Development of a multiplex qPCR for the species identification of Clostridium estertheticum, C. frigoriphilum, C. bowmanii and C. tagluense-like from blown pack spoilage (BPS) meats and from wild boars

Cesin, a short natural variant of nisin, displays potent antimicrobial activity against major pathogens despite lacking two C-terminal macrocycles

Nisin is a widely used lantibiotic owing to its potent antimicrobial activity and its food-grade status. Its mode of action includes cell wall synthesis inhibition and pore formation, which are attributed to the lipid II binding and pore-forming domains, respectively. We discovered cesin, a short natural variant of nisin, produced by the psychrophilic anaerobe Clostridium estertheticum. Unlike other natural nisin variants, cesin lacks the two terminal macrocycles constituting the pore-forming domain. The current study aimed at heterologous expression and characterization of the antimicrobial activity and physicochemical properties of cesin. Following the successful heterologous expression of cesin in Lactococcus lactis, the lantibiotic demonstrated a broad and potent antimicrobial profile comparable to that of nisin. Determination of its mode of action using lipid II and lipoteichoic acid binding assays linked the potent antimicrobial activity to lipid II binding and electrostatic interactions with teichoic acids. Fluorescence microscopy showed that cesin lacks pore-forming ability in its natural form. Stability tests have shown the lantibiotic is highly stable at different pH values and temperature conditions, but that it can be degraded by trypsin. However, a bioengineered analog, cesin R15G, overcame the trypsin degradation, while keeping full antimicrobial activity. This study shows that cesin is a novel (small) nisin variant that efficiently kills target bacteria by inhibiting cell wall synthesis without pore formation. IMPORTANCE The current increase in antibiotic-resistant pathogens necessitates the discovery and application of novel antimicrobials. In this regard, we recently discovered cesin, which is a short natural variant of nisin produced by the psychrophilic Clostridium estertheticum. However, its suitability as an antimicrobial compound was in doubt due to its structural resemblance to nisin(1-22), a bioengineered short variant of nisin with low antimicrobial activity. Here, we show by heterologous expression, purification, and characterization that the potency of cesin is not only much higher than that of nisin(1-22), but that it is even comparable to the full-length nisin, despite lacking two C-terminal rings that are essential for nisin's activity. We show that cesin is a suitable scaffold for bioengineering to improve its applicability, such as resistance to trypsin. This study demonstrates the suitability of cesin for future application in food and/or for health as a potent and stable antimicrobial compound.

A simple method for the isolation of cold-tolerant Clostridium spp. from meat samples

Pure isolates of Clostridium spp. are required when further investigations are needed, such as the characterisation of the colonies, sporulation and germination, biochemical analysis, growth rate and growth conditions, toxin production, spoilage potential and genomic profile. However, the isolation of cold-tolerant Clostridium spp. from suspicious meat samples is challenging due to their slow growth rates and overgrowth with less fastidious meat microbiota. Therefore, this study aimed to establish a practical method for the isolation of psychrophilic and psychrotolerant Clostridium spp. Primarily, meat drip samples (n = 3), enriched in Peptone Yeast Glucose Starch (PYGS) broth, were heated with different temperatures and durations, before they were subcultured on Columbia blood agar (CBA). The treatment procedure of heating samples at 80 °C for 5 min was evaluated as effective and was further validated using pure cultures of lactic acid bacteria (n = 5), bacteria belonging to the family of Enterobacteriaceae (n = 5), and cold-tolerant Clostridium spp. (n = 34). Almost all other meat microbiota was inactivated by heating at 80 °C for 5 min, while 28 strains of cold-tolerant Clostridium spp. survived. Finally, the treatment procedure was applied with drip of meat samples (n = 41) previously tested positive for 49 cold-tolerant Clostridium spp. using specific multiplex qPCR. All meat drip samples were enriched in PYGS broth by incubating them at 4 °C for 3 weeks, to ensure growth of Clostridium spp. before the enrichments were proceeded to heat treatment and to culturing on CBA. A total of 35 (71 %) from 49 Clostridium spp. strains were isolated using this culturing procedure. The accuracy of the recovery rates obtained from two replicates was 68 %. The method of detection and isolation applied in this study is easy and resulted in a high isolation rate of cold-tolerant Clostridium spp.

