Amino acid type selective isotope labelling of the multidrug ABC transporter LmrA for solid-state NMR studies

Solid-State NMR Reveals Asymmetric ATP Hydrolysis in the Multidrug ABC Transporter BmrA

The detailed mechanism of ATP hydrolysis in ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters is still not fully understood. Here, we employed ³¹P solid-state NMR to probe the conformational changes and dynamics during the catalytic cycle by locking the multidrug ABC transporter BmrA in prehydrolytic, transition, and posthydrolytic states, using a combination of mutants and ATP analogues. The ³¹P spectra reveal that ATP binds strongly in the prehydrolytic state to both ATP-binding sites as inferred from the analysis of the nonhydrolytic E504A mutant. In the transition state of wild-type BmrA, the symmetry of the dimer is broken and only a single site is tightly bound to ADP:Mg²⁺:vanadate, while the second site is more ‘open’ allowing exchange with the nucleotides in the solvent. In the posthydrolytic state, weak binding, as characterized by chemical exchange with free ADP and by asymmetric ³¹P–³¹P two-dimensional (2D) correlation spectra, is observed for both sites. Revisiting the ¹³C spectra in light of these findings confirms the conformational nonequivalence of the two nucleotide-binding sites in the transition state. Our results show that following ATP binding, the symmetry of the ATP-binding sites of BmrA is lost in the ATP-hydrolysis step, but is then recovered in the posthydrolytic ADP-bound state.

The effect of drug binding on specific sites in transmembrane helices 4 and 6 of the ABC exporter MsbA studied by DNP-enhanced solid-state NMR

MsbA, a homodimeric ABC exporter, translocates its native substrate lipid A as well as a range of smaller, amphiphilic substrates across the membrane. Magic angle sample spinning (MAS) NMR, in combination with dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) for signal enhancement, has been used to probe two specific sites in transmembrane helices 4 and 6 of full length MsbA embedded in lipid bilayers. Significant chemical shift changes in both sites were observed in the vanadate-trapped state compared to apo state MsbA. The reduced spectral line width indicates a more confined conformational space upon trapping. In the presence of substrates Hoechst 33342 and daunorubicin, further chemical shift changes and line shape alterations mainly in TM6 in the vanadate trapped state were detected. These data illustrate the conformational response of MsbA towards the presence of drugs during the catalytic cycle. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Beyond the Structure-Function Horizon of Membrane Proteins edited by Ute Hellmich, Rupak Doshi and Benjamin McIlwain.

Effects of nucleotide binding to LmrA: A combined MAS-NMR and solution NMR study

ABC transporters are fascinating examples of fine-tuned molecular machines that use the energy from ATP hydrolysis to translocate a multitude of substrates across biological membranes. While structural details have emerged on many members of this large protein superfamily, a number of functional details are still under debate. High resolution structures yield valuable insights into protein function, but it is the combination of structural, functional and dynamic insights that facilitates a complete understanding of the workings of their complex molecular mechanisms. NMR is a technique well-suited to investigate proteins in atomic resolution while taking their dynamic properties into account. It thus nicely complements other structural techniques, such as X-ray crystallography, that have contributed high-resolution data to the architectural understanding of ABC transporters. Here, we describe the heterologous expression of LmrA, an ABC exporter from Lactococcus lactis, in Escherichia coli. This allows for more flexible isotope labeling for nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies and the easy study of LmrA's multidrug resistance phenotype. We use a combination of solid-state magic angle spinning (MAS) on the reconstituted transporter and solution NMR on its isolated nucleotide binding domain to investigate consequences of nucleotide binding to LmrA. We find that nucleotide binding affects the protein globally, but that NMR is also able to pinpoint local dynamic effects to specific residues, such as the Walker A motif's conserved lysine residue.

