Exploring the microbial origins of p-cresol and its co-occurrence pattern in the Chinese liquor-making process

Effect of incubation temperature on identification of key odorants of sewage sludge using headspace GC analysis

Currently, headspace gas chromatography-mass spectrometry is a widely used method to identify the key odorants of sludge. However, the effect of incubation temperature on the generation and emission of key odorants from sludge was still uncertain. Thus, in this paper, headspace solid-phase microextraction gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (HS-SPME-GC-MS) and headspace gas chromatography-coupled ion mobility spectrometry (HS-GC-IMS) were carried out to analyze the volatiles emitted from the sludge incubated at different temperatures (30 °C, 50 °C, 60 °C, and 80 °C). The results indicated that the total volatile concentration of the sludge increased with temperatures, which affected the identified proportion of sludge key odorants to a certain extent. Differently from the aqueous solutions, the variation of volatile emission from the sludge was inconsistent with temperature changes, suggesting a multifactorial influence of incubation temperature on the identification of sludge odorants. The microbial community structure and adenosine triphosphate (ATP) metabolic activity of the sludge samples were analyzed at the initial state, 30 °C, and 80 °C. Although no significant effect of incubation temperature on the microbial community structure of the sludge, the incubation at 80 °C led to a noticeable decrease in microbial ATP metabolic activity, accompanied by a significant change in the proportion of odor-related microorganisms with low relative abundances. Changes in the composition and activity of these communities jointly contributed to the differences in odor emission from sludge at different temperatures. In summary, the incubation temperature affects the production and emission of volatiles from sludge through physicochemical and biochemical mechanisms, by which the microbial metabolism playing a crucial role. Therefore, when analyzing the key odorants of sludge, these factors should be considered.

Deciphering the core microbes and their interactions in spontaneous Baijiu fermentation: A comprehensive review

The spontaneous Baijiu fermentation system harbors a complex microbiome that is highly dynamic in time and space and varies depending on the Jiuqu starters and environmental factors. The intricate microbiota presents in the fermentation environment is responsible for carrying out various reactions. These reactions necessitate the interaction among the core microbes to influence the community function, ultimately shaping the distinct Baijiu styles through the process of spontaneous fermentation. Numerous studies have been conducted to enhance our understanding of the diversity, succession, and function of microbial communities with the aim of improving fermentation manipulation. However, a comprehensive and critical assessment of the core microbes and their interaction remains one of the significant challenges in the Baijiu fermentation industry. This paper focuses on the fermentation properties of core microbes. We discuss the state of the art of microbial traceability, highlighting the crucial role of environmental and starter microbiota in the Baijiu brewing microbiome. Also, we discuss the various interactions between microbes in the Baijiu production system and propose a potential conceptual framework that involves constructing predictive network models to simplify and quantify microbial interactions using co-culture models. This approach offers effective strategies for understanding the core microbes and their interactions, thus beneficial for the management of microbiota and the regulation of interactions in Baijiu fermentation processes.

Characterization of key flavor substances and their microbial sources in traditional sour bamboo shoots

Identifying key flavor compounds and their producing bacteria in sour bamboo shoots is crucial for flavor stabilization and industrial production. This study analyzed 15 traditional sour bamboo shoot samples from northern Guangdong to determine key flavor substances and microbial community. Results showed key flavor substances were acetic acid (RTC ≥ 50% in 10 samples), lactic acid (RTC ≥ 50% in 5 samples), and p-cresol (ROC ≥ 93%). Lactobacillus (ARA: 54.62%) was the dominant genus, significantly correlated with p-cresol (r = 0.80, p ≤ 0.01). Levilactobacillus (ARA: 3.33%) was positively correlated with lactic acid and p-cresol (r = 0.78, p ≤ 0.01; r = 0.66, p ≤ 0.01). Lentilactobacillus (ARA: 4.29%) was positively correlated with acetic acid (r = 0.85, p ≤ 0.01). Levilactobacillus was isolated, screened, identified, and its ability to produce key flavor substances was tested. Four strains of Levilactobacillus spicheri and their mixed strains produced lactic acid (10.12-16.62 g/kg), acetic acid (10.21-21.60 g/kg), and p-cresol (25.67-143.87 mg/kg). This is the first report of Levilactobacillus spicheri producing p-cresol.