Occurrence of genes encoding spore germination in Clostridium species that cause meat spoilage

Members of the genus Clostridium are frequently associated with meat spoilage. The ability for low numbers of spores of certain Clostridium species to germinate in cold-stored vacuum-packed meat can result in blown pack spoilage. However, little is known about the germination process of these clostridia, despite this characteristic being important for their ability to cause spoilage. This study sought to determine the genomic conditions for germination of 37 representative Clostridium strains from seven species (C. estertheticum, C. tagluense, C. frigoris, C. gasigenes, C. putrefaciens, C. aligidicarnis and C. frigdicarnis) by comparison with previously characterized germination genes from C. perfringens, C. sporogenes and C. botulinum. All the genomes analysed contained at least one gerX operon. Seven different gerX operon configuration types were identified across genomes from C. estertheticum, C. tagluense and C. gasigenes. Differences arose between the C. gasigenes genomes and those belonging to C. tagluense/C. estertheticum in the number and type of genes coding for cortex lytic enzymes, suggesting the germination pathway of C. gasigenes is different. However, the core components of the germination pathway were conserved in all the Clostridium genomes analysed, suggesting that these species undergo the same major steps as Bacillus subtilis for germination to occur.

Draft Genome Sequence of Clostridium bowmanii DSM 14206T, Isolated from an Antarctic Microbial Mat

Clostridium bowmanii type strain DSM 14206 (ATCC BAA-581) was isolated from a microbial mat sample retrieved from Lake Fryxell, Antarctica. This report describes the generation and annotation of the 4.9-Mb draft genome sequence of C. bowmanii DSM 14206^T.

Targeted Genome Mining Reveals the Psychrophilic Clostridium estertheticum Complex as a Potential Source for Novel Bacteriocins, Including Cesin A and Estercticin A

Antimicrobial resistance in pathogenic bacteria is considered a major public health issue necessitating the discovery of alternative antimicrobial compounds. In this regard, targeted genome mining in bacteria occupying under-explored ecological niches has the potential to reveal such compounds, including bacteriocins. In this study, we determined the bacteriocin biosynthetic potential of the psychrophilic Clostridium estertheticum complex (CEC) through a combination of genome mining and phenotypic screening assays. The genome mining was performed in 40 CEC genomes using antiSMASH. The production of bacteriocin-like compounds was phenotypically validated through agar well (primary screening) and disk diffusion (secondary screening) assays using cell free supernatants (CFS) and partially purified extracts, respectively. Stability of four selected CFS against proteolytic enzymes, temperature and pH was determined while one CFS was analyzed by HRMS and MS/MS to identify potential bacteriocins. Twenty novel bacteriocin biosynthetic gene clusters (BBGC), which were classified into eight (six lantibiotics and two sactipeptides) distinct groups, were discovered in 18 genomes belonging to C. estertheticum (n = 12), C. tagluense (n = 3) and genomospecies2 (n = 3). Primary screening linked six BBGC with narrow antimicrobial activity against closely related clostridia species. All four preselected CFS retained activity after exposure to different proteolytic, temperature and pH conditions. Secondary screening linked BBGC1 and BBGC7 encoding a lantibiotic and sactipeptide, respectively, with activity against Bacillus cereus while lantibiotic-encoding BBGC2 and BBGC3 were linked with activity against B. cereus, Staphylococcus aureus (methicillin-resistant), Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. MS/MS analysis revealed that C. estertheticum CF004 produces cesin A, a short natural variant of nisin, and HRMS indicated the production of a novel sactipeptide named estercticin A. Therefore, we have shown the CEC, in particular C. estertheticum, is a source of novel and stable bacteriocins that have activities against clinically relevant pathogens.

Unknown cold-tolerant Clostridium spp.: Characteristics and potential to cause meat spoilage

Clostridium spp. are ubiquitous bacteria and often found in foods and animals. Some species are pathogenic, others food spoiling or commensals. In this study, 65 cold-tolerant Clostridium spp. strains isolated from variable samples (beef, lamb, venison, feces/skin of wild boars) were investigated. Fifty strains were lecithinase positive; six additionally produced β-hemolysis. By applying specific qPCR, 16S rRNA gene analysis, RFLP method, and MALDI-TOF MS, they were classified into two major groups: 29 strains were identified as C. tagluense-like, while the other 36 remained unidentified. Subsequently, twenty-two vacuum-packed beef samples were spiked with a single strain from both groups and stored at 4 °C for 8 weeks. The odor of challenged samples was variable (from unchanged, sour/musty, to sulfurous), while color, meat consistency and drip loss were similar to the control group. The ability to produce gas of all tested strains was lower than of C. estertheticum. Even though both groups of cold-tolerant clostridia exhibited similar 16S rRNA genes and biochemical activities, RFLP methods and MALDI-TOF MS are sufficient to differentiate them. In terms of food safety, strains producing lecithinase and hemolysin should be further investigated for their potential to produce substances affecting human and animal health.