Efficient and stable reconstitution of the ABC transporter BmrA for solid-state NMR studies

We present solid-state NMR sample preparation and first 2D spectra of the Bacillus subtilis ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporter BmrA, a membrane protein involved in multidrug resistance. The homodimeric 130-kDa protein is a challenge for structural characterization due to its membrane-bound nature, size, inherent flexibility and insolubility. We show that reconstitution of this protein in lipids from Bacillus subtilis at a lipid-protein ratio of 0.5 w/w allows for optimal protein insertion in lipid membranes with respect to two central NMR requirements, high signal-to-noise in the spectra and sample stability over a time period of months. The obtained spectra point to a well-folded protein and a highly homogenous preparation, as witnessed by the narrow resonance lines and the signal dispersion typical for the expected secondary structure distribution of BmrA. This opens the way for studies of the different conformational states of the transporter in the export cycle, as well as on interactions with substrates, via chemical-shift fingerprints and sequential resonance assignments.

Methods to identify the NMR resonances of the ¹³C-dimethyl N-terminal amine on reductively methylated proteins

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is a proven technique for protein structure and dynamic studies. To study proteins with NMR, stable magnetic isotopes are typically incorporated metabolically to improve the sensitivity and allow for sequential resonance assignment. Reductive (13)C-methylation is an alternative labeling method for proteins that are not amenable to bacterial host over-expression, the most common method of isotope incorporation. Reductive (13)C-methylation is a chemical reaction performed under mild conditions that modifies a protein's primary amino groups (lysine ε-amino groups and the N-terminal α-amino group) to (13)C-dimethylamino groups. The structure and function of most proteins are not altered by the modification, making it a viable alternative to metabolic labeling. Because reductive (13)C-methylation adds sparse, isotopic labels, traditional methods of assigning the NMR signals are not applicable. An alternative assignment method using mass spectrometry (MS) to aid in the assignment of protein (13)C-dimethylamine NMR signals has been developed. The method relies on partial and different amounts of (13)C-labeling at each primary amino group. One limitation of the method arises when the protein's N-terminal residue is a lysine because the α- and ε-dimethylamino groups of Lys1 cannot be individually measured with MS. To circumvent this limitation, two methods are described to identify the NMR resonance of the (13)C-dimethylamines associated with both the N-terminal α-amine and the side chain ε-amine. The NMR signals of the N-terminal α-dimethylamine and the side chain ε-dimethylamine of hen egg white lysozyme, Lys1, are identified in (1)H-(13)C heteronuclear single-quantum coherence spectra.

A MAS NMR study of the bacterial ABC transporter ArtMP

ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transport systems facilitate the translocation of substances, like amino acids, across cell membranes energised by ATP hydrolysis. This work describes first structural studies on the ABC transporter ArtMP from Geobacillus stearothermophilus in native lipid environment by magic-angle spinning NMR spectroscopy. The 2D crystals of ArtMP and 3D crystals of isolated ArtP were prepared in different nucleotide-bound or -unbound states. From selectively (13)C,(15)N-labelled ArtP, several sequence-specific assignments were obtained, most of which could be transferred to spectra of ArtMP. Residues Tyr133 and Pro134 protrude directly into the ATP-binding pocket at the interface of the ArtP subunits, and hence, are sensitive monitors for structural changes during nucleotide binding and hydrolysis. Distinct sets of NMR shifts were obtained for ArtP with different phosphorylation states of the ligand. Indications were found for an asymmetric or inhomogeneous state of the ArtP dimer bound with triphosphorylated nucleotides. With this investigation, a model system was established for screening all functional states occurring in one ABC transporter in native lipid environment.

