Chemical instrumental analysis versus human evaluation to measure sensory properties of dairy products: What is fit for purpose?

Discrimination and screening of volatile metabolites in atractylodis rhizoma from different varieties using headspace solid-phase microextraction-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry and headspace gas chromatography-ion mobility spectrometry, and ultra-fast gas chromatography electronic nose

Atractylodis rhizoma is a common bulk medicinal material with multiple species. Although different varieties of atractylodis rhizoma exhibit variations in their chemical constituents and pharmacological activities, they have not been adequately distinguished due to their similar morphological features. Hence, the purpose of this research is to analyze and characterize the volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in samples of atractylodis rhizoma using multiple techniques and to identify the key differential VOCs among different varieties of atractylodis rhizoma for effective discrimination. The identification of VOCs was carried out using headspace solid-phase microextraction-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (HS-SPME-GC-MS) and headspace gas chromatography-ion mobility spectrometry (HS-GC-IMS), resulting in the identification of 60 and 53 VOCs, respectively. The orthogonal partial least squares discriminant analysis (OPLS-DA) model was employed to screen potential biomarkers and based on the variable importance in projection (VIP ≥ 1.2), 24 VOCs were identified as critical differential compounds. Random forest (RF), K-nearest neighbor (KNN) and back propagation neural network based on genetic algorithm (GA-BPNN) models based on potential volatile markers realized the greater than 90 % discriminant accuracies, which indicates that the obtained key differential VOCs are reliable. At the same time, the aroma characteristics of atractylodis rhizoma were also analyzed by ultra-fast gas chromatography electronic nose (Ultra-fast GC E-nose). This study indicated that the integration of HS-SPME-GC-MS, HS-GC-IMS and ultra-fast GC E-nose with chemometrics can comprehensively reflect the differences of VOCs in atractylodis rhizoma samples from different varieties, which will be a prospective tool for variety discrimination of atractylodis rhizoma.

Identification of Aroma-active Compounds in Milk by GC×GC-O-TOF-MS Combined with Check-all-that-apply

Understanding consumers' sensory preferences for dairy products is essential. This study employed sensory analysis and instrumental techniques to analyze the flavor of pasteurized milk and ultra-high temperature (UHT) milk. There were 6 milk samples with similar fat content (4.0-4.6 g/100mL) and protein content (3.2-3.8 g/100mL). Sensory data from consumer tests was collected using CATA (n = 100) and 9-point hedonic preferences. Research showed that Chinese consumers could distinguish the flavor of the 2 types of milk, and UHT milk showed a higher preference score, which may be due to the more pronounced milky flavor and sweet taste of UHT milk. A total of 48 aroma-active compounds were sniffed through GC × GC-O-TOF-MS, among which 11 were determined as key aroma-active compounds. Correlation analysis showed that milky odor, sweetness, and aftertaste-milky were positively correlated with γ-dodecalactone and γ-nonanolactone. Cooked and oxidized taste were positively correlated with 1-octen-3-ol and E-2-octenal. This study is important for developing Chinese dairy products and exporting dairy products to China by multinational companies.

Effects of Storage in an Active and Spontaneous Controlled O2/CO2 Atmosphere on Volatile Flavor Components and the Microbiome of Truffles

This study explored the potential to improve the storage quality and prolong the shelf life of truffles by storing them in a modified atmosphere fresh-keeping box with sealed gas components of Active Modified Atmosphere Packaging (AMAP, 40% O2 + 60% CO2) at 4 °C. During the storage period, a total of 63 volatile components in 10 categories were detected, with aldehydes being the most abundant and the relative content of ethers being the highest. The relative odor activity value and principal component analysis revealed that isovaleraldehyde, 1-octen-3-ol, 1-octen-3-one, and dimethyl sulfide were the characteristic flavor components of fresh truffles. However, 3-methylthiopropionaldehyde and (E, E)-2,4-nonadienal were the components that caused the deterioration of truffle flavor and could potentially serve as markers of truffle decay characteristics. 16S rDNA high-throughput sequencing showed that Leuconostoc and Lactococcus were dominant in the truffle samples stored for 14 days, but the abundance of putrefactive pathogenic bacteria showed an increasing trend in the truffle samples stored for 28 days. During the whole storage period, the common fungi detected in the different treatment groups were Candida and Aspergillus. The relative abundance of the former decreased, while the relative abundance of the latter decreased initially and then increased. The correlation between volatile components and the microbial flora was further analyzed, which indicated that Lactococcus and Lactobacillus had the same contributions to the same flavor, while Pseudomonas and Glutamicibacter had the opposite contributions to the same flavor. The results provide a reference for the storage and preservation of truffles.

