Preimplantation genetic testing: polar bodies, blastomeres, trophectoderm cells, or blastocoelic fluid?

A study on methods for preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) on in vivo- and in vitro-produced equine embryos, with emphasis on embryonic sex determination

Two methods for preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) have been described for equine embryos: trophoblast cell biopsy (TCB) or blastocoele fluid aspiration (BFA). While TCB is widely applied for both in vivo- and in vitro-produced embryos, BFA has been mostly utilized for in vivo-produced embryos. Alternative methods for PGT, including analysis of cell-free DNA (CFD) in the medium where in vitro-produced embryos are cultured, have been reported in humans but not for equine embryos. In Experiment 1, in vivo- (n = 10) and in vitro-produced (n = 13) equine embryos were subjected to BFA, cultured for 24 h, then subjected to TCB, and cultured for additional 24 h. No detrimental effect on embryonic diameter or re-expansion rates was observed for either embryo group (P > 0.05). In Experiment 2, the concordance (i.e., agreement on detecting the same embryonic sex using two techniques) among BFA, TCB, and the whole embryo (Whole) was studied by detecting the sex-determining region Y (SRY) or testis-specific y-encoded protein 1 (TSPY) (Y-chromosome), and androgen receptor (AR; X-chromosome) genes using PCR. Overall, a higher concordance for detecting embryonic sex was observed among techniques for in vivo-produced embryos (67-100 %; n = 14 embryos) than for in vitro-produced embryos (31-92 %; n = 13 embryos). The concordance between sample types increased when utilizing TSPY (77-100 %) instead of SRY (31-100 %) as target gene. In Experiment 3, CFD analysis was performed on in vitro-produced embryos to determine embryonic sex via PCR (SRY [Y-chromosome] and amelogenin - AMEL [X- and Y-chromosomes]). Overall, CFD was detected in all medium samples, and the concordance between CFD sample and the whole embryo was 60 % when utilizing SRY and AMEL genes. In conclusion, equine embryos can be subjected to two biopsy procedures (24 h apart) without apparent detrimental effects on embryonic size. For in vivo-, but not for in vitro-produced equine embryos, BFA can be considered a potential alternative to TCB for PGT. Finally, CFD can be further explored as a non-invasive method for PGT in in vitro produced equine embryos.

Preimplantation genetic testing: A narrative review

Preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) is a diagnostic procedure that has become a powerful complement to assisted reproduction techniques. PGT has numerous indications, and there is a wide range of techniques that can be used, each with advantages and limitations that should be considered before choosing the more adequate one. In this article, it is reviewed the indications for PGT, biopsy and diagnostic technologies, along with their evolution, while also broaching new emerging methods.

Genomic aspects in reproductive medicine

Infertility is a complex disease characterized by extreme genetic heterogeneity, compounded by various environmental factors. While there are exceptions, individual genetic and genomic variations related to infertility are typically rare, often family-specific, and may serve as susceptibility factors rather than direct causes of the disease. Consequently, identifying the cause of infertility and developing prevention and treatment strategies based on these factors remain challenging tasks, even in the modern genomic era. In this review, we first examine the genetic and genomic variations associated with infertility, and subsequently summarize the concepts and methods of preimplantation genetic testing in light of advances in genome analysis technology.

Evolution of Minimally Invasive and Non-Invasive Preimplantation Genetic Testing: An Overview

Preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) has become a common supplementary diagnοstic/testing tοol for in vitro fertilization (ΙVF) cycles due to a significant increase in cases of PGT fοr mοnogenic cοnditions (ΡGT-M) and de novο aneuplοidies (ΡGT-A) over the last ten years. This tendency is mostly attributable to the advancement and application of novel cytogenetic and molecular techniques in clinical practice that are capable of providing an efficient evaluation of the embryonic chromosomal complement and leading to better IVF/ICSI results. Although PGT is widely used, it requires invasive biopsy of the blastocyst, which may harm the embryo. Non-invasive approaches, like cell-free DNA (cfDNA) testing, have lower risks but have drawbacks in consistency and sensitivity. This review discusses new developments and opportunities in the field of preimplantation genetic testing, enhancing the overall effectiveness and accessibility of preimplantation testing in the framework of developments in genomic sequencing, bioinformatics, and the integration of artificial intelligence in the interpretation of genetic data.

The embryo non-invasive pre-implantation diagnosis era: how far are we?

Advancements in assisted reproduction (AR) methodologies have allowed significant improvements in live birth rates of women who otherwise would not be able to conceive. One of the tools that allowed this improvement is the possibility of embryo selection based on genetic status, performed via preimplantation genetic testing (PGT). Even though the widespread use of PGT from TE biopsy helped to decrease the interval from the beginning of the AR intervention to pregnancy, especially in older patients, in AR, there are still many concerns about the application of this invasive methodology in all cycles. Therefore, recently, researchers started to study the use of cell free DNA (cfDNA) released by the blastocyst in its culture medium to perform PGT, in a method called non-invasive PGT (niPGT). The development of a niPGT would bring the diagnostics power of conventional PGT, but with the advantage of being potentially less harmful to the embryo. Its implementation in clinical practice, however, is under heavy discussion since there are many unknowns about the technique, such as the origin of the cfDNA or if this genetic material is a true representative of the actual ploidy status of the embryo. Available data indicates that there is high correspondence between results observed in TE biopsies and the ones observed from cfDNA, but these results are still contradictory and highly debatable. In the present review, the advantages and disadvantages of niPGT are presented and discussed in relation to tradition TE biopsy-based PGT. Furthermore, there are also presented some other possible non-invasive tools that could be applied in the selection of the best embryo, such as quantification of other molecules as quality biomarkers, or the use artificial intelligence (AI) to identify the best embryos based on morphological and/or morphokitetic parameters.

Effectiveness of non-invasive chromosomal screening for normal karyotype and chromosomal rearrangements

Purpose: To study the accuracy of non-invasive chromosomal screening (NICS) results, in normal chromosomes and chromosomal rearrangement groups and to investigate whether using trophoblast cell biopsy along with NICS, to choose embryos for transfer can improve the clinical outcomes of assisted pregnancy.

Methods: We retrospectively analyzed 101 couples who underwent preimplantation genetic testing at our center from January 2019 to June 2021 and collected 492 blastocysts for trophocyte (TE) biopsy. D3-5 blastocyst culture fluid and blastocyst cavity fluid were collected for the NICS. Amongst them, 278 blastocysts (58 couples) and 214 blastocysts (43 couples) were included in the normal chromosomes and chromosomal rearrangement groups, respectively. Couples undergoing embryo transfer were divided into group A, in which both the NICS and TE biopsy results were euploid (52 embryos), and group B, in which the TE biopsy results were euploid and the NICS results were aneuploid (33 embryos).

Results: In the normal karyotype group, concordance for embryo ploidy was 78.1%, sensitivity was 94.9%, specificity was 51.4%, the positive predictive value (PPV) was 75.7%, and the negative predictive value (NPV) was 86.4%. In the chromosomal rearrangement group, concordance for embryo ploidy was 73.1%, sensitivity was 93.3%, specificity was 53.3%, the PPV was 66.3%, and the NPV was 89%. In euploid TE/euploid NICS group, 52 embryos were transferred; the clinical pregnancy rate was 71.2%, miscarriage rate was 5.4%, and ongoing pregnancy rate was 67.3%. In euploid TE/aneuploid NICS group, 33 embryos were transferred; the clinic pregnancy rate was 54.5%, miscarriage rate was 5.6%, and ongoingpregnancy rate was 51.5%. The clinical pregnancy and ongoing pregnancy rates were higher in the TE and NICS euploid group.

Conclusion: NICS was similarly effective in assessing both normal and abnormal populations. Identification of euploidy and aneuploidy alone may lead to the wastage of embryos due to high false positives. More suitable reporting methods for NICS and countermeasures for a high number of false positives in NICS are needed. In summary, our results suggest that combining biopsy and NICS results could improve the outcomes of assisted pregnancy.

