Association between continuity of care and emergency department visits and hospitalization in senior adults with asthma-COPD overlap

The Influence of Provider Connectedness on Continuity of Care and Hospital Readmissions in Patients With COPD: A Claims Data Based Social Network Study

Background

Hospital readmission rates are very high in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Continuity of care (CoC) with general practitioners (GPs) and ambulatory specialists can impact readmission rates. This study aimed to identify shared patient networks of ambulatory care physicians and to examine the effect of provider connectedness on CoC and hospital readmissions.

Methods

A retrospective observational study was conducted in claims data from the years 2016 to 2018 in patients with COPD (aged 40 years or older; hospital stay in 2017). Linkages between GPs, pneumologists, and cardiologists were determined on the basis of shared patients. Multilevel regression models were used to analyze the impact of provider connectedness, operationalized by several social network characteristics, on continuity of care (sequential continuity [SECON] index) and hospital readmission rates.

Results

A total of 7294 patients linked to 3673 GPs were available for analysis. Closeness centrality (β=- 0.029) and the external-internal (EI)-index (β =0.037) impacted on the SECON index. The EI-index (odds ratio [OR]=1.25) and degree centrality (OR=1.257) impacted 30-day readmission. Network density (OR=0.811) and the SECON index (OR=1.121) affected the likelihood of a 90-day readmission. None of the predictors had a significant impact on 180-day and 365-day readmissions.

Conclusions

Ambulatory care providers' connectedness showed some effects on hospital readmissions and CoC in patients with COPD up to 90 days after hospital discharge, but the additional predictive power is limited.

Measuring the Value Functions of Primary Care: Physician-Level Continuity of Care Quality Measure

PURPOSE

Care continuity is foundational to the clinician/patient relationship; however, little has been done to operationalize continuity of care (CoC) as a clinical quality measure. The American Board of Family Medicine developed the Primary Care CoC clinical quality measure as part of the Measures That Matter to Primary Care initiative.

METHODS

Using 12-month Optum Clinformatics Data Mart claims data, we calculated the Bice-Boxerman Continuity of Care Index for each patient, which we rolled up to create an aggregate, physician-level CoC score. The physician quality score is the percent of patients with a Bice-Boxerman Index ≥0.7 (70%). We tested validity in 2 ways. First, we explored the validity of using 0.7 as a threshold for patient CoC within the Optum claims database to validate its use for reflecting patient-level continuity. Second, we explored the validity of the physician CoC measure by examining its association with patient outcomes. We assessed reliability using signal-to-noise methodology.

RESULTS

Mean performance on the measure was 27.6%; performance ranged from 0% to 100% (n = 555,213 primary care physicians). Higher levels of CoC were associated with lower levels of care utilization. The measure indicated acceptable levels of validity and reliability.

CONCLUSIONS

Continuity is associated with desirable health and cost outcomes as well as patient preference. The CoC clinical quality measure meets validity and reliability requirements for implementation in primary care payment and accountability. Care continuity is important and complementary to access to care, and prioritizing this measure could help shift physician and health system behavior to support continuity.

Outcomes associated with higher relational continuity in the treatment of persons with asthma or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: A systematic review

Background

Asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) are chronic conditions where relational continuity of care, as in regularly meeting the same health care provider, creates opportunities for monitoring and adjustment of treatment based on an individual's changing needs, potentially affecting quality of delivered care. The aim of this systematic review was to investigate the effects of relational continuity in the treatment of persons with asthma or COPD.

Methods

Eleven databases (CINAHL, Medline, PsycINFO, Scopus, Embase, Cochrane Library, Database of Systematic Review of Effects, DARE, Epistemonikos, NICE Evidence Search, KSR Evidence and AHRQ) were searched between January 1, 2000, and February 1 - 4, 2021, for controlled and observational studies about relational continuity and health outcomes for persons with asthma and/or COPD. Inclusion criteria were studies investigating an index or aspect relevant to relational continuity between a health professional/team of health professionals and patients. After screening, and assessment of study relevance and quality by at least two independent reviewers, studies with acceptable risk of bias were included and summary data was extracted from the publications. Main outcomes were mortality, morbidity (including health care utilization) and cost measures. Syntheses without metanalyses were performed due to considerable study heterogeneity. The certainty of the summarized result was assessed using GRADE (the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation). PROSPERO study registration number: CRD42020196518.