Whole Genome Sequence-Based Identification of Clostridium estertheticum Complex Strains Supports the Need for Taxonomic Reclassification Within the Species Clostridium estertheticum

Isolates within the Clostridium estertheticum complex (CEC) have routinely been identified through the 16S rRNA sequence, but the high interspecies sequence similarity reduces the resolution necessary for species level identification and often results in ambiguous taxonomic classification. The current study identified CEC isolates from meat juice (MJS) and bovine fecal samples (BFS) and determined the phylogeny of species within the CEC through whole genome sequence (WGS)-based analyses. About 1,054 MJS were screened for CEC using quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR). Strains were isolated from 33 MJS and 34 BFS qPCR-positive samples, respectively. Pan- and core-genome phylogenomics were used to determine the species identity of the isolates. Average nucleotide identity (ANI) and digital DNA-DNA hybridization (dDDH) were used to validate the species identity. The phylogeny of species within the CEC was determined through a combination of these methods. Twenty-eight clostridia strains were isolated from MJS and BFS samples out of which 13 belonged to CEC. At 95% ANI and 70% dDDH thresholds for speciation, six CEC isolates were identified as genomospecies2 (n=3), Clostridium tagluense (n=2) and genomospecies3 (n=1). Lower thresholds of 94% ANI and 58% dDDH were required for the classification of seven CEC isolates into species C. estertheticum and prevent an overlap between species C. estertheticum and Clostridium frigoriphilum. Combination of the two species and abolishment of current subspecies classification within the species C. estertheticum are proposed. These data demonstrate the suitability of phylogenomics to identify CEC isolates and determine the phylogeny within CEC.

The pathogenic and spoilage bacteria associated with red meat and application of different approaches of high CO2 packaging to extend product shelf-life

With the fast-global development of packaging techniques, the potential antimicrobial effect of CO₂, as a safe, cheap and readily available gas, makes it the integral component for packaging of meat products. The associated spoilage and/or pathogenic bacteria on raw meat may respond in different ways to elevated CO₂ concentrations. The growth of some aerobic Gram-negative bacteria such as Pseudomonas spp. is significantly inhibited but some LAB bacteria may be allowed to grow faster and dominate the product. The antimicrobial efficacy of enriched CO₂ packaging is attributed to the rate of CO₂ solubility in the product which is itself affected by the level of headspace CO₂, product pH, temperature and the ratio of headspace gas to product (G:P). This review, first, explores the varied range of beef and sheep meat spoilage and pathogenic bacteria and the intrinsic and extrinsic parameters that may influence the pattern of microbial growth and meat spoilage rate during storage. Then, the antimicrobial mechanism of elevated CO₂ packaging will be discussed and the different approaches of achieving enriched CO₂ packaging i.e. the traditional technique of flushing a desired gas mixture and/or using the new commercially developed CO₂ emitters will then be compared in terms of their strengths, limitations and technical mode of action.

An investigation of the environmental niches of blown pack spoilage causing Clostridium estertheticum and Clostridium gasigenes on New Zealand beef and sheep farms

The transfer of blown pack spoilage causing Clostridium spores from the farm to the meat plant is of growing concern to the meat industry. This study investigated the environmental niches of these Clostridium spp., specifically Clostridium estertheticum and Clostridium gasigenes in the beef and sheep farm environments in New Zealand. Faecal, soil, grass, drinking water, puddle water and feed (fodder beet, hay, bailage and silage, where available) samples were collected on five beef and sheep farms during Winter and Spring in 2018, in North and South Island, respectively. Beef and sheep farm samples were tested for C. estertheticum and C. gasigenes using enrichment plus PCR, qPCR and direct plating. C. estertheticum was detected in bovine faecal (4%), soil (2-18%) and grass (0-12%) samples at concentration of up to 2.0 log₁₀ cfu/g. C. gasigenes were found in 18-46% of faecal, 16-82% of soil, 12-44% of grass, 0-44.4% of drinking water and 0-58.3% of puddle water samples tested and the direct counts ranged from 2.4 log₁₀ cfu/ml in puddle water to 3.4 log₁₀ cfu/g in soil. C. estertheticum were detected by qPCR in sheep farms in ovine feces (2.3%), soil (2.3%) and fodder beet (10%). All other sample types (grass, drinking water, puddle water, baleage, hay, silage and fodder beet) were negative using direct and enrichment plus PCR methods. In contrast C. gasigenes was detected in of faecal (22.7-38.6%), soil (22.7-84.1%), grass (17.5-34.1%) drinking water (35.7-78.6%), puddle water (33.3-40%), hay baleage (57%), silage (2%) and fodder beet (10%) at concentrations of up to 3.7 log₁₀ cfu/g/ml. It was concluded that C. estertheticum and C. gasigenes were common on beef and sheep farms with the latter having higher incidence and mean concentration.