An Update on Non-invasive Approaches for Genetic Testing of the Preimplantation Embryo

Preimplantation Genetic Testing (PGT) aims to reduce the chance of an affected pregnancy or improve success in an assisted reproduction cycle. Since the first established pregnancies in 1990, methodological approaches have greatly evolved, combined with significant advances in the embryological laboratory. The application of preimplantation testing has expanded, while the accuracy and reliability of monogenic and chromosomal analysis have improved. The procedure traditionally employs an invasive approach to assess the nucleic acid content of embryos. All biopsy procedures require high technical skill, and costly equipment, and may impact both the accuracy of genetic testing and embryo viability. To overcome these limitations, many researchers have focused on the analysis of cell-free DNA (cfDNA) at the preimplantation stage, sampled either from the blastocoel or embryo culture media, to determine the genetic status of the embryo non-invasively. Studies have assessed the origin of cfDNA and its application in non-invasive testing for monogenic disease and chromosomal aneuploidies. Herein, we discuss the state-of-the-art for modern non-invasive embryonic genetic material assessment in the context of PGT. The results are difficult to integrate due to numerous methodological differences between the studies, while further work is required to assess the suitability of cfDNA analysis for clinical application.

An additional medium renewal of D4 embryo culture improves the concordance of noninvasive chromosome screening with trophectoderm biopsy

Our research question was to evaluate the chromosome concordance of trophectoderm (TE) biopsy with noninvasive chromosome screening (NICS) using embryo culture medium renewed twice on Day 3 (D3) and Day 4 (D4). In this study, we evaluated 64 cycles with 223 biopsied blastocysts. These were categorized into two groups based on replacing embryo culture medium on D3 (control group) or on D3 and D4 (experimental group). The fundamental characteristics and main outcomes were compared. The concordance rates of NICS results with TE biopsy were determined according to next generation sequencing results. In total, 103 experimental and 120 control embryo cultures were collected, and the euploid status was analyzed using NICS technology. The overall concordance rates with TE biopsy of the experimental and control groups were 0.86 and 0.75, respectively. Statistically significant difference was found between the two groups. An additional medium renewal of the D4 embryo culture can improve the concordance of NICS with TE biopsy.

Karyotype of the Blastocoel Fluid Derived by Laser-Assisted Hatching Demonstrates a Low Agreement With the Trophectoderm

Objective

The aim of this study is to compare the amplification efficiency and the genomic profiles of blastocoel fluid (BF) derived by laser-assisted hatching and trophectoderm (TE) cells derived from the same blastocyst.

Methods

Fifty-four fresh blastocysts underwent shrinkage by laser-assisted hatching, and each BF sample was collected individually. BF and TE cells were retrieved from each blastocyst for chromosome analysis through multiple annealing and looping-based amplification cycles (MALBAC) and next-generation sequencing (NGS).

Results

Fifty-four BF samples and 32 TE samples were retrieved for this study. Out of the 54 BF samples, only 35 provided reliable NGS data for comprehensive chromosome analysis (64.8%), while all 32 TE samples did (100%). Finally, there were 23 pairs of BF and TE samples from the same blastocyst. Only 17.4% of the BF-DNA karyotypes were completely agreeable with the TE samples (4/23).

Conclusion

Blastocoel fluid derived by laser-assisted hatching is easy to operate, and BF-DNA can be successfully amplified and subjected to NGS. Due to the low amplification efficiency and increased discordance with TE, BF does not adequately represent the status of the rest of the blastocyst. The use of BF as a single source of DNA for preimplantation genetic screening (PGS) is not yet advised.

Non-Invasive Preimplantation Genetic Testing for Aneuploidy and the Mystery of Genetic Material: A Review Article

This review focuses on recent findings in the preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) of embryos. Different preimplantation genetic tests are presented along with different genetic materials and their analysis. Original material concerning preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A) was sourced by searching the PubMed and ScienceDirect databases in October and November 2021. The searches comprised keywords such as ‘preimplantation’, ‘cfDNA’; ‘miRNA’, ‘PGT-A’, ‘niPGT-A’, ‘aneuploidy’, ‘mosaicism’, ‘blastocyst biopsy’, ‘blastocentesis’, ‘blastocoel fluid’, ‘NGS’, ‘FISH’, and ‘aCGH’. Non-invasive PGT-A (niPGT-A) is a novel approach to the genetic analysis of embryos. The premise is that the genetic material in the spent embryo culture media (SECM) corresponds to the genetic material in the embryo cells. The limitations of niPGT-A are a lower quantity and lesser quality of the cell-free genetic material, and its unknown origin. The concordance rate varies when compared to invasive PGT-A. Some authors have also hypothesized that mosaicism and aneuploid cells are preferentially excluded from the embryo during early development. Cell-free genetic material is readily available in the spent embryo culture media, which provides an easier, more economic, and safer extraction of genetic material for analysis. The sampling of the SECM and DNA extraction and amplification must be optimized. The origin of the cell-free media, the percentage of apoptotic events, and the levels of DNA contamination are currently unknown; these topics need to be further investigated.

Ploidy Testing of Blastocoel Fluid for Screening May Be Technically Challenging and More Invasive Than That of Spent Cell Culture Media

Background

Recent studies have demonstrated that both blastocoel fluid (BF) and spent cell culture media (SCM) have potential as materials for non-invasive or less-invasive pre-implantation genetic analysis. BF may allow more opportunity to obtain cell-free DNA from the inner cell mass (ICM), and it has a lower risk of containing contaminant DNA from cumulus cells, sperm and culture media. There are no data regarding the ICM as a gold standard to evaluate the chromosome constitution of BF or SCM for embryo liquid biopsy.

Methods

Two hundred eighteen donated human blastocysts were warmed and cultured in blastocyst culture media for 18–24 h. The corresponding SCM was collected, and only clear ICM was biopsied in blastocysts; otherwise, the whole blastocyst (WB) was biopsied. Quantitative PCR was performed to determine the DNA levels in the SCM and BF before and after amplification. ChromInst was used to amplify BF/SCM and blastocyst DNA before sequencing. Chromosomal copy number variation (CNV) was investigated to evaluate the chromosome constitution.

Results

In total, 212 blastocysts were available for SCM and BF collection. The technical success rates (next-generation sequencing data) were 100 and 69.8% (148/212) for SCM and BF, respectively. Among the 148 blastocysts with both SCM and BF data, 101 were euploid and 47 were aneuploid based on ICM (n = 89) or WB (n = 59) analysis as the gold standard. Among all blastocysts, SCM was comparable to BF [specificity: 80.2 versus 61.4% (P = 0.005, χ² test); sensitivity: 91.5 versus 87.2% (P = 0.738, χ² test); negative predictive value (NPV): 95.3 versus 91.2% (P = 0.487, χ² test); positive predictive value (PPV): 68.3% versus 51.3% (P = 0.042, χ² test)]. The SCM and BF samples were 83.8% (124/148) and 69.6% (103/148) concordant with the corresponding ICM/WB samples when only two categories, euploid or aneuploid/mosaic, were grouped to calculate the concordance.

Conclusions

Compared with BF, SCM has superior diagnostic performance, and it is non-invasive for embryos.

Clinical Trial Registration

[http://www.chictr.org.cn], identifier [ChiCTR-BPD-17014087].

The expression of pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A (PAPP-A) in human blastocoel fluid-conditioned media: a proof of concept study

Purpose

The aim of this study was to determine if pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A (PAPP-A), typically measured in maternal serum and a potential predictor of adverse maternal and fetal outcomes such as spontaneous miscarriage, pre-eclampsia, and stillbirth, is expressed in blastocoel fluid–conditioned media (BFCM) at the embryonic blastocyst stage.

Design

This is an in vitro study.

Methods

BFCM samples from trophectoderm-tested euploid blastocysts (n = 80) from in vitro fertilization/intracytoplasmic sperm injection (IVF/ICSI) patients were analyzed for PAPP-A mRNA. BFCM was obtained from blastocyst stage embryos in 20 uL drops. Blastocysts underwent trophectoderm biopsy for preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy prior to blastocyst vitrification and BFCM collection for snap freezing. cfDNA was synthesized using BFCM collected from 80 individual euploid blastocysts. Next, real-time qPCR was performed to detect expression of PAPP-A with GAPDH for normalization of expression in each sample.

