Experimental investigation of rotational tomography in reconstructed middle ears with clinical implications

Cone-Beam CT Compared to Multi-Slice CT for the Diagnostic Analysis of Conductive Hearing Loss: A Feasibility Study

OBJECTIVES

Multislice computed tomography (MSCT) is commonly used as a diagnostic tool for patients with a conductive hearing loss. Recent studies indicate that cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) may be used as a low-radiation dose alternative for temporal bone imaging. This study compares image quality and radiation dose between CBCT and MSCT when assessing anatomical landmarks related to conductive hearing loss.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Five human cadaver heads (10 ears) were imaged on the NewTom 5G CBCT and the Discovery CT750 HD MSCT. Visibility of 16 anatomical landmarks of the middle and inner ear was assessed by two observers on a 4-point Likert scale. Furthermore, effective radiation dose was compared, and contrast-to-noise ratio and spatial resolution were measured with a phantom head.

RESULTS

Image quality of CBCT was assessed as superior to MSCT. Effective radiation dose of the high-resolution CBCT protocol was 30.5% of the clinical MSCT dose. High-resolution CBCT was reported as having a higher spatial resolution and superior contrast-to-noise perception in comparison with MSCT.

CONCLUSION

High-resolution CBCT was evaluated as superior to MSCT in the assessment of structures related to conductive hearing loss. Furthermore, CBCT imaging resulted in a considerably lower effective radiation dose.

Virtual Quality Control in Middle Ear Surgery: Is Image-guided Tympanoscopy a Valuable Tool for Depicting Borderline Situations?

HYPOTHESIS

Before modern imaging was introduced, revision surgery was the only way to evaluate possible reasons for inadequate improvement in hearing after ossicular replacement during reconstructive middle ear surgery.

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to evaluate freely navigable virtual tympanoscopy using different computed tomographic modalities. We compared cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT), flat panel computed tomography (FPCT), and conventional computed tomography in helical mode (CTH), volume mode (CTV), and ultra high resolution mode (CTD).

METHODS

Four temporal bone specimens were reconstructed with partial or total ossicular replacement prostheses. The best functional results for prosthetic coupling were achieved under the control of laser Doppler vibrometry (LDV). Afterward, a progressive step-by-step decoupling of the prostheses was carried out. Different prosthesis positions were evaluated by LDV as well as different computed tomographic modalities with 3D reconstruction of each dataset.

RESULTS

Anatomical structures were better depicted and the best position and coupling of inserted prostheses were achieved using CBCT. All imaging techniques could be used to control the position of middle ear prostheses, but CBCT provided the highest resolution and the best image quality in both 2D and 3D reformations and in 3D-animated video representation.

CONCLUSION

Compared with several other imaging modalities, CBCT was best at depicting miscellaneous coupling problems. Noninvasive detection of coupling problems caused by minimal loss of contact between prostheses and middle ear ossicles will influence the clinical outcome. This early detection will help to determine whether revision surgery is needed.

Feasibility Study of a Mechanical Real-Time Feedback System for Optimizing the Sound Transfer in the Reconstructed Middle Ear

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate electromechanical excitation as an alternative excitation mode for middle ear transfer function (METF) measurements as well as real-time feedback in prosthetic ossicular reconstruction.

METHOD

In eight human cadaveric temporal bones, the ossicular chain was excited using acoustic and mechanical (floating mass transducer, FMT) stimulation to determine the METF. After disconnecting the ossicular chain and reconstruction with partial or total prosthesis the METFs were measured again. Continuous FMT stimulation was then applied to improve the prosthesis' position using real-time feedback of the METF.

RESULTS

Mechanical stimulation of ossicular vibration showed characteristic differences to acoustic excitation resulting from the force characteristics of the FMT. Furthermore, the interspecimen METF variability was greater with electromechanical than acoustic stimulation because of interspecimen variability in the FMT coupling conditions. When the METF with FMT excitation was used as a real-time feedback tool, a measurable improvement in the quality of ossicular reconstruction could be achieved.

CONCLUSIONS

Mechanical excitation is an effective and suitable alternative stimulation method in experimental METF measurements. The system provides real-time feedback for ossicular reconstruction in the experimental setting. Some influencing factors still need to be distinguished for reliable measurements. However, the method does not yet meet the requirements for clinical application as an intraoperative, real-time monitoring tool. However, the system could be an excellent model for high-end cadaveric temporal bone training in ossiculoplasty.

