Substitution of iron with cobalt in the prosthetic group of bacterial cytochrome P450: Effects on the stability and structure of the protein

Molecular Determinants of Efficient Cobalt-Substituted Hemoprotein Production in E. coli

Exchanging the native iron of heme for other metals yields artificial metalloproteins with new properties for spectroscopic studies and biocatalysis. Recently, we reported a method for the biosynthesis and incorporation of a non-natural metallocofactor, cobalt protoporphyrin IX (CoPPIX), into hemoproteins using the common laboratory strain Escherichia coli BL21(DE3). This discovery inspired us to explore the determinants of metal specificity for metallocofactor biosynthesis in E. coli. Herein, we report detailed kinetic analysis of the ferrochelatase responsible for metal insertion, EcHemH (E. coli ferrochelatase). This enzyme exhibits a small, less than 2-fold preference for Fe2+ over the non-native Co2+ substrate in vitro. To test how mutations impact EcHemH, we used a surrogate metal specificity screen to identify variants with altered metal insertion preferences. This engineering process led to a variant with an ∼30-fold shift in specificity toward Co2+. When assayed in vivo, however, the impact of this mutation is small compared to the effects of alteration of the external metal concentrations. These data suggest that incorporation of cobalt into PPIX is enabled by the native promiscuity of EcHemH coupled with BL21's impaired ability to maintain transition-metal homeostasis. With this knowledge, we generated a method for CoPPIX production in rich media, which yields cobalt-substituted hemoproteins with >95% cofactor purity and yields comparable to standard expression protocols for the analogous native hemoproteins.

Computationally guided bioengineering of the active site, substrate access pathway, and water channels of thermostable cytochrome P450, CYP175A1, for catalyzing the alkane hydroxylation reaction

Understanding structure-function relationships in proteins is pivotal in their development as industrial biocatalysts. In this regard, rational engineering of protein active site access pathways and various tunnels and channels plays a central role in designing competent enzymes with high stability and enhanced efficiency. Here, we report the rational evolution of a thermostable cytochrome P450, CYP175A1, to catalyze the C-H activation reaction of longer-chain alkanes. A strategy combining computational tools with experiments has shown that the substrate scope and enzymatic activity can be enhanced by rational engineering of certain important channels such as the substrate entry and water channels along with the active site of the enzyme. The evolved enzymes showed an improved catalytic rate for hexadecane hydroxylation with high regioselectivity. The Q67L/Y68F mutation showed binding of the substrate in the active site, water channel mutation L80F/V220T showed improved catalytic activity through the peroxide shunt pathway and substrate entry channel mutation W269F/I270A showed better substrate accessibility to the active pocket. All-atom MD simulations provided the rationale for the inactivity of the wild-type CYP175A1 for hexadecane hydroxylation and predicted the above hot-spot residues to enhance the activity. The reaction mechanism was studied by QM/MM calculations for enzyme-substrate complexes and reaction intermediates. Detailed thermal and thermodynamic stability of all the mutants were analyzed and the results showed that the evolved enzymes were thermally stable. The present strategy showed promising results, and insights gained from this work can be applied to the general enzymatic system to expand substrate scope and improve catalytic activity.

Deciphering the role of the two metal-binding sites of DapE enzyme via metal substitution

DapE is a microbial metalloenzyme that hosts two Zn ions in its active site, although it shows catalytic activity with varying efficiency when the Zn ions in one or both of its metal-binding sites (MBS) are replaced by other transition-metal ions. The metal-ion promiscuity of DapE is believed to be a microbial strategy to overcome the homeostatic regulation of Zn ions by the mammalian host. Here, a hybrid QM/MM study is performed on a series of mixed-metal DapEs, where the Zn ion in the first MBS (MBS-1) is substituted by Mn, Co, Ni, and Cu ions, while the MBS-2 is occupied by Zn(II). The substrate binding affinity and the mechanism of catalytic action are estimated by optimizing the intermediates and the transition states with hybrid QM/MM method. Comparison of the binding affinity of the MBS-1 and MBS-2 substituted DapEs reveals that the MBS-1 substitution does not affect the substrate binding affinity in the mixed-metal DapEs, while a strong metal specificity was observed in MBS-2 substituted DapEs. On the contrary, the activation energy barriers show a high metal specificity at MBS-1 compared to MBS-2. Taken together, the QM/MM studies indicate that MBS-2 leads the substrate binding process, while MBS-1 steers the catalytic activity of the DapE enzyme.

Metal-ion promiscuity of microbial enzyme DapE at its second metal-binding site

Metalloenzymes are ubiquitous in nature catalyzing a number of crucial biochemical processes in animal and plant kingdoms. For better adaptation to the relative abundance of different metal ions in different cellular fluids, many of these enzymes exhibit metal promiscuity. The microbial enzyme DapE, an essential enzyme for bacterial growth and survival and a potentially safe target for antibiotics, continues to show enzyme activity when the two zinc ions in its active site are replaced by other transition metal ions. The effect of metal-ion substitution at the second metal-binding site of DapE on its substrate affinity and catalytic efficiency is investigated by QM/MM treatment of the enzyme-substrate complex, by modelling the enzyme with Mn(II), Co(II), Ni(II), or Cu(II) ion in place of Zn(II) at its second metal-binding site, while retaining Zn(II) ion at the first metal-binding site. On the basis of substrate binding energy and activation energy barrier for the chemical catalysis, it is found that Zn-Mn DapE shows poor binding affinity as well as inefficient chemical catalysis. Although Zn-Cu and Zn-Ni DapEs show activation energy barriers comparable to that of wild-type Zn-Zn DapE, their weaker substrate affinity renders these mixed-metal enzymes less efficient. On the other hand, Zn-Co DapE is found to outperform the naturally occurring Zn-Zn DapE, both in terms of substrate affinity and chemical catalysis. The observed metal promiscuity may have played an important role in the survival of bacteria even in those cellular media where Zn ions are in limited supply. Metal nonspecificity in the catalysis of DapE enzyme allows bacteria to thrive in different cellular media.