Results

PAPP-A mRNA was detected in 45 of 80 BFCM samples (56.3%), with varying levels of expression across samples.

Conclusion

Our study demonstrates the expression of PAPP-A in BFCM. To our knowledge, this is the first study to report detection of PAPP-A mRNA in BFCM. Further studies are required and underway to investigate a greater number of BFCM samples as well as the possible correlation of PAPP-A expression with pregnancy outcomes of transferred euploid blastocysts. If found to predict IVF and obstetric outcomes, PAPP-A may provide additional information along with embryonic euploidy for the selection of the optimal blastocyst for embryo transfer.

The integrity of cfDNA in follicular fluid and spent medium from embryo culture is associated with embryo grade in patients undergoing in vitro fertilization

PURPOSE

This study was conducted to verify if the cfDNA integrity (cfDI) in follicular fluid and subsequent spent embryo medium (SEM) could serve as potential non-invasive biomarker for high-grade embryo selection during IVF/ICSI.

METHODS

Thirty-two follicular fluids, 32 subsequent corresponding cleavage embryo SEM, and 23 subsequent blastocyst SEM were collected from 11 patients undergoing IVF/ICSI. CfDI was measured by ALU gene amplicons with different sizes by qPCR, as the ratio of long to short fragments.

RESULTS

CfDI in follicular fluid corresponding to subsequent high-grade cleavage embryos and blastocysts was significantly lower than that related to low-grade embryos (p = 0.018). Conversely, cfDI in SEM was significantly and positively correlated with high-grade embryos at both stages (p = 0.009). ROC curves of the analysis of cfDI in follicular fluid showed great potential in predicting subsequent embryogenesis and embryo grade (AUC > 0.927). Regardless of the cleavage embryo grade by morphology, cfDI in day 3 SEM could predict if the cleavage embryo could develop to a high-grade blastocyst (AUC = 0.820). A concordant shift pattern of cfDI from follicular fluid to subsequent day 3 SEM and day 5 SEM was found in 81.82% participants featured by various clinical characteristics.

CONCLUSION

CfDI in follicular fluid and SEM was significantly correlated with embryogenesis and embryo grade and could serve as a potential non-invasive biomarker in high-grade embryo selection. Direct qPCR was proved as a labor-saving and sensitive method for the analysis of cfDI in low volume of SEM.

Preimplantation Genetic Testing for Monogenic Conditions: Is Cell-Free DNA Testing the Next Step?

Genetic assessment of an embryo via preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) represents an important reproductive option for couples wanting to try and improve success rates from in vitro fertilisation (IVF) cycles, as well as reduce their risk of having a child born with a genetic condition. Currently, biopsy of the developing embryo prior to transfer allows genetic assessment of an embryo for either chromosome copy number (aneuploidy [PGT-A] or segmental rearrangement [PGT-SR]) or to avoid the transmission of a single gene condition (monogenic conditions [PGT-M]). However, this technology is invasive and commands considerable resources. Non-invasive PGT (niPGT) offers a potential alternate mode of embryonic analysis. Whilst the utility of niPGT-A has been recently explored, there has been limited consideration of niPGT-M as an option for couples at risk of passing on a single gene or chromosomal condition. This review examines the historical and current clinical context of preimplantation embryonic analysis for monogenic conditions, in addition to important considerations surrounding the origin and analysis of cell-free deoxyribose nucleic acid (cfDNA), whether it is sourced via blastocentesis or spent embryonic culture medium (SCM). Future capabilities of this testing modality will almost certainly be enhanced by integration of whole genome sequencing into everyday practice. In addition, the increased utilisation of reproductive carrier screening as part of standard reproductive healthcare will likely result in the identification of a larger high-risk population. As a result, stratification of limited and highly specialised reproductive genetic resources will be required. Prospective parents should continue to be made aware of the limitations of this technology, with prenatal confirmatory testing remaining an essential part of antenatal care in these patients. However, niPGT-M poses an important alternate testing modality for high-risk couples, particularly in the setting of embryos that cannot be biopsied for traditional PGT-M and as demand for this treatment continues to grow.

Preimplantation Genetic Testing for Aneuploidy: Current Perspectives

Despite improvements in assisted reproduction techniques (ARTs), live birth rates remain suboptimal, particularly in women with advanced maternal age (AMA). The leading cause of poor reproductive outcomes demonstrated in women with AMA, as well as women with recurrent miscarriage and repetitive implantation failure, is thought to be due to high rates of embryonic aneuploidy. Preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidies (PGT-A) aims to select an euploid embryo for transfer and therefore improve ART outcomes. Early PGT-A studies using fluorescent in situ hybridization on mainly cleavage-stage biopsies failed to show improved delivery rates and, in certain cases, were even found to be harmful. However, the development of comprehensive chromosome screening, as well as improvements in culture media and vitrification techniques, has resulted in an emerging body of evidence in favor of PGT-A, demonstrating higher implantation, pregnancy, and live birth rates. While there are concerns regarding the potential harm of invasive biopsy and the cost implications of PGT-A, the introduction of noninvasive techniques and the development of new high-throughput methods which lower costs are tackling these issues. This review aims to assess the evidence for PGT-A, address possible concerns regarding PGT-A, and also explore the future direction of this technology.

Non-invasive preimplantation genetic testing for putative mosaic blastocysts: a pilot study

STUDY QUESTION

What is the potential of applying non-invasive preimplantation genetic testing (niPGT) for chromosome abnormalities in blastocysts reported with a mosaic trophectoderm (TE) biopsy?

SUMMARY ANSWER

niPGT of cell-free DNA in blastocyst culture medium exhibited a good diagnostic performance in putative mosaic blastocysts.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

Advances in niPGT have demonstrated the potential reliability of cell-free DNA as a resource for genetic assessment, but information on mosaic embryos is scarce because the mosaicism may interfere with niPGT. In addition, the high incidence of mosaicism reported in the context of PGT and the viability of mosaic blastocysts raise questions about whether mosaicism really exists.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

The study was performed between May 2020 and July 2020. First, clinical data collected by a single-center over a 6-year period on PGT for chromosome aneuploidies (PGT-A) or chromosomal structural rearrangements (PGT-SR) were analyzed. After confirming the reliability of niPGT, 41 blastocysts classified as mosaics by trophectoderm (TE) biopsy were re-cultured. The chromosomal copy number of the blastocyst embryo (BE, the gold standard), TE re-biopsy, and corresponding cell-free DNA in the culture medium was assessed.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

Data on patients enrolled for PGT at a single center from 2014 to 2019 were collected and the cycles with available putative mosaic blastocysts were evaluated. To verify the diagnostic validity of niPGT, eight aneuploid blastocysts were thawed and re-cultured for 14-18 h. The concordance of the niPGT diagnosis results and the whole blastocyst testing results was analyzed. Forty-one blastocysts reported as mosaics from 22 patients were included and re-cultured for 14-18 h. The genetic material of the BE, TE re-biopsy, and corresponding cell-free DNA in the culture medium was amplified using multiple annealing and looping-based amplification cycles. The karyotype data from niPGT and TE re-biopsy were compared with that from the whole blastocyst, and the efficiency of niPGT was assessed.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

