Progressing towards the complete and thorough characterization of the HLA genes by NGS (or single-molecule DNA sequencing): Consequences, opportunities and challenges

A novel swab storage gel is superior to dry swab DNA collection, and enables long-range high resolution NGS HLA typing from buccal cell samples

HLA sequence-based DNA typing (SBT) by long-range PCR amplification (LR PCR) and next-generation sequencing (NGS) is a high-throughput DNA sequencing method (LR-NGS-SBT) for the efficient and sensitive detection of novel and null HLA alleles to the field-4 level of allelic resolution without phase ambiguity. However, the accuracy and reliability of the HLA typing results using buccal cells (BCs) and saliva as genetic source materials for the LR-NGS-SBT method are dependent largely on the quality of the extracted genomic DNA (gDNA) because a large degree of gDNA fragmentation can result in insufficient PCR amplification with the incorrect assignment of HLA alleles due to allele dropouts. In this study, we developed a new cost-efficient swab storage gel (SSG) for wet swab collection of BCs (BC-SSG) and evaluated its usefulness by performing different DNA analytical parameters including LR-NGS-SBT to compare the quality and quantity of gDNA extracted from BCs (in SSG or air dried), blood and saliva of 30 subjects. The BC-SSG samples after 5 days of storage revealed qualitative and quantitative DNA values equivalent to that of blood and/or saliva and better than swabs that were only air-dried (BC-nSSG). Moreover, all the gDNA extracted from blood, saliva and BC-SSG samples were HLA-typed successfully to an equivalent total of 408 alleles for each sample type. Therefore, the application of BC-SSG collection media for LR-NGS-SBT has benefits over BC dried samples (dry swabs) such as reducing retesting and the number of untestable BC samples due to insufficient DNA amplification. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Challenges in the application of NGS in the clinical laboratory

Next-generation sequencing (NGS), also known as massively parallel sequencing, has revolutionized genomic research. The current advances in NGS technology make it possible to provide high resolution, high throughput HLA typing in clinical laboratories. The focus of this review is on the recent development and implementation of NGS in clinical laboratories. Here, we examine the critical role of NGS technologies in clinical immunology for HLA genotyping. Two major NGS platforms (Illumina and Ion Torrent) are characterized including NGS library preparation, data analysis, and validation. Challenges of NGS implementation in the clinical laboratory are also discussed, including sequencing error rate, bioinformatics, result interpretation, analytic sensitivity, as well as large data storage. This review aims to promote the broader applications of NGS technology in clinical laboratories and advocate for the novel applications of NGS to drive future research.

Long-Read Nanopore Sequencing Validated for Human Leukocyte Antigen Class I Typing in Routine Diagnostics

Matching of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) gene polymorphisms by high-resolution DNA sequence analysis is the gold standard for determining compatibility between patient and donor for hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. Single-molecule sequencing (PacBio or MinION) is a newest (third) generation sequencing approach. MinION is a nanopore sequencing platform, which provides long targeted DNA sequences. The long reads provide unambiguous phasing, but the initial high error profile prevented its use in high-impact applications, such as HLA typing for HLA matching of donor and recipient in the transplantation setting. Ongoing developments on instrumentation and basecalling software have improved the per-base accuracy of 1D² nanopore reads tremendously. In the current study, two validation panels of samples covering 70 of the 71 known HLA class I allele groups were used to compare third field sequences obtained by MinION, with Sanger sequence-based typing showing a 100% concordance between both data sets. In addition, the first validation panel was used to set the acceptance criteria for the use of MinION in a routine setting. The acceptance criteria were subsequently confirmed with the second validation panel. In summary, the present study describes validation and implementation of nanopore sequencing HLA class I typing method and illustrates that nanopore sequencing technology has advanced to a point where it can be used in routine diagnostics with high accuracy.

A genomic perspective on HLA evolution

Several decades of research have convincingly shown that classical human leukocyte antigen (HLA) loci bear signatures of natural selection. Despite this conclusion, many questions remain regarding the type of selective regime acting on these loci, the time frame at which selection acts, and the functional connections between genetic variability and natural selection. In this review, we argue that genomic datasets, in particular those generated by next-generation sequencing (NGS) at the population scale, are transforming our understanding of HLA evolution. We show that genomewide data can be used to perform robust and powerful tests for selection, capable of identifying both positive and balancing selection at HLA genes. Importantly, these tests have shown that natural selection can be identified at both recent and ancient timescales. We discuss how findings from genomewide association studies impact the evolutionary study of HLA genes, and how genomic data can be used to survey adaptive change involving interaction at multiple loci. We discuss the methodological developments which are necessary to correctly interpret genomic analyses involving the HLA region. These developments include adapting the NGS analysis framework so as to deal with the highly polymorphic HLA data, as well as developing tools and theory to search for signatures of selection, quantify differentiation, and measure admixture within the HLA region. Finally, we show that high throughput analysis of molecular phenotypes for HLA genes-namely transcription levels-is now a feasible approach and can add another dimension to the study of genetic variation.