Simultaneous quantification of the most common and proteolytic Pseudomonas species in raw milk by multiplex qPCR

Abstract

The heat-stable peptidase AprX, secreted by psychrotolerant Pseudomonas species in raw milk, is a major cause of destabilization and premature spoilage of ultra-high temperature (UHT) milk and milk products. To enable rapid detection and quantification of seven frequent and proteolytic Pseudomonas species (P. proteolytica, P. gessardii, P. lactis, P. fluorescens, P. protegens, P. lundensis, and P. fragi) in raw milk, we developed two triplex qPCR assays taking into account species-dependent differences in AprX activity. Besides five species-specific hydrolysis probes, targeting the aprX gene, a universal rpoB probe was included in the assay to determine the total Pseudomonas counts. For all six probes, linear regression lines between C_q value and target DNA concentration were obtained in singleplex as well as in multiplex approaches, yielding R² values of > 0.975 and amplification efficiencies of 85–97%. Moreover, high specificity was determined using genomic DNA of 75 Pseudomonas strains, assigned to 57 species, and 40 other bacterial species as templates in the qPCR. Quantification of the target species and total Pseudomonas counts resulted in linear detection ranges of approx. 10³–10⁷ cfu/ml, which correspond well to common Pseudomonas counts in raw milk. Application of the assay using 60 raw milk samples from different dairies showed good agreement of total Pseudomonas counts calculated by qPCR with cell counts derived from cultivation. Furthermore, a remarkably high variability regarding the species composition was observed for each milk sample, whereby P. lundensis and P. proteolytica/P. gessardii were the predominant species detected.

Key points

• Multiplex qPCR for quantification of seven proteolytic Pseudomonas species and total Pseudomonas counts in raw milk

• High specificity and sensitivity via hydrolysis probes against aprX and rpoB

• Rapid method to determine Pseudomonas contamination in raw milk and predict spoilage potential

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s00253-021-11109-0.

High incidence of cold-tolerant Clostridium frigoriphilum and C. algidicarnis in vacuum-packed beef on retail sale in Germany

Sixty vacuum-packed beef samples retailed in Germany were investigated for the occurrence of cold-tolerant Clostridium spp. After a storage period at 4 °C for eight weeks, meat juice from all samples was processed for culturing, DNA extraction and SYBR green qPCR for Clostridium species. After that, a previously developed multiplex qPCR, sequence analysis of the 16S rRNA gene, and MALDI-TOF MS were applied in order to identify Clostridium spp. found in samples. Subsequently, 23 samples were found positive for C. frigoriphilum (n = 19), C. estertheticum (n = 2), C. tagluense (n = 1) and C. lacusfryxellense/C. frigoris (n = 1). By using a new multiplex qPCR and a new RFLP method developed in this study, a further 15 meat juice samples were revealed to be contaminated with C. algidicarnis. With some samples being co-contaminated with two different species, 53% (n = 32) of all investigated vacuum-packed beef samples were found to be positive for cold-tolerant clostridia. This is the first report of detection and identification of C. algidicarnis in meat samples in Germany and Central Europe.

Comparative Genome Analysis and Phenotypic Characterization of Clostridium gasigenes CGAS001 Isolated From Chilled Vacuum-Packed Lamb Meat

Genomic data for psychrophilic bacteria causing blown pack spoilage (BPS) are limited. This study characterizes the genome of a novel Clostridium gasigenes strain CGAS001 isolated from meat juice sample (MJS) of vacuum-packed lamb meat by comparing it with the type strain C. gasigenes DSM 12272 and five strains representing four other BPS-causing Clostridium sensu stricto species. Phenotypic characteristics of the strain, which include biochemical characteristics, antimicrobial resistance and production of putative polyketide, have been determined. The size of its draft genome is 4.1 Mb with 3,845 coding sequences, 28.7% GC content and 95 RNA genes that include 75 tRNAs, 17 rRNAs, and 3 ncRNAs. Average Nucleotide Identity (ANI) and digital DNA-DNA Hybridization (dDDH) predict that C. gasigenes CGAS001 and DSM 12272 constitute a single species (ANI and dDDH = 98.3% for speciation) but two distinct subspecies (dDDH = 73.3% for subspeciation). The genome is characterized by saccharolytic, lipolytic and proteolytic genes as well as hemolysins and phospholipases, which are consistent with its phenotype. The genome also reveals the ability of C. gasigenes to synthesize polyketides which is demonstrated by the antimicrobial activity of a crude polyketide extract against Listeria monocytogenes and Enterococcus devriesei. The strain is resistant to polymyxin B and streptomycin. The genetic and phenotypic analyses suggest that CGAS001 constitutes a novel subspecies of C. gasigenes adapted to a saprophytic lifestyle and can synthesize narrow spectrum antimicrobial compounds.