Data on 3738 blastocysts from 785 PGT-A or PGT-SR cycles of 677 patients were collected. According to the TE biopsy report, of the 3662 (98%) successfully amplified samples, 24 (0.6%) yielded no results, 849 (23.2%) were euploid, 2245 (61.3%) were aneuploid, and 544 (14.9%) were mosaic. Sixty patients without euploid blastocysts opted for a single mosaic blastocyst transfer, and 30 (50%) of them obtained a clinical pregnancy. With the BE chromosome copy number as the gold standard, niPGT and TE re-biopsy showed reliable detection ability and diagnostic efficiency in eight putative aneuploid blastocysts. Of the 41 putative mosaic blastocysts re-cultured and re-tested, 35 (85.4%) showed euploid BE results. All but two of the blastocysts previously diagnosed with segmental chromosomal mosaic were actually euploid. In addition, all blastocysts previously classified as low degree (20-50%) mosaics were identified as euploid by BE PGT, whereas four of the six putative high degree (50-80%) mosaic blastocysts showed chromosomal abnormalities. The raw concordance rates of spent culture medium (SCM) and TE re-biopsies compared with BE were 74.4% and 82%, respectively, in terms of overall ploidy and 96.2% and 97.6%, respectively, per single chromosome when considering all degree mosaic results as true positives. However, when we set a mosaicism identification threshold of 50%, the concordance rates of SCM and TE re-biopsies compared with BE were 87.2% and 85% at the overall ploidy level and 98.8% and 98.3% at the chromosomal level, respectively. At the full ploidy level, the sensitivity and false negative rates for niPGT were 100% and 0, respectively. After adjustment of the threshold for mosaicism, the specificity of niPGT increased from 69.7% to 84.8% in terms of overall ploidy and from 96.1% to 98.9% at the chromosomal level.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

The primary limitation of this study is the small sample size, which decreases the strength of our conclusions. If possible, identifying the clinical outcome of niPGT on reassessed mosaic blastocysts would be further progress in this field.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

This study is the first to explore the practicability of niPGT in diagnostic reassessment of putative mosaicism. The present study provides a novel opportunity for patients with only mosaic blastocysts and no euploid blastocysts, regardless of the technical or biological basis of mosaicism. Employing niPGT after 14-18 h of re-culturing might be a superior option for the best use of blastocysts because of its minimally invasive nature.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

This work was supported by grants from National Key Technology Research and Development Program of China (No. 2017YFC1002004), the Central Guiding the Science and Technology Development of the Local (2018080802D0081) and College Natural Science Project of Anhui Province (KJ2019A0287). There are no competing interests to declare.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

N/A.

An overview of the current and emerging platforms for preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidies (PGT-A) in in vitro fertilization programs

Preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidies (PGT-A) and PGT for monogenic disorders (PGT-M) have currently been used widely, aiming to improve IVF outcomes. Although with many years of unsatisfactory results, PGT-A has been revived because new technologies have been adopted, such as platforms to examine all 24 types of chromosomes in blastocysts. This report compiles current knowledge regarding the available PGT platforms, including quantitative PCR, array CGH, and next-generation sequencing. The diagnostic capabilities of are compared and respective advantages/disadvantages outlined. We also address the limitations of current technologies, such as assignment of embryos with balanced translocation. We also discuss the emerging novel PGT technologies that likely will change our future practice, such as non-invasive PGT examining spent culture medium. Current literature suggest that most platforms can effectively reach concordant results regarding whole-chromosome ploidy status of all 24 types of chromosomes. However, different platforms have different resolutions and experimental complexities; leading to different turnaround time, throughput and differential capabilities of detecting mosaicism, segmental mutations, unbalanced translocations, concurrent PGT-A and PGT-M etc. Based on these information, IVF staff can more appropriately interpret PGT data and counsel patients, and select suitable platforms to meet personalized needs. The present report also concisely discusses some crucial clinical outcomes by PGT, which can clarify the role of applying PGT in daily IVF programs. Finally the up-to-date information about the novel use of current technologies and the newly emerging technologies will also help identify the focus areas for the design of new platforms for PGT in the future.

Electrospray mass spectrometry analysis of blastocoel fluid as a potential tool for bovine embryo selection

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to analyze the metabolic profiles of blastocoel fluid (BF) obtained from bovine embryos produced in vivo and in vitro.

METHODS

Expanded blastocysts (20/group) that were in vitro and in vivo derived at day 7 were used. BF was collected and analyzed under direct infusion conditions using a microTOF-Q^® mass spectrometer with electrospray ionization and a mass range of 50-650 m/z.

RESULTS

The spectrometry showed an evident difference in the metabolic profiles of BF from in vivo and in vitro produced embryos. These differences were very consistent between the samples of each group suggesting that embryo fluids can be used to identify the origin of the embryo. Ions 453.15 m/z, 437.18 m/z, and 398.06 m/z were identified as biomarkers for the embryo's origin with 100% sensitivity and specificity. Although it was not possible to unveil the molecular identity of the differential ions, the resulting spectrometric profiles provide a phenotype capable of differentiating embryos and hence constitute a potential parameter for embryo selection.

CONCLUSION

To the best of our knowledge, our results showed, for the first time, an evident difference between the spectrometric profiles of the BF from bovine embryos produced in vivo and in vitro.

Cell-free DNA discoveries in human reproductive medicine: providing a new tool for biomarker and genetic assays in ART

Cell-free DNAs (cfDNAs) are fragmented forms of DNA that are released into extracellular environments. Analyzing them, regarding either concentration or genetic/epigenetic status can provide helpful information about disorders, response to treatments, estimation of success rates, etc. Moreover, since they are presented in body fluids, evaluation of the aforementioned items would be achieved by less/non-invasive methods. In human reproduction field, it is required to have biomarkers for prediction of assisted reproduction techniques (ART) outcome, as well as some non-invasive procedures for genetic/epigenetic assessments. cfDNA is an appropriate candidate for providing the both approaches in ART. Recently, scientists attempted to investigate its application in distinct fields of reproductive medicine that resulted in discovering its applicability for biomarker and genetic/epigenetic analyses. However, due to some limitations, it has not reached to clinical administration yet. In this article, we have reviewed the current reported data with respect to advantages and limitations of cfDNA utilization in three fields of ART, reproduction of male and female, as well as in vitro developed embryos.

Pre-implantation genetic testing: Past, present, future

BACKGROUND

Pre-implantation genetic testing (PGT) has been performed worldwide since it was first used by Handyside et al in the United Kingdom to sex embryos in 1990. Until about 2010, cleavage stage embryo biopsy and fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) were mainstream; however, in 2012, blastocyst biopsy (trophectoderm; TE biopsy) became mainstream. In addition, array comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH) was used for analysis and further evolved to next-generation sequencing (NGS), which is used worldwide.

METHODS

PGT for reciprocal balanced translocation and Robertsonian translocation (PGT-SR) was approved in Japan for habitual abortion to reduce pregnancy loss, and since 2008, we have been performing PGT-SR using cleavage stage embryos and FISH. In 2014, we performed TE biopsy and NGS analysis.

MAIN FINDINGS

In this paper, I separately described the details of our methods and clinical results of FISH and NGS. NGS is superior to FISH because it can detect all chromosomes.

CONCLUSION

TE biopsy and NGS, which have recently become mainstream, have stable outcomes, because TE biopsy yields more cells and fewer mosaics than the cleavage stage. As a result, diagnoses are more reliable, resulting in higher pregnancy rates and lower abortion rates.

Improved Non-Invasive Preimplantation Genetic Testing for Beta-Thalassemia Using Spent Embryo Culture Medium Containing Blastocoelic Fluid

OBJECTIVES

To compare successful beta-thalassemia (β-thalassemia) detection rates obtained using spent culture medium and spent culture medium containing blastocoelic fluid (BF).

METHOD

This study involved data from 10 couples who underwent preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) for β-thalassemia. A total of 26 samples of spent culture medium containing BF (group A) and 33 samples without BF (group B) were collected and analyzed. The DNA concentration and β-thalassemia detection rates were evaluated.

RESULTS

The HBB mutation analysis results of 34 samples were concordant with the biopsy results (34/59, 57.6%). In group A, the HBB mutation analysis results of 19 of 26 samples (73.1%) were concordant with the biopsy results. The concordance rate in group A was higher than that in group B (15/33, 45.5%; P < 0.05). The haplotyping results of 38 samples were concordant with the biopsy results (38/59, 64.4%). The concordance rate in group B was 17/33 (51.5%), which was significantly lower than that in group A (21/26, 80.8%) (P < 0.05). In group A, the mean DNA concentration of samples with <10% fragmentation was 107.3 ± 70.1 ng/μL, which was lower than that of samples with ≥10% fragmentation (194.6 ± 28.0 ng/μL) (P < 0.05). However, the detection rates of <10% and ≥10% fragmentation were not significantly different (P > 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The β-thalassemia detection rate with non-invasive PGT using the spent culture medium containing BF was higher than that using the spent culture medium alone. Fragmentation is associated with DNA concentration in the spent culture medium containing BF.

