Age-related differences in the E2A-encoded transcription factor E47 in bone marrow-derived B cell precursors and in splenic B cells

Immune Memory in Aging: a Wide Perspective Covering Microbiota, Brain, Metabolism, and Epigenetics

Non-specific innate and antigen-specific adaptive immunological memories are vital evolutionary adaptations that confer long-lasting protection against a wide range of pathogens. Adaptive memory is established by memory T and B lymphocytes following the recognition of an antigen. On the other hand, innate immune memory, also called trained immunity, is imprinted in innate cells such as macrophages and natural killer cells through epigenetic and metabolic reprogramming. However, these mechanisms of memory generation and maintenance are compromised as organisms age. Almost all immune cell types, both mature cells and their progenitors, go through age-related changes concerning numbers and functions. The aging immune system renders the elderly highly susceptible to infections and incapable of mounting a proper immune response upon vaccinations. Besides the increased infectious burden, older individuals also have heightened risks of metabolic and neurodegenerative diseases, which have an immunological component. This review discusses how immune function, particularly the establishment and maintenance of innate and adaptive immunological memory, regulates and is regulated by epigenetics, metabolic processes, gut microbiota, and the central nervous system throughout life, with a focus on old age. We explain in-depth how epigenetics and cellular metabolism impact immune cell function and contribute or resist the aging process. Microbiota is intimately linked with the immune system of the human host, and therefore, plays an important role in immunological memory during both homeostasis and aging. The brain, which is not an immune-isolated organ despite former opinion, interacts with the peripheral immune cells, and the aging of both systems influences the health of each other. With all these in mind, we aimed to present a comprehensive view of the aging immune system and its consequences, especially in terms of immunological memory. The review also details the mechanisms of promising anti-aging interventions and highlights a few, namely, caloric restriction, physical exercise, metformin, and resveratrol, that impact multiple facets of the aging process, including the regulation of innate and adaptive immune memory. We propose that understanding aging as a complex phenomenon, with the immune system at the center role interacting with all the other tissues and systems, would allow for more effective anti-aging strategies.

Cell signaling and the aging of B cells

The uniqueness of each B cell lies in the structural diversity of the B-cell antigen receptor allowing the virtually limitless recognition of antigens, a necessity to protect individuals against a range of challenges. B-cell development and response to stimulation are exquisitely regulated by a group of cell surface receptors modulating various signaling cascades and their associated genetic programs. The effects of these signaling pathways in optimal antibody-mediated immunity or the aberrant promotion of immune pathologies have been intensely researched in the past in young individuals. In contrast, we are only beginning to understand the contribution of these pathways to the changes in B cells of old organisms. Thus, critical transcription factors such as E2A and STAT5 show differential expression or activity between young and old B cells. As a result, B-cell physiology appears altered, and antibody production is impaired. Here, we discuss selected phenotypic changes during B-cell aging and attempt to relate them to alterations of molecular mechanisms.

Age-Associated B Cells: A T-bet-Dependent Effector with Roles in Protective and Pathogenic Immunity

A newly discovered B cell subset, age-associated B cells, expresses the transcription factor T-bet, has a unique surface phenotype, and accumulates progressively with age. Moreover, B cells with these general features are associated with viral infections and autoimmunity in both mice and humans. In this article, we review current understanding of the characteristics, origins, and functions of these cells. We also suggest that the protective versus pathogenic actions of these cells reflect appropriate versus aberrant engagement of regulatory mechanisms that control the Ab responses to nucleic acid-containing Ags.

B cell maintenance and function in aging

In this review we discuss the changes that occur in the B lymphocyte compartment of mice and humans as they progress to old age, focusing on recent advances in this important area of research. Primary areas considered include increased morbidity and mortality in the elderly following infection, and decreased responsiveness to vaccines that evoke primary humoral immune responses, as well as those that evoke responses by memory B cells generated following vaccination and natural infection earlier in life. We then consider some of the mechanisms that may underlie these observed declines in humoral immune function. This includes a discussion of alterations in B cell repertoire and subcompartment distribution, as well as defects in B lymphopoiesis, cell development and homeostasis that may contribute to these alterations, and ultimately to declining protective quality of antibodies produced in the elderly.