Succession of microbial community of the pit mud under the impact of Daqu of Nongxiang Baijiu

Complex microbiomes of pit mud play significant roles in imbuing flavors and qualities of Nongxiang Baijiu during fermentation. However, pit mud microbial enrichment and succession is a long process that is also accompanied by aging. Development of high-quality artificial pit mud becomes an urgent problem. In this study, a new medium based on space (TK) Daqu was used to effectively enrich the dominant microorganisms in pit mud. The results showed that Caproiciproducens was the most preponderance in the cultures unadded Daqu, whereas Clostridium sensu stricto 12 was the most preponderance, followed by Caproiciproducens in the enrichment cultures added TK Daqu. It is worth noting that TK Daqu balanced the relative abundance of Caproiciproducens and Clostridium sensu stricto 12 in 100-year pit mud culture (S100), which was more conducive to the increase of methanogens. PICRUSt2 prediction results showed that hydrogenotrophic methanogens could promote the synthesis of caproic acid by using the product H2 as the metabolic substrate and increased significantly in the pit mud enrichment cultures with TK Daqu. The increase of lactate dehydrogenase (EC 1.1.1.27) content in S100 contributed to the degradation of lactic acid and the increase of caproic acid. Adding TK Daqu enrichment cultures is more conducive to the enrichment and metabolic balance of pit mud microorganisms.

Spatiotemporal accumulation differences of volatile compounds and bacteria metabolizing pickle like odor compounds during stacking fermentation of Maotai-flavor baijiu

Pickle like odor (PLO) is undesirable in Maotai-flavor baijiu; however, its formation mechanism is unclear. Furthermore, there is a lack of understanding of the spatiotemporal accumulation of volatile compounds (including PLO compounds, PLOC) and of the microorganisms responsible for the production of PLOC during stacking fermentation. In this study, we analyzed the spatiotemporal distribution differences of 132 volatile compounds in piled fermented grains. PLOC (n = 5) were higher in pile surface than in pile center, reaching their highest levels at 6th and 5th rounds, respectively. The microorganisms in pile center were more conducive to the formation of alcohols, while those in the pile surface more promoted the synthesis of esters. Rhodococcus and Zygosaccharomyces promoted the formation of PLOC. Acetobacter was negatively correlated with the content of sulfur compounds by promoting their conversion into non-volatile sulfur compounds, thereby reducing the content of PLOC. This study provides information on the spatiotemporal differences of volatile compounds (especially PLOC) in piled fermented grains and identified the microorganisms that produce PLOC.

Characterization of the differences in aroma-active compounds in strong-flavor Baijiu induced by bioaugmented Daqu using metabolomics and sensomics approaches

Bioaugmenting Daqu is an effective strategy to improve the quality of Baijiu, but its effect on overall flavor profiles and aroma-active compounds is unknown. Here, 168 volatiles were determined from fresh strong-flavor Baijiu (SFB) and bioaugmented Daqu increased their diversity and altered the flavor characteristics. Among 49 odorants identified by aroma extraction dilution analysis, 29 aroma-active compounds had odor activity values ≥1, of which 18, 8, and 3 components exhibited the highest content in the SFB fermented by fortified-, space- and conventional-Daqu, respectively. The contribution of increasing ethyl hexanoate and decreasing ethyl lactate of fresh SFB by bioaugmented Daqu was confirmed, and their content changed from 4650 and 1890 mg/L (conventional-SFB) to 6680 and 1760 mg/L (fortified-SFB) and 6130 and 1710 mg/L (space-SFB). Meanwhile, the discriminators among different samples were determined by multivariate statistical analysis. These findings are beneficial for the optimization and improvement of Baijiu aroma.

