performed simultaneously on all variants in a pooled format, without the need for barcodes or viral transduction. The resulting dataset characterized the surface expression of every RHO library variant with a high degree of reproducibility (r² = 0.92–0.95), recategorizing 37 variants. For example, three retinitis pigmentosa pedigrees were solved by identifying VUS which showed low expression levels (p.G18D, p.G101V, and p.P180T). Results were validated across multiple assays and correlated with clinical disease severity. This study presents a parallelized, higher‐throughput cell‐based assay for the functional characterization of VUS in RHO, and can be applied more broadly to other inherited retinal disease genes and other disorders.

Cas9/sgRNA selective targeting of the P23H Rhodopsin mutant allele for treating retinitis pigmentosa by intravitreal AAV9.PHP.B-based delivery

P23H is the most common mutation in the RHODOPSIN (RHO) gene leading to a dominant form of retinitis pigmentosa (RP), a rod photoreceptor degeneration that invariably causes vision loss. Specific disruption of the disease P23H RHO mutant while preserving the wild-type (WT) functional allele would be an invaluable therapy for this disease. However, various technologies tested in the past failed to achieve effective changes and consequently therapeutic benefits. We validated a CRISPR/Cas9 strategy to specifically inactivate the P23H RHO mutant, while preserving the WT allele in vitro. We, then, translated this approach in vivo by delivering the CRISPR/Cas9 components in murine Rho+/P23H mutant retinae. Targeted retinae presented a high rate of cleavage in the P23H but not WT Rho allele. This gene manipulation was sufficient to slow photoreceptor degeneration and improve retinal functions. To improve the translational potential of our approach, we tested intravitreal delivery of this system by means of adeno-associated viruses (AAVs). To this purpose, the employment of the AAV9-PHP.B resulted the most effective in disrupting the P23H Rho mutant. Finally, this approach was translated successfully in human cells engineered with the homozygous P23H RHO gene mutation. Overall, this is a significant proof-of-concept that gene allele specific targeting by CRISPR/Cas9 technology is specific and efficient and represents an unprecedented tool for treating RP and more broadly dominant genetic human disorders affecting the eye, as well as other tissues.

The molecular and cellular basis of rhodopsin retinitis pigmentosa reveals potential strategies for therapy

Inherited mutations in the rod visual pigment, rhodopsin, cause the degenerative blinding condition, retinitis pigmentosa (RP). Over 150 different mutations in rhodopsin have been identified and, collectively, they are the most common cause of autosomal dominant RP (adRP). Mutations in rhodopsin are also associated with dominant congenital stationary night blindness (adCSNB) and, less frequently, recessive RP (arRP). Recessive RP is usually associated with loss of rhodopsin function, whereas the dominant conditions are a consequence of gain of function and/or dominant negative activity. The in-depth characterisation of many rhodopsin mutations has revealed that there are distinct consequences on the protein structure and function associated with different mutations. Here we categorise rhodopsin mutations into seven discrete classes; with defects ranging from misfolding and disruption of proteostasis, through mislocalisation and disrupted intracellular traffic to instability and altered function. Rhodopsin adRP offers a unique paradigm to understand how disturbances in photoreceptor homeostasis can lead to neuronal cell death. Furthermore, a wide range of therapies have been tested in rhodopsin RP, from gene therapy and gene editing to pharmacological interventions. The understanding of the disease mechanisms associated with rhodopsin RP and the development of targeted therapies offer the potential of treatment for this currently untreatable neurodegeneration.

Das Überlesen von Nonsense-Mutationen

Nonsense-Mutationen weisen eine Inzidenz von etwa 12 % bezogen auf alle krankheitsverursachenden Mutationen auf. Eine ähnliche Rate gilt für Netzhauterkrankungen. Ein speziell auf diesen Mutationstyp ausgerichteter Therapieansatz könnte somit praktikabel und ökonomisch im Sinne einer Therapie „eine für viele“ sein. Nonsense-Mutationen führen zu vorzeitigen Terminationscodons (PTCs), wodurch die Degradation der mRNA über den „nonsense-mediated decay“ (NMD) induziert werden kann oder die Translation am PTC endet und ein verkürztes, zumeist nicht mehr funktionelles Protein synthetisiert wird. Ein pharmakogenetischer Ansatz induziert das Überlesen („read-through“) von PTCs und erlaubt somit die Synthese von vollständigen Proteinen. Die hierbei eingesetzten Wirkstoffe werden als TRIDs („translational read-through inducing drugs“) bezeichnet. Die ersten identifizierten TRIDs gehören zur Klasse der Aminoglykosidantibiotika. Modernere TRIDs sind Amlexanox, Ataluren und Derivate von Aminoglykosidantibiotika. Während Aminoglykoside eine hohe Oto‑, Nephro- und Retinotoxizität aufweisen, zeichnen sich die modernen TRIDs durch eine verbesserte Verträglichkeit aus. Eine Vielzahl von präklinischen Studien belegt die Überlese-Effizienz von TRIDs bei Nonsense-Mutationen und zeigt die Funktionalität der wiederhergestellten Proteine in Zellkultur, Tiermodellen und patientenspezifischen Zellen. Für die Therapie von Netzhauterkrankungen werden systemische und lokale Applikationen evaluiert. Patientenspezifische Zellen stellen ein personalisiertes Screeningmodell für die Identifizierung eines wirksamen TRID dar. Der pharmakogenetische Überlese-Ansatz könnte in Zukunft für jeden Patienten, dessen Netzhauterkrankung durch eine Nonsense-Mutation verursacht wird, eine personalisierte Therapie erlauben.

Monoallelic and Biallelic Variants in EMC1 Identified in Individuals with Global Developmental Delay, Hypotonia, Scoliosis, and Cerebellar Atrophy

The paradigm of a single gene associated with one specific phenotype and mode of inheritance has been repeatedly challenged. Genotype-phenotype correlations can often be traced to different mutation types, localization of the variants in distinct protein domains, or the trigger of or escape from nonsense-mediated decay. Using whole-exome sequencing, we identified homozygous variants in EMC1 that segregated with a phenotype of developmental delay, hypotonia, scoliosis, and cerebellar atrophy in three families. In addition, a de novo heterozygous EMC1 variant was seen in an individual with a similar clinical and MRI imaging phenotype. EMC1 encodes a member of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER)-membrane protein complex (EMC), an evolutionarily conserved complex that has been proposed to have multiple roles in ER-associated degradation, ER-mitochondria tethering, and proper assembly of multi-pass transmembrane proteins. Perturbations of protein folding and organelle crosstalk have been implicated in neurodegenerative processes including cerebellar atrophy. We propose EMC1 as a gene in which either biallelic or monoallelic variants might lead to a syndrome including intellectual disability and preferential degeneration of the cerebellum.