c-Cbl deficiency leads to diminished lymphocyte development and functions in an age-dependent manner

Aging is broadly defined as a progressive decline of tissue and organ functions due to deregulation of various cell intrinsic and extrinsic factors. In the immune system, aging preferentially affects lymphopoiesis and thus results in the reduced competence of the adaptive immune system in the elderly. Despite recent discoveries that shed light on the molecular basis of aging, pathways that lead to diminished lymphoid development in aging individuals remain largely unknown. In the present study, we document that a deficiency of the E3 ubiquitin ligase c-Cbl in lymphocytes results in an age-dependent lymphopenia. c-Cbl-deficient mice show normal frequencies of lymphocytes at 12 weeks of age; however, their development and functions were remarkably diminished at 24 weeks after birth. Intriguingly, c-Cbl mutant lymphocytes displayed increased responses to IL7 in vitro and failed to down-regulate surface levels of IL7Ralpha. Further, our biochemical studies have identified an interaction of c-Cbl with IL7Ralpha and have unraveled the involvement of c-Cbl in the ubiquitylation of IL7Ralpha. In essence, our studies demonstrate that a lack of signaling events mediated by c-Cbl might result in diminished lymphocyte development and functions, particularly, at the later stages of life.

Intra-bone marrow bone marrow transplantation rejuvenates the B-cell lineage in aged mice

Age-related reductions in the frequency and absolute number of early B lineage precursors in the bone marrow of aged mice have been reported. Reversal of B-cell lineage senescence has not been achieved. Age-related impairment of the B-cell lineage is caused by the decreasing functionality of hematopoietic and B lineage precursors, and reduced efficacy of bone marrow stromal cells that constitute the bone marrow microenvironment. To induce rejuvenation of aged B cells, we injected whole bone marrow from young donors to irradiated aged recipients through the tibia and analyzed B-cell development and immune responsiveness. In aged mice, we found significant reductions in the frequencies and absolute numbers of pro-B cells (B220(+)CD43(+)CD24(+)BP-1(-) and B220(+)CD43(+)CD24(int)BP-1(+)) and pre-B cells (B220(+)CD43(+)CD24(high)BP-1(+) and B220(+)CD43(-)IgM(-)IgD(-)). Intra-bone marrow bone marrow transplantation (IBM-BMT) of young marrow cells including both hematopoietic stem cells and bone marrow stromal cells reversed the reduction of pro-B cells and pre-B cells. In the periphery, the frequency and absolute number of marginal zone-B cell were not significantly different between young, old and IBM-BMT group. The frequency of follicular-B cells in the IBM-BMT group was significantly increased compared to old group. The frequency of B1a B cells in the peritoneal cavity was significantly decreased in the IBM-BMT group. Antibody production against T-independent antigens was not different among the young, the aged and IBM-BMT groups.

B cells and aging: molecules and mechanisms

Recent advances allow aging-associated changes in B-cell function to be approached at a mechanistic level. Reduced expression of genes crucial to lineage commitment and differentiation yield diminished B-cell production. Moreover, intrinsic differences in the repertoire generated by B-cell precursors in aged individuals, coupled with falling B-cell generation rates and life-long homeostatic competition, result in narrowed clonotypic diversity. Similarly, reductions in gene products crucial for immunoglobulin class switch recombination and somatic hypermutation impact the efficacy of humoral immune responses. Together, these findings set the stage for integrated analyses of how age-related changes at the molecular, cellular and population levels interact to yield the overall aging phenotype.

RNA Stability of the E2A-Encoded Transcription Factor E47 Is Lower in Splenic Activated B Cells from Aged Mice