Effect of microbial interaction on flavor quality in Chinese baijiu fermentation

Chinese baijiu brewing is an open, complex, and synergetic functional microbiota fermentation process. Microbial interaction is pivotal for the regulation of microbial structure and function in the brewing microecosystem, consequently affecting the flavor and quality of baijiu. This article mainly summarizes the effect of microbial interactions among functional microbiota on the growth performance, flavor formation, and safe quality of baijiu fermentation process. In addition, the review specifically emphasizes on the microbial interactions for the regulation of “Ethyl Caproate-Increasing and Ethyl Lactate-Decreasing” in Chinese strong-flavor baijiu. Furthermore, the construction of synthetic microbiota by metabolic characteristics of the functional microbes and their interactions for regulating and controlling flavor quality of Chinese baijiu is also reviewed and prospected.

Research on interaction regularities and mechanisms between lactic acid and aroma compounds of Baijiu

This study investigated the interactions between lactic acid (LA) and odorants of Baijiu using headspace solid phase microextraction with gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (HS-SPME-GC-MS), ultraviolet absorption spectroscopy (UV) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). The HS-SPME-GC-MS analysis results showed that LA promoted the volatilities of most of low boiling acids, esters, alcohols, aldehydes and ketones, especially short-chain branched esters were promoted by 41-49%. In contrast, LA suppressed the volatilities of most aromatic compounds. UV spectroscopy, thermodynamic analysis, and NMR combined with theoretical calculations further revealed that the interactions between LA and 4-ethyl-2-methoxyphenol (4-EP), 2-methoxy-4-methylphenol (2-MP) and 1-butanol were dominated by van der Waals forces and supplemented by electrostatic interactions, which included hydrogen bonds formed between the carboxyl group in LA and the hydroxyl and methoxy groups in 4-EP or 2-MP and π-hydrogen bonds between the hydrogen of the carboxyl group of LA and the benzene ring of 4-EP or 2-MP.

Metabolite-Based Mutualistic Interaction between Two Novel Clostridial Species from Pit Mud Enhances Butyrate and Caproate Production

Pit mud microbial consortia play crucial roles in the formation of Chinese strong-flavor baijiu's key flavor-active compounds, especially butyric and caproic acids. Clostridia, one of the abundant bacterial groups in pit mud, were recognized as important butyric and caproic acid producers. Research on the interactions of the pit mud microbial community mainly depends on correlation analysis at present. Interaction between Clostridium and other microorganisms and its involvement in short/medium-chain fatty acid (S/MCFA) metabolism are still unclear. We previously found coculture of two clostridial strains isolated from pit mud, Clostridium fermenticellae JN500901 (C.901) and Novisyntrophococcus fermenticellae JN500902 (N.902), could enhance S/MCFA accumulation. Here, we investigated their underlying interaction mechanism through the combined analysis of phenotype, genome, and transcriptome. Compared to monocultures, coculture of C.901 and N.902 obviously promoted their growth, including shortening the growth lag phase and increasing biomass, and the accumulation of butyric acid and caproic acid. The slight effects of inoculation ratio and continuous passage on the growth and metabolism of coculture indicated the relative stability of their interaction. Transwell coculture and transcriptome analysis showed the interaction between C.901 and N.902 was accomplished by metabolite exchange, i.e., formic acid produced by C.901 activated the Wood-Ljungdahl pathway of N.902, thereby enhancing its production of acetic acid, which was further converted to butyric acid and caproic acid by C.901 through reverse β-oxidation. This work demonstrates the potential roles of mutually beneficial interspecies interactions in the accumulation of key flavor compounds in pit mud. IMPORTANCE Microbial interactions played crucial roles in influencing the assembly, stability, and function of the microbial community. The metabolites of pit mud microbiota are the key to flavor formation of Chinese strong-flavor baijiu. So far, researches on the interactions of the pit mud microbial community have been mainly based on the correlation analysis of sequencing data, and more work needs to be performed to unveil the complicated interaction patterns. Here, we identified a material exchange-based mutualistic interaction system involving two fatty acid-producing clostridial strains (Clostridium fermenticellae JN500901 and Novisyntrophococcus fermenticellae JN500902) isolated from pit mud and systematically elucidated their interaction mechanism for promoting the production of butyric acid and caproic acid, the key flavor-active compounds of baijiu. Our findings provide a new perspective for understanding the complicated interactions of pit mud microorganisms.

