Non-immunoglobulin A mesangial immune complex glomerulonephritis in kidney transplants

Subclinical C1q Nephropathy Combined with Possible Donor-Derived IgA Deposition in a 1-Year Kidney Allograft Biopsy: A Case Report

Few previous studies have reported immune-complex nephropathy that has not been classified as a specific phenotype in kidney allografts. We report a case of a de novo subclinical "full-house" pattern of deposition in a pediatric transplantation recipient with possible donor-derived IgA deposition. A five-year-old boy underwent living kidney transplantation due to congenital kidney and urinary tract anomalies. A one-hour implantation biopsy revealed IgA deposition. A four-month protocol biopsy finding showed less intense IgA deposition, in contrast with the one-hour biopsy, and trace para-mesangial deposits. A one-year protocol biopsy demonstrated a full-house deposition pattern and massive electron-dense deposits with minor glomerular changes. At the time of the one-year biopsy, kidney function was stable, with no urinalysis abnormalities. No evidence of systemic lupus erythematosus was observed in clinical and serologic examinations. Mesangial IgG, IgM, C3, and C1q deposition was codominant, and IgA deposition was weaker. We diagnosed this case as C1q nephropathy combined with remaining donor-derived IgA deposition. Few studies have reported C1q nephropathy in kidney allograft; further accumulation of cases is required. To distinguish between donor-derived and de novo glomerular lesions, it is important to assess the serial histologic findings of immunofluorescence and electron microscopy. Here, we report a rare case of subclinical C1q nephropathy with possible donor-derived IgA nephropathy.

Glomerular Diseases of the Kidney Allograft: Toward a Precision Medicine Approach

The continual development of potent immunosuppressive regimens has led to a decreased incidence of acute rejection and improvement of short-term kidney allograft survival. In contrast to acute rejection, glomerular diseases of the kidney allograft are being encountered more frequently and are emerging as leading causes of late kidney allograft failure. Although data on the pathogeneses of glomerular diseases in the kidney allograft are sparse, cumulative evidence suggests that post-transplant glomerular diseases may be the result of inherited predispositions and immunologic triggers. Although studying immunologic signals and performing genome-wide association studies are ideal approaches to tackle glomerular diseases in the kidney allograft, such studies are challenging because of the lack of adequately powered cohorts. In this review, we focus on the most commonly encountered recurrent and de novo glomerular diseases in the kidney allograft. We address the important advances made in understanding the immunopathology and genetic susceptibility of glomerular diseases in the native kidney and how to benefit from such knowledge to further our knowledge of post-transplant glomerular diseases. Defining genomic and immune predictors for glomerular diseases in the kidney allograft would support novel donor-recipient matching strategies and development of targeted therapies to ultimately improve long-term kidney allograft survival.

Histologic Case Definition of an Atypical Glomerular Immune-Complex Deposition Following Kidney Transplantation

Introduction

Immune-complex deposition in the transplanted kidney can present as well-phenotyped recurrent or de novo glomerular disease. However, a subset, herein termed immune-complex glomerulopathy not otherwise specified (ICG-NOS), defies classification. We quantified, categorized, and characterized cases of transplant ICG-NOS occurring at a single US academic medical center.

Methods

We retrospectively reviewed our single-institution pathology database (July 2007–July 2018) to identify and categorize all cases of immune-complex deposition in kidney allografts (based on immunofluorescence microscopy). We extracted clinicopathologic and outcome data for ICG-NOS (i.e., immune complex deposition not conforming to any well-characterized glomerular disease entity).

Results

Of 104 patients with significant immune deposits, 28 (27%) were classified as ICG-NOS. We created 5 mutually exclusive ICG-NOS categories: Full-house, Quasi-full-house, IgA-rich, C1q-rich, and C1q-poor. Overall, 16 (57%) patients met criteria for definite or possible allograft rejection, including 9 (32%) with antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR), 3 (11%) suspicious for ABMR, 1 (4%) with T-cell–mediated rejection (TCMR), and 9 (32%) with borderline TCMR. After a median follow-up of 2.3 (range, 0.1–14.0) years after biopsy, 7 (25%) allografts had failed and an additional 8 (29%) had persistent renal dysfunction (hematuria, 14%; proteinuria, 21%; and estimated glomerular filtration rate <60 ml/min per 1.73 m², 11%).

Conclusion

In contrast to prior studies, our findings suggest that ICG-NOS is not necessarily a benign glomerular process and that there may be an association between ICG-NOS and alloimmunity. Our immunofluorescence-based classification provides a framework for future studies aiming to further elucidate ICG-NOS pathogenesis and prognosis.

De novo immune complex deposition in kidney allografts: a series of 32 patients

Immune complex deposition in kidney allografts can include both recurrent and de novo processes. Recurrent glomerulonephritis is a well-recognized phenomenon and has been shown to be a common cause of allograft failure. De novo immune complex-mediated disease remains relatively poorly characterized, likely owing to the less frequent use of immunofluorescence and electron microscopy in the transplant setting. We performed a retrospective review of kidney allograft biopsies showing glomerular immune complex deposition. Cases with de novo deposits were identified and further organized into two groups depending on whether the immune complex deposition could be clinically and/or histologically classified. Thirty-two patients with de novo immune complex deposition were identified over a 7-year period. A broad range of immune complex-mediated injuries were observed, the majority (63%) of which could be readily classified either clinically or histologically. These included cases of membranous glomerulonephropathy, IgA nephropathy, infection-related glomerulonephritis and glomerulonephritis related to an underlying autoimmune process. A smaller subset of patients (37%) demonstrated immune complex deposition that was difficult to histologically or clinically classify. These patients typically showed mild mesangial immune complex deposition with co-dominant IgG and IgM staining by immunofluorescence microscopy. The presence of concurrent antibody-mediated rejection and donor-specific antibody positivity was significantly higher in the unclassifiable group. The significance of these deposits and their possible relationship to allograft rejection deserves further investigation.