Detection of Psychrophilic Clostridium spp. Causing "Blown Pack" Spoilage in Meat Juice Samples from Chilled Vacuum-Packed Beef and Lamb Meat Imported from Different Countries to Switzerland

"Blown pack" spoilage (BPS) of chilled vacuum-packed meat is mainly caused by anaerobic and psychrophilic Clostridium spp., including C. estertheticum, C. gasigenes, C. frigoriphilum, and C. frigidicarnis. Recently, its occurrence has been reported in several countries, especially in internationally traded meat. Therefore, this study aimed at detecting the occurrence of psychrophilic Clostridium spp. causing BPS in meat juice samples (MJS) from chilled vacuum-packed beef and lamb meat imported from other countries to Switzerland. One hundred fifty-four MJS (n = 78 from beef; n = 76 from lamb meat) were screened for psychrophilic Clostridium spp. by quantitative PCR, whereby MJS with a crossing point PCR cycle value <35 and >35 were considered positive and negative, respectively. Psychrophilic Clostridium spp. were detected in 10 MJS, of which 2 were from beef and 8 were from lamb meat. The two beef MJS originated from Spain and Lithuania, whereas the lamb MJS originated from New Zealand (six) and Australia (two). This is the first report of psychrophilic Clostridium spp. in MJS from chilled vacuum-packed beef and lamb meat imported from other countries to Switzerland and provides further evidence that the risk of BPS in lamb meat is higher than in beef.

A case of 'blown pack' spoilage of vacuum-packaged pork likely associated with Clostridium estertheticum in Canada

This study investigated the potential causative agents for vacuum-packaged pork that had shown gross package extension during a routine storage life study in a Canadian pork plant using both conventional and culture-independent methods. The spoilage-associated bacteria in purge samples from two packages were enumerated using selective media and profiled using 16S rDNA amplicon analysis. The presence of Clostridium estertheticum was detected using species-specific real-time PCR. An enrichment procedure was used to isolate C. estertheticum from one of the purge samples. The average population density in the two purge samples of total aerobes, lactic acid bacteria (LAB), coliforms and Brochothrix thermosphacta was 9·4, 9·1, 6·0 and 4·6 log CFU per ml respectively, as determined by plating. The estimated numbers of C. estertheticum were >7 log cells per ml. Clostridium estertheticum was recovered although the enrichment condition used for isolation favoured the growth of LAB more than that of Clostridium spp. Based on 16S rDNA amplicon analysis, the microbiota in the two purge samples had 64·7 and 20·7% of Clostridium spp., and 32·5 and 70·1% of LAB respectively. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Blown pack spoilage of vacuum-packaged meat may lead to severe economic losses and is often associated with beef, venison and lamb. This study is the first to report vacuum-packaged chilled pork can also be subject to blown pack spoilage, and data support the conclusion that the causative agent is likely Clostridium estertheticum. The lysozyme-digestion step greatly improved the isolation efficiency for C. estertheticum, a spore-forming anaerobic organism that has been proven to be difficult to recover. This method can be used for isolating spore-forming organisms from food samples.

Relevant Aspects of Clostridium estertheticum as a Specific Spoilage Organism of Vacuum-Packed Meat

Clostridium estertheticum is a psychrotolerant, gram-positive, motile, anaerobic, spore-forming, rod-shaped bacteria that causes blown pack spoilage (BPS). Spoilage occurs in vacuum-packed meat without temperature abuse. Having been reported in the last 30 years in several countries, BPS by Cl. estertheticum is a major issue around the world and presents a huge economic impact on the meat industry. Despite being an important spoilage microorganism, studies on Cl. estertheticum are challenged by numerous aspects. These include, lack or poor growth in laboratory media, long culturing periods, and unpredictable isolation on the media. These factors hamper the detection of Cl. estertheticum before occurrence of BPS, which further undermines efforts to prevent the occurrence of BPS. Nevertheless, considerable developments have taken place with regard to culture-independent methods. Although information on Cl. estertheticum is available, it is limited and remains highly fragmented. Therefore, this review collates the available information and discusses relevant aspects of Cl. estertheticum as a specific spoilage organism of BPS in vacuum-packed meat.