Synechocystis ferredoxin/ferredoxin-NADP(+)-reductase/NADP+ complex: Structural model obtained by NMR-restrained docking

Changing the tracks: screening for electron transfer proteins to support hydrogen production

Abstract

Ferredoxins are essential electron transferring proteins in organisms. Twelve plant-type ferredoxins in the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii determine the fate of electrons, generated in multiple metabolic processes. The two hydrogenases HydA1 and HydA2 of. C. reinhardtii compete for electrons from the photosynthetic ferredoxin PetF, which is the first stromal mediator of the high-energy electrons derived from the absorption of light energy at the photosystems. While being involved in many chloroplast-located metabolic pathways, PetF shows the highest affinity for ferredoxin-NADP⁺ oxidoreductase (FNR), not for the hydrogenases. Aiming to identify other potential electron donors for the hydrogenases, we screened as yet uncharacterized ferredoxins Fdx7, 8, 10 and 11 for their capability to reduce the hydrogenases. Comparing the performance of the Fdx in presence and absence of competitor FNR, we show that Fdx7 has a higher affinity for HydA1 than for FNR. Additionally, we show that synthetic FeS-cluster-binding maquettes, which can be reduced by NADPH alone, can also be used to reduce the hydrogenases. Our findings pave the way for the creation of tailored electron donors to redirect electrons to enzymes of interest.

Graphical abstract

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s00775-022-01956-1.

Biohybrid photosynthetic charge accumulation detected by flavin semiquinone formation in ferredoxin-NADP+ reductase

Flavin chemistry is ubiquitous in biological systems with flavoproteins engaged in important redox reactions. In photosynthesis, flavin cofactors are used as electron donors/acceptors to facilitate charge transfer and accumulation for ultimate use in carbon fixation. Following light-induced charge separation in the photosynthetic transmembrane reaction center photosystem I (PSI), an electron is transferred to one of two small soluble shuttle proteins, a ferredoxin (Fd) or a flavodoxin (Fld) (the latter in the condition of Fe-deficiency), followed by electron transfer to the ferredoxin-NADP⁺ reductase (FNR) enzyme. FNR accepts two of these sequential one electron transfers, with its flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) cofactor becoming doubly reduced, forming a hydride which is then passed onto the substrate NADP⁺ to form NADPH. The two one-electron potentials (oxidized/semiquinone and semiquinone/hydroquinone) are similar to each other with the FNR protein stabilizing the hydroquinone, making spectroscopic detection of the intermediate semiquinone state difficult. We employed a new biohybrid-based strategy that involved truncating the native three-protein electron transfer cascade PSI → Fd → FNR to a two-protein cascade by replacing PSI with a molecular Ru(ii) photosensitizer (RuPS) which is covalently bound to Fd and Fld to form biohybrid complexes that successfully mimic PSI in light-driven NADPH formation. RuFd → FNR and RuFld → FNR electron transfer experiments revealed a notable distinction in photosynthetic charge accumulation that we attribute to the different protein cofactors [2Fe2S] and flavin. After freeze quenching the two-protein systems under illumination, an intermediate semiquinone state of FNR was readily observed with cw X-band EPR spectroscopy. The increased spectral resolution from selective deuteration allowed EPR detection of inter-flavoprotein electron transfer. This work establishes a biohybrid experimental approach for further studies of photosynthetic light-driven electron transfer chain that culminates at FNR and highlights nature's mechanisms that couple single electron transfer chemistry to charge accumulation, providing important insight for the development of photon-to-fuel schemes.