Stapes piston insertion depth and clinical correlations

Background: The insertion of the stapes piston within the vestibule provides the physical basis for a successful stapedotomy. An insertion depth of 0.5 mm is recommended to avoid the dislocation of the stapes prosthesis (e.g. sneezing). Aims: The objective of this study is to analyze the depth of stapes prosthesis insertion and its correlation with clinical outcome. Material and methods: We observed in a retrospective case series 39 otosclerosis patients after a stapedotomy and a postoperative performed flat panel tomography/cone beam CT. The evaluation included the radiologically found depth of prosthesis insertion within the vestibule, the vestibule depth, and the correlation with the bone conduction (BC) threshold, vertigo, and tinnitus. Results: Insertion depth varied between 0.2 and 1.6 mm (mean 0.74 mm). The ratio of insertion depth versus the vestibule depth was between 8% and 59% (mean 26.6%). We observed no correlation between the insertion depth, the length of the prosthesis, the ratio of insertion depth/vestibule depth, postoperative BC, appearance of vertigo, or tinnitus. Conclusions and significance: In our group, we observed no significant relation between insertion depth of the stapes piston, postoperative vertigo, tinnitus, or decrease of the BC.

Tympanoplasty - news and new perspectives

Techniques and biomaterials for reconstructive middle ear surgery are continuously and steadily developing. At the same time, clinical post-surgery results are evaluated to determine success or failure of the therapy. Routine quality assessment and assurance is of growing importance in the medical field, and therefore also in middle ear surgery. The exact definition and acquisition of outcome parameters is essential for both a comprehensive and detailed quality assurance. These parameters are not the audiological results alone, but also additional individual parameters, which influence the postoperative outcome after tympanoplasty. Selection of patients and the preoperative clinical situation, the extent of the ossicular chain destruction, the chosen reconstruction technique and material, the audiometric frequency selection and the observational interval are only some of them. If these parameters are not well documented, the value of comparative analyses between different studies is very limited. The present overview aims at describing, comparing, and evaluating some of the existing assessment and scoring systems for middle ear surgery. Additionally, new methods for an intraoperative quality assessment in ossiculoplasty and the postoperative evaluation of suboptimal hearing results with imaging techniques are available. In the area of implant development, functional elements were integrated in prostheses to enable not only good sound transmission but also compensation of occurring atmospheric pressure changes. In combination with other components for ossicular repair, they can be used in a modular manner, which so far show experimentally and clinically promising results.

Experimental Simulation of Clinical Borderline Situations in Temporal Bone Specimens After Ossiculoplasty

OBJECTIVES

One reason for insufficient hearing improvement with a distinct air-bone gap after ossiculoplasty with implantation of partial or total ossicular replacement prostheses can be the dislocation or minimal shifting of the prosthesis. The aim of this study was the simulation of common clinical borderline situations with minimal shifting of the prosthesis in temporal bone specimens after ossiculoplasty. It was furthermore the goal to identify these specific situations through imaging by cone beam computed tomography (cbCT) and direct visual inspection using the operation microscope. Additionally, the functional status was evaluated using laser-Doppler vibrometry (LDV).

DESIGN

We used a total of four temporal bone specimens for this study. A reconstruction with a partial ossicular replacement prostheses was performed in three specimens and with a total ossicular replacement prostheses in one specimen, with good initial acoustic properties. Subsequently, one specific type of prosthesis failure was simulated in each specimen, respectively, by minimally shifting, tilting, or bending the prostheses from their initial positions. These changes were introduced step-by-step until a borderline situation just short of complete acoustic decoupling was reached. Each step was examined using both LDV and cbCT and observed through the operation microscope.

RESULTS

LDV was able to quantify the mechanic function of the ossicular chain after most of the manipulation steps by demonstrating the effect of any shifting of the prosthesis on the middle ear transfer function. However, in some situations, the middle ear transfer function was better with a visually more advanced failure of the prosthesis. In addition, cbCT showed most of the steps with excellent resolution and was able to delineate changes in soft tissue (e.g., cartilage covering).