Preimplantation genetic testing for carriers of BRCA1/2 pathogenic variants

The detection of germline BRCA1/2 pathogenic variant has relevant implications for the patients and their family members. Family planning, prophylactic surgery and the possibility of preimplantation genetic testing for monogenic disorders (PGT-M) to avoid transmittance of pathogenic variants to the offspring are relevant topics in this setting. PGT-M is valuable option for BRCA carriers, but it remains a controversial and underdiscussed topic. Although the advances in PGT technologies have improved pregnancy rate, there are still several important challenges associated with its use. The purpose of this review is to report the current evidence on PGT-M for BRCA1/2 carriers, ethical concerns and controversy associated with its use, reproductive implications of BRCA pathogenic variants, underlying areas in which an educational effort would be beneficial as well as possibilities for future research efforts in the field.

Noninvasive preimplantation genetic testing in assisted reproductive technology: current state and future perspectives

Invasive genetic screening of pre-implantation embryos via biopsied trophectoderm (TE) cells has been in use for more than 20 years, while its benefits in selecting euploid embryos remain controversial. Recent advances in the ability to process embryonic cell-free DNA (cfDNA) from blastocoel fluid (BF) and spent culture media (SCM) of blastocysts in a manner similar to that of a biopsied TE sample provide a potential alternative holding great promise for obtaining cytogenetic information of the embryos without intrusive biopsy of traditional biopsy-based pre-implantation genetic testing (PGT). Several studies have reported even higher diagnostic accuracy in non-invasive PGT (ni-PGT) than conventional PGT. However, there are still several technical challenges to be overcome before ni-PGT can be accepted as a reliable genomic information source of embryo. In this review, we have summarized the emergence and current state of ni-PGT, and discussed our own perspectives on their limitations and future prospect. There is still a long way to go before truly wide clinical application of ni-PGT.

The dawn of the future: 30 years from the first biopsy of a human embryo. The detailed history of an ongoing revolution

Following early studies showing no adverse effects, cleavage stage biopsy by zona drilling using acid Tyrode's solution, and removal of single blastomeres for preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) and identification of sex in couples at risk of X-linked disease, was performed by Handyside and colleagues in late 1989, and pregnancies reported in 1990. This method was later used for specific diagnosis of monogenic conditions, and a few years later also for chromosomal structural and/or numerical impairments, thereby establishing a valuable alternative option to prenatal diagnosis. This revolutionary approach in clinical embryology spread worldwide, and several other embryo biopsy strategies developed over three decades in a process that is still ongoing. The rationale of this narrative review is to outline the different biopsy approaches implemented across the years in the workflow of the IVF clinics that provided PGT: their establishment, the first clinical experiences, their downsides, evolution, improvement and standardization. The history ends with a glimpse of the future: minimally/non-invasive PGT and experimental embryo micromanipulation protocols. This grand theme review outlines a timeline of the evolution of embryo biopsy protocols, whose implementation is increasing worldwide together with the increasing application of PGT techniques in IVF. It represents a vade mecum especially for the past, present and upcoming operators and experts in this field to (re)live this history from its dawn to its most likely future.

Non-invasive preimplantation genetic testing (niPGT): the next revolution in reproductive genetics?

BACKGROUND

Preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) encompasses methods that allow embryos to be tested for severe inherited conditions or for chromosome abnormalities, relevant to embryo health and viability. In order to obtain embryonic genetic material for analysis, a biopsy is required, involving the removal of one or more cells. This invasive procedure greatly increases the costs of PGT and there have been concerns that embryo viability could be compromised in some cases. The recent discovery of DNA within the blastocoele fluid (BF) of blastocysts and in spent embryo culture media (SCM) has led to interest in the development of non-invasive methods of PGT (niPGT).

OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE

This review evaluates the current scientific evidence regarding non-invasive genetic assessment of preimplantation embryos. The success of different PGT methodologies in collecting and analysing extra-embryonic DNA is evaluated, and consideration is given to the potential biological and technical hindrances to obtaining a reliable clinical diagnosis.

SEARCH METHODS

Original research and review papers concerning niPGT were sourced by searching PubMed and Google Scholar databases until July 2019. Searches comprised the keywords: 'non-invasive'; 'cell-free DNA'; 'blastocentesis'; 'blastocoel fluid'; 'spent culture media'; 'embryo culture medium'; 'preimplantation genetic testing'; 'preimplantation genetic diagnosis'; 'preimplantation genetic screening'; and 'aneuploidy'.

OUTCOMES

Embryonic DNA is frequently detectable in BF and SCM of embryos produced during IVF treatment. Initial studies have achieved some success when performing cytogenetic and molecular genetic analysis. However, in many cases, the efficiency has been restricted by technical complications associated with the low quantity and quality of the DNA. Reported levels of ploidy agreement between SCM/BF samples and biopsied embryonic cells vary widely. In some cases, a discrepancy with respect to cytogenetic data obtained after trophectoderm biopsy may be attributable to embryonic mosaicism or DNA contamination (usually of maternal origin). Some research indicates that aneuploid cells are preferentially eliminated from the embryo, suggesting that their DNA might be over-represented in SCM and BF samples; this hypothesis requires further investigation.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS

Available data suggest that BF and SCM samples frequently provide DNA templates suitable for genetic analyses, offering a potential means of PGT that is less expensive than traditional methods, requires less micromanipulation skill and poses a lower risk to embryos. Critically, DNA isolation and amplification protocols must be optimised to reproducibly obtain an accurate clinical diagnosis, whilst minimising the impact of confounding factors such as contamination. Further investigations are required to understand the mechanisms underlying the release of embryonic DNA and to determine the extent to which this material reflects the true genetic status of the corresponding embryo. Currently, the clinic al potential of niPGT remains unknown.

Trophectoderm biopsy for preimplantation genetic test and technical tips: A review

BACKGROUND

Recently, the Japan Society of Obstetrics and Gynecology initiated a clinical study of preimplantation genetic test for aneuploidy. There will be a great need for a standardized embryo biopsy technique in Japan. However, the gold standard trophectoderm (TE) biopsy procedure has not been established, and this review outlines the clinical use of TE biopsy.

METHODS

Based on literature, the method and associated techniques for TE biopsy, a dissection method of TE cells from blastocysts, were investigated.

MAIN FINDINGS

Two TE biopsy methods are used, namely assisted hatching (herniating) and non-assisted hatching (direct suction); however, it is not clear which of these methods is superior. It is critical to understand whether the flicking or pulling method is beneficial.

CONCLUSION

Non-assisted hatching biopsy method may cause blastocyst collapse with a higher probability, and it may extend the biopsy time. The biopsy procedure should be performed within 3 minutes, and thus direct TE suction may have greater disadvantages. It is a fact that pulling method of TE dissection with laser pulse is simple; however, excess laser shots may induce a higher frequency of mosaicism. It is important to understand that each technique of TE biopsy has benefits and disadvantages.

Preimplantation Genetic Testing for Aneuploidy: A Review

Importance

Preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A) has undergone many technical developments over recent years, including changes in biopsy timings, methodology, and genetic analysis techniques. The evidence surrounding the efficaciousness of PGT-A is sporadic and inconsistent; as such, significant doubt and concern remain regarding its widespread implementation.

Objective

This review seeks to describe the historical development of PGT-A and to analyze and summarize the current published literature.

Conclusions

At times during its infancy, PGT-A failed to display conclusive improvements in results; with newer technologies, PGT-A appears to yield superior outcomes, including reductions in miscarriages and multiple gestations. Clinicians and patients should assess the use of PGT-A on a case-by-case basis, with laboratories encouraged to utilize blastocyst biopsy and next-generation sequencing when conducting PGT-A. Further studies providing cumulative live birth rates and time to live birth are required if PGT-A is to be proven as producing superior outcomes.