Fine-tuning of FeS proteins monitored via pulsed EPR redox potentiometry at Q-band

As essential electron translocating proteins in photosynthetic organisms, multiple plant-type ferredoxin (Fdx) isoforms are involved in a high number of reductive metabolic processes in the chloroplast. To allow quick cellular responses under changing environmental conditions, different plant-type Fdxs in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii were suggested to have adapted their midpoint potentials to a wide range of interaction partners. We performed pulsed electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) monitored redox potentiometry at Q-band on three Fdx isoforms for a straightforward determination of their midpoint potentials. Additionally, site-directed mutagenesis was used to tune the midpoint potential of CrFdx1 in a range of approximately -338 to -511 mV, confirming the importance of single positions in the protein environment surrounding the [2Fe2S] cluster. Our results present a new target for future studies aiming to modify the catalytic activity of CrFdx1 that plays an essential role either as electron acceptor of photosystem I or as electron donor to hydrogenases under certain conditions. Additionally, the precisely determined redox potentials in this work using pulsed EPR demonstrate an alternative method that provides additional advantages compared with the well-established continuous wave EPR technique.

Prochlorococcus phage ferredoxin: structural characterization and electron transfer to cyanobacterial sulfite reductases

Marine cyanobacteria are infected by phages whose genomes encode ferredoxin (Fd) electron carriers. These Fds are thought to redirect the energy harvested from light to phage-encoded oxidoreductases that enhance viral fitness, but it is unclear how the biophysical properties and partner specificities of phage Fds relate to those of photosynthetic organisms. Here, results of a bioinformatics analysis using a sequence similarity network revealed that phage Fds are most closely related to cyanobacterial Fds that transfer electrons from photosystems to oxidoreductases involved in nutrient assimilation. Structural analysis of myovirus P-SSM2 Fd (pssm2-Fd), which infects the cyanobacterium Prochlorococcus marinus, revealed high levels of similarity to cyanobacterial Fds (root mean square deviations of ≤0.5 Å). Additionally, pssm2-Fd exhibited a low midpoint reduction potential (-336 mV versus a standard hydrogen electrode), similar to other photosynthetic Fds, although it had lower thermostability (T_m = 28 °C) than did many other Fds. When expressed in an Escherichia coli strain deficient in sulfite assimilation, pssm2-Fd complemented bacterial growth when coexpressed with a P. marinus sulfite reductase, revealing that pssm2-Fd can transfer electrons to a host protein involved in nutrient assimilation. The high levels of structural similarity with cyanobacterial Fds and reactivity with a host sulfite reductase suggest that phage Fds evolved to transfer electrons to cyanobacterially encoded oxidoreductases.

Solvent dynamics play a decisive role in the complex formation of biologically relevant redox proteins

Electron transfer processes between proteins are vital in many biological systems. Yet, the role of the solvent in influencing these redox reactions remains largely unknown. In this study, terahertz-time domain spectroscopy (THz-TDS) is used to probe the collective hydration dynamics of flavoenzyme ferredoxin-NADP+-reductase (FNR), electron transfer protein ferredoxin-1 (PetF), and the transient complex that results from their interaction. Results reveal changes in the sub-picosecond hydration dynamics that are dependent upon the surface electrostatic properties of the individual proteins and the transient complex. Retarded solvent dynamics of 8-9 ps are observed for FNR, PetF, and the FNR:PetF transient complex. Binding of the FNR:PetF complex to the substrate NADP+ results in bulk-like solvent dynamics of 7 ps, showing that formation of the ternary complex is entropically favored. Our THz measurements reveal that the electrostatic interaction of the protein surface with water results in charge sensitive changes in the solvent dynamics. Complex formation between the positively charged FNR:NADP+ pre-complex and the negatively charged PetF is not only entropically favored, but in addition the solvent reorganization into more bulk-like water assists the molecular recognition process. The change in hydration dynamics observed here suggests that the interaction with the solvent plays a significant role in mediating electron transfer processes between proteins.