Volatile Nitrogenous Compounds from Bacteria: Source of Novel Bioactive Compounds

Bacteria can produce nitrogenous compounds via both primary and secondary metabolic processes. Many bacterial volatile nitrogenous compounds produced during the secondary metabolism have been identified and reported for their antioxidant, antibacterial, antifungal, algicidal and antitumor activities. The production of these nitrogenous compounds depends on several factors, including the composition of culture media, growth conditions, and even the organic solvent used for their extraction, thus requiring their identification in specific conditions. In this review, we describe the volatile nitrogenous compounds produced by bacteria especially focusing on their antimicrobial activity. We concentrate on azo-compounds mainly pyrazines and pyrrolo-pyridines reported for their activity against several microorganisms. Whenever significant, extraction and identification methods of these compounds are also mentioned and discussed. To the best of our knowledge, this is first review describing volatile nitrogenous compounds from bacteria focusing on their biological activity.

Profiling the effects of physicochemical indexes on the microbial diversity and its aroma substances in pit mud

Microbial diversity of pit mud (PM) plays a significant role in Baijiu's flavour. Here we explored the microbial community structures and aroma substances of Wenwang Winery with high-throughput sequencing coupling with headspace solid-phase microextraction-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. We discovered that the odorant was mainly derived from 14 aroma compounds because of their OAVs ≥ 1 (OAV, the ratio of substance concentration to aroma threshold; s, on behalf of the plural), such as ethyl hexanoate (2438), ethyl octanoate (975), caproic acid (52) and etc. Moreover we also revealed that Lactobacillaceae (97·08%) was the mainly bacterial microbial community in 2-year-old PM, companied by the primarily fungi including Aspergillaceae (55·45%), Unclassified Ascomycota (11·13%) and Dipodascaceae (5·72%). Compared with the 2-year-old PM, bacterial floras in 20-year-old PM and 30-year-old PM were more abundant (i.e. Dysgonomonadaceae, Clostridium and Synerggstaceas), while no fungi were detected. Besides, the physicochemical analysis showed that the content of Lactobacillaceae was inversely associated with moisture, pH and ammonia nitrogen. By further Spearman's correlation coefficient analysis, we verified that the content of Lactobacillaceae was positively correlated with ethyl hexanoate, while negatively correlated with ethyl octanoate and caproic acid. Meanwhile, ethyl octanoate and caproic acid were positively correlated with most flora including Ruminococcaceae, Dysgonomonadaceae and Clostridiacea, which were related to physicochemical indexes. This work demonstrates promise for adjusting the physicochemical indexes of PM to affect the micro-organisms and aroma, which may provide a reference for the production of high-quality Baijiu.