We have demonstrated previously that DNA binding and protein expression of the E2A-encoded transcription factor E47 are lower in nuclear extracts of activated splenic B cells from old mice. In the present study, we address how E47 protein expression is regulated in aging. Results herein show that E2A mRNA levels were decreased in stimulated splenic B cells from old as compared with young mice. RNA stability assays showed that the rate of E2A mRNA decay was accelerated in stimulated splenic B cells from old mice, but E47 protein degradation rates were comparable in young vs aged B cells, indicating that the regulation of E47 expression in activated splenic B cells occurs primarily by mRNA stability. The rates of decay of other mRNAs showed that the increased mRNA degradation in aged splenic activated B cells is not a general phenomenon but restricted to a subset of mRNAs. We next investigated the signal transduction pathways controlling E2A mRNA expression and stability and found that p38 MAPK regulates E2A mRNA expression through increased mRNA stability and is down-regulated in aged activated B cells. Results show that inhibition of p38 MAPK significantly reduces E2A mRNA stability in both young and old B cells, further stressing the role of p38 MAPK in E2A RNA stabilization. These studies demonstrate that the transcription factor E2A, critical for many aspects of B cell function, is regulated by a novel mechanism in aging.

Linking age-related defects in B lymphopoiesis to the aging of hematopoietic stem cells

B cell genesis declines with age, but at what stage and why remains unclear. Previous studies attribute the decline in B cell production in aged mice to both environmental and cell-intrinsic defects that impact mid-to-late stream B cell precursors. However, mounting evidence suggests that the aging process may also negatively affect the earliest phases of B cell development. We review past studies on the B cells and aging question, discuss recent data suggesting that age-associated defects in B cell development reflect deficiencies in hematopoietic stem cell-proximal progenitor pools, and provide an integrative model that will hopefully facilitate further studies into this complex problem.

Bone marrow microenvironmental changes in aged mice compromise V(D)J recombinase activity and B cell generation

B cell generation and immunoglobulin (Ig) diversity in mice is compromised with aging. Our recent work sought to understand mechanism(s) that contribute to reduced B cell production in aged mice. Using in vivo labeling, we found that reduction in marrow pre-B cells reflects increased attrition during passage from the pro-B to pre-B cell pool. Analyses of reciprocal bone marrow (BM) chimeras reveal that the production rates of pre-B cells are controlled primarily by microenvironmental factors, rather than intrinsic events. To understand changes in pro-B cells that could diminish production of pre-B cells, we evaluated rag2 expression and V(D)J recombinase activity in pro-B cells at the single cell level. The percentage of pro-B cells that express rag2 is reduced in aged mice and is correlated with both a loss of V(D)J recombinase activity in pro-B cells and reduced numbers of pre-B cells. Reciprocal BM chimeras revealed that the aged microenvironment also determines rag2 expression and recombinase activity in pro-B cells. These observations suggest that extrinsic factors in the BM that decline with age are largely responsible for less efficient V(D)J recombination in pro-B cells and diminished progression to the pre-B cell stage. These extrinsic factors may include cytokines and chemokines derived from BM stromal cells that are essential to the development of B cell precursors. The changes during aging within the BM hematopoietic microenvironment most likely are linked to the physiology of aging bone. Bone degrades with age (osteoporosis) due to decreased formation of new bone by osteoblasts. Marrow stem cells (MSC) are considered the progenitor of both adipocytes, osteoblasts and hematopoietic stromal cells and a controlled reciprocal regulation exists of osteoblast versus adipocyte differentiation; with age adipocytes increase, and osteoblast decrease. It is possible that stromal cell generation from MSC is compromised during aging. Currently, understanding of BM microenvironmental factors that regulate rag gene expression is very limited. However, as early progenitors differentiate, it is increasing clear that a limited set of transcription factors (e.g. ikaros, PU.1, E2A, EBF, pax5) regulate B-lineage specific genes, and that expression and stability of these factors is responsive to the microenvironment. Current and future work by several groups will strive to understand mechanisms that regulate these factors and how aging impacts these regulatory circuits.

Dwindling competition with constant demand: Can homeostatic adjustments explain age-associated changes in peripheral B cell selection?

The close relationship between specificity-based selection and homeostatic processes in maintaining peripheral B cell pools has become increasingly evident. Thus, age-associated changes observed within these pools may reflect homeostatic responses to proximal primary lesions. Marked shifts in the size and dynamics of most B lymphocyte subsets and their progenitors occur with age: perturbations in B lineage precursors result in reduced production of immature B lymphocytes in the bone marrow and transitional pools in the periphery, but these effects appear to be offset by compensatory homeostatic processes at the marrow-periphery interface. We propose a model whereby these "distal" homeostatic adjustments relax the stringency of specificity based selection, affording a potential explanation for the increased frequency of autoreactive specificities with age.