Findings

We identified 2824 unique references and included 15 studies (14 observational and 1 randomized controlled trial) in the review, from which results were derived for six outcomes. For persons with asthma or COPD we found that higher compared to lower relational continuity of care prevents premature mortality (low certainty; 2 studies, 111 545 participants), lowers risk of emergency department visits (low certainty, 5 studies, 362 305 participates) and risk of hospitalization (moderate certainty, 9 studies, 525 716 participants), and lowers health care costs (low certainty; 4 studies, 390 682 participants). Results regarding treatment adherence (1 study, 971 participants) and patient perceptions (3 studies, 2026 participants) were assessed as having very low certainty.

Interpretation

Low to moderate certainty evidence suggests that higher versus lower relational continuity of care for persons with asthma or COPD prevents premature mortality, lowers risks of unplanned health care utilization and reduces health care costs. The results may be of value when planning care for individuals and for policymakers in organizing health care and developing guidelines for treatment and follow-up routines.

Funding

None.

Physician versus Practice-Level Primary Care Continuity and Association with Outcomes in Medicare Beneficiaries

OBJECTIVE

To compare physician versus practice-level primary care continuity and their association with expenditure and acute care utilization among Medicare beneficiaries and evaluate if continuity of outpatient primary care at either/both physician or/and practice level could be useful quality measures.

DATA SOURCE

Medicare Fee-For-Service claims data for community dwelling beneficiaries without End-Stage Renal Disease who were attributed to a national random sample of primary care practices billing Medicare (2011-2017).

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective secondary data analysis at per Medicare beneficiary per year level. We used multivariable linear regression with practice-level fixed effects to estimate continuity of care score at physician vs. practice level and their associations with outcomes.

DATA COLLECTION/EXTRACTION METHOD

We calculated clinician and practice level Bice-Boxerman continuity of care index scores, ranging from 0 to 1, using primary care outpatient claims. Medicare expenditures, hospital admissions, emergency department visits, and readmissions were obtained from the Medicare Beneficiary Summary File: Cost and Utilization Segment. Ambulatory care sensitive conditions (ACSC) were defined using diagnosis codes on inpatient claims.

PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

We studied 2,359,400 beneficiaries who sought care from 13,926 physicians. Every 0.1 increase in physician continuity score was associated with a $151 reduction in expenditures per beneficiary per year (P<0.01), and every 0.1 increase in practice continuity score was associated with $282 decrease (P<0.01) per beneficiary per year. Both physician- and practice-level continuity were associated with lower Medicare expenditures among small, medium, and large practices. Both physician- and practice-level continuity were associated with lower probabilities of hospitalization, emergency department visit, admissions for ACSC, and readmission.

CONCLUSIONS

Primary care continuity of care could serve as a potent value-based care quality metric. Physician-level continuity is a unique value center that cannot be supplanted by practice level continuity.

Determining the Association Between Continuity of Primary Care and Acute Care Use in Chronic Kidney Disease: A Retrospective Cohort Study

PURPOSE

Acute care use is high among individuals with chronic kidney disease (CKD). It is unclear how relational continuity of primary care influences downstream acute care use. We aimed to determine if poor continuity of care is associated with greater rates of acute care use and decreased prescriptions for guideline-recommended drugs.

METHODS

We conducted a population-based retrospective cohort study of adults with stage 3-4 CKD and ≥3 visits to a primary care clinician during the period April 1, 2011 to March 31, 2014 in Alberta, Canada. Continuity was calculated using the Usual Provider Continuity index. Descriptive statistics were used to summarize patient and acute care encounter characteristics. Adjusted rates and incidence rate ratios for all-cause and CKD-related ambulatory care-sensitive condition (ACSC) hospitalizations and emergency department (ED) visits were estimated using negative binomial regression. Adjusted odds ratios for prescription use were estimated by multivariable logistic regression.