Relevance

PGT-A has the potential ability to impact in vitro fertilization success rates, and as it is increasingly adopted worldwide, it is crucial that clinicians are aware of the evidence for its continued use.

Preimplantation Genetic Testing: Where We Are Today

Background: Preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) is widely used today in in-vitro fertilization (IVF) centers over the world for selecting euploid embryos for transfer and to improve clinical outcomes in terms of embryo implantation, clinical pregnancy, and live birth rates. Methods: We report the current knowledge concerning these procedures and the results from different clinical indications in which PGT is commonly applied. Results: This paper illustrates different molecular techniques used for this purpose and the clinical significance of the different oocyte and embryo stage (polar bodies, cleavage embryo, and blastocyst) at which it is possible to perform sampling biopsies for PGT. Finally, genetic origin and clinical significance of embryo mosaicism are illustrated. Conclusions: The preimplantation genetic testing is a valid technique to evaluated embryo euploidy and mosaicism before transfer.

Preimplantation Genetic Testing for Chromosomal Abnormalities: Aneuploidy, Mosaicism, and Structural Rearrangements

There is a high incidence of chromosomal abnormalities in early human embryos, whether they are generated by natural conception or by assisted reproductive technologies (ART). Cells with chromosomal copy number deviations or chromosome structural rearrangements can compromise the viability of embryos; much of the naturally low human fecundity as well as low success rates of ART can be ascribed to these cytogenetic defects. Chromosomal anomalies are also responsible for a large proportion of miscarriages and congenital disorders. There is therefore tremendous value in methods that identify embryos containing chromosomal abnormalities before intrauterine transfer to a patient being treated for infertility—the goal being the exclusion of affected embryos in order to improve clinical outcomes. This is the rationale behind preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A) and structural rearrangements (-SR). Contemporary methods are capable of much more than detecting whole chromosome abnormalities (e.g., monosomy/trisomy). Technical enhancements and increased resolution and sensitivity permit the identification of chromosomal mosaicism (embryos containing a mix of normal and abnormal cells), as well as the detection of sub-chromosomal abnormalities such as segmental deletions and duplications. Earlier approaches to screening for chromosomal abnormalities yielded a binary result of normal versus abnormal, but the new refinements in the system call for new categories, each with specific clinical outcomes and nuances for clinical management. This review intends to give an overview of PGT-A and -SR, emphasizing recent advances and areas of active development.

Minimally Invasive Cell-Free Human Embryo Aneuploidy Testing (miPGT-A) Utilizing Combined Spent Embryo Culture Medium and Blastocoel Fluid -Towards Development of a Clinical Assay

Preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidies (PGT-A) using trophectoderm (TE) biopsy samples is labour intensive, invasive, and subject to sampling bias. In this study, we report on the efficacy and factors affecting accuracy of a technique we pioneered for minimally invasive preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (miPGT-A). Our technique uses cell-free embryonic DNA (cfeDNA) in spent embryo culture medium (SEM) combined with blastocoel fluid (BF) to increase the amount of assayable cfeDNA. We compared miPGT-A results (n = 145 embryos) with standard PGT-A analysis of the corresponding trophectoderm biopsy. We found that accuracy of miPGT was not related to blastocyst morphological grade. The overall concordance rate per sample for euploidy/aneuploidy status between miPGT-A and TE biopsy samples was 88/90 (97.8%), and was not different between good 47/48 (97.9%) and moderate/low quality blastocysts 41/42 (97.9%) (p > 0.05). Importantly, we also discovered that for cfeDNA analysis, the SurePlex whole genome amplification (WGA) kit can be utilized without an additional cell lysis/extraction DNA step; this efficiency likely reduces the risk of maternal contamination. Regarding origin of embryonic cfeDNA, the average amount of miPGT-A WGA-DNA we obtained from blastocysts with different morphological grades, as well as the size miPGT-A WGA-DNA fragments, suggest that it is unlikely that apoptosis and necrosis are only mechanisms of DNA release from the inner cell mass (ICM) and TE into BF and SEM.

The mechanisms and clinical application of mosaicism in preimplantation embryos

Embryos containing distinct cell lines are referred to as mosaic embryos, which are considered to be caused by mitotic errors in chromosome segregation during preimplantation development. As the accuracy and resolution of detection techniques improve, more and more mosaic embryos were identified recently. The impacts of mosaic embryos on survival and potential pregnancy outcome have been reported to be diverse in different studies. Because of the universality and clinical significance of mosaicism, it is essential to unravel the mechanisms and consequences with regard to this phenomenon in human pre- and post-implantation embryos. The purpose of this review is to explore the mechanisms, causes of mosaicism, and the development of pre- and post-implantation mosaic embryos in the light of recent emerging data, with the aim of providing new references for clinical applications.

Noninvasive preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy in spent medium may be more reliable than trophectoderm biopsy

Preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A) with trophectoderm (TE) biopsy is widely applied in in vitro fertilization (IVF) to identify aneuploid embryos. However, potential safety concerns regarding biopsy and restrictions to only those embryos suitable for biopsy pose limitations. In addition, embryo mosaicism gives rise to false positives and false negatives in PGT-A because the inner cell mass (ICM) cells, which give rise to the fetus, are not tested. Here, we report a critical examination of the efficacy of noninvasive preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (niPGT-A) in the spent culture media of human blastocysts by analyzing the cell-free DNA, which reflects ploidy of both the TE and ICM. Fifty-two frozen donated blastocysts with TE biopsy results were thawed; each of their spent culture medium was collected after 24-h culture and analyzed by next-generation sequencing (NGS). niPGT-A and TE-biopsy PGT-A results were compared with the sequencing results of the corresponding embryos, which were taken as true results for aneuploidy reporting. With removal of all corona-cumulus cells, the false-negative rate (FNR) for niPGT-A was found to be zero. By applying an appropriate threshold for mosaicism, both the positive predictive value (PPV) and specificity for niPGT-A were much higher than TE-biopsy PGT-A. Furthermore, the concordance rates for both embryo ploidy and chromosome copy numbers were higher for niPGT-A than TE-biopsy PGT-A. These results suggest that niPGT-A is less prone to errors associated with embryo mosaicism and is more reliable than TE-biopsy PGT-A.

Minimally invasive preimplantation genetic testing using blastocyst culture medium

STUDY QUESTION

Is minimally invasive chromosome screening (MICS) using blastocyst culture medium (BCM) sufficiently fast and accurate for preimplantation genetic testing (PGT)

SUMMARY ANSWER

A new assay for MICS, named MICS-Inst achieved high-resolution, comprehensive chromosome ploidy detection using BCM.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

BCM is a viable source of genomic DNA for use in PGT.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

Forty-one vitrified blastocysts donated by 22 couples known to carry a chromosome rearrangement and 21 vitrified blastocysts donated from 8 couples with normal karyotypes were used in this study. Good-quality blastocysts, defined as Day 5 and Day 6 embryos ≥ BB (AA, AB, BA, BB) based on the Gardner system were used for analysis. Recruitment took place from May 2018 to August 2018. We performed PGT for structural rearrangements (PGT-SR) on 41 BCM, trophectoderm (TE) biopsy and blastocyst-stage embryo (BE) samples as well as PGT for aneuploidies (PGT-A) on 21 BCM, TE biopsy and BE samples.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

We made several significant modifications to the BCM composition (mixing blastocoel fluid and spent blastocyst medium) as well as the pre-existing multiple annealing and looping-based amplification cycles (MALBAC) techniques and library generation procedures. The design of a quasilinear preamplification (Pre-AMP) primer and AMP primers 1 and 2 enables the preparation of a next-generation sequencing library after the exponential amplification stage by introducing the Illumina P5 and P7 primers into the final products, which are then ready for sequencing. Sequencing was performed on the Illumina Hiseq 2500 platform with 2.0 Mb raw reads generated for each sample.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

