Changes in volatile composition during the processing and storage of black ripe olives

Comparative study of Spanish-style and natural cv. Chalkidiki green olives throughout industrial-scale spontaneous fermentation and 12-month storage: safety, nutritional and quality aspects

Table olives are among the most popular fermented foods and cv. Chalkidiki green table olives are particularly popular in both Greek and international markets. This work aimed at comparatively investigating the effect of processing method on the production of Spanish-style and natural cv. Chalkidiki green olives during fermentation and 12-month storage in brines with different chloride salts composition (NaCl, KCl, CaCl2) at industrial scale. All delivered products were safe with satisfactory color and texture characteristics. Employment of UPLC-HRMS revealed differences in metabolites' profile of polar extracts from olives and brines between the processing methods. Τhe application of alkali treatment drastically decreased the content of hydroxytyrosol and tyrosol in drupes, still an essential amount (1037-2012 and 385-885 mg/kg dry flesh, respectively) of these health-promoting phenolic compounds was retained in all products, even after storage. Noteworthy, fermentation of natural olives in brine (5 % NaCl) yielded in products with significantly lower Na levels in olive flesh (1.7 g/100 g), followed by Spanish-style olives fermented in low (4 %) and high (8 %) NaCl brines (2.7 and 5.2 g Na/100 g, respectively), supporting the efforts toward the establishment of table olives as functional food. Moreover, maslinic and oleanolic acids content was 1.5-2-fold higher in the natural table olives compared to the Spanish-style ones owing to the detrimental effect of alkali treatments. The processing method did not exert a differential effect on α-tocopherol content of olives. Sensory analysis indicated that all the final products were acceptable by consumers, with a slight preference for Spanish-style green olives fermented in brines with 50 % lower NaCl content. Present findings could be beneficial to the ongoing endeavor directed for the establishment of table olives as a source of bioactive compounds that concerns both industrial and scientific communities.

The Rising Role of Omics and Meta-Omics in Table Olive Research

Table olives are often the result of fermentation, a process where microorganisms transform raw materials into the final product. The microbial community can significantly impact the organoleptic characteristics and safety of table olives, and it is influenced by various factors, including the processing methods. Traditional culture-dependent techniques capture only a fraction of table olives' intricate microbiota, prompting a shift toward culture-independent methods to address this knowledge gap. This review explores recent advances in table olive research through omics and meta-omics approaches. Genomic analysis of microorganisms isolated from table olives has revealed multiple genes linked to technological and probiotic attributes. An increasing number of studies concern metagenomics and metabolomics analyses of table olives. The former offers comprehensive insights into microbial diversity and function, while the latter identifies aroma and flavor determinants. Although proteomics and transcriptomics studies remain limited in the field, they have the potential to reveal deeper layers of table olives' microbiome composition and functionality. Despite the challenges associated with implementing multi-omics approaches, such as the reliance on advanced bioinformatics tools and computational resources, they hold the promise of groundbreaking advances in table olive processing technology.

Effect of Calcium Salts on the Firmness and Physicochemical and Sensorial Properties of Iranian Black Olive Cultivars

Black olive has become one of the most prestigious olives processed in the olive industry, and its processing has been increased recently in different countries. The firmness of black olives may be changed by the processing methods, fermentation, and solution salts. In this study, the employment of CaCl2, Ca-acetate, and Ca-lactate during the processing of some Iranian black olive cultivars, including Mari, Zard, Rowghani, Shengeh, Dakal, Dezful, and Fishomi, was evaluated in terms of physicochemical and phenolic compounds and textural attributes. The results showed that Ca-lactate improved the firmness of the Mari cultivar from 1455 to 1765 N/100 g in the pitted olive, and the same trend was obtained for the other cultivars. Ca-acetate improved the black shiny color of the Mari cultivar from 4.36 to 4.85 and the sensorial properties of the black olives, including gustatory and kinesthetic sensations, were improved by using a Ca-lactate solution. The application of calcium salts in the salt-free preservation solutions imparted neither bitterness to the olives nor discoloration. The highest amounts of acid (1.42-1.56%), fructose to mannitol ratio (1-1.2), and phenolic compounds (955-963 mg/kg) were found for the Zard cultivar. Furthermore, the residual content of oleuropein was higher when CaCl2 was employed (357 mg/kg). All of the calcium salts improved the firmness of the black olives, although the maximum firmness was observed for the Ca-lactate. Consequently, the formation of a black shiny color is related to the diffusion of phenolic compounds; however, this needs further investigation to determine which kind of phenolic compound is responsible for its black color.