RESULTS

Among 86,475 patients with CKD, 51.3%, 30.0%, and 18.7% had high, moderate, and poor continuity of care, respectively. There were 77,988 all-cause hospitalizations, 6,489 ACSC-related hospitalizations, 204,615 all-cause ED visits, and 8,461 ACSC-related ED visits during a median follow-up of 2.3 years. Rates of all-cause and ACSC hospitalization and ED use increased with poorer continuity of care in a stepwise fashion across CKD stages. Patients with poor continuity were less likely to be prescribed a statin.

CONCLUSIONS

Poor continuity of care is associated with increased acute care use among patients with CKD. Targeted strategies that strengthen patient-physician relationships and guide physicians regarding guideline-recommended prescribing are needed.

Continuity of care of Swiss residents aged 50+: a longitudinal study using claims data

Background

Continuity of care (COC) should be measured for healthcare quality monitoring and evaluation and is a key process indicator for integrated care. Measurement of COC using routinely collected data is widespread, but there is no consensus on which indicator to use and the relevant time horizon to apply. Information about COC is especially warranted in highly fragmented healthcare systems, such as in Switzerland. Our study aimed to compare COC measures in Swiss residents aged 50+ obtained with various indices and time horizons.

Methods

Using insurance claims data, we computed and compared several commonly used visit-based Continuity of Care Indices (COCIs): Bice-Boxerman Index, Usual Provider of Care, Herfindahl-Hirschman Index, Modified, Modified Continuity Index and Modified Continuity Index, based on all doctor visits and on primary care (PC) visits only. Indices were computed over short (1 year) and medium (4 years) terms.

Results

The mean indices based on all visits varied between 0.51 and 0.77, while PC indices presented less variation with a median of 1.00 for all but one index. Indices focusing on a variety of individual providers decreased with time horizon, while indices focusing on the overall number of visits and providers showed the opposite trend. These findings suggest fundamental differences in the interpretation of COCIs.

Conclusions

Broad COC appeared moderately low in Switzerland, although comparable to other countries, and PC COC was close to one. The choice of indices and time horizon influenced their interpretation. Understanding these differences is key to select the appropriate index for the monitoring of COC.

Emergency Department/ Urgent Care as Usual Source of Care and Clinical Outcomes in CKD: Findings From the CRIC (Chronic Renal Insufficiency Cohort) Study

Rationale & Objective

Having a usual source of care increases use of preventive services and is associated with improved survival in the general population. We evaluated this association in adults with chronic kidney disease (CKD).

Study Design

Prospective, observational cohort study.

Setting & Participants

Adults with CKD enrolled in the Chronic Renal Insufficiency Cohort (CRIC) Study.

Predictor

Usual source of care was self-reported as: 1) clinic, 2) emergency department (ED)/urgent care, 3) other.

Outcomes

Primary outcomes included incident end-stage kidney disease (ESKD), atherosclerotic events (myocardial infarction, stroke, or peripheral artery disease), incident heart failure, hospitalization events, and all-cause death.

Analytical Approach

Multivariable regression analyses to evaluate the association between usual source of care (ED/urgent care vs clinic) and primary outcomes.

Results

Among 3,140 participants, mean age was 65 years, 44% female, 45% non-Hispanic White, 43% non-Hispanic Black, and 9% Hispanic, mean estimated glomerular filtration rate 50 mL/min/1.73 m². Approximately 90% identified clinic as usual source of care, 9% ED/urgent care, and 1% other. ED/urgent care reflected a more vulnerable population given lower baseline socioeconomic status, higher comorbid condition burden, and poorer blood pressure and glycemic control. Over a median follow-up time of 3.6 years, there were 181 incident end-stage kidney disease events, 264 atherosclerotic events, 263 incident heart failure events, 288 deaths, and 7,957 hospitalizations. Compared to clinic as usual source of care, ED/urgent care was associated with higher risk for all-cause death (HR, 1.53; 95% CI, 1.05-2.23) and hospitalizations (RR, 1.41; 95% CI, 1.32-1.51).

Limitations

Cannot be generalized to all patients with CKD. Causal relationships cannot be established.

Conclusions

In this large, diverse cohort of adults with moderate-to-severe CKD, those identifying ED/urgent care as usual source of care were at increased risk for death and hospitalizations. These findings highlight the need to develop strategies to improve health care access for this high-risk population.