NMR and EPR studies of membrane transporters

In order to fulfill their function, membrane transport proteins have to cycle through a number of conformational and/or energetic states. Thus, understanding the role of conformational dynamics seems to be the key for elucidation of the functional mechanism of these proteins. However, membrane proteins in general are often difficult to express heterologously and in sufficient amounts for structural studies. It is especially challenging to trap a stable energy minimum, e.g., for crystallographic analysis. Furthermore, crystallization is often only possible by subjecting the protein to conditions that do not resemble its native environment and crystals can only be snapshots of selected conformational states. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy are complementary methods that offer unique possibilities for studying membrane proteins in their natural membrane environment and for investigating functional conformational changes, lipid interactions, substrate-lipid and substrate-protein interactions, oligomerization states and overall dynamics of membrane transporters. Here, we review recent progress in the field including studies from primary and secondary active transporters.

The ABC transporter MsbA interacts with lipid A and amphipathic drugs at different sites

MsbA is an essential ABC (ATP-binding cassette) transporter involved in lipid A transport across the cytoplasmic membrane of Gram-negative bacteria. The protein has also been linked to efflux of amphipathic drugs. Purified wild-type MsbA was labelled stoichiometrically with the fluorescent probe MIANS [2-(4′-maleimidylanilino)naphthalene-6-sulfonic acid] on C315, which is located within the intracellular domain connecting transmembrane helix 6 and the nucleotide-binding domain. MsbA–MIANS displayed high ATPase activity, and its folding and stability were unchanged. The initial rate of MsbA labelling by MIANS was reduced in the presence of amphipathic drugs, suggesting that binding of these compounds alters the protein conformation. The fluorescence of MsbA–MIANS was saturably quenched by nucleotides, lipid A and various drugs, and estimates of the K_d values for binding fell in the range of 0.35–10 μM. Lipid A and daunorubicin were able to bind to MsbA–MIANS simultaneously, implying that they occupy different binding sites. The effects of nucleotide and lipid A/daunorubicin binding were additive, and binding was not ordered. The K_d of MsbA for binding lipid A was substantially decreased when the daunorubicin binding site was occupied first, and prior binding of nucleotide also modulated lipid A binding affinity. These results indicate that MsbA contains two substrate-binding sites that communicate with both the nucleotide-binding domain and with each other. One is a high affinity binding site for the physiological substrate, lipid A, and the other site interacts with drugs with comparable affinity. Thus MsbA may function as both a lipid flippase and a multidrug transporter.

Caught in the act: ATP hydrolysis of an ABC-multidrug transporter followed by real-time magic angle spinning NMR

The ATP binding cassette (ABC) transporter LmrA from Lactococcus lactis transports cytotoxic molecules at the expense of ATP. Molecular and kinetic details of LmrA can be assessed by solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (ssNMR), if functional reconstitution at a high protein-lipid ratio can be achieved and the kinetic rate constants are small enough. In order to follow ATP hydrolysis directly by 31P-magic angle spinning (MAS) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), we generated such conditions by reconstituting LmrA-dK388, a mutant with slower ATP turnover rate, at a protein-lipid ration of 1:150. By analysing time-resolved 31P spectra, protein activity has been directly assessed. These data demonstrate the general possibility to perform ssNMR studies on a fully active full length ABC transporter and also form the foundation for further kinetic studies on LmrA by NMR.

Proteorhodopsin: characterisation of 2D crystals by electron microscopy and solid state NMR

Proteorhodopsin (PR) a recent addition to retinal type 1 protein family, is a bacterial homologue of archaeal bacteriorhodopsin. It was found to high abundance in gamma-proteobacteria in the photic zone of the oceans and has been shown to act as a photoactive proton pump. It is therefore involved in the utilisation of light energy for energy production within the cell. Based on data from biodiversity screens, hundreds of variants were discovered worldwide, which are spectrally tuned to the available light at different locations in the sea. Here, we present a characterisation of 2D crystals of the green variant of proteorhodopsin by electron microscopy and solid state NMR. 2D crystal formation with hexagonal protein packing was observed under a very wide range of conditions indicating that PR might be also closely packed under native conditions. A low-resolution 2D projection map reveals a ring-shaped oligomeric assembly of PR. The protein state was analysed by 15N MAS NMR on lysine, tryptophan and methionine labelled samples. The chemical shift of the protonated Schiff base was almost identical to non-crystalline preparations. All residues could be cross-polarised in non-frozen samples. Lee-Goldberg cross-polarisation has been used to probe protein backbone mobility.

