Evidence of exposure to organophosphorus toxicants by detection of the propionylated butyrylcholinesterase-derived nonapeptide-adduct as a novel biomarker

Study on phosphonylation and modification characteristics of organophosphorus nerve agents on multi-species and multi-source albumins

Protein adducts are vital targets for exploring organophosphorus nerve agents (OPNAs) exposure and identification, that can be used to characterize the chemical burden and initiate chemical safety measures. However, the use of protein adducts as biomarkers of OPNA exposure has developed slowly. To further promote the development of biomarkers in chemical forensics, it is crucial to expand the range of modified peptides and active sites, and describe the characteristics of OPNA adducts at specific reaction sites. This study utilized multi-species and multi-source albumins as the protein targets. We identified 56 peptides in albumins from various species (including human, horse, rat and pig), that were modified by at least two OPNAs. Diverse modification characteristics were observed in response to certain agents: including (1) multiple sites on the same peptide modified by one or more agents, (2) different reactivities at the same site in homologous albumins, and (3) different preferences at the same active sites associated with differences in the biological matrix during exposure. Our studies provided an empirical reference with rationalized underpinnings supported by estimated conformation energetics through molecular modeling. We employed different peptide markers for detection of protein adducts, as (one would do) in forensic screening for identification and quantification of chemical damage. Three characteristic peptides were screened and analyzed in human albumin, including Y287ICENQDSISSK, K438VPQVS443TPTLVEVSR, and Y162LY164EIAR. Stable fragment ions with neutral loss were found from their tandem MS/MS spectra, which were used as characteristic ions for identification and extraction of modified peptides in enzymatic digestion mixtures. Coupling these observations with computer simulations, we found that the structural stability of albumin and albumin-adduct complexes (as well as the effective force that promotes stability of different adducts) changes in the interval before and after adduct formation. In pig albumin, five active peptides existed stably in vivo and in vitro. Most of them can be detected within 30 min after OPNA exposure, and the detection window can persist about half a month. These early findings provided the foundation and rationale for utilizing pig albumin as a sampling target for rapid analysis in future forensic work.

Progressive expansion of albumin adducts for organophosphorus nerve agent traceability based on single and group adduct collection

Protein adducts are important biological targets for traceability of organophosphorus nerve agents (OPNAs). Currently, the recognized biomarkers that can be used in actual samples in the field of chemical forensics only include Y411 in albumin and the active nonapeptide in butyrylcholinesterase (BChE). To explore stable and reliable protein adducts and increase the accuracy of OPNAs traceability further, we gradually expanded OPNAs-albumin adducts based on single and group adduct collection. Several stable peptides were found via LC-MS/MS analysis in human serum albumin (HSA) exposed to OPNAs in a large exposure range. These adducts were present in HSA samples exposed to OPNAs of each concentration, which provided data support for the reliability and stability of using adducts to trace OPNAs. Meanwhile, the formation mechanism of OPNAs-cysteine adduct was clarified via computer simulations. Then, these active sites found and modified peptides were used as raw materials for progressive expansion of albumin adducts. We constructed an OPNAs-HSA adducts group, in which a specific agent is the exposure source, and three or more active peptides constitute data sets for OPNAs traceability. Compared with single or scattered protein adducts, the OPNAs-HSA adduct group improves OPNAs identification by mutual verification using active peptides or by narrowing the identity range of the exposure source. We also determined the minimum detectable concentration of OPNAs for the adduct group. Two or more peptides can be detected when there is an exposure of 50 times the molar excess of OPNAs in relation to HSA. This improved the accuracy of OPNAs exposure and identity confirmation. A collection of OPNAs-albumin adducts was also examined. The collection was established by collecting, classifying, and integrating the existing albumin adducts according to the species to which each albumin belongs, the types of agents, and protease. This method can serve as a reference for discovering new albumin adducts, characteristic phosphonylated peptides, and potential biomarkers. In addition, to avoid a false negative for OPNAs traceability using albumin adducts, we explored OPNAs-cholinesterase adducts because cholinesterase is more reactive with OPNAs than albumin. Seven active peptides in red blood cell acetylcholinesterase (RBC AChE) and serum BChE can assist in OPNAs exposure and identity confirmation.