Economic Burden of Asthma-Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Overlap among Older Adults in the United States

The objective of this study is to estimate the excess economic burden of Asthma-COPD Overlap (ACO) among older adults in the United States. We used a cross-sectional study design with data from a nationally representative survey of Medicare beneficiaries (Medicare Current Beneficiary Survey) linked to Medicare fee-for-service claims. Older adults with ACO had higher average total healthcare expenditures ($45,532 vs. $12,743) and higher out-of-pocket spending burden (19% vs. 8.5%) compared to those with no-asthma no-COPD (NANC). Individuals with ACO also had almost two, and 1.5 times higher expenditures compared to individuals with asthma only and COPD only, respectively. Multivariable regression models indicated that the adjusted associations of ACO to economic burden remained positive and statistically significant. In comparison with NANC, nearly three-quarters of the excess total healthcare expenditures and 83% of the out-of-pocket spending burden of older adults with ACO were explained by differences in predisposing, enabling, need, personal healthcare practices, and external factors among the two groups. The higher number of unique medications and the increased incidence of fragmented care were the leading contributors to the excess economic burden among older adults with ACO comparing to NANC individuals. Interventions that reduce the number of medications and fragmented care have the potential to reduce the excess economic burden among older adults with ACO.

Perception and Willingness to Maintain Continuity of Care by Parents of Children with Asthma in Taiwan

To investigate caregivers’ attitudes toward continuity of care (COC) and their willingness to maintain continuity for their children with asthma under a national health insurance (NHI) system without strict referral management. We sampled 825 individuals from six pediatric outpatient departments in different parts of Taiwan from 2017 to 2018. We used a contingent valuation with a payment card method. Post-stratification weighting adjustment and coarsened exact matching were utilized. Multiple logistic regression was used to compare the willingness to pay and spend extra time maintaining continuity by parents. More than 80% of caregivers in the asthma group believed having a primary pediatrician was important for children’s health. Only 27.5% and 15.8% of caregivers in the asthma and control groups, respectively, believed changing pediatricians would negatively affect therapeutic outcomes. Regression analysis showed that the predicted willingness to pay for the asthma and non-asthma groups were NT$508 (SD = 196) and NT$402 (SD = 172), respectively, and there was a significant positive dose–response relationship between household income and willingness to pay for maintaining health care provider continuity. Caregivers’ free choices among health care providers may reduce willingness to spend extra effort to maintain high COC. Caregivers should be educated on the importance of COC.

Continuity of care: evaluating a multidisciplinary care model for people with early CKD via a nationwide population-based longitudinal study

OBJECTIVES

To control and prevent the burdens associated with chronic kidney disease (CKD), Taiwan's National Health Insurance Administration (NHIA) launched the 'early-CKD programme' in 2011 to extend care and education to patients with CKD. This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of the early-CKD programme in terms of continuity of care (COC).

DESIGN AND PARTICIPANTS

This study used secondary data from 2010 to 2014 provided by the NHIA to identify 86 581 participants each for the intervention and control groups. Patients with CKD who participated in the early-CKD programme between 2011 and 2013 were defined as the intervention group. For the control group, propensity score matching was used to select patients with CKD who did not participate in the programme, but were seen by the same group of physicians.

INTERVENTION

A multidisciplinary care model for patients with early CKD launched in 2011.

PRIMARY OUTCOME MEASURES

Outcome variables included the continuity of care index (COCI), which measures a physician's COC; number of essential examinations; and resource utilisation. To better identify the difference between groups, we separated COCI into two groups based on mean: high (above mean) and low (below mean). A generalised estimating equation model was used to examine the effects of the early-CKD programme.

RESULTS

The programme significantly increased the number of essential examinations/tests administered to patients (β=0.61, p<0.001) and improved COCI between physicians and patients (OR=4.18, p<0.001). Medical expenses (β=1.03, p<0.001) and medication expenses (β=0.23, p<0.001) significantly increased after the programme was implemented, but patients' kidney-related hospitalisations and emergency department visits decreased (β=-0.13, p<0.001).

CONCLUSION

From the COC viewpoint, the programme in Taiwan showed a positive effect on COCI, number of essential examinations and resource utilisation.