Different DRB1*03:01-DQB1*02:01 haplotypes confer different risk for celiac disease

Celiac disease is associated with the HLA-DR3-DQA1*05:01-DQB1*02:01 and DR4-DQA1*03:01-DQB1*03:02 haplotypes. In addition, there are currently over 40 non-HLA loci associated with celiac disease. This study extends previous analyses on different HLA haplotypes in celiac disease using next generation targeted sequencing. Included were 143 patients with celiac disease and 135 non-celiac disease controls investigated at median 9.8 years (1.4-18.3 years). PCR-based amplification of HLA and sequencing with Illumina MiSeq technology were used for extended sequencing of the HLA class II haplotypes HLA-DRB1, DRB3, DRB4, DRB5, DQA1 and DQB1, respectively. Odds ratios were computed marginally for every allele and haplotype as the ratio of allelic frequency in patients and controls as ratio of exposure rates (RR), when comparing a null reference with equal exposure rates in cases and controls. Among the extended HLA haplotypes, the strongest risk haplotype for celiac disease was shown for DRB3*01:01:02 in linkage with DQA1*05:01-DQB1*02:01 (RR = 6.34; P-value < .0001). In a subpopulation analysis, DRB3*01:01:02-DQA1*05:01-DQB1*02:01 remained the most significant in patients with Scandinavian ethnicity (RR = 4.63; P < .0001) whereas DRB1*07:01:01-DRB4*01:03:01-DQA1*02:01-DQB1*02:02:01 presented the highest risk of celiac disease among non-Scandinavians (RR = 7.94; P = .011). The data also revealed 2 distinct celiac disease risk DR3-DQA1*05:01-DQB*02:01 haplotypes distinguished by either the DRB3*01:01:02 or DRB3*02:02:01 alleles, indicating that different DRB1*03:01-DQB1*02:01 haplotypes confer different risk for celiac disease. The associated risk of celiac disease for DR3-DRB3*01:01:02-DQA1*05:01-DQB1*02:01 is predominant among patients of Scandinavian ethnicity.

Targeted Next-Generation Sequencing for Human Leukocyte Antigen Typing in a Clinical Laboratory: Metrics of Relevance and Considerations for Its Successful Implementation

CONTEXT

- Numerous feasibility studies to type human leukocyte antigens (HLAs) by next-generation sequencing (NGS) have led to the development of vendor-supported kits for HLA typing by NGS. Some clinical laboratories have introduced HLA-NGS, and many are investigating the introduction. Standards from accrediting agencies form the regulatory framework for introducing this test into clinical laboratories.

OBJECTIVES

- To provide an assessment of metrics and considerations relevant to the successful implementation of clinical HLA-NGS typing, and to provide as a reference a validated HLA-NGS protocol used clinically since December 2013 at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia (Philadelphia, Pennsylvania).

DATA SOURCES

- The HLA-NGS has been performed on 2532 samples. The initial 1046 and all homozygous samples were also typed by an alternate method. The HLA-NGS demonstrated 99.7% concordance with the alternate method. Ambiguous results were most common at the DPB1 locus because of a lack of phasing between exons 2 and 3 or the unsequenced exon 1 (533 of 2954 alleles; 18.04%) and the DRB1 locus because of not sequencing exon 1 (75 of 3972 alleles; 1.89%). No ambiguities were detected among the other loci. Except for 2 false homozygous samples, all homozygous samples (1891) demonstrated concordance with the alternate method. The article is organized to address the critical elements in the preanalytic, analytic, and postanalytic phases of introducing this assay into the clinical laboratory.

CONCLUSIONS

- The results demonstrate that HLA typing by NGS is a highly accurate, reproducible, efficient method that provides more-complete sequencing information for the length of the HLA gene and can be the single methodology for HLA typing in clinical immunogenetics laboratories.

Generation of Full-Length Class I Human Leukocyte Antigen Gene Consensus Sequences for Novel Allele Characterization

BACKGROUND

Routine, high-resolution human leukocyte antigen (HLA) genotyping by next generation sequencing within clinical immunogenetics laboratories can now provide the full-length gene sequence characterization of fully phased HLA alleles. This powerful technique provides insights into HLA variation beyond the traditionally characterized antigen recognition domain, providing sequence annotation across the entire gene including untranslated and intronic regions and may be used to characterize novel alleles from massively parallel sequencing runs.

METHODS

We evaluated the utility of the Omixon Holotype HLA assay to generate credible, fully phased full-length gene consensus sequences for 50 individuals at major histocompatibility complex, class I, A (HLA-A), HLA-B, and HLA-C loci (300 genotyped alleles in total) to identify and characterize novel class I HLA alleles using our downstream analytical pipeline.

RESULTS

Our analysis revealed that 7.7% (23/300) of genotyped class I HLA alleles contain novel polymorphisms. Interestingly, all of the novel alleles identified by our analysis were found to harbor sequence variations within intronic regions of the respective locus. In total our analysis identified 17 unique novel class I HLA alleles from 23 of the 300 genotyped alleles and generated full-length gene sequence annotations for 9 previously incompletely annotated HLA class I allele sequences derived from 14 of the 300 genotyped alleles.

CONCLUSIONS

The demonstrated utility of the Omixon Holotype HLA assay in combination with our downstream analytical framework to generate fully phased, full-length gene consensus sequences for the identification and characterization of novel HLA alleles, facilitates the study of HLA polymorphism beyond the antigen recognition domain in human health and disease.