Burn Defect and Phenol Prediction for Flavoured Californian-Style Black Olives Using Digital Sensors

Californian-style black olives can undergo different chemical changes during the sterilization process that can affect their sensory and phenol characteristics. Thus, these olives were stuffed with flavoured hydrocolloids and submitted to different thermal sterilization treatments to assess sensory categories. The triangular test indicated that the panellists were able to discriminate between samples from different categories according to their aromas with more than 85% success. The results indicated that the negative aroma detected by tasters was related to burn defects. The highest level of defects was found in standard olives, while the lowest was identified in the extra category. Furthermore, olives submitted to the lowest thermal sterilization treatment (extra) presented significantly higher phenol profile content, such as for hydroxytyrosol, tyrosol, oleuropein and procyanidin B1. The electronic nose (E-nose) discriminated between samples from different categories according to the specific aroma (PC1 = 82.1% and PC2 = 15.1%). The PLS-DA classified the samples with 90.9% accuracy. Furthermore, the volatile organic compounds responsible for this discrimination were creosol, copaene, benzaldehyde and diallyl disulphide. Finally, the models established by the PLS analysis indicated that the E-nose could predict olives according to their aroma and total phenol profile (RCV2 values were 0.89 and 0.92, respectively). Thus, this device could be used at the industrial level to discriminate between olives with different sensory aromas to determine those with the highest quality.

E-Nose Discrimination of Almond Oils Extracted from Roasted Kernels

Almonds contain around 50% fat with a health-promoting fatty acid profile that can be extracted by pressing to obtain high-quality oils. To improve oil sensory properties, the almonds can be subjected to roasting treatments before oil extraction. However, intense thermal treatments may cause the appearance of undesirable volatile compounds causing unpleasant aromas. Thus, oils from almonds subjected to different roasting treatments (30, 45, 60 and 90 min at 150 °C) were analyzed from sensory and the chemical points of view. In addition, an electronic device (E-nose) was used in order to evaluate its usefulness in discriminating samples according to their aromas. The almonds’ roasting treatments caused changes in the sensory properties, since defects such as a burned, dry smell or wood fragrance appeared when almonds were subjected to roasting treatments (>45 min). These data agree with the analysis of volatile compounds, which showed an increase in the content of aldehyde and aromatic groups in roasted almonds oils while alcohols and terpenes decreased. Partial least squares discriminant analysis and partial least squares obtained from the E-nose were able to classify samples (97.5% success) and quantify the burned defect of the oils (Rp2 of 0.88), showing that the E-nose can be an effective tool for classifying oils.

Masking Effect of Cassia grandis Sensory Defect with Flavoured Stuffed Olives

Carao (Cassia grandis) is an America native plant characterized by its high iron content. This particular property allows its use as a natural additive to fix the black colour in California-style black olives, while masking its unpleasant aroma by stuffing olives with flavoured hydrocolloid. The tasting panel evaluated olives filled with unflavoured hydrocolloid with a fruity aroma, classified them as an extra category. Olives with the Carao addition presented a positive aroma, but also showed negative sensory attributes such as cheese, fermented and metallic flavours/aromas. The aroma of lyophilized Carao was better than the fresh one. The ‘Mojo picón’ aroma masked defective olives, allowing their classification from the second to the first commercial category. The volatile compounds belonged to the following families: terpenes, hydrocarbons, and oxygenated compounds, while the minor ones were alcohols and acid derivatives. The main volatile compounds identified were dialyl disulphide and 3-methyl-butanoic acid; among the minor ones were 2,4-dimethyl-hexane and dimethyl-silanediol and nonanal. Addition of fresh Carao increased the unpleasant aroma provoked by 3-methyl-butanoic acid, 2-methyl-butanoic acid and (E)-2-Decenal. Finally, an electronic device was able to discriminate these aromas and the results obtained agreed with those of the tasting panel and the volatile compounds.