Instrumental Analysis or Human Evaluation to Measure the Appearance, Smell, Flavor, and Physical Properties of Food

Instrumental analysis and sensory evaluation are two fundamental approaches used to assess the quality of food products, encompassing attributes such as appearance, smell, flavor, and physical properties [...].

The influence of the texture and color of goat’s salad cheese on the emotional reactions of consumers compared to cow’s milk cheese and Feta cheese

In this study, the sensory and mechanical aspects of the texture of goat’s milk salad cheese were correlated with the emotional profiles of consumers. Using descriptive sensory analysis and instrumental assessment, the texture profile of goat’s milk salad cheese was compared to cow’s milk salad cheese and Feta cheese. Texture measurements confirmed that goat’s cheese compared to cow’s cheese had more softness and less hardness, and Feta cheese had the highest whiteness index compared to the other cheeses. Goat’s milk salad cheese was much less acceptable to consumers compared to cow’s milk cheese and Feta cheese. Consumers also indicated that the hardness of goat’s cheese was lower than that of cow’s cheese and Feta cheese. A reduction in “stickiness” in comparison with cow’s cheese was also reported; however, it was much higher than that for Feta cheese. The “fracturability” and “graininess” of goat’s cheese was similar to cow’s cheese. Emotional profile analysis showed that goat’s cheese evokes mainly negative emotions. Consumers indicated only one positive emotion in the case of this cheese, which was “healthy”. The most frequently mentioned emotions after the consumption of goat’s cheese were “upset”, “disgusted” and “worried”. Many consumers also indicated “disappointed” and “angry”, which did not occur after the consumption of cow’s cheese. This research shows how important it is to combine several analyses and techniques when evaluating dairy products, including salad cheeses. It is also important that consumer research is enriched by emotional profiling.

Graphical abstract

Impact of different processing techniques on the key volatile profile, sensory, and consumer acceptance of black truffle (Tuber melanosporum Vittadini)

Fresh truffles which include black truffle (Tuber melanosporum Vittadini) deteriorate and lose aroma rapidly after harvest; therefore, postharvest processing via freeze-drying or encapsulation is an option to preserve truffle aroma for extended supply. However, the aroma profile that directly affects the truffle quality and consumer acceptance is influenced by processing and producers require processing options that balance processing feasibility with retention of a suitable aroma profile. This study aimed to determine the impact of freeze-drying and encapsulation on the profile of key volatiles, consumer discrimination, and overall sensory impression (aroma intensity, liking, and acceptability) of processed truffle products compared to the starting material (positive control). The study combined experimental-scale processing with GC-MS analysis and consumer sensory evaluation to compare and optimize postharvest processing options. Based on the results, some volatile changes were detected in the processed truffle products compared to the positive control which were aligned with the consumer discrimination (triangle test) and the aroma intensity score (consumer sensory test). Despite some chemical and sensory differences detected, the consumer panel did not have any preference for processed truffle products compared to the positive control. The overall finding indicates the potential value of processing truffles into a natural flavoring ingredient for food application via freeze-drying or encapsulation, which should be of great interest for the truffle and food industry. According to the correlation analysis, the consumer acceptance of a truffle product may be increased by retaining 1-octen-3-ol and methional, while reducing the amount of p-cresol in the product. PRACTICAL APPLICATION: The postharvest process of turning truffles into a food flavoring ingredient may cause undesirable volatile changes that would directly impact the aroma quality and consumer acceptance of the processed truffle products. Hence, the impacts of freeze-drying and encapsulation on the chemical and sensory profile of truffles were evaluated in this study. Overall, the results of the concurrent instrument and sensory analysis demonstrated that both freeze-drying and encapsulation are potential options for processing.

Methods used for extraction of plant volatiles have potential to preserve truffle aroma: A review

Truffles are considered one of the world's most highly prized foods mainly due to their desirable organoleptic properties and rarity. However, truffles are seasonal (harvested mostly in winter from June to August in the Southern Hemisphere and from December to February in the Northern Hemisphere) and extremely perishable. Truffles deteriorate rapidly showing undesirable changes within 10 days from harvest in aroma and visual appearance after harvest. The very short postharvest shelf life (about 7-10 days) limits the potential for export and domestic consumption all year round. Several preservation methods have been studied to prolong their shelf life without the loss of aroma. However, all traditional preservation techniques have their own shortcomings and remain challenging. The extraction of natural truffle aroma volatiles for food applications could be a potential alternative to replace the existing synthetic flavoring used for processed truffle products. Four commonly used extraction methods for recovering volatile compounds from plants, namely, supercritical carbon dioxide extraction, Soxhlet extraction, distillation, and cold pressing, are critically analyzed. Up to date, existing research about the extraction of aroma volatiles from truffles is limited in the literature but based on the volatility of the key truffle volatile compounds, supercritical carbon dioxide extraction may offer the best possibility so that a natural truffle-based product that can be used in food applications throughout the year can be made available.