For PGT-A, BCM and TE biopsy samples showed 90% and 86% clinical concordance with the corresponding BE samples, respectively. In addition, both BCM and TE biopsy samples showed 76% karyotype concordance with the corresponding BE samples. For PGT-SR, we successfully obtained ploidy information for all 23 chromosomes with the exception of any rearrangements involving the Y chromosome. Both BCM and TE biopsy samples showed 100% clinical concordance with the corresponding BE samples in detecting chromosomal rearrangements. BCM and TE biopsy samples showed 90% and 100% karyotype concordance with the corresponding BE samples, respectively. Additionally, no statistically significant differences were detected in the aforementioned values of the BCM and TE biopsy samples in either PGT-A or PGT-SR (P > 0.05). Moreover, we achieved accurate quantification of segmental abnormalities using BCM samples. In addition, MICS-Inst reduced the number of steps required for library preparation through the use of new primer designs, resulting in an overall time reduction of 7.5 h. This time reduction allows for the performance of fresh blastocyst transfers.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

The main limitation is that BE, rather the inner cell mass, was used as the standard to evaluate the chromosome screening results.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

These results show that MICS-Inst is effective in procedure and precision for PGT, and that it is possible to achieve fresh blastocyst transfer following PGT. The implications are significant, as these findings may lead to minimally invasive PGT methods in the future.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 81671423 and No. 81402130), the National Key Research and Development Program of China (No. 2018YFC1003100), Liaoning Provincial Key Research and Development Program (No. 2018225090), the Fok Ying Tung Education Foundation (No. 151039) and Distinguished Talent Program of Shengjing Hospital (No. ME76). No competing interests declared.

Non-invasive pre-implantation genetic testing of human embryos: an emerging concept

The accurate genetic screening of pre-implantation embryos currently entails the use of technically challenging and biologically invasive biopsies of the human embryos. Investigating a more conservative sampling approach has emerged as a timely and desired alternative. Circulating cell-free embryonic DNA is present in the blastocoel fluid and spent culture media of blastocysts, and this has lately been sought as an attractive source of genetic information. The genetic analysis of cell-free embryonic DNA has been reported, to be useful in evaluating the genetic constitution of embryos; thus, providing a potential alternative to conventional biopsy-derived pre-implantation genetic testing (PGT). In this review, we have summarized these non-invasive alternative applications of PGT and discussed their current limitations and future clinical implications.

Current status of spent embryo media research for preimplantation genetic testing

In recent years, a growing body of literature has emerged investigating the clinical utility of spent embryo media (SEM) for preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A) (Hammond et al. in Fertil Steril. 107(1):220-8, 2017; Xu et al. in Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 113(42):11907-12, 2016; Shamonki et al. in Fertil Steril. 106(6):1312-8, 2016; Feichtinger et al. in Reprod BioMed Online. 34(6):583-9, 2017; Vera-Rodriguez et al. in Hum Reprod. 33(4):745-56, 2018; Kuznyetsov et al. in PLoS One. 13(5):e0197262, 2018; Ho et al. in Fertil Steril. 110(3):467-75, 2018; Capalbo et al. in Fertil Steril. 110(5):870-9, 2018). Most of these studies have reported moderate success rates, suggesting the need for improvements in sensitivity and specificity. The concordance between spent media and embryo biopsy or whole embryo was reported to be between 30.4 and 90%, with 50-70% correlation being the most representative (Xu et al. in Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 113(42):11907-12, 2016; Shamonki et al. in Fertil Steril. 106(6):1312-8, 2016; Feichtinger et al. in Reprod BioMed Online. 34(6):583-9, 2017; Vera-Rodriguez et al. in Hum Reprod. 33(4):745-56, 2018; Kuznyetsov et al. in PLoS One. 13(5):e0197262, 2018; Ho et al. in Fertil Steril. 110(3):467-75, 2018). Here, we will analyze all spent media testing strategies including SEM collection methods, whole genome amplification (WGA) strategies, chromosome copy number detection, and bioinformatics analysis tools. We will propose improvements to further increase the accuracy and sensitivity of the assay before bringing PGT-A with SEM into the clinical sphere.

Chromosome screening using culture medium of embryos fertilised in vitro: a pilot clinical study

BACKGROUND

Previous studies from this as well as other research groups suggested that non-invasive chromosome screening (NICS) with embryo culture medium can be used to identify chromosomal ploidy and chromosomal abnormalities. We here report a series of clinical cases utilizing the technology.

METHODS

A total of 45 couples underwent in vitro fertilisation during a period between February 2016 and February 2017. Karyotyping revealed normal chromosomes in both partners in 23 couples, and chromosomal rearrangements in at least one partner in 22 couples. Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) was used for fertilization. NICS was carried out using embryo culture medium at the blastocyst stage via multiple annealing and looping-based amplification cycles, whole-genome amplification and next-generation sequencing.

RESULTS

A total of 413 embryos were obtained; 170 blastocysts were subjected to NICS. The screening showed euploidy in 79 embryos, aneuploidy in 52 embryos, and mosaic ploidy for 33 embryos. The rate of euploidy was comparable in couples with normal karyotype (50.7%; 38/75) vs. chromosomal rearrangement (43.2%; 41/95). A total of 52 euploid embryos (50 oocyte retrieval cycles) were transferred in 43 women. Biochemical pregnancy rate was 72.0% (36/50). Clinical pregnancy rate was 58.0% (29/50). The rate of spontaneous miscarriage was 3/29 (none with chromosomal aneuploidy). A total of 27 healthy babies were delivered.

CONCLUSIONS

NICS could identify embryo chromosomal abnormalities in couples either with or without chromosomal rearrangement, with satisfying clinical outcomes.

In vitro fertilisation/intracytoplasmic sperm injection beyond 2020

Over 8 million babies have been born following IVF (in vitro fertilisation) and other artificial reproductive technology (ART) procedures since Louise Brown's birth 40 years ago. New innovations have added much complexity to both clinical and laboratory procedures over the last four decades. Translation of novel approaches from basic science into clinical practice continues unabated, widening the applicability of ART to new groups of people and helping improve both chances of healthy live birth and patient acceptability. However, the impact of ART on the health of both patients and their offspring continues to cause concern, and many ethical challenges created by new scientific developments in this field attract widely differing opinions. What is undeniable is that there will be a sustained global growth in utilisation of ART and that reproductive tourism will allow many people to access the treatment they desire notwithstanding national regulations that may forbid some approaches. The greatest challenge is to expand access to ART to those living in the less wealthy nations who are equally deserving of its benefits.

Blastocoel Fluid Biopsy

The identification of viable embryos for transfer is one of the main challenges in reproductive medicine. As chromosomal abnormalities are the major cause of implantation failure, preimplantation genetic testing of aneuploidy plays an important role in embryo selection. To make this approach more efficient, the possibility to retrieve informative DNA through a moderately invasive technique compared to the traditional forms of biopsy is appealing. Blastocoelic fluid is a valuable source of DNA. Its presence, as detected by whole genomic amplification, and the following analysis by comprehensive chromosome screening could add important information on the blastocyst ploidy condition and developmental potential.

Identification of extracellular vesicles and characterization of miRNA expression profiles in human blastocoel fluid

In this study, for the first time, we demonstrated the presence of microRNAs and extracellular vesicles in human blastocoel fluid. The bioinformatic and comparative analyses identified the biological function of blastocoel fluid microRNAs and suggested a potential role inside the human blastocyst. We found 89 microRNAs, expressed at different levels, able to regulate critical signaling pathways controlling embryo development, such as pluripotency, cell reprogramming, epigenetic modifications, intercellular communication, cell adhesion and cell fate. Blastocoel fluid microRNAs reflect the miRNome of embryonic cells and their presence, associated with the discovery of extracellular vesicles, inside blastocoel fluid, strongly suggests their important role in mediating cell communication among blastocyst cells. Their characterization is important to better understand the earliest stages of embryogenesis and the complex circuits regulating pluripotency. Moreover, blastocoel fluid microRNA profiles could be influenced by blastocyst quality, therefore, microRNAs might be used to assess embryo potential in IVF cycles.