Determination of the Masking Effect of the ‘Zapateria’ Defect in Flavoured Stuffed Olives Using E-Nose

Spanish-style table olives are one of the most common processed foods in the Mediterranean countries. Lack of control during fermentation can lead to one of the main defects of the olive, called ‘Zapateria’, caused by the combination of volatile fatty acids reminiscent of rotten leather. In this study, table olives altered with ‘Zapateria’ defect were stuffed with a hydrocolloid flavoured with the aroma ‘Mojo picón’ to improve consumer acceptance. Sensory analysis, determination of volatile compounds and electronic nose (E-nose) were used to evaluate the quality of the olives. The control samples had a high concentration of the defect ‘Zapateria’ and were classified in the second commercial category, while higher ‘Mojo picón’ flavour concentrations resulted in these olives being classified as ‘extra category’ (a masking effect). The main volatile compounds in olives with ‘Zapateria’ defect were cyclohexanecarboxylic acid and pentanoic acid. E-nose allowed discrimination between stuffed olives without added flavouring and olives with ‘Mojo picón’ flavouring at different concentrations. Finally, PLS regression allowed a predictive linear model to be established between E-nose and sensory analysis values. The RP2 values were 0.74 for perceived defect and 0.86 for perceived aroma. The E-nose was successfully applied for the first time to classify Spanish-style table olives with ‘Zapateria’ defect intensity and with the addition of the ‘Mojo picón’ aroma masking the defect.

Application of Electronic Nose to Discriminate Species of Mold Strains in Synthetic Brines

The chemical composition of the brine for Spanish-style table olives plays a crucial role during the fermentation process. Traditional laboratory analysis requires a high consumption of reagents, highly qualified personnel, sophisticated equipment, long analysis times, and large amounts of samples. Analysis carried out using an electronic nose (E-nose) offers an alternative, non-destructive technique and is useful in determining alterations in brines caused by microorganisms. In the present research, nine mold strains isolated from spoiled olives were inoculated in synthetic brines to determine the effect of microbial development on sensory quality, volatile profile, and the capacity of E-nose to discriminate altered brines from the healthy ones. The brines inoculated with the mold strains presented negative attributes related to aromas of mold, wood, leather, rancidity and, organic solvents among others. The highest intensity of defect was presented by the brines inoculated with the strains Galactomyces geotricum (G.G.2); three Penicillium expansum (P.E.3, P.E.4, and P.E.20); one Penicillium glabrum (P.G.19); three Aspergillus flavus (A.F.9, A.F.18, and A.F.21); and one Fusarium solani (F.S.11). A total of 19 volatile compounds were identified by gas chromatography. Sensory analysis allowed us to classify the synthetic brines based on the degree of alteration produced by the mold strains used. Also, the E-nose data were able to discriminate the inoculated brines regardless of the intensity of the defect. These results demonstrate the capacity of the E-nose to discriminate alterations in brines produced by molds, thereby making it a useful tool to be applied during the elaboration process to detect early alterations in table olive fermentation.

Electronic nose application for the discrimination of sterilization treatments applied to Californian-style black olive varieties

BACKGROUND

Olive oil continues to be the main destination for olives. The production of table olives is increasing. 'Californian-style' processes are among the most frequently employed to produce oxidized olives. Sensory evaluation requires the development of an instrumental detection method that can be used as an adjunct to traditional tasting panels.

RESULTS

An electronic nose (E-nose) was used to classify two varieties of olives following exposure to different sterilization. Principal component analysis (PCA) revealed that both varieties had different volatile profiles. Sensory panel evaluations were similar for both. Partial least squares-discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) obtained from the E-nose was able to separate the two varieties and explained 82% of total variance. Moreover, volatile profiles correctly classified olives according to sterilization times recorded up to 121 °C . The only exception was at F₀  ≥ 22 min, at which a plot of PCA outcomes failed to differentiate scores. E-nose data showed similar results to those produced from the volatile analysis when grouping samples were sterilized to F₀  ≥ 18 min, at the same time distinguishing these samples from those subjected to less intense thermal treatments. A partial least squares (PLS) chemometric approach was evaluated for quantifying important olive quality parameters. With regards to validation parameters, R P 2 pertaining to perceived defect was 0.88, whilst R P 2 pertaining to overall assessment was 0.78.

CONCLUSIONS

E-nose offers a fast, inexpensive and non-destructive method for discriminating between varieties and thermal treatments up to a point at which cooking defects are highly similar (from F₀  = 18 onwards). © 2021 Society of Chemical Industry.