Structural and metabolic performance of p-cresol producing microbiota in different carbon sources

p-Cresol (PC) is a potential off-flavor and carcinogenic compound that affects food flavor and safety. However, controlling the production of PC when making fermented food is hindered by a lack of knowledge of the microbial diversity and the growth requirements of the microbiota that produce PC. To address this, the present study used three media with selected carbon sources (glucose, ethanol and lactic acid) to explore the microbial origin of PC and to determine the preferred carbon source for the PC-producing microbiota in the pit mud of the strong-aroma type Baijiu. The results showed that the different carbon sources affected the microbial structure, especially of the PC-producing microbiota. Glucose led to the highest production of PC and lactic acid to the lowest. The production of PC was significantly correlated (p < 0.05, |ρ| > 0.6) with Dorea, Sporanaerobacter, Tepidimicrobium, Tissierella Soehngenia, Clostridium and Sedimentibacter in the glucose medium; with Proteiniborus, Ruminococcus and Sporanaerobacter in the ethanol medium; and with Lutispora and Tepidimicrobium in the lactic acid medium. Multiphasic metabolite target analysis further indicated that the PC-producing microbiota could also metabolize flavor compounds. Lactic acid could inhibit the production of PC and ensure that the microbiota produced the appropriate flavor compounds during culture. Collectively, Dorea, Sporanaerobacter, Tepidimicrobium, Tissierella_Soehngenia, Clostridium, Sedimentibacter, Proteiniborus, Ruminococcus and Lutispora were identified as potential PC producers in three media with glucose preferred as the carbon source. These findings provide a perspective on the microbiota and carbon source preference for ultimately improving the quality of distilled alcoholic beverage.

Characterization of key odorants causing the roasted and mud-like aromas in strong-aroma types of base Baijiu

The roasted and mud-like aromas in Chinese strong-aroma types of base Baijiu (base SAB) and the interactions among the corresponding key compounds causing these two characteristic aromas were investigated. A total of 68 and 64 odorants were identified in the base and commercial SAB by comparative aroma extract dilution analysis. Furthermore, the complex matrix of Baijiu always pose a long-term challenge for quantitative accuracy and precision of target aroma compounds; thus, the odorants with flavor dilution (FD) ≥ 9 were further quantified by multiple quantitative techniques, including the direct injection combined with gas chromatography-flame ionization detector, the vortex-assisted surfactant-enhanced emulsification liquid-liquid microextraction (VSLLME) combined with GC-MS, and the derivatization method combined with VSLLME-GC-MS, and 37 and 26 odorants were shown to be important odorants as their OAVs ≥1. Among these components, 5 compounds, hexanoic acid, butyric acid, p-cresol, 3-methylindole, and 3-(methylthio)propanal showed higher OAVs in base than in commercial SAB, and based on aroma recombination and omission analysis, they were confirmed to be the key odorants responsible for the mud-like and roasted odors. The evaluation of the aforementioned five key odorants by the "addition" test showed that the roasted and mud-like aromas of base SAB were related, and the odors were mainly attributed to additive or masking effects among the compounds.

Clostridium fermenticellae sp. nov., isolated from the mud in a fermentation cellar for the production of the Chinese liquor, baijiu

A novel Gram-stain-positive, rod-shaped, obligately anaerobic, non-motile, spore-forming and binary fission encapsulated bacterium, designated strain JN500901^T, was isolated from a mud cellar which has been continuously used for the fermentation of Chinese strong-flavour baijiu for over 100 years. Growth of JN500901^Toccurred at pH 4.5-8.0 (optimum, pH 5.0), 20-40 °C (37 °C), 0-2 % (w/v) NaCl and 0-10 % (v/v) ethanol. The Biolog assay revealed that strain JN500901^T metabolized d-fructose, l-fucose, isomaltulose and l-rhamnose among the 95 studied carbon sources. p-Cresol was the predominant volatile metabolite in the fermentation broth of strain JN500901^T incubated in liquid reinforced clostridial medium under anaerobic conditions. Phylogenetic analysis based on 16S rRNA gene sequences showed that strain JN500901^T belongs to Clostridiumsensu stricto, and shared the highest sequence similarity to Clostridiumcarboxidivorans DSM 15243^T (94.2 %), followed by Clostridiumscatologenes DSM 757^T (94.1 %). The dominant cellular fatty acids (>10 %) were C16 : 0 FAME (36.6 %), C19 : 0 cyc 9,10 DMA (19.8 %) and C16 : 1 cis 9 DMA (11.8 %). The complete genome of strain JN500901^T contained a circular chromosome of 2.812 Mb with 2611 genes and 31.0 mol% G+C content. Comparative genome analysis of the strain JN500901^T, Clostridiumcarboxidivorans DSM 15243^T and Clostridiumscatologenes DSM 757^T revealed 74.5 and 74.8 % average nucleotide identity, respectively. Based on the phenotypic, biochemical and phylogenetic analyses presented here, strain JN500901^T is considered to be a novel species of the genus Clostridiumsensustricto, for which the name Clostridium fermenticellae sp. nov. is proposed. The type strain is JN500901^T (=CICC 24501^T=JCM 32827^T).