Investigating transport proteins by solid state NMR

Transporters form an interesting and complex class of membrane proteins. Many of them are potential drug targets due to their role in translocation of ions, small molecules and peptides across the membrane or due to their role in multidrug resistance. Hence elucidating their structure and mechanism is of great importance and may lead to a host of new drugs and methods to alter or inhibit their function. Solid state NMR is an emerging technique for investigating transport proteins. Along with other biochemical and biophysical techniques solid state NMR can provide data on drug binding, protein dynamics and structure at the interface between structural biology and functional analysis. Here, we review solid state NMR applications to primary active and secondary transporters involved in translocation of small molecules. We discuss current experimental limitations and give an overall perspective on how the technique may be used to address some pertinent questions relevant to transporters.

How to prepare membrane proteins for solid-state NMR: A case study on the alpha-helical integral membrane protein diacylglycerol kinase from E. coli

Several studies have demonstrated that it is viable to use microcrystalline preparations of water-soluble proteins as samples in solid-state NMR experiments [1-5]. Here, we investigate whether this approach holds any potential for studying water-insoluble systems, namely membrane proteins. For this case study, we have prepared proteoliposomes and small crystals of the alpha-helical membrane-protein diacylglycerol kinase (DGK). Preparations were characterised by 13C- and 15N-cross-polarization magic-angle spinning (CPMAS) NMR. It was found that crystalline samples produce better-resolved spectra than proteoliposomes. This makes them more suitable for structural NMR experiments. However, reconstitution is the method of choice for biophysical studies by solid-state NMR. In addition, we discuss the identification of lipids bound to membrane-protein crystals by 31P-MAS NMR.

NMR and fluorescence spectroscopy approaches to secondary and primary active multidrug efflux pumps

Multidrug efflux pumps are found in all major transporter families. Along with a lack of three-dimensional structure information, the mechanism of drug recognition, energy coupling with drug translocation and the catalytic cycle are so far not understood. In the present study, we present first data of a fluorescence-based assay to study the pH-gradient-mediated activity of the multidrug antiporter EmrE, by co-reconstitution with the light-driven proton pump bacteriorhodopsin. In addition to biochemical approaches, the emerging technique, solid-state NMR, can be used for the investigation of these transporters. A number of experiments based on MAS (magic angle sample spinning) NMR are available to provide data on protein structure and dynamics, drug binding and protein–lipid interactions. However, these experiments dictate a number of constraints with respect to sample preparation that will be discussed for proteins from the SMR (small multidrug resistance transporter) family. In addition, 2H-NMR is used to probe protein mobility of Lactococcus lactis ABC transporter, LmrA.

Investigation of Ligand-Receptor Systems by High-Resolution Solid-State NMR: Recent Progress and Perspectives

Solid-state Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) provides a general method to study molecular structure and dynamics in a non-crystalline and insoluble environment. We discuss the latest methodological progress to construct 3D molecular structures from solid-state NMR data obtained under magic-angle-spinning conditions. As shown for the neurotensin/NTS-1 system, these methods can be readily applied to the investigation of ligand-binding to G-protein coupled receptors.

Structural and dynamic studies of proteins by solid-state NMR spectroscopy: rapid movement forward

Starting only a few years ago, many solid-state NMR spectroscopy laboratories have become engaged in solving the complete structures of biological macromolecules using high-resolution methods based on magic angle spinning. These efforts typically involve structurally homogeneous samples, and utilize recently developed pulse sequences for the sequential correlation of resonances, the detection of tertiary contacts and the characterization of torsion angles. Thereby, systems have been studied that evaded other, more established, structure determination methods.