The phosphylated butyrylcholinesterase-derived tetrapeptide GlyGluSerAla proves exposure to organophosphorus agents with enantioselectivity

We herein present for the first time the phosphylated (*) tetrapeptide (TP)-adduct GlyGluSer198*Ala generated from butyrylcholinesterase (BChE) with proteinase K excellently suited for the verification of exposure to toxic organophosphorus nerve agents (OPNA). Verification requires bioanalytical methods mandatory for toxicological and legal reasons. OPNA react with BChE by phosphonylation of the active site serine residue (Ser198) forming one of the major target protein adducts for verification. After its enzymatic cleavage with pepsin, the nonapeptide (NP) PheGlyGluSer*AlaGlyAlaAlaSer is typically produced as biomarker. Usually OPNA occur as racemic mixtures of phosphonic acid derivatives with the stereocenter at the phosphorus atom, e.g. (±)-VX. Both enantiomers react with BChE, but the adducted NP does not allow their chromatographic distinction. In contrast, the herein introduced TP-adducts appeared as two peaks when using a stationary reversed phase (1.8 µm) in micro-liquid chromatography-electrospray ionisation tandem-mass spectrometry (µLC-ESI MS/MS) analysis. These two peaks represent diastereomers of the (+)- and (-)-OPNA adducted to the peptide that comprises chiral L-amino acids exclusively. Concentration- and time-dependent effects of adduct formation with (±)-VX and its pure enantiomers (+)- and (-)-VX as well as with (±)-cyclosarin (GF) were investigated in detail characterising enantioselective adduct formation, stability, ageing and spontaneous reactivation. The method was also successfully applied to samples from a real case of pesticide poisoning as well as to samples of biomedical proficiency tests provided by the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons.

Current Progress for Retrospective Identification of Nerve Agent Biomarkers in Biological Samples after Exposure

Organophosphorus neurotoxic agents (OPNAs) seriously damage the nervous system, inhibiting AChE activity and threatening human health and life. Timely and accurate detection of biomarkers in biomedical samples is an important means for identifying OPNA exposure, helping to recognize and clarify its characteristics and providing unambiguous forensic evidence for retrospective research. It is therefore necessary to summarize the varieties of biomarkers, recognize their various characteristics, and understand the principal research methods for these biomarkers in the retrospective detection of OPNA exposure. Common biomarkers include mainly intact agents, degradation products and protein adducts. Direct agent identification in basic experimental research was successfully applied to the detection of free OPNAs, however, this method is not applicable to actual biomedical samples because the high reactivity of OPNAs promotes rapid metabolism. Stepwise degradation products are important targets for retrospective research and are usually analyzed using a GC–MS, or an LC–MS system after derivatization. The smaller window of detection time requires that sampling be accomplished within 48 h, increasing the obstacles to determining OPNA exposure. For this reason, the focus of retrospective identification of OPNA exposure has shifted to protein adducts with a longer lifetime. Compared to the fluoride-induced reactivation method, which cannot be used for aged adducts, digestive peptide analysis is the more elegant method for detecting various adducts, identifying more active sites, exploring potential biomarkers and excavating characteristic ions. Retrospective identification of biomarkers after OPNA poisoning is of primary importance, providing unambiguous evidence for forensic analysis in actual cases and judgment of chemical accidents. At present, degradation products, the nonapeptide from BChE adducts and Y411 from human serum adducts are used successfully in actual cases of OPNA exposure. However, more potential biomarkers are still in the discovery stage, which may prove inconclusive. Therefore, there is an urgent need for research that screens biomarker candidates with high reactivity and good reliability from the potential candidates. In addition, mass spectrometry detection with high resolution and reactivity and an accurate data processing system in the scanning mode must also be further improved for the retrospective identification of unknown agents.

Simultaneous quantification of multiple amino acid adducts from sulfur mustard-modified human serum albumin in plasma at trace exposure levels by ultra-high performance liquid chromatography-triple quadrupole mass spectrometry after propionyl derivatization

