A closer look: Alternative pain management practices by heart failure patients with chronic pain

Prevalence of chronic pain and chronic widespread pain among subjects with heart failure in the general population: The HUNT study

BACKGROUND

Pain in chronic heart failure (HF) is a significant but often unrecognized symptom. Characteristics of pain in subjects with HF are largely undescribed. The study aimed to address a knowledge gap in the relationship between HF and pain by investigating the prevalence of chronic pain and chronic widespread pain (CWP) among subjects with HF.

METHODS

Population data from the HUNT3 study in Norway (2006-2008, n = 50,802) was used. HF was measured by self-report. CWP was defined as having pain in both sides of the body, pain in the upper and lower limbs, and axial pain for at least 3 months in the last year. Associations between HF and CWP and HF and moderate to high pain intensity were analysed with logistic regression.

RESULTS

Among subjects with HF in the general population, the prevalence of chronic pain was 67.8%, 20.7% had CWP, and 58.8% had moderate to high intensity pain. Compared to participants with cardiovascular disease but not HF, the odds of both CWP (OR = 1.6; 95% CI: 1.3-2.0) and moderate to high intensity pain (OR = 1.3; 95% CI: 1.3-1.8) were higher among participants with HF-controlled for age, sex, body mass index, and comorbidity.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study confirmed the high prevalence of pain among HF subjects. This pain could not be explained by comorbidity or sociodemographic factors, which are relevant for clinical and research purposes. Pain management should not be restricted to cardiac-related pain but to chronic pain in general.

SIGNIFICANCE

This epidemiological study corroborates previous studies reporting a high prevalence of pain in the HF-population. We found that the relationship between HF, CWP, and pain intensity could not be explained by comorbidity or sociodemographic factors, illustrating the burden of chronic pain related to HF. Our results expand the understanding of pain in HF and highlight the need to identify and manage chronic pain among individuals with HF, as widespread pain adds to the symptom burden in individuals with HF.

Pain sensation and gut microbiota profiles in older adults with heart failure

Objectives

Patients with heart failure (HF) experience severe pain and may have altered pain sensation; however, the underlying mechanisms of these symptoms are not yet fully understood. Identifying pain sensation and genomic biomarkers of pain in older adults with HF is a critical step toward developing personalized interventions to improve pain management and outcomes. This study aimed to investigate the differences in pain sensation, gut microbiota, self-reported pain, and symptoms in older adults with and without HF.

Methods

Twenty older adults with HF and age-matched healthy controls (HCs) were recruited in the Northeastern United States. Quantitative sensory testing and conditioned pain modulation were performed on the nondominant upper arm to detect the mechanical, thermal, and pressure pain thresholds and pain modulations. Stool samples were collected, and the 16S rRNA V4 gene region of stool samples was sequenced and processed using the Mothur 1.42.3 pipeline. Self-reported pain and symptoms were measured by the Brief Pain Inventory and the NIH Patient-reported Outcomes Measurement Information System. The associations between pain sensation, gut microbiota α-diversity indices, and pain and symptoms were explored using the Spearman correlations.

Results

The HF and HC subjects' mean ages were 73.50 (SD = 8.33) and 67.10 (SD = 7.64), respectively. The HF subjects reported significantly higher pain intensity and interference, sleep disturbance, fatigue, anxiety, and depression than the HCs. The HF subjects also had a significantly lower level of physical function and participation in social roles and activities. Compared with the HCs, the HF subjects had significantly altered conditioned pain modulation heat effect and gut microbiota compositions and predicted metabolic functions. The Statistical Analysis Of Metagenomic Profiles indicated that the HF subjects had a significantly decreased cardiac muscle contraction pathway compared with the HCs. The correlation analysis showed that the quantitative sensory testing profiles and gut microbiota diversity index were significantly associated with pain and symptoms in older adults with HF.

Conclusions

Older adults with HF had more severe self-reported pain and symptoms, altered pain sensation, and different gut microbiota composition and function compared with age-matched HCs. Pain sensation and gut microbiota may contribute to pain and symptoms in older adults with HF and could serve as biomarkers of pain and symptoms of HF. Further research with a larger sample size is warranted to confirm these findings.

Differential Gene Expression Among Patients With Heart Failure Experiencing Pain

BACKGROUND

Chronic pain is frequently experienced by patients with heart failure (HF) and is associated with higher mortality, higher symptom burden, and worsened health-related quality of life. However, the genomic mechanisms underlying chronic pain in HF are understudied. Building an understanding of the mechanistic underpinnings of pain may inform novel interventions.