The aging of early B-cell precursors

B-cell genesis in the bone marrow declines with advancing age. In this review, we discuss our current understanding of why B-cell production rates decline with age with a special emphasis on why age-related factors might target very early lymphoid precursors. We consider the impact of aging on cytokine responsiveness and how current models for lineage relationships for very early B- and T-cell precursors might influence interpretations of experiments addressing age-associated declines in B- and T-cell differentiation. This discussion centers on the notion that aging affects events associated with the process by which hematopoietic stem cells are guided toward the B-cell pathway. Finally, we present a model in which the age-associated loss of early B-cell precursors is linked to suboptimal function of key transcriptional regulators of very early B-cell development.

B cells, E2A, and aging

Both mouse and human exhibit deficiencies in humoral immunity during 'old age'. While alterations in phenotype and function have been well documented, the molecular mechanisms that result in immune senescence remain undefined. B lymphopoiesis is suppressed in senescent mice, which may result from deficits at the pre-B-cell stage or earlier (e.g. pro-B cells). This deficit contrasts with the maintenance of the normal number of total peripheral B lymphocytes in senescent mice. However, mature peripheral B cells in aged mice can exhibit reduced efficiencies of both immunoglobulin isotype switching and somatic hypermutation. The basic helix-loop-helix transcription factor E2A is crucial at several stages of B-lymphocyte differentiation, including the development of pro-B and pre-B cells within the bone marrow and in isotype switch and somatic hypermutation among peripheral B cells. Therefore, we have focused on the regulation of E2A expression and function during both B lymphopoiesis and isotype class switching in senescent mice. These studies show that E2A expression is normally under complex control at both post-transcriptional and post-translational levels. Alterations in E2A expression at both the B-cell precursor and mature B-cell developmental stages are hypothesized to contribute to defects in humoral immunity during senescence.

B cells and aging: gauging the interplay of generative, selective, and homeostatic events

Lymphocyte homeostasis encompasses a continuum of processes that together determine the production, turnover, composition, and representation of lymphocyte pools. These processes include commitment to lymphoid lineages, expansion of progenitor pools, successful transit through intermediate maturation stages, negative and positive selection based on receptor specificity, steady-state maintenance of peripheral lymphocytes, and regulation of antigen-driven activation. Understanding the impact of aging on lymphocyte homeostasis thus requires appreciation of not only the mechanisms responsible for generating and sustaining antigen-reactive B and T cells but also how age-related events can subvert these. Even under the influence of normally operating homeostatic mechanisms, lesions yielding perturbations outside of evolutionarily anticipated boundaries will yield aberrant lymphoid function and representation both upstream and downstream of the primary defect. Accordingly, determining the relative contribution of lineage-intrinsic versus compensatory homoeostatic processes throughout the continuum of lymphoid system development, selection, and maintenance are critical first steps towards understanding age-associated alterations in the immune system.

Bone marrow microenvironmental changes underlie reduced RAG-mediated recombination and B cell generation in aged mice

During aging, adaptive immunity is severely compromised, due in part to decreased production of B lymphocytes and loss of immunoglobulin (Ig) diversity. However, the molecular mechanisms that underlie age-associated diminished B cell production remain unclear. Using in vivo labeling, we find that this reduction in marrow pre–B cells reflects increased attrition during passage from the pro–B to pre–B cell pool. Analyses of reciprocal bone marrow chimeras reveal that the magnitude and production rates of pre–B cells are controlled primarily by microenvironmental factors, rather than intrinsic events. To understand changes in pro–B cells that could diminish production of pre–B cells, we evaluated rag2 expression and V(D)J recombinase activity in pro–B cells at the single cell level. The percentage of pro–B cells that express rag2 is reduced in aged mice and is correlated with both a loss of V(D)J recombinase activity in pro–B cells and reduced numbers of pre–B cells. Reciprocal bone marrow chimeras revealed that the aged microenvironment also determines rag2 expression and recombinase activity in pro–B cells. Together, these observations suggest that extrinsic factors in the bone marrow that decline with age are largely responsible for less efficient V(D)J recombination in pro–B cells and diminished progression to the pre–B cell stage.