CONCLUSION

cbCT seems to be a promising imaging technique for middle ear problems. As cbCT and LDV exhibited slightly different advantages and disadvantages regarding the demonstration of borderline situations, the combination of both techniques allowed for a more precise evaluation of middle ear reconstructions. Knowledge of the specific characteristics of these methods and their possible combination might help otologists and otosurgeons to refine indications for revision surgery and improve their personal patient counseling.

[Quality control following reconstructive middle ear surgery: from bench to bedside]

BACKGROUND

The ongoing improvement of imaging quality nowadays focuses increasingly more on immediate quality evaluation of surgical measures.

METHODS

Rotational tomography (RT) has been experimentally proven to be an alternative imaging technique to computed tomography (CT) in terms of quality and postoperative localization of middle ear implants in temporal bones. Based on these results imaging parameters were determined in the form of a surgical check list in order to systematically check individual but important surgical reconstructive steps.

RESULTS

The positive benefit of RT concerning immediate and significant postoperative quality control was confirmed by a patient study. The surgical check list was successfully implemented under clinical framework requirements. Among these standardized parameters the determined angulation of inserted middle ear implants was given outstanding significance due to the predictive value concerning functional outcome.

CONCLUSION

The RT procedure has been proven to be a reliable imaging tool for postoperative quality control following reconstructive middle ear surgery.

Evaluation of functional results of CWD surgery with ossicular replacement prosthesis due to cholesteatoma using computed tomography

With the use of high-resolution computed tomography, this retrospective clinical study evaluated the factors affecting hearing in patients who were operated on due to chronic otitis media with cholesteatoma and underwent ossiculoplasty with titanium total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP). Fifteen patients with postoperative hearing results of 20 dB or less air-bone gap, and thirteen patients with postoperative hearing results of 21 dB or more air-bone gap were the subjects of this study. All patients were operated on due to chronic otitis media and underwent ossiculoplasty with titanium TORP. High-Resolution Computed Tomography (HRCT) and pure-tone audiometry were performed on each patient after an average of 17 months, postoperatively. Three-dimensional oblique CT cross-sections were analyzed with Vitrea 2(®) software. The presence of soft tissue in the middle ear and contact between the prosthesis head plate and the bone had an adverse effect on hearing (p < 0.05). The angle between the TORP and the oval window did not seem to affect the hearing results (p > 0.05). The study results indicate that an examination of the patients with poor postoperative hearing with HRCT may help find the possible cause and allow for the determination of the prosthesis location.

Visualisation of the Bonebridge by means of CT and CBCT

Background

With the Bonebridge, a new bone-anchored hearing aid has been available since March 2012. The objective of the study was to analyse the visualisation of the implant itself as well as its impact on the representation of the bony structures of the petrosal bone in CT, MRI and cone beam CT (CBCT).

Methods

The Bonebridge was implanted unilaterally in two completely prepared human heads. The radiological imaging by means of CBCT, 64-slice CT, 1.5-T and 3.0-T MRI was conducted both preoperatively and postoperatively. The images were subsequently evaluated from both the ENT medical and nd radiological perspectives.

Results

As anticipated, no visualisation of the implant or of the petrosal bones could be realised on MRI because of the interactive technology and the magnet artefact. In contrast, an excellent evaluability of the implant itself as well as of the surrounding neurovascular structures (sinus sigmoideus, skull base, middle ear, inner ear, inner auditory canal) was exhibited in both the CT and in the CBCT.

Conclusion

The Bonebridge can be excellently imaged with the radiological imaging technologies of CT and CBCT. In the process, CBCT shows discrete advantages in comparison with CT. No relevant restrictions in image quality in the evaluation of the bony structures of the petrosal bones could be seen.