OBJECTIVE

The objective was to identify genes associated with pain from messenger RNA sequence data collected from patients with HF with and without pain.

METHODS

The current study analyzed data from 40 patients with HF previously enrolled in a clinical trial. Pain presence was measured using the Health Utilities Index Mark-3. Genes were tested for differential expression using DESeq2, and differentially expressed genes were analyzed for protein-protein interaction (PPI) and relevant ontological pathways using Metascape. Genes located within the core of the PPI network were considered key in disease-relevant biological pathways. Differentially expressed genes within this PPI network were reviewed in existing literature to narrow down candidate genes of interest. These target genes of interest were reanalyzed in a second sample of 24 patients with HF using validation quantitative polymerase chain reaction.

RESULTS

A total of 334 genes (279 upregulated, 55 downregulated) were differentially expressed between patients with and without pain in the primary sample of 40. These genes were largely aligned with neutrophil degranulation pathways. Seven genes of interest were identified from a core network of 15 co-expressed genes in the PPI network and existing literature. Three of these seven genes, matrix metallopeptidase 8 ( MMP8 ), proprotein convertase subtilisin/kexin type 9 ( PCSK9 ), and neutrophil defensin 3 ( DEFA3 ), were upregulated in patients with pain versus without pain in both the primary and validation samples. All seven genes of interest are involved in immune, inflammatory, and atherosclerotic processes.

DISCUSSION

These results identify potential genes that may play a mechanistic role in chronic pain in HF. Further research is needed to evaluate these potential genes among clearly delineated pain phenotypes.

Pain in Homebound Older Adults with Heart Failure after Hospital Discharge

Pain is not uncommon in older adult patients with heart failure (HF) and has been identified as a risk factor for rehospitalization of homebound patients with HF. Little is known about the pain experiences and management of older adults with HF after hospital discharge. We sought to describe pain and other symptoms among homebound older adults with HF using a qualitative and descriptive approach. We conducted semistructured interviews to obtain qualitative data and used the Brief Pain Instrument-Short Form and the Edmonton Symptom Assessment Scale to obtain descriptive data on symptom burden. We interviewed 18 participants within 10 days after hospital discharge. Participants' mean age was 75.8 ± 9.0 years; 78% were White. The mean pain score at its worst was 5.2 ± 3.1, and for pain interfering with sleep was 4.3 ± 3.41. Most participants managed pain with medications. Using thematic analysis of qualitative data, we identified three distinct categories: (1) the diversity of patients' pain experiences, (2) the diversity of pain management routines, and (3) patients' experiences with healthcare providers' pain assessment and management practices. Our findings show that homebound older adults with HF experience various pain symptoms and receive inconsistent education about how to manage pain from healthcare providers. This study supports the need for better pain assessment and education about the appropriate use of pain medications and nonpharmacologic approaches to pain control for homebound older adults with HF.

Back pain and heart failure in community-dwelling older adults: Findings from the Health ABC study

This study explored the association of back pain and heart failure (HF) with health outcomes among community-dwelling older adults. Older adults who completed a follow-up in the 11th year (2007-2008) of the Health, Aging, and Body Composition (Health ABC) study were included. The mean age was 83.4 ± 2.78 years. Back pain and heart failure were reported by 55.40% (n = 657) and 8.09 % (n = 96) of the total subjects (N = 1186), respectively. Regression analysis indicated that older adults with back pain reported worse depressive symptoms, fatigue, and physical performance and function compared with those without back pain (p < 0.05), and HF presence increased fatigue levels and decreased physical function (p < 0.05) among older adults with back pain. The high incidence and negative impact of back pain highlight the need to develop strategies for pain management among older adults with and without HF.

Prioritizing symptom management in the treatment of chronic heart failure

Chronic heart failure (CHF) is a chronic, progressive disease that has detrimental consequences on a patient's quality of life (QoL). In part due to requirements for market access and licensing, the assessment of current and future treatments focuses on reducing mortality and hospitalizations. Few drugs are available principally for their symptomatic effect despite the fact that most patients' symptoms persist or worsen over time and an acceptance that the survival gains of modern therapies are mitigated by poorly controlled symptoms. Additional contributors to the failure to focus on symptoms could be the result of under‐reporting of symptoms by patients and carers and a reliance on insensitive symptomatic categories in which patients frequently remain despite additional therapies. Hence, formal symptom assessment tools, such as questionnaires, can be useful prompts to encourage more fidelity and reproducibility in the assessment of symptoms. This scoping review explores for the first time the assessment options and management of common symptoms in CHF with a focus on patient‐reported outcome tools. The integration of patient‐reported outcomes for symptom assessment into the routine of a CHF clinic could improve the monitoring of disease progression and QoL, especially following changes in treatment or intervention with a targeted symptom approach expected to improve QoL and patient outcomes.