Cumulus-corona gene expression analysis combined with morphological embryo scoring in single embryo transfer cycles increases live birth after fresh transfer and decreases time to pregnancy

PURPOSE

Clinical pregnancy rate after IVF with eSET stagnates between 30 and 40%. In order to increase pregnancy and live birth rates, multiple embryo transfer is still common practice. Providing additional non-invasive tools to choose the competent embryo for transfer could avoid multiple pregnancy and improve time to pregnancy. Cumulus mRNA analysis with quantitative PCR (QPCR) is a non-invasive approach. However, so far, no gene sets have been validated in prospective interventional studies.

METHODS

A prospective interventional single-center pilot study with two matched controls (day-3 and day-5 eSET) was performed in 96 patients consenting to the analysis of the cumulus-corona of their oocytes. All patients were super-ovulated for ICSI and eSET at day 3. All oocytes were denuded individually and cumulus was analyzed by quantitative PCR using three predictive genes (EFNB2, SASH1, CAMK1D) and two housekeeping genes (UBC and β2M). Patients (n = 62) with 2 or more day-3 embryos (good or excellent morphology) had their embryo chosen following the normalized expression of the genes.

RESULTS

Corona testing significantly increased the clinical pregnancy and live births rates (63% and 55%) compared to single embryo transfer (eSET) on day 3 (27% and 23%: p < 0.001) and day 5 (43% and 39%: p = 0.022 and p = 0.050) fresh transfer cycle controls with morphology-only selection. Time-to-pregnancy was significantly reduced, regardless of the number of good-quality embryos available on day 3.

CONCLUSION

Combining standard morphology scoring and cumulus/corona gene expression analysis increases day-3 eSET results and significantly reduces the time to pregnancy.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

This is not an RCT study and was only registered by the ethical committee of the University Hospital UZBRUSSEL of the Vrije Universiteit Brussel VUB (BUN: 143201318000).

Deoxyribonucleic acid detection in blastocoelic fluid: a new predictor of embryo ploidy and viable pregnancy

OBJECTIVE

To investigate blastocysts, defined as euploid and aneuploid by trophectoderm (TE) cell analysis, for the presence of DNA in the blastocoelic fluid (BF) detected by whole-genomic amplification (WGA); and to correlate the presence of DNA in BF with the clinical outcome after the transfer of TE-euploid blastocysts.

DESIGN

Retrospective study.

SETTING

In vitro fertilization unit.

PATIENT(S)

This study included 91 patients performing preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy on TE cells from January 2015 to December 2017. In the case of ET, only single blastocyst transfers were performed.

INTERVENTION(S)

Blastocoelic fluids and TE cells were retrieved from 256 blastocysts before vitrification. All blastocysts were diagnosed by array-comparative genomic hybridization (a-CGH) on TE cells. Amplification and a-CGH of DNA from BFs was performed at a later time after TE biopsy and ET.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Whole-genomic amplification of BFs, evaluation of the chromosome condition in BFs and TE cells, and correlation of BF results with the clinical outcome of TE-euploid transferred blastocysts.

RESULT(S)

The incidence of amplification after WGA was significantly lower in BFs from TE-euploid blastocysts (n = 32, 45%) when compared with the aneuploid ones (n = 150, 81%), resulting in 182 BFs with successful DNA amplification. When submitted to a-CGH, informative results were obtained from 172 BFs. Comparison of these results with those from the corresponding TE cells gave a ploidy concordance of 93.6% and a mean number of aneuploid events per sample that was higher in BFs than in TE cells (2.0 vs. 1.4, respectively). After the transfer of 53 TE-euploid blastocysts, the clinical pregnancy rate was 77% in the group with BF-failed amplification, and 37% after BF-successful amplification. The same trend was found for the ongoing pregnancy rate (68% vs. 31.5%, respectively).

CONCLUSION(S)

The presence of DNA in BFs detected by WGA is correlated with the blastocyst ploidy condition defined by TE cell biopsy and with the implantation potential of TE-euploid blastocysts. These findings could have a clinical implication for the selection of the most viable embryo for transfer because, after submitting BFs to WGA, priority would be given to TE-euploid blastocysts with BF-failed amplification. Similarly, BF-failed amplification could be an additional selection criterion to prioritize embryos for transfer even in conventional IVF cycles with blastocysts that were vitrified after BF aspiration.

Chromosomal analysis in IVF: just how useful is it?

Designed to minimize chances of genetically abnormal embryos, preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) involves in vitro fertilization (IVF), embryo biopsy, diagnosis and selective embryo transfer. Preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A) aims to avoid miscarriage and live born trisomic offspring and to improve IVF success. Diagnostic approaches include fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) and more contemporary comprehensive chromosome screening (CCS) including array comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH), quantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR), next-generation sequencing (NGS) and karyomapping. NGS has an improved dynamic range, and karyomapping can detect chromosomal and monogenic disorders simultaneously. Mosaicism (commonplace in human embryos) can arise by several mechanisms; those arising initially meiotically (but with a subsequent post-zygotic 'trisomy rescue' event) usually lead to adverse outcomes, whereas the extent to which mosaics that are initially chromosomally normal (but then arise purely post-zygotically) can lead to unaffected live births is uncertain. Polar body (PB) biopsy is the least common sampling method, having drawbacks including cost and inability to detect any paternal contribution. Historically, cleavage-stage (blastomere) biopsy has been the most popular; however, higher abnormality levels, mosaicism and potential for embryo damage have led to it being superseded by blastocyst (trophectoderm - TE) biopsy, which provides more cells for analysis. Improved biopsy, diagnosis and freeze-all strategies collectively have the potential to revolutionize PGT-A, and there is increasing evidence of their combined efficacy. Nonetheless, PGT-A continues to attract criticism, prompting questions of when we consider the evidence base sufficient to justify routine PGT-A? Basic biological research is essential to address unanswered questions concerning the chromosome complement of human embryos, and we thus entreat companies, governments and charities to fund more. This will benefit both IVF patients and prospective parents at risk of aneuploid offspring following natural conception. The aim of this review is to appraise the 'state of the art' in terms of PGT-A, including the controversial areas, and to suggest a practical 'way forward' in terms of future diagnosis and applied research.

Pushing the limits of detection: investigation of cell-free DNA for aneuploidy screening in embryos

OBJECTIVE

To determine the accuracy of cell-free DNA (cfDNA) in spent embryo medium (SEM) for ploidy and sex detection at the cleavage and blastocyst stages. To determine if assisted hatching (AH) and morphologic grade influence cfDNA concentration and accuracy.

DESIGN

Prospective cohort.

SETTING

Academic fertility center.

PATIENT(S)

Nine patients undergoing IVF; 41 donated two-pronuclei embryos and 20 embryos from patients undergoing preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A).

INTERVENTIONS(S)

In a donated embryo arm, SEM was collected on days 3 and 5, with one-half of the embryos undergoing AH before and one-half after. In a clinical arm, SEM was collected on day 5 before trophectoderm (TE) biopsy. Samples underwent PGT-A with the use of next-generation sequencing. cfDNA results were compared with corresponding whole embryos and TE biopsies.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Concordance rates, sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) for ploidy and sex detection with the use of cfDNA.

RESULT(S)

Of 141 samples, cfDNA was amplified in 39% and 80.4% of days 3 and 5 SEM, respectively. Concordances for ploidy and sex, respectively, were 56.3% and 81.3% between day 3 cfDNA and whole embryos, and 65% and 70% between day 5 cfDNA and TE biopsies. Day 5 cfDNA sensitivity and specificity for aneuploidy were 0.8 and 0.61, respectively. PPV and NPV were 0.47 and 0.88, respectively. Timing of AH and morphology did not influence cfDNA concentration or accuracy.

CONCLUSION(S)

cfDNA is detectable on days 3 and 5, but more accurate on day 5. Although our data suggest moderate concordance rates, PGT-A with the use of cfDNA must be further optimized before clinical implementation.