Characterization of Polyphenol and Volatile Fractions of Californian-Style Black Olives and Innovative Application of E-nose for Acrylamide Determination

Californian-style black olives require a sterilization treatment that produces a carcinogenic contaminant, acrylamide. Thus, this compound was evaluated in two different olive cultivars using an electronic nose (E-nose). The sterilization intensity had a significant influence on the final phenol concentrations, acrylamide content, and volatile compounds. Increasing the sterilization intensity from 10 to 26 min (F0) reduced the phenol content, but it promoted acrylamide synthesis, leading to a wide range of this toxic substance. The Ester and phenol groups of volatile compounds decreased their content when the sterilization treatment increased; however, aldehyde and other volatile compound groups significantly increased their contents according to the thermal treatments. The compounds 4-ethenyl-pyridine, benzaldehyde, and 2,4-dimethyl-hexane are volatile compounds with unpleasant odours and demonstrated a high amount of influence on the differences found after the application of the thermal treatments. The “Manzanilla Cacereña” variety presented the highest amount of phenolic compounds and the lowest acrylamide content. Finally, it was found that acrylamide content is correlated with volatile compounds, which was determined using multiple linear regression analysis (R² = 0.9994). Furthermore, the aroma of table olives was analysed using an E-nose, and these results combined with Partial Least Square (PLS) were shown to be an accurate method (range to error ratio (RER) >10 and ratio of performance to deviation (RPD) >2.5) for the indirect quantification of this toxic substance.

E-Nose Discrimination of Abnormal Fermentations in Spanish-Style Green Olives

Current legislation in Spain indicates that table olives must be free of off-odors and off-flavors and without symptoms of ongoing alteration or abnormal fermentations. In this regard, the International Olive Council (IOC) has developed a protocol for the sensory classification of table olives according to the intensity of the predominantly perceived defect (PPD). An electronic nose (e-nose) was used to assess the abnormal fermentation defects of Spanish-style table olives that were previously classified by a tasting panel according to the IOC protocol, namely zapateria, butyric, putrid, and musty or humidity. When olives with different defects were mixed, the putrid defect had the greatest sensory impact on the others, while the butyric defect had the least sensory dominance. A total of 49 volatile compounds were identified by gas chromatography, and each defect was characterized by a specific profile. The e-nose data were analyzed using principal component analysis (PCA) and partial least square discriminant analysis (PLS-DA). The different defects were clearly separated from each other and from the control treatment, independently of PPD intensity. Moreover, the e-nose differentiated control olives from table olives with combined sensory defects despite the dilution effect resulting from the combination. These results demonstrate that e-nose can be used as an olfactory sensor for the organoleptic classification of table olives and can successfully support the tasting panel.

Volatile Composition of Industrially Fermented Table Olives from Greece

Table olives represent one of the most important fermented products in Greece. Their highly appreciated flavor is directly associated with the volatile composition. However, extensive data on the volatile profile of table olives from Greek cultivars are scarce in the literature. For this reason, the volatile components of industrially fermented table olives from Kalamata, Conservolea and Halkidiki cultivars grown in different geographical areas within Greece were determined using headspace solid-phase microextraction combined with gas chromatography–mass spectrometry. More than 100 volatile compounds were identified and distributed over different chemical classes. All samples were rich in esters, alcohols and acids, whereas the samples of cv. Halkidiki were also characterized by increased levels of volatile phenols. Both qualitative and quantitative differences were observed, which resulted in the discrimination of the table olives according to olive cultivar and growing location. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first systematic study on the volatile profiles of table olives from Greek cultivars that also highlights the pronounced effect of olives’ growing location.

Aroma profile and volatile composition of black ripe olives (Manzanilla and Hojiblanca cultivars)

The aroma profile and volatile composition of 8 samples of black ripe olives from Manzanilla and Hojiblanca cultivars were analyzed with the aim to characterize this type of table olive. The aroma of samples was described by a sensory panel using quantitative descriptive analysis (QDA), whereas the volatiles were analyzed by headspace solid-phase microextraction (HS-SPME) followed by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS). Eleven odor descriptors (briny, sautéed mushroom, earthy/soil-like, oak barrel, nutty, artificial fruity/floral, natural fruity/floral, vinegary, alcohol, fishy/ocean-like, and cheesy) were evaluated, of which only one descriptor (briny) showed a significant difference between cultivars. A total of 74 volatile compounds were identified in the headspace of samples, of which 12 were identified as significant volatiles contributing to the discrimination between Manzanilla and Hojiblanca black ripe olives. Partial least squares (PLS) regression was able to predict one odor descriptor (nutty) with sufficient accuracy and allowed identifying the volatiles that highly contributed to three odor descriptors of black ripe olives (nutty, natural fruity/floral, and cheesy).