Growth hormone: in search of the Holy Grail for poor responders (or a felony)

A 10-Year Perspective on the Utility of Three Adjuvants Often Used in IVF: Growth Hormone, Melatonin and DHEA

Since 2010, numerous studies reported from PIVET, a pioneer IVF facility established over 40 years ago, have explored the use of three adjuvants designed to improve laboratory and clinical outcomes in cases where a poor prognosis has been demonstrated. The adjuvants reported commenced with recombinant growth hormone (rGH), followed by dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) after developing a unique troche to avoid the first-pass effect and, subsequently, melatonin. The studies show that rGH is beneficial in the situation where women have poor-quality embryos in the setting of additional poor prognosis factors, such as advanced female age, a very low ovarian reserve, an insulin growth factor profile in the lowest quartile or recurrent implantation failure. The studies also imply that the adjuvants may actually reduce live birth productivity rates if used on women without poor prognosis factors; hence, further studies, which can now be better designed, should be undertaken to explore the notion of underlying adult growth hormone deficiency in some cases as well as the suggestion that DHEA can provide equivalent benefits in some poor prognosis settings. Melatonin showed no suggestive benefits in any of the studies and can be excluded from consideration in this context. Future studies should compare rGH and DHEA with a focus on those women who have poor embryo quality with additional poor prognosis factors. Such trials should be extended to 12 weeks to cover the entire period of oocyte activation.