Interprotein electron transfer biohybrid system for photocatalytic H2 production

Worldwide there is a large research investment in developing solar fuel systems as clean and sustainable sources of energy. The fundamental mechanisms of natural photosynthesis can provide a source of inspiration for these studies. Photosynthetic reaction center (RC) proteins capture and convert light energy into chemical energy that is ultimately used to drive oxygenic water-splitting and carbon fixation. For the light energy to be used, the RC communicates with other donor/acceptor components via a sophisticated electron transfer scheme that includes electron transfer reactions between soluble and membrane bound proteins. Herein, we reengineer an inherent interprotein electron transfer pathway in a natural photosynthetic system to make it photocatalytic for aqueous H₂ production. The native electron shuttle protein ferredoxin (Fd) is used as a scaffold for binding of a ruthenium photosensitizer and H₂ catalytic function is imparted to its partner protein, ferredoxin-NADP⁺-reductase (FNR), by attachment of cobaloxime molecules. We find that this 2-protein biohybrid system produces H₂ in aqueous solutions via light-induced interprotein electron transfer reactions (TON > 2500 H₂/FNR), providing insight about using native protein-protein interactions as a method for fuel generation.

Rational redesign of the ferredoxin-NADP+-oxido-reductase/ferredoxin-interaction for photosynthesis-dependent H2-production

Utilization of electrons from the photosynthetic water splitting reaction for the generation of biofuels, commodities as well as application in biotransformations requires a partial rerouting of the photosynthetic electron transport chain. Due to its rather negative redox potential and its bifurcational function, ferredoxin at the acceptor side of Photosystem 1 is one of the focal points for such an engineering. With hydrogen production as model system, we show here the impact and potential of redox partner design involving ferredoxin (Fd), ferredoxin-oxido-reductase (FNR) and [FeFe]‑hydrogenase HydA1 on electron transport in a future cyanobacterial design cell of Synechocystis PCC 6803. X-ray-structure-based rational design and the allocation of specific interaction residues by NMR-analysis led to the construction of Fd- and FNR-mutants, which in appropriate combination enabled an about 18-fold enhanced electron flow from Fd to HydA1 (in competition with equimolar amounts of FNR) in in vitro assays. The negative impact of these mutations on the Fd-FNR electron transport which indirectly facilitates H₂ production (with a contribution of ≤42% by FNR variants and ≤23% by Fd-variants) and the direct positive impact on the Fd-HydA1 electron transport (≤23% by Fd-mutants) provide an excellent basis for the construction of a hydrogen-producing design cell and the study of photosynthetic efficiency-optimization with cyanobacteria.

Identification of the ferredoxin interaction sites on ferredoxin-dependent glutamate synthase from Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803

Based on in silico docking methods, five amino acids in glutamate synthase (Gln-467, His-1144, Asn-1147, Arg-1162, and Trp-676) likely constitute key binding residues in the interface of a glutamate synthase:ferredoxin complex. Although all interfacial mutants studied showed the ability to form a complex under low ionic strength, these docking mutations showed significantly less ferredoxin-dependent activities, while still retaining enzymatic activity. Furthermore, isothermal titration calorimetry showed a possible 1:2 molar ratio between the wild-type glutamate synthase and ferredoxin. However, each of our interfacial mutants showed only a 1:1 complex with ferredoxin, suggesting that the mutations directly affect the glutamate synthase:ferredoxin heterodimer interface.

Predicting Protein-Protein Interactions Using BiGGER: Case Studies

The importance of understanding interactomes makes preeminent the study of protein interactions and protein complexes. Traditionally, protein interactions have been elucidated by experimental methods or, with lower impact, by simulation with protein docking algorithms. This article describes features and applications of the BiGGER docking algorithm, which stands at the interface of these two approaches. BiGGER is a user-friendly docking algorithm that was specifically designed to incorporate experimental data at different stages of the simulation, to either guide the search for correct structures or help evaluate the results, in order to combine the reliability of hard data with the convenience of simulations. Herein, the applications of BiGGER are described by illustrative applications divided in three Case Studies: (Case Study A) in which no specific contact data is available; (Case Study B) when different experimental data (e.g., site-directed mutagenesis, properties of the complex, NMR chemical shift perturbation mapping, electron tunneling) on one of the partners is available; and (Case Study C) when experimental data are available for both interacting surfaces, which are used during the search and/or evaluation stage of the docking. This algorithm has been extensively used, evidencing its usefulness in a wide range of different biological research fields.

