Arthroscopic excision of ganglion cysts

Ganglions in the Hand and Wrist: Advances in 2 Decades

Ganglion cysts represent the most common soft-tissue mass in the hand and wrist. Ganglion cysts are most commonly encountered at the dorsal or volar aspects of the wrist, although cysts may arise from the flexor tendon sheath, interphalangeal joint, and extensor tendons. Intraosseous and intraneural ganglion cysts have also been described. Diagnosis of ganglion cysts relies primarily on history and physical examination. Transillumination and aspiration of masses may be useful adjuncts to diagnosis. Imaging such as radiography and ultrasonography may be indicated to evaluate for associated conditions, such as degenerative joint disease, or to rule out a solid or heterogeneous mass. Advanced imaging such as MRI is generally reserved for patients in whom occult ganglions, intraosseous ganglions, or solid tumors, including sarcoma, remain a concern. Treatment of ganglion cysts includes observation, aspiration or puncture with possible corticosteroid injection, and surgical excision. Nonsurgical management may result in cyst resolution in over 50% of patients. Surgical excision is associated with recurrence rates of 7% to 39%. Advances in surgical techniques have allowed surgeons to conduct arthroscopic ganglion excision, with recurrence rates similar to those of open management. This study highlights the advances in diagnosis, treatment, and outcomes that have taken place over the past 2 decades for this common condition affecting the hand and wrist in the adult population.

Recurrence of Ganglion Cysts Following Re-excision

Background

The recurrence of ganglion cysts after surgical excision has a reported rate of 4% to 40%. Recurrence rate after revision surgical excision is unknown. The purpose of this study was to define the incidence of recurrent ganglion cysts in patients who underwent a secondary excision procedure.

Methods

With Institutional Review Board approval, we retrospectively identified by CPT code and reviewed charts of patients who had recurrent ganglion cyst excision performed over a five-year period (2010 - 2014). Recurrence was defined as reappearance of a cyst in the same area as it was previously. Demographic information including recurrences and revision surgeries was collected in addition to outcome variables such as patient satisfaction, pain levels, and functional limitations.

Results

Out of the 42 revision cases identified 20 patients were reached. Mean time to recurrence of the cyst after the first ganglion cyst excision was 2.5 years (range: 1 month - 12 years). After the second ganglion cyst excision, three patients (15%) had a recurrence, each occurring within one year (mean: 11 months; range: 9-12). One of the three patients underwent a third successful ganglion cyst excision. The other two patients declined surgical intervention to date. Patients without a second recurrence (n=17) reported an average pain score of 0.1 (range: 0-2) on a scale of 1-10. Three (18%) reported some difficulty with day-to-day activities due to their scar. Seven (41%) patients reported at least transient numbness or tingling. Mean satisfaction was 9.8 on a scale of 1-10, and 100% reported that they would undergo another ganglion cyst excision should they ever have another recurrence.

Conclusion

Patients should be advised about the risk of recurrence after re-excision of ganglion cysts, which was noted to be 15% in our cohort. This rate of recurrence is similar to that of primarily excised cysts.

Cost Minimization Analysis of Ganglion Cyst Excision

PURPOSE

Cost minimization analysis can be employed to determine the least costly option when multiple treatments lead to equivalent outcomes. We present a cost minimization analysis from the payers' perspective, of the direct per patient cost of arthroscopic versus open ganglion cyst excision. We tested the null hypothesis that there is no difference in cost between the 2 procedures from the payer perspective.

METHODS

We utilized data from a private payer administrative claims database comprising 16 million individuals from 2007 to 2015. Using Current Procedural Terminology codes to identify open and arthroscopic ganglion excisions, we extracted demographic data and fees paid to providers and facilities for the procedure.

RESULTS

We identified 5,119 patients undergoing open ganglion cyst excision and 20 patients undergoing arthroscopic ganglion excision. The average cost of an open excision was significantly lower than an arthroscopic excision ($1,821 vs $3,668).

CONCLUSIONS

Surgical costs from arthroscopic ganglion excision are significantly more than open excision. This data can inform health systems participating in value-based models.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Economic and Decision Analysis IV.