Characterization of 3-Methylindole as a Source of a "Mud"-like Off-Odor in Strong-Aroma Types of Base Baijiu

The "mud"-like off-odor, which is an odor reminiscent of musty and strong animal fecal odors, affects the quality classification of the strong-aroma types of baijiu (SAB), but little is known about which compounds are responsible for this aroma, except for certain phenolic compounds. However, not all mud-like off-odor expressions in SAB can be attributed to those phenolic compounds. In this work, volatile compounds in pit mud and SAB samples were isolated by headspace solid-phase microextraction and liquid-liquid extraction. An odoriferous zone was detected by GC-MS/olfactometer and GC-MS and was attributed to 3-methylindole rather than ethyl oleate on the basis of their odor characteristics, MS data, and retention indices. Combined with the detection threshold of 3-methylindole determined by a three-alternative forced-choice (6.09 μg/L) procedure, odor activity values in the tested base SAB were from 1 to 23. Sensory studies and the prepared heat map highlighted the contribution of this compound to the odor characteristics for the first time.

Diversity, Function, and Application of Clostridium in Chinese Strong Flavor Baijiu Ecosystem: A Review

Baijiu is a Chinese traditional distilled liquor with an annual yield over 13.12 million tons. Strong flavor baijiu (SFB) also called Luzhou-flavor liquor, takes account for > 70% of the total baijiu produced. SFB is produced by an open solid fermentation process with a complex microbial ecosystem. Clostridium is one of the most important microorganisms for the formation of the main flavor compounds of SFB, such as ethyl caproate. In this paper, we review current research progress on the Clostridium in the SFB ecosystem, focusing on the species diversity, physiological and metabolic features along with interspecies interactions. Systems biology approaches for the study of Clostridium from SFB ecosystems were discussed and explored. Furthermore, current applications of Clostridium in SFB production were discussed.

PRACTICAL APPLICATION

Strong flavor baijiu (SFB) accounts for more than 70% of total yield of Chinese baijiu, which exists for hundreds of years. Clostridium is common in SFB ecosystem and identified to be one of main contributors of flavor compounds in SFB. Study on the Clostridium from SFB ecosystem is not only helpful for the understanding of flavor compounds formation mechanism, but also the improvement of SFB quality. This study focuses on the current researches on the Clostridium species in SFB ecosystem, including the species diversity, physiological and metabolic features, and applications.

Diversity and Function of Microbial Community in Chinese Strong-Flavor Baijiu Ecosystem: A Review

Strong flavor baijiu (SFB), also called Luzhou-flavor liquor, is the most popular Chinese baijiu. It is manufactured via solid fermentation, with daqu as the starter. Microbial diversity of the SFB ecosystem and the synergistic effects of the enzymes and compounds produced by them are responsible for the special flavor and mouthfeel of SFB. The present review covers research studies focused on microbial community analysis of the SFB ecosystem, including the culturable microorganisms, their metabolic functions, microbial community diversity and their interactions. The review specifically emphasizes on the most recently conducted culture-independent analysis of SFB microbial community diversity. Furthermore, the possible application of systems biology approaches for elucidating the molecular mechanisms of SFB production were also reviewed and prospected.