Photoreduction of the ferredoxin/ferredoxin-NADP(+)-reductase complex by a linked ruthenium polypyridyl chromophore

Photosynthetic ferredoxin and its main partner ferredoxin-NADP(+)-reductase (FNR) are key proteins during the photoproduction of reductive power involved in photosynthetic growth. In this work, we used covalent attachment of ruthenium derivatives to different cysteine mutants of ferredoxin to trigger by laser-flash excitation both ferredoxin reduction and subsequent electron transfer from reduced ferredoxin to FNR. Rates and yields of reduction of the ferredoxin [2Fe-2S] cluster by reductively quenched Ru* could be measured for the first time for such a low redox potential protein whereas ferredoxin-FNR electron transfer was characterized in detail for one particular Ru-ferredoxin covalent adduct. For this adduct, the efficiency of FNR single reduction by reduced ferredoxin was close to 100% under both first-order and diffusion-limited second-order conditions. Interprotein intracomplex electron transfer was measured unambiguously for the first time with a fast rate of c. 6500s(-1). Our measurements point out that Ru photosensitizing is a powerful approach to study the functional interactions of ferredoxin with its numerous partners besides FNR.

Highly Efficient CYP167A1 (EpoK) dependent Epothilone B Formation and Production of 7-Ketone Epothilone D as a New Epothilone Derivative

Since their discovery in the soil bacterium Sorangium cellulosum, epothilones have emerged as a valuable substance class with promising anti-tumor activity. Because of their benefits in the treatment of cancer and neurodegenerative diseases, epothilones are targets for drug design and pharmaceutical research. The final step of their biosynthesis – a cytochrome P450 mediated epoxidation of epothilone C/D to A/B by CYP167A1 (EpoK) – needs significant improvement, in particular regarding the efficiency of its redox partners. Therefore, we have investigated the ability of various hetero- and homologous redox partners to transfer electrons to EpoK. Hereby, a new hybrid system was established with conversion rates eleven times higher and V_max of more than seven orders of magnitudes higher as compared with the previously described spinach redox chain. This hybrid system is the most efficient redox chain for EpoK described to date. Furthermore, P450s from So ce56 were identified which are able to convert epothilone D to 14-OH, 21-OH, 26-OH epothilone D and 7-ketone epothilone D. The latter one represents a novel epothilone derivative and is a suitable candidate for pharmacological tests. The results revealed myxobacterial P450s from S. cellulosum So ce56 as promising candidates for protein engineering for biotechnological production of epothilone derivatives.

Protein docking with predicted constraints

This paper presents a constraint-based method for improving protein docking results. Efficient constraint propagation cuts over 95% of the search time for finding the configurations with the largest contact surface, provided a contact is specified between two amino acid residues. This makes it possible to scan a large number of potentially correct constraints, lowering the requirements for useful contact predictions. While other approaches are very dependent on accurate contact predictions, ours requires only that at least one correct contact be retained in a set of, for example, one hundred constraints to test. It is this feature that makes it feasible to use readily available sequence data to predict specific potential contacts. Although such prediction is too inaccurate for most purposes, we demonstrate with a Naïve Bayes Classifier that it is accurate enough to more than double the average number of acceptable models retained during the crucial filtering stage of protein docking when combined with our constrained docking algorithm. All software developed in this work is freely available as part of the Open Chemera Library.