Sulfur mustard (HD) is a highly toxic vesicant and is prohibited by the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW). HD can modify human serum albumin (HSA) to generate hydroxyethylthioethyl (HETE) adducts, which could be utilized as biomarkers for verifying HD exposure in forensic analysis. Here, five amino acid adducts generated from pronase digestion of HD-exposed human serum albumin (HD-HSA) in plasma were selected as biomarkers to retrospectively detect HD exposure. HD-HSA was precipitated from plasma with acetone, digested by pronase, derivatized with propionic anhydride (PA), and analysed with ultra-high performance liquid chromatography coupled with triple quadrupole mass spectrometry (UHPLC-TQ MS). The limits of detection (LODs) and limits of quantification (LOQs) of the HD exposure concentrations were evaluated as 1.00 ng/mL at S/N≥3 and 3.00 ng/mL at S/N≥10, respectively, which are approximately 60 times lower than those of the reported method. The approach shows good linearity (R²≥0.997) from 3.00 ng/mL to 10.0 µg/mL of HD-exposed human plasma with satisfactory precision and accuracy. The developed approach was applied to analysing samples from the 6^th OPCW Biomedical Proficiency Test (BioPT). The study showed that the developed approach was also suitable for analysing human plasma samples that were exposed to six of HD analogues, which were common impurities in sulfur mustard mixtures. Moreover, the method was successfully applied to plasma from other species, including rabbits, rats and cattle. This study provides a reliable and sensitive tool for the retrospective detection of vesicants exposure based on multiple biomarkers.

Alkylated glutamic acid and histidine derived from protein-adducts indicate exposure to sulfur mustard in avian serum

Sulfur mustard (SM, bis(2-chloroethyl)-sulfide) is a banned chemical warfare agent deployed in the violent conflict in the Middle East poisoning humans and animals. For legal reasons bioanalytical methods are mandatory proving exposure to SM. Reaction products (adducts) of SM with endogenous proteins e.g., serum albumin (SA) are valuable long-lived targets for analysis. Whereas nearly all methods known so far focus on human proteins, we address for the first time neat chicken SA and avian serum from chicken, duck and ostrich. After proteolysis, protein precipitation, evaporation of the supernatant and re-dissolution analysis was performed by micro liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization tandem-mass spectrometry in the selected reaction monitoring mode, μLC-ESI MS/MS (SRM), for detection of the hydroxyethylthioethyl product ion [HETE]⁺ at m/z 105.0. After in vitro incubation with SM and pronase-catalyzed proteolysis the alkylated amino acids Glu(-HETE) and His(-HETE) were detected. Both borne the SM-characteristic HETE-moiety bound to their side chain. The 8-fold deuterated SM analogue (d8-SM) was also applied to support adduct identification. Proteolysis conditions were optimized with respect to pH (8.0), temperature (50°C) and time to maximize the yield of Glu(-HETE) (30 min) and His(-HETE) (180 min). Amino acid adducts were stable in the autosampler for at least 24 h. Protein-adducts were stable in serum at -30°C for at least 33 d and for three freeze-and-thaw cycles. At the body temperature of chicken (+40°C) Glu(-HETE) was degraded in serum (period of half-change 3 d) whereas His(-HETE) remained stable. The presented method broadens the toolbox of procedures to document poisoning with SM.

Nontargeted High-Resolution Mass Spectrometric Workflow for the Detection of Butyrylcholinesterase-Derived Adducts with Organophosphorus Toxicants and Structural Characterization of Their Phosphyl Moiety after In-Source Fragmentation

Organophosphorus (OP) nerve agents were used for chemical warfare, assassination, and attempted murder of individuals. Therefore, forensic methods are required to identify known and unknown incorporated OP poisons. Serum is tested for the presence of covalent reaction products (adducts) of the toxicant with, e.g., butyrylcholinesterase (BChE) typically by targeted analysis, thus only detecting known OP adducts. We herein present a nontargeted two-step mass spectrometry (MS)-based workflow taking advantage of a high-resolution (HR) Orbitrap mass spectrometer and its option for in-source collision-induced dissociation (IS-CID) highly valuable for the detection of unknown agents. BChE adducts are extracted by immunomagnetic separation and proteolyzed with pepsin yielding a phosphylated nonapeptide (NP) biomarker NP(OP). In step 1, the sample is separated by micro liquid chromatography (μLC) detecting the NP(OP) by nontargeted HR MS followed by data-dependent tandem-MS (ddMS2). Extracted ion chromatograms of diagnostic product ions at m/z 778.33661, 673.29402, and 602.25690 reveal the accurate mass of the NP(OP) precursor ion as well as the elemental composition of the adducted phosphyl moiety. Considering this information, a second μLC run is performed (step 2) for nonselective IS-CID of NP(OP) yielding the cleaved charged phosphyl moiety. This fragment ion is immediately subjected to targeted CID in parallel reaction monitoring (PRM). The accurate mass of its product ions allows the determination of their elemental composition and thus supports its structural elucidation. The described workflow was exemplarily applied to NP(OP) of three Tamelin esters and VX providing highly appropriate abilities for the detection of adducts even of unknown OP poisons like Novichok agents.