Pain Management in Patients with Heart Failure: A Survey of Nurses' Perception

BACKGROUND

Over 50% of patients with heart failure (HF) report suffering from pain and pain-related burdens; however, pain in HF patients has not been recognized or well treated. Few studies have comprehensively examined pain management in patients with HF from nurses' perception.

AIMS

To investigate nurses' perception of pain management in HF patients.

METHODS

Members of American Association of Heart Failure Nurses (AAHFN) were invited to participate in a cross-sectional online survey.

RESULTS

A total of 147 nurses responded and completed the survey. The majority agreed that pain in HF patients was related to anxiety, depression, fatigue, and unplanned hospitalization, and that pain should be individually assessed and managed. More than 80% thought pain management practice in HF patients should be improved, and 78.1% were interested in getting more information and believed an online education module was the most preferable approach. Lack of pain assessment tools, drug addiction, side effect, overuse, underuse, and contraindication with other medications were the main concerns regarding opioid use in pain management in HF. The gaps in pain management in HF patients included lack of knowledge of opioid use, lack of consideration and awareness of pain, no clinical guidelines for pain assessment and treatment, and complicated pain management with multiple chronic conditions.

CONCLUSIONS

The impact of pain and need for individual assessment and management of pain in HF patients were perceived by nurses; improvement in pain management practice in HF patients is needed. Concerns regarding opioid use and gaps in pain management of HF patients should be addressed.

Palliative Care in Heart Failure

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This review illustrates the dynamic role of palliative care in heart failure management and encapsulates the commonly utilized pharmacologic and non-pharmacologic therapeutic strategies for symptom palliation in heart failure. In addition, we provide our experience regarding patient care issues common to the domain of heart failure and palliative medicine which are commonly encountered by heart failure teams.

RECENT FINDINGS

Addition of palliative care to conventional heart failure management plan results in improvement in quality of life, anxiety, depression, and spiritual well-being among patients. Palliative care should not be confused with hospice care. Palliative care teams should be involved early in the care of heart failure patients with the aims of improving symptom palliation, discussing goals of care and improving quality of life without compromising utilization of evidence-based heart failure therapies. A consensus on the appropriate timing of involvement and evidence for many symptom palliation therapies is still emerging.

The Characteristics of Pain in Patients Diagnosed with Depression and Heart Failure

Heart failure (HF) is a costly and growing health problem that is routinely complicated by chronic pain and depression. The purpose of this paper is to describe the characteristics of pain and pain management in depressed HF patients. In this descriptive cross-sectional study, we analyzed data from 62 participants with depression and class II-IV HF. Study variables of interest were collected from the Brief Pain Inventory, Beck Depression Inventory, and Rand-36. Almost all participants (98%) had some pain in the past month and most had pain in the last 24 hours (66%). The median pain score was 4 (0-10 scale) with the majority reporting moderate to severe pain. The median pain interference score was 4.42 (0-10 scale) with the majority reporting moderate to extreme interference. Medication to treat pain was used by all participants who reported pain, with only 5% also using nonpharmacologic treatment. The majority of participants reported moderate or severe pain while also having moderate to extreme pain interference. Nonpharmacologic pain treatments were severely underused. Women were more likely to have higher levels of pain intensity and more pain interference than men, suggesting that additional screening for the impact of pain is especially important in women. The wide variety of body areas affected, along with moderate to high intensity pain and considerable interference scores reported, indicate that pain was ineffectively treated. Nonpharmacologic treatments should be considered to decrease the impact of pain.

Pain in the Geriatric Patient with Advanced Chronic Disease

The World Health Organization, one of the leading authorities on pain management, stressed the need for further guidelines to help manage pain in patients with chronic disease. In light of the impact of pain on morbidity and quality of life, this article summarizes current knowledge about pain experienced by older adults in 3 advanced non-cancer-related chronic diseases (ie, congestive heart failure, end-stage renal disease, and stroke) in which pain is common but not typically a primary focus of disease management. This article examines the data on the prevalence of pain, co-occurring symptoms, and challenges in managing pain in these conditions.