Characterization of the key step for light-driven hydrogen evolution in green algae

Under anaerobic conditions, several species of green algae perform a light-dependent hydrogen production catalyzed by a special group of [FeFe] hydrogenases termed HydA. Although highly interesting for biotechnological applications, the direct connection between photosynthetic electron transport and hydrogenase activity is still a matter of speculation. By establishing an in vitro reconstitution system, we demonstrate that the photosynthetic ferredoxin (PetF) is essential for efficient electron transfer between photosystem I and HydA1. To investigate the electrostatic interaction process and electron transfer between PetF and HydA1, we performed site-directed mutagenesis. Kinetic analyses with several site-directed mutagenesis variants of HydA1 and PetF enabled us to localize the respective contact sites. These experiments in combination with in silico docking analyses indicate that electrostatic interactions between the conserved HydA1 residue Lys(396) and the C terminus of PetF as well as between the PetF residue Glu(122) and the N-terminal amino group of HydA1 play a major role in complex formation and electron transfer. Mapping of relevant HydA1 and PetF residues constitutes an important basis for manipulating the physiological photosynthetic electron flow in favor of light-driven H(2) production.

Structural and functional diversity of ferredoxin-NADP(+) reductases

Although all ferredoxin-NADP(+) reductases (FNRs) catalyze the same reaction, i.e. the transfer of reducing equivalents between NADP(H) and ferredoxin, they belong to two unrelated families of proteins: the plant-type and the glutathione reductase-type of FNRs. Aim of this review is to provide a general classification scheme for these enzymes, to be used as a framework for the comparison of their properties. Furthermore, we report on some recent findings, which significantly increased the understanding of the structure-function relationships of FNRs, i.e. the ability of adrenodoxin reductase and its homologs to catalyze the oxidation of NADP(+) to its 4-oxo derivative, and the properties of plant-type FNRs from non-photosynthetic organisms. Plant-type FNRs from bacteria and Apicomplexan parasites provide examples of novel ways of FAD- and NADP(H)-binding. The recent characterization of an FNR from Plasmodium falciparum brings these enzymes into the field of drug design.

Atomic resolution modeling of the ferredoxin:[FeFe] hydrogenase complex from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

The [FeFe] hydrogenases HydA1 and HydA2 in the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii catalyze the final reaction in a remarkable metabolic pathway allowing this photosynthetic organism to produce H(2) from water in the chloroplast. A [2Fe-2S] ferredoxin is a critical branch point in electron flow from Photosystem I toward a variety of metabolic fates, including proton reduction by hydrogenases. To better understand the binding determinants involved in ferredoxin:hydrogenase interactions, we have modeled Chlamydomonas PetF1 and HydA2 based on amino-acid sequence homology, and produced two promising electron-transfer model complexes by computational docking. To characterize these models, quantitative free energy calculations at atomic resolution were carried out, and detailed analysis of the interprotein interactions undertaken. The protein complex model we propose for ferredoxin:HydA2 interaction is energetically favored over the alternative candidate by 20 kcal/mol. This proposed model of the electron-transfer complex between PetF1 and HydA2 permits a more detailed view of the molecular events leading up to H(2) evolution, and suggests potential mutagenic strategies to modulate electron flow to HydA2.

Electrochemical study of a reconstituted photosynthetic electron-transfer chain

A multi-enzyme electron-transfer chain involving solubilized photosystem I (PSI) as photocatalytic unit, cytochrome c6 and ferredoxin as electron carriers and ferredoxin/NADPH oxidoreductase (FNR) as electron acceptor was reconstituted in an electrochemical cell and studied by cyclic voltammetry. The working gold electrodes were modified to react selectively with cytochrome c6. Quantitative analysis of the photocatalytic current under continuous illumination allowed the determination of the values kon and koff for the ferredoxin/PSI interaction. An efficient recycling system for NADPH was established, and the dissociation constant of the oxidized ferredoxin/semiquinone FNR complex was extracted by modeling the catalytic efficiency of the chain as a function of ferredoxin concentration. The value determined hereby is consistent with a shift of -50 to -100 mV of the reduction potential of ferredoxin when complexed with FNR.