PORP vs. TORP: a meta-analysis

After the surgical procedure of ossicular chain reconstruction, the effectiveness and/or stability of partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) or total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP) were systematically compared and evaluated using meta-analysis. A total of 40 eligible investigations with 4,311 subjects were included in our study. There was a significant difference in the effectiveness of the reconstruction of the ossicular chain between PORP and TORP; the data showed a combined risk ratio (RR) of 1.28 (95 % CI 1.17-1.41, p < 0.00001), but no notable difference was obtained in staged procedures subgroup and cholesteatoma subgroup, with a combined RR of 1.13 (95 % CI 0.60-2.11, p = 0.70) in staged procedures subgroup and RR of 2.60 (95 % CI 0.20-36.21, p = 0.59 in cholesteatoma subgroup). There was a statistically significant difference in the stability of the prostheses in long-term follow-up, with a combined RR of 0.37 (95 % CI 0.16-0.85, p = 0.02), but no significant difference was observed in the total sample, with a combined RR of 0.64 (95 % CI 0.40-1.03, p = 0.06). Our overall results suggest that the effectiveness of PORP was higher than TORP, except within staged procedures subgroup and cholesteatoma subgroup. In addition, the stability of PORP was significantly superior to TORP in long-term follow-ups, but no significant effect was detected in the general study.

[Intracochlear electrode position: evaluation after deep insertion using cone beam computed tomography]

INTRODUCTION

Due to the increasing number of cochlear implantations (CI), postoperative radiological verification of the electrode position, e.g., with respect to quality control, plays a central role. The aim of this study was to evaluate the intracochlear position of deep inserted electrodes by cone beam computed tomography (CBCT).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

CBCT data sets (Accu-I-tomo, Morita, Kyoto, Japan) of 22 patients (28 ears operated between 2008 and 2011) were retrospectively analyzed. All patients underwent a CI (round window approach) with deep insertion of the electrode (Flex soft or standard electrode from MedEl©). CBCT data were analyzed for intracochlear position of the electrode (scala vestibuli, scala tympani, malposition between the scalae) and the certainty of this evaluation.

RESULTS

All ears could be evaluated with the status certain or relatively certain in the basal turn of the cochlea. Thereby, the electrode array was inserted into the scala tympani in 93% (n = 26). Primary insertion into the scala vestibuli and the scala media was observed in 3.5% of the ears, respectively. In the apical part of the cochlea, only 32% (n = 9 ears) could be evaluated with relative certainty. The remaining 68% of cases could not be evaluated. Of the 32% interpretable cases in the apical part of the cochlea, 25% (n = 7) were inserted into the scala tympani, 3.5% (n = 1) into the scala vestibuli, and 3.5% (n = 1) were malpositioned between the scalae.

CONCLUSION

The exact evaluation of the intracochlear position of the electrode by CBCT is only possible in the basal turn of the cochlea. In deep insertion, determination of the position in the medial and apical parts of the cochlea by CBCT is still not possible. Furthermore, the round window approach allows reliable implantation into the scala tympani.

Analysis of pneumatization and neurovascular structures of the sphenoid sinus using cone-beam tomography (CBT)

BACKGROUND

The sphenoid sinus is a frequent target of paranasal sinus surgery. Because of the high risk of injuring the surrounding structures (e.g. internal carotid artery, optical nerve) a preoperative imaging is absolutely necessary.

PURPOSE

To analyze the possibilities of cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT), which is especially quite a new technique in ENT, in the evaluation of the sphenoid sinus, its surrounding structures, and the corresponding anatomical variations.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This was a retrospective, single-centre study of 580 patients (1160 sides = cases). The Accu-I-Tomo-F17 was used. Pneumatization of sphenoid sinus, course of internal artery, course of optical nerve, and dehiscence of the bony canals were evaluated.

RESULTS

In the case of pneumatization a type I (completely missing or minimal sphenoid sinus) was found in two patients (0.3%), type II (posterior wall of sphenoid sinus is in front of the anterior wall of the sella) in 38 patients (6.6%), type III (posterior wall is between anterior and posterior wall of sella) in 332 patients (57,2%), type IVa (posterior wall is behind the posterior wall of sella without air dorsal the sella) in 104 patients (17.9%), and type IVb (similar to type IVa but with air dorsal the sella) in 104 patients (17.9%). In 1025 cases (89.5%) a smooth course of the internal carotid artery was found whereas a free course could be detected in 120 cases (10.5%). Defects of the bony canal of the optical nerve were found in 16.7% and of the internal carotid artery in 2.7% of the cases. The optical nerve showed a free course through the sphenoid in 151 cases (13.7%) and a smooth course in 1007 cases (87.0%).

CONCLUSION

CBCT could evaluate all relevant anatomic structures and answer the questions of different anatomical variants. A modified classification of the pneumatization of the sphenoid sinus could be described. Frequencies of anatomical variations are in accordance with the current literature of CT research.